Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This book is everything I love about Ruth Ware and I’m really glad she wrote another book.

This is about a woman whose roommate was murdered 10 years ago and she is beginning to question whether the person convicted- the person she testified against- is actually guilty.

The story is so well developed and unravels perfectly. I love the way she reveals small details without matter of factly stating them, and the way each new thing uncovered left me wanting more.

I always love books that switch between past and present and it was well done in this book, and gave just the right amount of both reveal as well as adding more mystery in each chapter. I did not suspect the ending, so many times I was sure I had it figured out, but it wasn’t any of the scenarios I imagined. Overall such a well done book and I’m thankful to have the opportunity to read it early!

Was this review helpful?

Another fabulous thriller from Ruth Ware! I had looked forward to reading The It Girl, as I have loved all of Ware’s books—and it did not disappoint. The format of chapters that alternate between the current life of protagonist Hannah, as a married and pregnant woman in Edinburgh, and her first year at Oxford University ten years ago, is well done and sets a lively pace. The focus of the book is the murder of Hannah’s roommate at Oxford and the man convinced of that crime, in large part due to Hannah’s testimony. But when that man dies—still proclaiming his innocence—Hannah wonders if she could have been wrong, although it seems unlikely. Ware does a wonderful job of conveying Hannah’s angst and anxiety as she searches for the truth, and readers will once again be thoroughly engaged in this well-plotted thriller. Thanks to NetGalley for the opportunity to review this book!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Gallery Books and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

The It Girl by Ruth Ware is the explosive thriller that all of her author's fans have been waiting for! The story revolves around Hannah, who was part of a close-knit group of friends at Oxford a decade ago. But the queen bee April was found dead at the end of their first year. Now, it's a decade later, and new evidence has come out that the man convicted of April's murder may have been innocent. Can Hannah figure out who the real murderer is before they come looking for her?

Here is a chilling excerpt from the opening chapter:

"She knew what happened next only from what the others told her. Her screams. Hugh following her up the stairs, two at a time. April’s limp body sprawled across the hearth rug in front of the fire, almost theatrically, in the photos she was shown afterwards.
But she could not remember it herself. It was as if her brain had blocked it out, shut down, like a memory glitch on a computer: file corrupted—and no amount of patient questioning from the police ever brought her closer to that actual moment of recognition.
Only sometimes, in the middle of the night, she wakes up with a picture in front of her eyes, a picture different from the grainy Polaroids of the police photographer, with their careful evidence markers and harsh floodlit lighting."

Overall, It Girl is an unputdownable college-based thriller that will appeal to fans of Pretty Little Liars or The Girls Are All So Nice Here. One highlight of this book is how action-packed it is. At about the midway mark, the action ramps up higher and higher until the explosive finale. Another highlight of this book were the nonstop twists and turns. Just when I thought I had everything figured out, the author inserted twists that I did not see coming. If you're intrigued by the excerpt above, or if you're a fan of thrillers in general, I highly recommend that you check out this book when it comes out in July!

Was this review helpful?

One of my favorite books of 2022. I loved the before and after aspect of the chapters and how the whole story unfolded.. So much suspense, so many emotions. .

Was this review helpful?

I have some mixed feelings about this one. On the one hand the plot was pretty good and left me guessing as to who the real killer was. But the characters and the motive for the murder left me feeling underwhelmed about the whole thing.

Hannah was a typical lead character in this type of book. Appears or thinks of herself as weak but proves that she can muster up the strength when needed. She is also naive, innocent about how the world works and makes many questionable life choices. She also puts her health and that of her unborn child at risk because of all of the stress. Speaking of the pregnancy, it was mentioned way to often and felt like we were beaten over the head with it. Which would have been okay if it had been central to the story, but it wasn’t, so it just became annoying.

Hannah’s relationship with April was also a bit annoying and kind of a weak link in the story. April was not a very nice person, and did not particularly show kindness to Hannah, so why should she be tormented by her murder? Also the man she accused, while innocent of this crime was not a good person, in fact he was a perv, who sexually harassed and assaulted Hannah. Should she feel guilt for sending an innocent man to prison? Maybe, but she certainly saved other women from his torment by doing so.

There were many other characters in this story, most of them from the time Hannah was at Oxford, and almost all of them were suspects at some point in the story. The real murderer was a bit of a surprise, as they had the best alibi, but not too surprising. Although I felt that the motive was a bit weak. The ending was also kind of weak, as Hannah finally puts it all together after accusing her husband of the murder.

The dual timeline worked for the most part, until 2/3rds in when the past timeline stops and the action takes place all in the present. The past is where we meet all of the suspects and their relationships with April are revealed. I never felt like we fully got to know April and as I said before the motive behind the killing was weak and not very believable. If April had been a bit more developed, I might have felt something about her and Hannah and the many other characters.

I think I am sounding a bit harsher than I mean to in this review. This wasn’t a bad book, in fact it will make a pretty good beach read. How the killer pulls off the murder was intriguing and not what I saw coming. The pacing was good, and it was somewhat compelling and hard to put down at times. If you are looking for a standard psychological thriller to read on the beach than this is the one you should pick up.

Was this review helpful?

What really happened that night? A snotty rich brat was murdered. The only reason I cared about the killer was the affect that night had on the main character, Hannah. As the only one of a group of friends who had no money, she seemed like the only one with a soul. The murder victim got what was coming to her.

Was this review helpful?

Hannah Jones and April Clarke-Cliveden meet as first-year students and suite-mates three floors up in staircase 7 of a charming old Oxford quadrangle. Their names alone tell you who is the middle-class girl from state schools and who is the posh golden girl. [At some point, it looks like Ruth Ware changed April’s name from Coutts Cliveden to Clarke-Cliveden. Or maybe the other way around? I read an advance review copy, so I don’t know.]

But April is friendly and inclusive, which ensures that Hannah is in a group of six friends from her first day. Some are part of April’s prep-school set, but others are new to the world of privilege and the arcana of Oxford’s vocabulary and traditions. The most striking is Will de Chastaigne, with whom Hannah is infatuated upon first sight. Unfortunately for Hannah, he is also April’s boyfriend.

An Oxford tradition is to have porters, who are gatekeepers, handlers of mail, superintendents of the quad. One of the quad’s porters, John Neville, is a musty-smelling middle-aged man who behaves like a stalker to Hannah. On the night Hannah discovers April’s body in their living room, she has just seen Neville leaving through the ground-level door to their staircase. Her testimony puts Neville away.

That is the Before of this book, which is arranged in Before and After chapters. The After is set 10 years after April’s murder. Hannah is married, pregnant, and living in Edinburgh. When she learns that there are reasons to think Neville may not have killed April, she begins asking questions of her old friends, which raises more questions—and danger.

The Ruth Ware formula, if there is one, is to place a woman in an unfamiliar situation, often one that puts her off kilter and that becomes threatening. The suspense and tension tend to start out at about a two on the dial and click up steadily and inexorably.

This latest novel doesn’t crank up the tension nearly as quickly or steadily. This is more of a slow burn, with the shock of the reveal(s) and immediate threat to Hannah left to very close to the end of the book. That slowness may be disappointing to some readers, but I was fine with it. I’m a complete sucker for academic mysteries, and anything set in Oxford is irresistible to me, so I enjoyed the immersion into descriptions of student life in Oxford. I wouldn’t say this is Ware’s strongest novel, but I enjoyed it. A few quibbles didn’t spoil it for me; for example, Hannah’s frustrating failure to tell anyone the complete story of Neville’s treatment of her.

Ruth Ware is often called today’s Agatha Christie. While Ware doesn’t have a sleuth like Miss Marple or Hercule Poirot, she does have Christie’s penchant for identifying several suspects with motives to murder, and subtly dropping clues so that the reader can figure out the whodunnit. A fair-play whodunnit isn’t that common these days, and I appreciate the few contemporary writers, like Ruth Ware, who can pull it off.

Was this review helpful?

This is more of 3.5 stars. The thing keeping it from 4 for me is that it’s just too long winded and long. I wanted a faster paced story. I think for this type it was much too slow of a burn. I did like the mystery. I liked the characters. I didn’t have it figured out and i did want to know what happened and i totally didn’t figure out the why. But i think it could have cut 100 pages and been better. Still a huge Ware fan. Slow burns just aren’t my fav

Was this review helpful?

I was given an advanced reader copy of this book by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Ruth Ware always seems to deliver a page turner and this one is no exception! I thought it times it got bogged down with extraneous information but if you are looking for a book to put you on the edge of y-ur seat, this is it.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for an advanced digital copy of this book in exchange for a review.

Hannah Jones is a smart girl from a small town and is somewhat lost when she arrives at Clapham College at Oxford. When she gets to her room, she finds that she doesn't have the single room she expected in the newer dorms but a two-bedroom suite in the older hall - and a roommate! April Clarke-Cliveden is not just ANY other freshman, but is well-known as an Instagram influencer before they even existed!. Despite Hannah's initial shyness, she is soon best friends with April and an integral part of her group of friends.. She even thinks she may be falling in love with Will, one of that group.. There is one small problem - a porter who seems to have a special interest in her and scares her, but she takes every opportunity to avoid him and is mostly successful.

But at the end of the year, after a party celebrating April's performance in the Spring theater production, Hannah returns to their rooms to find April dead on their sitting room floor. She has seen the porter leaving their stairway when she approached, tells the police, and he is arrested, tried and convicted of the murder.

Now it is ten years later, Hannah is married and pregnant when she hears that the porter has died in prison, proclaiming his innocence to the end.

Hannah and her husband Will now live in Edinburgh, hopefully far enough away from Oxford that the reporters won't hunt her down to again question her about this latest development. But of course they do find her and one seems to have information about the case. Does Hannah really remember that night the way she thinks she does? Could there be someone else involved in the murder? Did she send an innocent man to his death in prison?

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much NetGalley and Gallery Books for the eARC!

RATING: 3.5/5 stars
PUB. DATE: July 12, 2022

The It Girl is my second book I’ve read by Ruth Ware. I read The Turn of the Key a couple months ago and really enjoyed it, so I was THRILLED when I was approved for this highly anticipated read!

I liked this one, but felt like it dragged on longer than it should’ve. The ending felt somewhat rushed. I hardly ever catch the twist, but I did in this one quite early on. However, it’s suspenseful and keeps you second guessing the entire time. Also a big fan of campus thriller vibes so really loved that aspect!

Overall, I’d recommend this one, especially to Ware fans. I’m excited to read more from her!

Was this review helpful?

April Clarke-Cliveden was the first person Hannah Jones met at Oxford. Vivacious, bright, occasionally vicious, and the ultimate It girl, she quickly pulled Hannah into her dazzling orbit. Together, they developed a group of devoted and inseparable friends—Will, Hugh, Ryan, and Emily—during their first term. By the end of the year, April was dead. Now, a decade later, Hannah and Will are expecting their first child, and the man convicted of killing April, former Oxford porter John Neville, has died in prison. Relieved to have finally put the past behind her, Then a young journalist comes knocking at Hannah's door and presents new evidence that Neville may have been innocent. As Hannah reconnects with old friends and delves deeper into the mystery of April’s death, she realizes that the friends she thought she knew all have something to hide…including a murder.

This is the third book I have read by Ruth Ware, and she sucks me in every time! Her writing is impeccable, and her characters are so well developed. Then she throws in a twist that I am never expecting! Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for granting my request to read this book for a honest review. I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

While I wanted to save this read for an upcoming beach trip, I couldn't. I told myself I'd read just the first page, then the first chapter, and then . . . Once I started, I couldn't stop.

THE IT GIRL took me back to my college days. Dark academia and a decade-old crime drew me into the premise.
The characters kept me there.

Loved Hannah. She was easy to root for, especially as she grappled with her decisions (both past and present).

This was a smart, compulsive read. It was classic Ruth Ware at her finest. She draws you in with an immersive setting. She gets you grounded before the twists come. I was very satisfied with the ending and the process of getting there.

Thank you to Gallery Books and NetGalley for the ARC. This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The first day Hannah moves into college, her life is changed when she meets her roommate April. April is the It Girl at their college, popular, beautiful, outgoing and wealthy. She can date anyone she wants and can get away with anything. At dinner that evening, Hannah meets a few other people that she becomes close to. Yet the good times end when Hannah finds April dead in their room at the end of their second term. 10 years later Hannah and Will (April's ex-boyfriend) are happily married and expecting a baby. When the man Hannah accused of murdering April dies in prison and a journalist thinks someone else was the murderer, Hannah begins looking into what really happened that night. This book will keep you guessing until the end.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!

I really enjoyed Lying Game by Ruth Ware, so I thought I would give this one a shot. It had me going for a while--I was suspicious of everyone to the point of considering an unreliable narrator. In the end, the pacing was a little slow, and I found the final reveal to be lackluster. I'm picky about a thriller, and this one didn't really hit the spot. I'm sure fans of Wares, or fans of a collegiate mystery in general, will enjoy this one.

Was this review helpful?

I’ll be the first to admit that I have a strange relationship with Ware’s books - I either lovr them or I don’t. This one I loved. Whether I have higher exceptions for an author of her stature, sometimes they miss the mark for me. This one was classic Ware - a slow burn with an explosive conclusion. Well written plot with believable characters and I had no idea until the final chapters who was the real villain. Exclusive school, priveledged students, money, power, podcasts, greed, class jealousy and love are some of the ingredients in most popular thrillers. All conspire here to deliver a great summer read. Phew, a great one Ms Ware, thank you!

Was this review helpful?

This was the perfect whodunnit story, yet it's so much more than that. The It Girl follows Hannah through her journey of self-reflection, and confronting her worst fears in order to find out the truth of what really happened to April that fateful night at Oxford. Set against the backdrop of Oxford and modern-day Edinburgh, it gives off dark academia vibes in flashbacks that correspond with Hannah's life now.

I thought the chapter layout was absolutely brilliant, segmented into "before" April's death, and "after". The twists and turns were unpredictable, even right up until the very end. Overall this was very well-written, and extremely hard to put down. Definitely a 5-star read for me.

Was this review helpful?

First I wanna say thank you to Ruth Ware, Gallery Books and Netgalley for the opportunity to read this ARC. This was my first Ruth Ware book and definitely not my last.

This story is about Hannah & April who meet as roommates freshmen year at college and instantly become best friends. When Hannah arrives home to find April murdered her whole world shattered into pieces. Years later the convicted murderer dies in prison but Hannah is left with some unsettling feelings especially after a reporter reaches out convinced that the killer may still be out there and Neville was wrongly convicted.

Thoughts: I was pulled in by this academic thriller. It was a bit of a slow build and drawn out in a few spots. I was shocked when the “official killer” came to light because my thoughts were all pointing to someone else so I enjoyed the surprise and suspense of that. The characters are all relatively likable, although Hannah was a bit annoying with her obsession with April, especially as it came out that April wasn’t the greatest friend or person at times. All in all this was a good thriller that I’m giving 4 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Overall, I really enjoyed this book. It is one my new favorites by Ruth Ware. The writing was creative hopping back and forth between time periods “before” and “after” the death of a beloved friend named April. I also really enjoyed the characters and final twist on who murdered their friend. The reason this book will not receive five stars from me is that I feel like it could have been much shorter and still just as good. Otherwise, I loved it!

Was this review helpful?

There is so much publicity around Ruth Ware’s novels that I was excited to read and review her latest book, The It Girl, to experience the hype for myself. In my mind, I thought this novel was going to be a thriller. I was expecting to be kept at the edge of my seat for the bulk of the book. The read is more of a “who did it” murder mystery that revolves around the lives first-year college students and resurfaces over a decade later.

Ware’s characters are well-developed, and I kept wanting to read more about each of them. However, if you are looking for a book consisting of nonstop action, this is not that book. It is still very much an enjoyable read, and the surprising twist at the end is quite shocking!

Thank you, NetGalley and Gallery Books, for the digital ARC in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions stated above are my own.

Was this review helpful?