Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you so so much to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the ARC!

I unfortunately was not able to finish this book, and I DNFed it halfway through. I don't think that this was necessarily a bad book, I just think that I was not the target audience and it was not the right book for me.

I did like a few things, and that was Lizzie. I thought she was very much adorable, and I liked reading about her. I liked reading about her ADHD and how she got through her struggles, and she was overall a very likeable character. However, what I felt was that her ADHD was more of her whole personality, which was disappointing, since she lacked much complexity. There were also quite a few funny moments that I did laugh at, and I enjoyed the writing style of the author as it wasn't too hard to follow along with.

However, when it came to other characters, they felt dull to read about, and I felt very disconnected from them. While Rake had the potential to be a very interesting character, I hardly knew anything about him. It was hard to root for him to get over his fear of emotional vulnerability when I couldn't exactly understand them how I wanted to.

The plot fell short for me, however. There wasn't much conflict involved, and I felt as if everything wrapped up way too neatly without any struggle for the characters. It caused the story to drag on for a long time and it was hard to be interested in it when nothing was happening most of the time. There wasn't really much I could anticipate either, and I wish that the narrative was a little more complex.

Just as a personal preference, I wasn't the biggest fan of the insta-love. I felt the characters had a shortage of chemistry, and both didn't connect nearly as much as I wanted to. There were quite a few time jumps, but not enough time for me to be fully invested in Lizzie and Rake's relationship.

Unfortunately, I'm going to have to give this a 2/5 stars. Again, thank you so much for the opportunity to review this, and all opinions are mine.

Was this review helpful?

YAII. THIS BOOK. I literally teared up at the
dedication, and then basically the entire last 20%. And don't even get me started on the acknowledgments. As a fellow ADHDer, this book honestly meant more than I think I can ever express. I am very different from Lizzie in a lot of ways. But the way she felt about her brain. The way she felt like she was too much, unlovable. A lot of her quirks and habits. These were all things that felt like a reflection of my own life. I ended up highlighting like half of the book. Not only is this story sexy, and sweet, and HILARIOUS. It's a love letter to every ADHD person who has felt like they were too much and yet not enough at the same time. Who have felt like they're a failure and don't deserve love. And
even more generally, just any neurodiverse person who has felt this way (even if it wasn't ADHD). This book is my newest hyper fixation/obsession and I won't be getting over it anytime soon

Was this review helpful?

4.5

i stalled for a couple of days about 25% of the way in; there was less of rake’s pov as lizzie reels and realizes she’s pregnant. i am here to tell you to KEEP ON GOING. the switching between lizzie and rake works to the story’s advantage; while i think lizzie is a rich and exciting character, she is kind of draining and at times frustrating to read about (at least at first), so throwing things to rake and his thoughts helps balance the energy out … and there IS a strong sense of balance as things progress. great spice, and i did like lizzie and rake’s relationship more than harper and dan’s!

#netgalley

Was this review helpful?

This one is a little hard to review, so I will get the good stuff out of the way!

I love the cover, and I love the ADHD rep (I too cannot take meds without the side effects). I also loved Lizzie’s promiscuous personality.

Both characters were wonderful in their own way but Lizzie took the cake with her fun and spunky self. I really enjoyed the storyline and wow my heart melted so many times near the end when she was being taken care of by Rafe with her pregnancy. So adorable.

Now, the so-so stuff.

I KNOW the main thing about this whole book was that they both gain insta lust for each other and have the best sex of their lives for two nights in order for the whole surprise pregnancy ball to get rolling, but ughh I feel like it was just so. Insta lovey. So boring. So corny. So sappy. Maybe I’m just not personally fond of these tropes, so whatever! I think many people will love this book!

Was this review helpful?

Mazey Eddings does such a beautiful job curating these endearing and wonderful characters with ADHD and Anxiety. I absolutely busted out laughing so many times! This book was so fun, witty and honest! We'll be hand selling her books like crazy!

Was this review helpful?

Main character Lizzie has ADHD and Eddings portrays her and her diagnosis in a genuine and loving way. I really appreciate that Lizzie's ADHD is recognized as part makes her a wonderful person instead of a quirky character trait.

Lizzie and Rake's one night-turned two night stand leads to unexpected circumstances that set the stage for a delightful story of friendship, love, and acceptance. I adore this book.

Was this review helpful?

MAZEY EDDINGS!!!!! WOW. What can I say other than after finishing A Brush with Love, I had to get my hands on this novel. This book was the perfect follow-up to Harper and Dan's story. I'm a sucker for series that involve interconnected friend groups. Lizzie Blake was such a fun character and getting to showcase the good, bad, and ugly of adult ADHD, especially in a woman was amazing. Rake was SO lovable and easy to root for; he was literally a golden retriever character and I loved him so much. This book felt like pure SUNSHINE and the pregnancy trope was adorable and well-executed and it was overall such a blast to read. Quick, easy, amazing neurodiverse representation, and made me feel all warm and fuzzy. I am so glad I didn't have to wait all the way until September for this so thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for this ARC!!

Was this review helpful?

Read this if you:
•have ever doubted yourself
•feel like social norms try to dim your light
•have ADHD or want to know more about it

Two-night stand turned her life upside down and now Lizzie finds herself living with her baby daddy platonically who moved across the ocean to help co-parent. This book was great. It shed a lot of light on ADHD and how the brain works. It discussed touchy family relationships. Great rom-com that touches on deep subject matters in a good way.

Thank you NetGalley & St Martins Press for the eARC in exchange for an honest review. Pub date: Sept 6

Was this review helpful?

thank you to netgalley and st martins press for an ARC of this book!

3.5 stars

this book was adorable. i loved Lizzie and how confident she was in herself. Rake was super nice- he didn't have much personality, but he was likable nonetheless. this was centered around a trope i don't really love (accidental pregnancy) which contributed to the lower rating. this book was a great way to pass time, but overall pretty average.

Was this review helpful?

Lizzie and Rafe were just a pure joy to read about. I am obsessed with Mazey Eddings and everything she writes and this one was pure gold!

Lizzie has ADHD and is a whirlwind of things which makes it hard to keep a job for long. She craves human touch and connection and finds that satisfaction by going on dates and having sex without the commitment of a relationship. Then she meets Rafe this sexy Australian who makes her feel all the things. He is in town for a business trip and Rafe and Lizzie enjoy their time together. However, Lizzie soon realizes that their time together will bond them for longer than she ever expected.

Mazey Eddings has an amazing knack for writing beautiful, complex neuro diverse characters and the most amazing men who love them just the way they are. This book tackled so many hard topics and issues such as ADHD and ableism and the self doubt that is created when living a life full of people telling you that you are too much. I am not sure I have ever teared up so much throughout as a book as I did this one at the pure pain I felt in reading about how Lizzie saw herself. It honestly fractured my heart. But then there was Rafe who loved her wholly and completely. I loved how Lizzie and Rafe helped each other find what they needed most in a partner to help them find parts of themselves.

And Dan...oh Dan. I am Dental Dan's number 1 fan after ABWL and he and Harper make some guest appearances in this book that just melted every last part of my heart. Dan and Lizzie's friendship is truly perfection and it made me fall in love with him all over again.

This book is beautiful and wonderful and a must read for anyone who has ever been told they are "too much" . This one will have you tearing up from the dedication page but man, what a great read. This book is also hilarious and steamy and all the things that make you just love Mazey and her writing. I would highly recommend checking this one out!

HUGE thanks to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for allowing me to read an advanced copy of this one in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to live in Rake and Lizzie’s world for so many more chapters. They were hysterical and also so so endearing. This was the perfect follow up to A Brush With Love, and I will read any book Mazey writes!!!,

Was this review helpful?

Lizzie Blake's Best Mistake follows Lizzie as she seeks to live her best life while navigating the pitfalls of adult ADHD. There is some beautiful writing in this book; with great imagery and word usage that paints a picture of the characters and the sights and sounds and smells in a very appealing and readable way.
I'll admit, that for at least the first third of this book, I found Lizzie to be fairly irritating. I felt like she used her ADHD to justify decisions that she consciously made even when she knew they were bad decisions when she made them, and she refused to use any of the "tools" suggested to her to help her steer clear of her common "mistakes". Still, I was rooting for her the entire time. Once she started using those tools, taking more responsibility for her own actions, and the story delves a little more deeply into her life, I did come to like her more, although I still found her quite selfish at times.
Overall, I give this book 3.5 stars. I liked it, but did not love it. I would read more by this author as I liked her writing style.
I received an advanced review copy of this book for free from NetGalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This was another amazing book from Mazey Eddings. I initially was interested in this book just because I loved A Brush with Love so much. But then I realized it had an accidental pregnancy and my interest dipped a little - it’s just not a trope I typically enjoy very much. I also struggled at the beginning of the book with the descriptions of Lizzie’s “mistakes” and “messiness.” My anxious type-A rule-following people-pleasing self was so uncomfortable imagining a person being late for work and getting fired for mistakes and doing embarrassing things in public. But on the flip side, I was also enamored with Lizzie’s ability to make quick connections with people. I just couldn’t help but love her and could practically hear all of her giggling as I was reading! Rake was a great hero. He was so dazzled with Lizzie and so driven by his desire to care for her, even when he couldn’t understand his own emotions. I loved all of the silly, funny and awkward moments just as much as I loved the vulnerable ones where Rake and Lizzie took a step in trusting one another. Thank you, Mazey Eddings, for writing this beautiful love story with a neurodiverse heroine (Lizzie has ADHD). I appreciate any opportunity I have to learn about people who are different from me and I’m enjoying the chance to reflect on the ways I interact with all of the wonderfully unique people I have in my own life. If you love funny yet thought-provoking romance novels, and if you enjoyed A Brush with Love, definitely check this one out when it comes out this fall!

Was this review helpful?

Fair warning, this book is incredibly sexual. Not your typical romcom with a sex scene... like a ton of sex straight from the beginning, barely knowing the characters. I almost dnfed because that is not my kind of book, but the book had fantastic reviews so I kept reading. While it did calm down further into the book, this one wasn't for me.

Was this review helpful?

I requested this as soon as I finished Eddings' debut, A Brush with Love, and WOW, this book did not disappoint. I loved learning more about Lizzie, but that our re-appearing characters were not a huge part of the story. This book felt different from the first in a really good way--if felt like it embodied Lizzie and Rake's story instead of just being an extension of the same voice/story, which you sometimes see in second books. I highly recommend this book. I loved it!!

Was this review helpful?

I loved “Lizzie Blake’s Best Mistake”! Mazey Eddings has crafted the sweetest summer beach read and I am excited to get this on my shelves.

Was this review helpful?

"If yellow was a sound, he thought, it would be her laugh. Bright and booming, warm and joyful. Different varieties ranging from sunbeams and lemon zest to the soft puffs of golden wattle."


I have so much to say about this book. I've been trying to find the best word to describe the reading experience, and I think it comes down to a FUN read. Very few books have made me laugh out loud, but this was undoubtedly one of them. This book changed my mindset on the pregnancy trope and took such a new and unique take on the plotline. Not only does Mazey Eddings build up the characters throughout the story, but she makes them some of the most loveable characters from the start. One of the main characters, Lizzie, has always struggled with her ADHD and has been told by everyone that she was too chaotic, unrestrained, and overwhelming. I love how throughout the novel, we get to watch Lizzie try new strategies and skills to help her executive functioning. Rake and Lizzie demonstrate how far love and support can impact someone's life which I believe is a great message to convey to as many people as possible. I look forward to seeing this book on the shelves and I have no doubt it will be a hit!

Was this review helpful?

Synopsis: Lizzie Blake is a woman known for having one-night stands. She’s an avid baker, but constantly late for work, and is just trying to keep her latest job. Lizzie has a two-night stand with a drop-dead gorgeous man named Rake. He happens to be Australian and heading back to his native land soon. Shortly after Rake arrives back in Australia, Lizzie gets some unexpected news. She knows she has to tell Rake, but is worried for how he’ll take the life-altering news. Read this funny, romantic, heartwarming novel to find out what happens between Lizzie and Rake!


To say I loved this book is an understatement! Mazey Eddings hit it out of the park with this one. It was such a fun read and I fell in love with Lizzie and Rake from the beginning! This is an easy 5 ⭐️ review!

Was this review helpful?

This book caught me by surprise. At first, I was having a hard time connecting with Lizzie and her choices and not really feeling her two night stand with Rake, but then they were faced with real life decisions and they way they grew from it turned the book around completely for me. It started rooting for them, and understanding Lisa if a bit better. The was an endearing romance with great character development. I would decir read more in the series.

Was this review helpful?

I had just finished reading A Brush With Love the week before and this sequel is so different, yet amazing! First, Mazey Eddings did such an amazing job addressing ADHD and the daily struggles that Lizzie faces managing her mental health. The dual perspectives with Rake and Lizzie are hilarious, they also don't feed into the typical miscommunication trope with duo POVs. It definitely didn't focus on her relationships with her friends other than the beginning, but I really like how their timelines line up throughout the story. This also a very steamy one so if that's not your thing, you may want to skip a good couple dozen pages

Was this review helpful?