Cover Image: A Christmas Candy Killing

A Christmas Candy Killing

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

his was a decent cozy mystery. I did find it predictable, though. I definitely could have done without the book about a chocolate shop talking so much about how the characters don’t want to get fat.

Was this review helpful?

This is a great debut novel and if you are a fan of Joanna Fluke and Laura Childs then this is the series for you. Alex and Hannah are identical twins that own Murder and Mayhem, a mystery bookshop that sells their famous poison themed chocolates only now there really is a killer on the loose. Alex's neighbor Jane tells her that there really is a murderer from a true crime show hiding in their village. Alex is worried about the confession and tries to keep it on the downlow but unfortunately Jane also told the town gossip about it. Things escalate quickly and Jane is found dead with a box of chocolates from Alex's store near her. When the sheriff discovers that Alex is a beneficiary in Jane's will she becomes prime suspect number one. Can Alex solve the murder before she winds up in jail?

Was this review helpful?

Chocolate and murder in a Christmas mystery? I couldn't resist! In the book store Alex and Hannah ran, I was enchanted by their poison-themed chocolates and books. As a fan of true crime shows, I enjoyed A Christmas Candy Killing's inclusion of Jane, a retired woman convinced that there was a killer in their community.

Even though there were many characters to keep track of in this small town and there was a lot of gossip, I enjoyed it. A fast-paced book. Alex soon became a suspect following Jane's murder. Despite this, Alex does not hold back when it comes to catching a killer before Christmas.

Thank you Crooked Lane Books and Netgalley for a copy of this this book. This was a honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I'd probably do a 3.5/5; this one grew on me as it went on.

It felt really great to actually read a Christmas book at the start of the season instead of the weird not-thriller I wound up with on Christmas Eve last year. I have to say I adore the cover; it helped put me in a cozy Christmas space. Also, I think I quite like the mystery bookstore/chocolate shop idea. The recipes at the back actually have me pretty interested in giving chocolate making a go just for the heck of it.

I'm not sure I'm particularly enamored with any of the characters; I think the book's biggest mistake was in who we lost fairly early on. I had been expecting said person to be a staple character in the series and I think we would have really enjoyed them in that role.
There were a few lines that just threw me way off from some of the town residents and suspects; they were a bit too over the top. *cough* Netta *cough*
At times it seemed hard to believe how little an impact the death seemed to have in a tight knit community, but I have to remember that tending towards the ridiculous is kind of a real thing in small towns even if people are grieving... I lived in one for so long as the daughter of one of the funeral directors. I should know better than most!

I noticed a lot of reviews pointed out the book's pretty frequent jokes about weight. I'm caught in the middle here; I do think the author should find a different schtick going forward. But, it is part of a larger trend in the cozy genre we could stand to re-examine. I don't think there was any ill will, and I make cracks about how much I'm eating through the holidays all the time... it was more the ones about scales moving the wrong way that I think could be retooled more respectfully.

I think one setup was a bit obvious towards the end, and the twins could be weirdly blunt in their sleuthing at times- however I make that complaint about most of the cozies I read, and now that I'm trying to write one, ya know what? I get it.
If we make the characters going forward a bit more stand out I think this will be quite a solid series. I humbly suggest yeeting Duncan; the less cops in these books the better, and I can't stand the police love interest trope. It's at least like, 40% of cozies. It's true, you can google it

Since the mystery of this book was pretty solid; lots of questions, physical clues, inconsistencies, etc... I'll probably be back for more of this series. I may even come back and round this up to a 4... it needs to marinate

Shoutout to NetGalley and the author for providing me with an e-ARC to read in exchange for honest review, and Merry Christmas!

Was this review helpful?

This series introduction is set in a shop that sells books and chocolate- my favorite things! I would have enjoyed the book just for the cleverly named (after poisons) chocolates but the mystery and characters were also interesting.

I expected some obvious cozy mystery tropes to happen, given the setup, but the story went in different directions- yay! And no love triangle!

I'd recommend this as a fun, solid cozy mystery.

Was this review helpful?

⭐⭐⭐⭐ -- Great cover on this one!

This was a decent start to the <b>Killer Chocolate</b> series. The writing was good. It was well paced. I really love the setting. Especially a mystery bookstore that sells handmade chocolates named after poisons. I thought that was quite original! The plot was engaging and kept me guessing with plenty of suspects and red herrings. Alex is a good main sleuth, and the secondary characters are likable. And of course, it wouldn't be a cozy without a few recipes to end us off! I look forward to diving into the next book in this series. 👍🏻👍🏻

**ARC Via NetGalley**

Was this review helpful?

Alex convinces her twin Hanna to leave their parents shop in PA and open up a new venture in a small Montana town--a way for both to start fresh. The store, Murder and Mayhem, does well with its' focus on mystery books and candies based on real poisons that Hanna creates. One of the older residents, Jane, loves mysteries and true crime podcasts. As a regular at the store, she tells Alex she thinks someone in their small community is on the run after she listens to a new podcast. When she is found murdered, Alex is named beneficiary and number one suspect. This was a good read, with great characters, sense of place and twisty murder trail.

Was this review helpful?

This is a fun cozy mystery with emphasis on cozy. There is really no gruesome details at all and no suspense until the very end. It is a good debut effort. It will appeal to readers who like bookstore settings as the heroine owns one. It will also appeal to foodies as delicious candies are involved, some deadly though not by initial design.

Romeril's writing style is good and kept me engaged. There is mostly an emphasis on character discussion, such as trying to find out one's history, in the course of amateur sleuthing. There are plenty of suspects and a few red herrings to keep the mystery going. And I was happy to see recipes included for the most delicious sounding treats.

This will be an author to watch for more tantalizing cozy mysteries.

I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really fun start to a series, For a series to start off at the holidays, well that is a win win for me. I love middle aged protagonists, the fact that they were twin sisters made it more fun. I was really sad by the characters that were victims in this story, usually in cozies its unknown characters.

I had a suspicion of the who dunnit but not the true why. Obviously, there was something to hide, but I was shocked when revealed. It reminds me a lot of my best friend and I watching the ID channel and talking about the stories.

I will definitely continue on with this series.

I wasn't taken with the narration to start but it got so much better once the story took off.

Was this review helpful?

What a great book to kick off the start of my holiday reading!

I have been pining for this book ever since the cover reveal on Instagram. I mean seriously, how cute is it with the Christmas decorations and chocolates? Adorable!

This is the first in a new cozy mystery series and I really enjoyed the setting of a bookstore/chocolate shop. As much as I love a good bookstore/bakery/coffee shop, this was a fun twist that I really liked. And I appreciated the inclusion of instructions of how to make your own chocolates at the end!

Overall I really enjoyed the story. I liked the way the mystery unraveled and event though I did figure out who the killer was before the sleuth did, I still found myself enjoying the reveal. If I'm being honest, the setting and the vibes are really what did it for me with this book. I loved the small town and Alex and Hanna's shop so much.

This was a solid first in a new series and I do plan on picking up the future books. I saw on instagram that the author (who is Canadian, which is always a bonus for me) is currently working on the third book which is also Christmas themed and I am SO excited about that!

Thank you so much to Netgalley and Crooked Lane Books for providing me with an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I always enjoy a cute Christmas cozy, so I was excited to see this one become available on NetGalley, it is the first in a new series by Christina Romeril.
While I enjoyed the two sisters, I felt it moved a little slow, but I feel that way about most first in series, I’m curious to see how this series develops as it continues.
I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book, all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

There is promise in this debut but when the amateur sleuth goes around blantantly asking people where they were the night of the murder, shows there are opportunities where some hard editing could have been made. I really wanted to love this being as it's the author's debut novel, but the writing needed to be flushed out more and futher editing. Because of this, it was hard to fully enjoy the story.

Was this review helpful?

This debut novel in a delectable new cozy mystery series will surely put fans in the mood for Christmas and chocolate.

"A Christmas Candy Killing" is the first book in a delicious new cozy mystery series, "Killer Chocolate," by Christina Romeril. The main characters, Alex and Hanna, are warm, curious, and capable sleuths but the small Montana village and its residents are real gems. Despite the murder, it's sure to put readers in a holiday spirit.

The action begins quickly, with the murder occurring within the first couple of chapters. With Christmas only days away, the sheriff is pushing to successfully close the case before the holiday and make up her mind right away on who's to blame. As Alex is a prime suspect, trying to clear her name justifies her determined snooping. I thought it was fun and pretty realistic that the people she questioned were not shy about telling her to butt out. It happened often enough that you could play a drinking game involving taking a shot every time one of the characters told Alex to "mind your own business" or similar. It wouldn't take long for all participants to find themselves in a stupor. Fun times. But Alex is focused and thick-skinned enough to barrel on ahead.

There is an entertaining subplot involving Alex, her neighbor, Tom, and Penelope Shaw, the single (again) woman who lives across the street from them and views Alex as her rival for Tom's affections. I laughed out loud over Alex's dream that featured Penelope and one of her frozen casseroles.

With an engaging amateur sleuth and several plausible red herrings with excellent motives for mischief, I recommend A CHRISTMAS CANDY KILLING to cozy mystery readers who enjoy culinary-themed stores, settings in small-town Montana, or chocolate. (Recipes for some of Hanna's delectable handmade treats are included.)

Was this review helpful?

Dollycas’s Thoughts

Killer Chocolates and mysteries are what you will find at twin sisters Alex and Hanna’s Murder and Mayhem shop in Harriston, Montana. With names like Strychnine Strawberry, Ricin Raspberry Creams, Cotton Candy Coniine, and Veronal Vanilla Cream, the candies are flying out the door as Christmas approaches. While these poison theme candies have fun names, and no poison is used in the creations there may be a real killer nearby. Alex’s elderly friend Jane watches every true crime television show she can. She tells Alex that she knows one of the killers she has seen on television is living in Harriston. She confesses she also told her friend Nessa, who has never met a piece of gossip she hasn’t spread. Alex reluctantly agrees to visit Jane the next day to watch the program.

When Alex arrives at Jane’s house the next day she finds Jane dead . . . with a box of Killer Chocolates too close for comfort.

Alex is beside herself when she is named as a suspect along with a handyman, Zach who did a lot of work for Jane. Hanna knows she is innocent and she believes Zach is too. She just needs to prove it and fast. She has no desire to spend the holiday behind bars.

This new series is off to a fabulous start.

I really like these twin sisters. Alex runs the book part of the shop and Hanna makes the chocolate creations, but they crossover to help each other and work with the customers because most usually leave the place with a least one book and a box of candy. Their relationship is comfortable and relatable. Alex has a real knack for getting people to open up to her especially if she is offering candy. These characters are well-developed for the first book in the series. Ms. Romeril has left plenty of room for them to continue to evolve as the series continues though.

The author took the first couple of chapters to introduce readers to Alex, Hanna, and their dog Miss Watson. We also meet their neighbor Pastor Tom Kennedy, Penelope Shaw, a divorcee, who lives across the street from Tom, and her sights on him as her next husband, Duncan Fletcher who dated Hanna for about 2 months and then he put her in the friend zone and Gary, owner of Harriston Bloom greenhouse. These characters as well as others we meet in the story are all cleverly crafted.

The mystery was very well-plotted. I really enjoyed the way Alex attacked her investigation. Her former career in banking for 20 years gave her the instincts and knowledge needed to be a pretty good amateur sleuth. I was delighted to follow along with her step by step as she worked through the clues. A key piece of evidence reveals the truth she was looking for and everything started to fall into place. The ending was exciting. I loved the way it played out with a surprising hero.

What more could you want? Candy and books are what this girl loves and to have them both in one place is Perfect!

A Christmas Candy Killing was such an entertaining cozy. With characters I can’t wait to visit again, a sweet mystery, a unique theme, a fun setting, and humor in all the right places, this book is A Perfect Escape. I am excited about the next Killer Chocolate Mystery.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars
I enjoyed the mystery and loved the poison-themed chocolates. A perfect treat while browsing in a mystery bookshop. I didn't warm up to the characters immediately but by the end I was invested. I did think Tom moved on a little fast from his wife's passing. Overall, it was a good read and I'll probably watch for the next in the series.

Was this review helpful?

A pair of sisters looking into a murder suspect to clear one's name. A cozy mystery that has you eager to figure out what comes next. Look forward to seeing what comes next in the series.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this one! Alex and Hanna are endearing protagonists, and I enjoyed following their journey in solving the mystery. I wish we got more of Hanna, but I think that will be fixed in the subsequent books. I loved the setting and the mystery. It was well paced and well plotted. I cannot wait for book 2!

Was this review helpful?

"If we want that window replaced in the bathroom at the shop, we'd better find the real killer."

This new cozy mystery series is pretty basic. Twin sisters run a mystery bookshop that also sells poison themed (not poisonous) chocolates. Like most basic of cozy mystery businesses, the bookshop is only open from 9-5 and one of the owners can be gone for hours at a time playing Nancy Drew. Alex is shocked that the shop is busy on the Saturday before Christmas, yet leaves to go do her own shopping in another town.

I didn't really like this book. It was slow. Alex and her sister are mid-40s but honestly acted like retirees. The Nancy Drew sleuthing was also very basic, mostly consisting of asking point blank questions to people like, "oh nice to see you Mary. So what's your alibi for Monday night? Also, did you change your name when you moved here? Any ex-spouses we should know about? Thanks for shopping with us! See you soon!!" I also didn't enjoy all the barbs at people's weight when making or eating sweets.

This exchange totally cracked me up and sums up the main character pretty well:
Alex: "I'm sure I'll be fine. Not that many people know what I'm doing."
Tom: "The whole village probably knows what you're up to. If the killer doesn't, it's because they've left town or they're in a coma."

*I received an advance copy of this book from NetGalley and the publisher and I am required to disclose that in my review in compliance with federal law.

Was this review helpful?

I love the idea of twin sisters owning a mystery bookshop called Murder and Mayhem that also sells their famous poison themed candy chocolates. Another thing that was fun for me is their mother lives and owns her own shop that is in my home state and knew the city that was mentioned. There's a lot of fun and cozy Christmas mentioning. I did enjoy a handful of characters from this small close knit community. I did feel this was a little slow for my taste but I look forward seeing where the author takes us in the second book.

Thank you NetGalley for an early review copy.

Was this review helpful?

ARC received for an honest review

Welcome back to Little Italy and the D'angelos.

I think I put on about 5kg just reading this book, thinking of the delicious Italian food.

I liked getting back to them all, and seeing Chloe D'Angelo get her HEA - even if it does take a little while and a few wrong turns to get there.

Loved the protective vibe from the big brothers (even though in real life I would feel like Chloe and hate that they do it). I adored that she and Dante finally work on the feelings they have had for each other. Loved that they finally told the brothers to back off.

I want to be part of this family so bad (and not just for the cannoli!)

Looking forward to seeing which D'Angelo gets their happy next

Was this review helpful?