Beautifully qeitten as always from Courtney Summers, but not what I was expecting. Slow at times, so felt like it dragged too often.

Set in same world as Sadie, but not a sequel or companion novel.

Very hard topics, but dealt with so carefully.

'm the Girl by Courtney Summers is a gripping and intense novel that tackles important themes, but it didn’t fully capture me as I had hoped. The writing is clear and the story is well-paced, with a strong central mystery that kept me reading. However, some parts of the plot felt a bit predictable, and I struggled to connect deeply with the characters at times.

That said, Summers does a good job of handling sensitive topics, and the book certainly has its moments of tension and reflection. It’s an interesting read for those who enjoy dark, psychological thrillers, but it didn’t leave a lasting impression for me.

A raw, haunting YA thriller exploring ambition, exploitation, and survival. I flew through this in one sitting!

When I saw that Courtney summers wrote another novel, I know I needed to get my hands on it. After slicing sadie I was so excited, for a new banger. And unfortunately it wasn’t that great for me.
The ending fell flat for me. I was left with questions.
My rating would be a 2.5 but on here it is rounded up to a 3.

Courtney Summers has a talent for crafting raw, emotionally intense stories, and I’m the Girl is no exception. Much like Sadie, this novel dives deep into themes of power, exploitation, and the brutal realities of girlhood, all wrapped in Summers’ signature sharp, immersive prose.

The story follows Georgia, a 16-year-old girl who stumbles upon the body of a murdered girl and is soon drawn into a world of wealth, privilege, and predatory darkness. Summers captures Georgia’s naivety and desperation with heartbreaking precision, making her both frustrating and deeply sympathetic. The novel's atmosphere is tense and unsettling, with a slow-burn mystery that simmers beneath its deeply emotional core.

While I appreciated the novel’s unflinching honesty, some aspects of the pacing felt uneven, and the resolution, though fitting, left me wanting just a bit more. That said, I’m the Girl is a haunting, thought-provoking read that lingers long after the last page. If you loved Sadie for its intensity and hard-hitting themes, this one is definitely worth reading.

Riveting, but also terrifying. I was hooked into this story's claws, but didn't feel as much for its characters as I have for characters in Summers' previous novels. The ending felt off as well. I'd still recommend this one, but go in knowing there is no neat, tidy ending or really any answers here.

"I'm the Girl" by Courtney Summers delivers a gritty and intense coming-of-age thriller, perfect for when you're too tired to tackle anything overly complex but still want something gripping. Georgia Avis's journey through a world of wealth and power feels raw and unfiltered, peeling back layers of privilege to reveal unsettling truths. While the narrative draws you in with its emotional depth and realistic portrayal of a young woman grappling with harsh realities, it sometimes feels heavy-handed with its message. Georgia's alliance with Nora adds both tension and heart, offering a glimpse of hope amid the darkness. Although not every moment lands perfectly, Summers's storytelling compels you to confront uncomfortable questions about society's power dynamics. If you've got the energy for a challenging yet rewarding read, this book might be what you need to shake off the haze of daily life.

So so engaging!!!!! The characters were well fleshed out and the writing style was very easy to get through. Courtney Summers always writes the heart pounding and twisty plots out there. Love love loved this.

Courtney Summer’s novel I’m the Girl follows sixteen year old Georgia. One day she finds the body of a murdered thirteen year old girl named Ashley. Georgia agrees to help Nora, Ashley’s sister, catch the killer. At the same time, Georgia sets her sights on following her dreams. Both of these things land Georgia in a dangerous situation.

Honestly this book was 100% not what I thought it was going to be. I did not really care for the plot, characters, or pacing. I think Summers is a skilled author with polished writing, but this book fell short. The plot just did not sit right with me. It also felt like nothing was happening, then everything at once, then nothing at the end too.

I appreciate that the author was attempting to address complex topics like beauty standards, predatory power structures, the patriarchy, etc. I just do not quite think a clear message or conclusion was drawn in the end.

The only things I enjoyed about this novel were how quickly I finished it and the sapphic aspect. Even then, I was not super invested or interested.

If you tend to enjoy books by Courtney Summers, maybe you would still want to check this one out. (Definitely look up content warnings prior.) However, The Project was a better read. I have also heard Sadie is a good one, so I am still interested in checking out that book at some point too.

Thank you to Wednesday Books/St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for giving me the chance to read and review this novel.

Courtney Summers writes phenomenal suspense. Loved this book. Kept me guessing page after page. I was looking forward to this after reading Sadie and while I think I still like that book more, I'm the Girl comes in a very close second to me. Will definitely read more from this author.

I'm The Girl by Courtney Summers didn't disappoint. I loved everything about it. Thank to you NetGalley for the ARC!

This is a dark YA thriller that makes you wonder if you ever know who you can trust. The story takes you into the darker side of the rich and privileged. And what predators can look like the suspecting.

I liked most of the story, but it’s definitely not my favorite Courtney summers novel. This story showcases things some young women face which follows suite with other books written by Courtney Summers. This is something I always liked about her writing. She’s not afraid to write about the uncomfortable.

I found I enjoyed reading this one more than listening to the audiobook. I had to increase the speed of the audiobook to enjoy the listening experience.

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the arc. All thoughts and feelings are my own.

I've said before and I'll say it again -- Courtney Summers is one of the best YA mystery/thriller authors out there, and she gets better and better with each book. Her characters and stories are always so full of depth!

I have always enjoyed Courtney Summers and this was another gripping novel! Truly can be enjoyed by teens and adults.

Not my fave Summers but I do really like the way the author spins her stories. I’ve since moved on from YA books in general so I wonder if I’d like it more if I did read YA still.

Courtney Summers does it again with her unflinching and searing critique of the very society that regularly allows for the brutalization of the most vulnerable among us. I especially appreciated Courtney's refusal to shave down Georgia's character for the comfort of the audience. I'm The Girl is a powerhouse novel that will have us all facing the uncomfortable reality of why we support certain survivors while leaving others to the wolves.

Sadie was so good, I don't understand how this could be so bad? Self indulgent and just, zero nuance.

The main character never really clicked with me. The mystery left me a little confused like I had missed something. I was hoping to enjoy this more.

What and uncomfortably fantastic book. I can't say this was a particularly enjoyable read, but it was necessary. It's a timely and provocative story of abuse and so much more. The main character Georgia wasn't exactly likable, but she was raw and real and wholly imperfect, in all the best ways. Both her naivety and her strong awareness of the power of her looks played essential roles in this story.

Even though this is an incredibly important kind of story and Courtney Summers is a brilliant writer, I did bump it down a star because they story didn't click for me as much as Sadie did. Parts were a little bit clunky and I questioned the characters' choices more than once.

This book was so good but damn, it was rough. I hope those girls ended up with a happier ending than they got.