Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Pure fun! This story has a couple thrown into the world of child care and instant family. After a terrible tragedy Colby & Rip are forced into parenting her best friend and his sister’s kids. There are emotional topics in the story that could be heavy but are in handled in a lighthearted way that doesn’t pull down the entertaining focus of the story. Neither Colby nor Rip have much experience with child rearing and being thrust into parenthood is a lot for both. Plus there’s the history between the two that didn’t end well. Yup, certainly no love lost between these two that are now joined in this new circumstance. One unfortunate incident changes everything between the new parents and the romance blooms. Throw in the cute kiddos and it’s light-hearted fun as this family gels in the best way. Worth the read!

Was this review helpful?

I didn't get to download this but I've read a bit of the book and it's romance perfection! Definitely recommend to any romance lovers out there!

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This books was so cute and amazing! I really really loved it! And it was one of the best I love Rachel Van Dyken writing! And this was not exception🥰
This book was everything and it was really cute and I can’t wait to read more from RVD!

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars

Colby and Rip are forced into parenthood when their sister and best friends die in a horrible accident, leaving their two young children behind.

While I enjoyed this one, and flew through it, there were several things that I couldn't overlook. For one, it was a little too similar to the movie Life As We Know It with Katherine Heigl and Josh Duhamel.
The tension between Colby and Rip felt juvenile for a reason that (in my opinion) wasn't a big deal, and definitely wouldn't excuse their interactions that were just plain mean. Rip was supposed to be grumpy, but he came off more pompous than endearing.
There was also an event at the end that seemed unnecessary and didn't add anything to the story.

Despite these things, it had some funny and very real parenting moments that I found myself laughing out loud at.

Maybe my expectations were too high or misplaced, because a lot of people loved this one. I would still recommend it to someone looking for a fun enemies to lovers with a parenthood twist.

Thanks to Forever Pub and Netgalley for the complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Ok, so I know this review is a little late but I’d like to thank Netgalley as well as the publisher for giving me an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest review!

3.5

If you were a fan of Life As We Knew It this book is for you. This book was cute and fluffy( but also made me tear up multiple times). I did really enjoy this book, I thought the mmc was pretty unlikeable for the first 40% of the book but I’m a sloot for for a good book boyfriend and can forgive just about any behaviour. And once we started being nice he was very likeable!

I could have done without all of the tiktok references. That’s just a personal opinion though. And I did feel like the book wrapped up way to fast. The third act incident (no third act break-up) happened at like 94%. It was VERY fast.

Overall I would recommend giving it a read

Was this review helpful?

I had high expectations for this book and can confidently say it beat my expectations! I loved her other books “the matchmakers playlist” and “the matchmakers replacement” both amazing books! This book intrigued me mostly by the author but then I found it reminded me of the movie “ life as we know it” which is one of my favorites! The author did so amazing with the character development for even the side characters! Banks was my favorite! I just wish he ended up with someone other than heather and wish I could have read another book on his love story. Rachel van dyken has become in instant buy for me from now on! I had been originally planning on getting this book the day it came out to treat myself after my procedure. I ended up getting the arc on NetGalley from forever (grand central publishing) and I don’t think I’ve screamed with happiness so much before! Even though I have read this book on NetGalley I know I don’t need the paperback copy but do I want to get one after loving it so much…? YES!!!!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a funny and yet had plenty of emotional moments. Rip and Colby’s bickering and hate/love relationship was so cute and I loved it. I love how both of them came to realize that they cared for each of and were able to move past their “hate”. I also loved how they tackled grief, not just their own but that of the kids. It was a fun read with fun characters and witty banter.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute book! I really liked the romance between Rip and Colby. The children were downright adorable. I enjoyed the banter and the overall hilarity among the members of this disfunctional family. I could literally picture the movie Life As We Know It as I read the book. Unfortunately, the needing fell a little flat for me. I thought it was a bit rushed and would have liked to see about 50 more pages in order to rate this higher.

Was this review helpful?

thank you netgalley and forever grand central publishing for an eARC of this book.
i am genuinely so happy right now. this book had me smiling, laughing, and crying. rip and colby are some of my new favorite characters and the connection they shared with each other and with ben and viera was so precious. this book was great and i loved that it was dual pov. the whole premise of this book was that two enemies become coparents to their best friends children and they start to become a family with each other after a tragedy. the family bonding and healing that happened was very fulfilling and made my heart very happy and i loved the build up. please read this book :)

Was this review helpful?

After a tragic accident, Rip is named guardian of his niece and nephew. What he didn’t expect was that his sister and best friend had also named Colby as a guardian. They could not be more opposite, or more out of control. While they juggle grief and their animosity towards each other, the years old sparks start to rekindle.

This was an absolute delight, even though I got fully red and puffy because of how often I cried. This straddles the line between feel good romance and tragedy with so much grace. The grieving that each of the characters goes through felt so genuine.

I’m a sucker for hilarious kids in books, and Ben and Viera were two wild children with so much love in their hearts. Hearing them talk about their family made me sob - sometimes in sadness, but a lot of the time because of how dang sweet they are.

I understand that Heather represents a different path for Rip, but her character felt unnecessary to me. I thought Colby and Rip had enough friction without her adding to the mix.

This is a clear your sinuses kind of book, and I would recommend it wholeheartedly. Seriously, grab a box of tissues - you’ll need it.

Was this review helpful?

i really enjoyed this one! the godparent trap is about love, loss, and found family. i loved all the side characters, and the children?! stop it. adorable!! colby and rip are one of my favorites now, and rightfully so!! the ending felt a bit rushed, but all is forgiven bc we had an epilogue.

thank you so much to valentine PR and netgalley for the ARC!

4.5 🦋

Was this review helpful?

I was approved for this eARC after its scheduled pub day (07/19), but I am still very excited to read this nonetheless! My two book besties described this as the perfect Enemies-to-Lovers romcom with also plenty of depth & sensitive handling of some tough subject matter. I can’t wait to dive in!

Was this review helpful?

This story has it all. It was sweet. It was swoony. It was emotional and it even made me laugh. I enjoyed this story so much. Every Rachel van Dyken book I read makes me love her writing even more and this story was no different. I am so in love with these characters and found myself rooting for their happy ending. I loved being on their journey and seeing the way their relationship developed through out the book. I could not put it down. I absolutely cannot wait for more from this author and I can't wait to see what she has in store for us next.

Was this review helpful?

It's been a while since I've read a Rachel Van Dyken book. This sounded interesting so I decided to pick it up. Rip and Colby are thrown into an impossible and tragic situation. I really felt for them and what they were going through. They needed to work together and be there for their two godchildren. Rip and Colby are as opposite as you can get. So, seeing them trying to mesh was interesting. I did like the interactions with the children. That was nice to see. I just wanted more when it came to Rip and Colby. It was hard for me to really see how these two could be together. Towards the end I could see it though. There were good moments where I was really able to root for this instant family. It has fine writing and I was able to see the potential. I just wanted more.

*There are some triggers so readers should pay attention to the warning.*

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick read, I wanted to read it mostly bc the synopsis reminded me so much of one of the movie “Life as we know it”.

The book for having such a heavy opening and dealing with grief was funny and I liked some characters but the characters and dialogues felt flat and weak. The main characters go from hate to love all of sudden, the way Rip treated Colby at the beginning was really harsh and suddenly he realizes he likes her they forget everything he said… that really didn't work for me.

Overall, It was ok, easy to read but it was shallow and it lacked development and I had no real investment towards any of the characters.


Thank you Netgalley for this ARC for an exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to share a super cute book that I read this week - The Godparent Trap by Rachel Van Dyken! Thank you @readforeverpub for the #giftedbook.

If you’ve ever seen the movie Life As We Know it, starring Katherine Heigl and Josh Duhamel, the plot will be similar. A couple tragically dies, leaving their kids to their godparents, Colby and Rip. Who happen to hate each other - but do they really? Colby is a bit of a mess and struggling adjusting to mom life and missing her best friend while caring for the two kids. Rip is anal and has a stick up his a$s and thinks Colby is ridiculous.

Let’s just say this book is #enemiestolovers at its finest, and will give you all the feels.

The Godparent Trap is available now, and if you are a romcom fan, go grab a copy!

Was this review helpful?

I don’t know how this talented author has written a book that makes me want to weep, and then this book makes me laugh…innovative story that reads like real life…quirky characters…family dynamics…amazing novel…could be a memoir…the book was sent to me by Netgalley for review… thanks to the publisher for the electronic review…a sad story that turns I to one that works…don’t miss this…

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this and recommend it. Colby is a food blogger and travels all the time. Rip is Colby's best friend's brother and is a staid, follow the rules, very structured accountant. They have always had a spark that typically resulted in them getting under each other's skin.

Slight spoiler alert- (it is on the back of the book and is the premise of the book)- Horribly, a tragic accident takes their best friend/sister and her husband, leaving Colby and Rip as co-guardians of two adorable, grieving kids.

This has such a perfect combination of poignant grief that comes in waves intertwined with laugh-out-loud humor as Colby and Rip figure out how to parent (yes, legos are evil!). It's a quick read, and I was both satisfied and sorry when it ended. I absolutely could have stayed in this world longer.

Thanks to the publisher for a copy. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I've not read this author before and didn't really know what to expect when I began The Godparent Trap. The subject matter had the potential to be fraught with emotion but looking at the cover of the novel, one could reasonably expect the story to be a lighthearted romcom. It was both...and so much more than I expected.

The launching point for this story is the sudden, tragic death of a young husband and wife, leaving behind two young children, along with a brother and best friend designated to care for them. A brother and best friend who are polar opposites, had one disastrous date years ago, and have been adversaries ever since. They don't like each other, don't understand each other, and can't deny the simmering attraction that simmers below the surface in spite of that. Throw them into an emotionally volatile situation where they have to live and work together to care for two kids and, oh yeah, it's going to be messy.

One of the things I most appreciated about this book was that Van Dyken didn't shy away from those messy emotions that are part and parcel of navigating grief. Some of the scenes were heartbreaking and took me straight back to my own grief after losing loved ones but others had me laughing out loud and elicited memories of doing the same in similar situations. The evolving relationship between Colby and Rip - and the children - was raw, real, hilarious in many parts, and poignant in others. Rip and Colby really were enemies in the beginning with the author using biting humor and disdain (especially on Rip's part) to bring that point home. Kudos to her for giving them no easy fixes, which would have been easy to do. Instead, she took them on a winding journey filled with real-life challenges, attitude adjustments, eye-opening experiences (having full responsibility for two young children will do that), heart-tugging romance, and a slow awakening of possibilities.

Both humor and emotional depth are strong in this story, one equally balanced by the other. The characters are well developed, relatable, and felt very authentic. I was fully invested in Colby, Rip (once he got rid of that stick up his...and we began to see his heart), the kids, and let's not forget Rip's self-appointed, chatty best friend, Banks, the architect of more than a few of the humorous scenes in this story. Everyone should have a best friend that invested in your happiness. I adored him.

I recommend adding The Godparent Trap to your summer reading list. Keep the tissues handy but be prepared for plenty of laughter too, along with a satisfying HEA and some surprises along the way.

4.5 stars
ARC received for fair and unbiased review

Was this review helpful?

This book was phenomenal! It was fast-paced and packed an emotional punch, which had me flying through well over half the story in one sitting. I loved Rip and Colby’s love story, watching them go from genuine dislike after a disastrous date to friendship and love as they struggle with the transition into parenthood. The death of Rip’s sister and best friend was shockingly emotional, which speaks to how well the book was written. Despite knowing the characters for one chapter before they died, I felt their loss acutely, and watching their children, as well as Rip and Colby, go through the process of grieving was heartbreaking. I love the found family that was created with Rip and Colby and the kids. The children in particular stood out to me. Each of them were distinctive and memorable, as well as surprisingly perceptive, which I really loved. As for Rip and Colby, I loved seeing how their relationship progressed, in all its opposites-attract perfection. Overall, this was a heartwarming romance that completely gripped me and did not let me go until I turned the final page.

Was this review helpful?