Skip to main content

Member Reviews

At times, this book gives Crazy Rich Asians vibes, but it is also very much its own thing. I enjoyed seeing Sharlot get to connect with her culture a bit more, and it was kind of neat to see the meddling parents thing get blown up a bit. The social media celebrity bit was...a thing, but made sense in context. A special shout-out to Sutanto for managing to address adult sexual identity in this novel as well, in a way that felt natural and somewhat progressive, considering.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved Dial A for Aunties so I was super excited to pick this one up. This one is definitely more on YA end and the beginning where our MCs get caught by their parents reminded me of the kids in Crazy, Stupid, Love. It felt crass and cringey honestly. It kinda put me off the book but my love for Dial A pushed me through.

It's written in multiple POV and the Asian dynamics were spot on! I loved learning about Indonesia - all the interesting places to visit and my mouth was watering thinking about all the food! I just had to keep reminding myself they're young and expected to make stupid decisions and be bratty and spoiled. I did enjoy the family dynamics! The banter is funny and I love the fake dating trope! The side characters are so fabulous!! Still it was mostly a fun and entertaining read!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun YA novel. I enjoyed Suranto’s books skewed towards an older population, but i truly liked this one!

Was this review helpful?

sweet fun YA read, some aspects reminded me of aunties and i like seeing them play out for teens (why do so many parents catfish LOL) both main characters are so sweet and funny

Was this review helpful?

I can honestly say I have not laughed as much as I did with this book, ever. This was my first Jesse Q. Sutanto book, and it for sure will not be the last. Sharlot's mom catches her in the act of almost having sex for the first time. As punishment, her mom whisks her off to Indonesia, where she grew up. Meanwhile, in Indonesia, George gets caught literally with his pants down by his father resulting in embarrassment and his phone being taken away. George's dad and Sharlot's mother think they are helping their children out by creating online profiles for their children and end up communicating with each other and setting up a date for the two to go on without their knowledge. What ensues is laugh out loud funny and one fun ride. Thank you, NetGalley, for the eARC. 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

Well, That Was Unexpected follows two teenagers who are forced into fake dating each other (wait for it) because their parents catfished each other. I’m not even joking. Our female lead, Sharlot, was caught by her mom almost having sex with her then-boyfriend, while our male lead, George, was caught masturbating by his dad and sister. After finding their children in these compromising positions, Sharlot’s mom and George’s dad both decide that they need to find their child the perfect significant other. George’s dad and sister take over George’s phone and on a whim decide to DM the fake profile that Sharlot’s mom set up to find the perfect boy. What results is a wild ride where Sharlot and George find themselves pressured to date each other, not knowing that the DMs they’ve used to get to know (and kind of loathe) one another were really just their parents bonding over the failure of the new generation.

I have to admit that I just saw Jesse Q Sutanto’s name on this tour and signed up without reading anything about the book. Going into this novel blind was an amazing experience because I had no idea what was going to happen. Was this going to be a love story for the kids or for the single parents? I have to commend Jesse for coming up with this premise because it is amazing.

Usually when a book describes itself as “laugh-out-loud”, I find myself disappointed with how little it actually makes me laugh. With Well, That Was Unexpected though, there were a few moments where I literally did laugh out loud, something that is rare for me when reading a book. Some of the scenes in this book are a bit absurd, and I’m not sure how realistic some of the dialogue is—do people really say ffs out loud as eff-eff-ess or blurt out things like “f*** your mom” without meaning to? Regardless, I can’t deny that I had a fun time reading it.

All of the characters in this book are both likable and realistically flawed. I honestly think I would have preferred for George to be more flawed, because I felt like most of the character growth fell on Sharlot’s shoulders. I also found myself at the epilogue wishing this book was longer by like 100 pages or so. I thoroughly enjoyed the fake-dating aspect of the novel and wanted to see more scenes with Sharlot and George fumbling over trying to be themselves while also being the online personas that their parents established. I did notice that this is listed as book one in an untitled series, so I’m excited to see what comes of it!

Was this review helpful?

Overall, it was a cute read! There were parts of this book that I really liked and got me hooked, and then parts that dragged on. The characters were funny, cute, and vibrant. Some unexpected twists were sprinkled in there, but I found the ending to be a little too convenient. I know it was a happy ending everyone would benefit from, but it just was "too perfect" (sorry if this sounds awfully cynical and pessimistic of me).

I was hooked into reading this because of the concept of two parents setting up the main characters by posing as them on their online accounts was so UNIQUE to me. I found this to be a cute YA read, especially with an emphasis on the focus of Chinese Indonesian culture.

Was this review helpful?

what a delightfully entertaining read! we are following george and sharlot, who are both found in compromising positions by their respective parents. sharlot is whisked away to indonesia for the summer and ends up in a fake dating relationship with george, after their parents set them up in a double-catfish situation. it was fun to watch these characters try to reconcile the person in front of them with the person that they met online and that created plenty of room for miscommunication. i really enjoyed seeing sharlot's cultural exploration as she gets to experience life in indonesia for the first time. jesse sutanto did a great job of making the reader feel immersed in this place, from the food descriptions (yum!) to the architecture of the city. pacing-wise, it takes a minute to get going, but once sharlot touches down in indonesia, it really picks up! this made for a great light read and i really enjoyed my time with these characters!

*thank you delacorte & netgalley for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute book! I was not expecting to like it as much as I did. It felt like a younger version of Crazy Rich Asians but with real life situations. I found the main characters to be a little young at certain points but when you think of being that age, it all makes sense. I was into every single twist and turn and rooting for the two of them. Highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

The premise sounded interesting (parents accidentally catfishing each other instead of their kids but the kids end up together anyway), but the execution missed the mark for me. The voice, especially Sharlot's, seemed like Sutanto was trying too hard to write "a teenager," and I didn't love Sharlot's character and personality for a good chunk of it. George sounded really nice though, and Eleanor stole the show! But overall, it just didn't do it for me. I would love to read Dial A For Aunties though!

(Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review. Any quotes are taken from an advanced copy and may be subject to change upon final publication.)

Was this review helpful?

OMG, this was amazing! This was hilarious and touching, so much fun to read, and I loved everything about it. I had to finish this in one sitting because I could not find a stopping point.

Was this review helpful?

There were parts of this book that I loved and parts that dragged on for me. Overall, it's a cute story and I liked the characters. There are a couple of unexpected twists and I liked how the ending wrapped everything up.

The concept of two parents setting up the main characters by posing as them on their online accounts was funny and led to them thinking they were completely different people when they met. It was fun to read along as they truly got to know each other.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very cute story about two teenagers whose parents catfishes them into meeting each other. I thought the plot was very unique, and although unrealistic, it was still very cute. While this is considered a YA book, it was definitely upper YA because of the language and other things throughout the story. I loved that parts were unpredictable and do recommend this one. If you are looking for a upper YA summer vacation read with fake dating, than this is your book!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Did someone say YA fake dating? With a hot nerdy boy? Complete with family bonding? If you said yes to any of those questions you are correct. If you said no you should still pick up this book.

Sharlot unexpectedly finds herself in Indonesia for the summer after her mother walks in on her in a compromised situation. Meanwhile, George is also caught in a compromising position, but by his father and sister. Their parents decide to do what any rational parent would do and decide to find their children a partner. The parents catfish each other and Sharlot and George end up fake dating for the summer.

I loved this book. I spent half the book obsessing over how much I loved George and Sharlot's relationship, and the other half wishing I was in Indonesia. Sutanto's writing made me feel like I was right alongside them in Jakarta and Bali (unfortunately, I was not actually there, but it sure felt like it).

The side characters were all perfect. I loved their interactions with each other and how they helped George and Sharlot grow. Speaking of character growth, their character arcs were stunning. I felt like a proud parent watching them. And there was some amazing family bonding. All those emotional conversations with parents had me reaching for the tissue box.

I absolutely loved this book and I hope you will check it out.

Was this review helpful?

In Well, That Was Unexpected Sharlot Citra's Chinese Indonesian mother catches her in a compromising position with her boyfriend and immediately takes her to Jakarta for the summer to get her away from him. To ensure Sharlot finds a suitable romantic partner, Mom starts an online conversation with George Clooney Tanuwijaya's father. George's dad is equally worried about his son's romantic endeavors. Online each parent is pretending to be their teenage offspring. Sharlot and George reluctantly meet for coffee and immediately butt heads. Neither resemble the online version of themselves that their parents created. However, George is the public face of an etiquette app for teen boys that is being launched by his family's wealthy business empire and he agrees to a fake dating situation. As they spend time together, Sharlot begins to warm to Jakarta and George himself. This charming romcom is filled with humor and romance and an intriguing insight into the Chinese Indonesian culture.

Was this review helpful?

Whar a ride! This was a very entertaining read! I really liked the starting point of the story with both parents catfishing each other and enjoyed learning about the indonesian-chinese culture and the exotic setting! It really came out of the page and made me crave some real strong Indonesian coffee! I feel like Jesse Q. Sutanto has a distinctive style which is instantly recognizable and while this isn't my favorite of hers, I can say with certainty that I'm pulled in by her stories and always will! This was a fun one!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book so much is was a fun and fast read for me. I would definitely recommend it to others! Thank you NetGalley for this copy!

Was this review helpful?

I LOVED 'Dial A for Aunties' so I knew I had to pick this one up..... was I disappointed??? NOPE! this was such a fun romantic read. The perfect combination of romance and comedy, FABULOUS

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, @netgalley for my gifted copy of this book.

I have loved everything that I have read so far by this author. This book did not disappoint!

Pick this one up if you like young adult romance + fake dating that has relatable characters, is laugh out loud funny, & is just overall really entertaining.

After reading this one, I really want to visit Indonesia and have a really good cup of coffee!

Was this review helpful?

So, I read this cute book over the weekend. Written by the same author as Dial A for Aunties but more YA focused, this one was just what I needed to make me smile. When Sharlot's mother flies her back unexpectedly, to the homeland, Indonesia, Sharlot does not envisage enjoying herself. But when her mother plays matchmaker and sets her up with a nice boy (George), Sharlot finds herself in a situation where fake dating becomes necessary. Give me the fake dating trope any day and I'm in. Our main characters were fantastic but the supporting characters were even better, with so much personality. If you're after a quick read, delightful YA romance, make sure you have this one on your to read list.

Was this review helpful?