Cover Image: Such a Good Mother

Such a Good Mother

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This book is told through the eyes of Rose O'Connell, the daughter of a conman just trying to make life more for herself & her family (husband & child). I found it difficult to root for any character in this book. The twists & turns kept it somewhat interesting but the unredeemable characters made it hard to finish. I did have to finish though just to see what ended up happening. In the end, it was okay.

Thanks to the publisher & NetGalley for advanced copy in exchange for my honest review

Was this review helpful?

I received a digital advance copy of Such A Good Mother by Helen Monks Takhar via NetGalley. Such a Good Mother is scheduled for release on August 2, 2022.

Such a Good Mother begins with Rose attending an open house at the school she just knows will make all the difference for her son. Woolf Academy is tremendously hard to get into, and guided by a small circle of powerful women who are quick to judge what a potential new family can offer them and the school. To her own surprise, Rose manages to snag a coveted spot at the school for her son. When one of the women in the inner circle dies unexpectedly, Rose sets her sights on the open spot, just like every other mother at the school. After Amala, the center of the circle, chooses to bring her into the inner circle, Rose finds herself quickly pulled into a web of secrets and pressures she did not expect.

On the surface, the plot of this novel is driven by Rose’s wants. She wants things she can’t afford. She wants opportunities for her family. She wants prestige. She wants the envy of others. Underneath this outer shallow covering, Rose is also dealing with the pressures and challenges of being a wife and mother. She wants her family to be the best they can be, and would love for the world around her (and her husband) to help her get there, or at least not destroy her attempts at progress. As the only point of view character, we are seeing the events of the story through Rose. This became challenging for me as a reader. While I felt I should identify with her, based on the issues she is facing with her husband and job, the way she dealt with those issues was very unrelatable for me. This was true of almost all of the characters in the novel. I struggled to feel for any of the characters, and felt overall, that I couldn’t root for any of them. I also took issue with a reveal toward the end of the story. We have been in Rose’s mind for the length of the novel, in first person. When she suddenly revealed an important piece of information that she had known all along (and was really her motivation throughout the novel) it felt like a cheat to me.

Such a Good Mother had some interesting points, and a potentially intriguing premise, but did not deliver a fascinating thriller for me. I was missing a character to root for, and felt cheated by a twist at the end.

Was this review helpful?

This was just OK for me. The reveal at the end was good but it was a slow buildup without much intensity. Nothing really gripped you and pulled you in. A very quiet approach.

Was this review helpful?

Rose wants her son Charlie to have everything she didn't as a child- the child of a con man whose mom died young. And she thinks the Woolf Academy will do it for him, despite all the hints that this won't be the solution. The Circle are the mean moms who run everything and she wants to be part of this too, and she is- but is she really? Amala, who pulls her in, has secrets, as do the other members of the group (not everything is as shiny as it seems). And there's a murder. Hmm. This is trope-y in the way of this genre of outsider-mom novel but it's also intriguing because of Rose's back story, which is more important than it might appear at first. Thanks to netgalley for the ARC. It's a fast and entertaining read.

Was this review helpful?

How much would you do for your child? Helen Monks Takhar's Such a Good Mother gets to the heart of modern motherhood.The deeper Rose O'Connell gets in with the elite and secretive group of mothers who rule the prestigious Woolf Academy (known as the Circle), the more she learns it's just as much for herself as it is for her son. Soon, things go awry.

This is a well-written domestic thriller, that builds slowly but surely to a satisfying (if almost unbelievable) close. I appreciated some of the wild twists in the latter half of the book. However, given Rose's history, it was frustrating how easily she fell for some of the tricks. But it's a fun, nicely paced read! Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Some women would do anything for their children... Rose O'Connell, daughter of a con artist and barely scraping by in the present, desperately wants to enroll her son in the prestigious Woolf Academy located in her rapidly gentrifying neighborhood. After a member of The Circle, a small group of elite moms on The Inside dies under somewhat mysterious circumstances, Rose yeans to fill her designer shoes. But the Woolf and all of the women in The Circle harbor dark secrets, drawing Rose into a dangerous game of cat mouse.

While I am so grateful for the chance to read this ARC, I didn't really care for it. Though it was written in a way that the story is supposed to unfold slowly while keeping the reader in the dark, it gave so few details that I was 70% in and not really even able to describe it to a friend. The characters were horrible people with the exception of MC's sister in law and her son, with no redeeming qualities to make you like them just a little. I was really excited for this one but it fell flat for me.

I received this ebook in exchange for my honest review. This does not affect my views and all thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Mostly shocked at the surprise ending (who is actually conning who???). Great cast of stepford wives clique at a rivals school. And what seems preferable is absolutely not! Enjoyed the story.

Was this review helpful?

Rosie is a mom who would sacrifice anything and everything for her son, when a position opens up for The Circle, an elite club of horrifying women, because of a death, she wants to belong and join.

This tight knit group of mothers who run the school are awful human beings but Rosie is just driving to survive.

This was dark and twisty with turns I didn’t see coming and an enjoyable thriller. I enjoyed how the twists unraveled.

⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
Thank you @netgalley for an arc for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

If you enjoy reading about bitchy mom cliques this book is for you!

Unfortunately, I live in an area with these fancy kid prep schools and snobby rich moms and so this book was slow and drab compared to real life. Eh. I was sold on it because I wanted this "dark side of motherhood" it promised but it read more like Where'd You Go Bernadette? then a dark mothering novel.

Was this review helpful?

Such a Good Mother is a slow burn that eventually leads up to a shocking conclusion. Rose’s frustration is clearly felt on the pages and her motivations make sense. The most interesting part of the story is hearing about Rose’s dad, a hustler. While I do wish the story was a bit faster, it was still a good read.

Was this review helpful?

Be careful what you wish for, you never know, it might come true. For Rose who was horribly teased as a child and raised on the outside, she is determined to do better for her son, Charlie. The Woolf Academy is the prestigious school just across the street from her small flat. Of course these mums are so competitive and well put together, how will Rose ever fit in? Well for starters, there is a murder!

Many thanks to NetGalley and Random House for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher and the author, for an ARC of this book, in exchange for an honest review.
The premise of the book drew me in but once I started reading it, I just couldn’t get into it at all.
I wish the author, publisher and all those promoting the book much success and connections with the right readers.

Was this review helpful?

Such a Good Mother starts out with a bang and then slowly tells the tale of Rosie O'Connell who wants nothing more than to be part of "The Inner CIrcle" at the prestigious Woolf Academy where her son now attends.

The Inner CIrcle is powerful and Rosie just wants to belong .

Be careful what you wish for Rosie will soon learn.

Run Rosie run is what I think

You cant help but feel for Rosie who has had her share of problems and they seem never ending.

Not wanting to give anything away I will say that the twists and turns and the ending that took me totally by surprise will keep the lights on and the pages turning.

Treat yourself to Such a Good Mother, you will be glad you did.

Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group, Random House Trade Paperbacks for a read I wont soon forget.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this was not the book for me. While it was captivating at first, I eventually found the plot and the events that took place to be insanely over the top. What started out as an interesting take on power dynamics in an elementary school quickly snowballed into an unbelievable story of deceit and corruption. I didn’t find this to be fresh or thrilling take on modern motherhood— the story is about a small clique of women led by one powerhouse who were scheming excessively to benefit themselves, but in a way that was highly unbelievable. It didn’t even delve into the motherhood aspects of their characters, more just their own social-climbing and selfishness. The characters were difficult to connect with, as those in The Circle were both shallow and mean, and the protagonist was sad and pathetic. It was hard to root for anyone or anything, and I trudged through this one.

Was this review helpful?

Rose O'Connell is struggling, Her son got into the school of her dreams, but he isn't fitting in and hates it. Her husband is out of work and her salary is barely covering the bills. They are quickly becoming priced out of their neighborhood. So when the leader of her son's school takes Rose into her inner circle, it seems the answer to all her troubles. But quickly it becomes apparent that being part of the Circle won't help, and in fact, may make these worse.

This one dragged for me in the middle. It started off with a strong and shocking event but got bogged down in the unlikeable personalities for just about all the characters - except for sister-in-law Jacq - until another big event at the end.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Group for providing me with an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Availalbe August 2, 2022.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! If you like dark and twisty stories full of suspense and mystery, you'll love this book! Helen Monks Takhar managed to draw me into this story and I never knew what to expect next. This is not my typical type of read but I was immediately hooked and had to keep reading. Thanks #NetGalley #RandomHouse and #HelenMonksTakhar

Was this review helpful?

This was a very dark but compelling read - what will a mother do to improve the life and fortune of her child?

For Rose, living on the shabby side of a rapidly improving neighborhood, watching the well dressed and ambitious mothers push their children at the prestigious Woolf Academy right across the street from her house, jealousy sets in. She is stuck barely making ends meet, in her job as a bank teller, with a good looking husband who is struggling to get work as a plumber. Rose is the daughter of a well known local con artist, and lives in the shadow of his name.

She manages to get her son Charlie a place at the school, but both he and she struggle to fit in with the students and mothers who all look down on Rose and Charlie. She watches enviously as members of "the circle' - the small group of mothers who run the school under the leadership of the formidable Amala Kaur - seem to have everything going their way at the school. When one of the circle is found dead on school grounds, Rose finds herself chosen as her unlikely replacement. Once on the inside, her fortunes start to improve, but at what terrible cost.

This was one of those books that made me truly wonder at the evil and devious minds that exist in this world. The plot took several turns that I didn't expect, and left me thinking about the roles of victim and villain long after I finished reading the book.

Was this review helpful?

Rosie O’Connell is a wife and a mother struggling to get by. She knows she doesn’t belong at the prestigious Woolf Academy but she is determined to put her son Charlie in the school. She will do whatever it takes to fit in to be like the rest of the Woolf Mothers and especially The Circle.
The Circle is an exclusive club in the Woolf Academy run by a woman named Amala Kaur. All the woman inside the Circle are horrible people who obey whatever Amala says. Rosie believes her life will turn around for the better if she can just get inside the circle. She won’t need to struggle, she won’t need to worry about child care not only in the morning but after school too. It will all be there for her.

However, once she is inside the Circle she learns things are not what they seem.

This book had so many twists and turns which I really enjoyed it kept me very intrigued. Just when I thought I had things figured out, we are hit with another big twist. The writing was great and the story is very compelling.

A big thank you to Netgalley and Random House for an eARC in exchange for my honest revew.

Was this review helpful?

This was definitely an interesting read. I picked it up because I seen it was about a school and rich people. Which honestly is my jam. I love me some drama, and moms who have way to much money. I am not a mom and I still could kind of relate to the main character. I say kind of because some of her characteristics were odd. I would read more from this author as I enjoyed the writing style.

Was this review helpful?

Such a Good Mother by Helen Monks Takhar

Published: August 2, 2022
Random House
Pages: 354
Genre: Thriller
KKECReads Rating: 5/5
I received a copy of this book for free, and I leave my review voluntarily.

Helen Monks Takhar worked as a journalist, copywriter, and magazine editor, having graduated from Cambridge in 1997. She began her career writing for financial trade newspapers in 1999 before contributing to UK national newspapers, including The Times and The Observer. Born in Southport, Merseyside, in 1976, she lives in North London with her husband and two daughters.

“Magis et Magis.”

Rose has not always lived a healthy and safe life. Her father was a talented con artist who wouldn’t hesitate to make his daughter participate in a con if it meant succeeding. Now, as an adult, Rose wants her young son to have every opportunity life offers. So when the chance to enroll him in a prestigious school occurs, Rose doesn’t hesitate. She also doesn’t realize she may not survive meeting the other hardworking mothers.

HOLY BUCKETS. This was intense. I devoured this novel in hours. I could not put it down. Just when I thought things couldn’t possibly get more complicated, that did.

I liked Rose. She was a significant lead. I enjoyed how she was presented and how she played the game. Amala was also a great character. She was just as intelligent, determined, hardworking, devoted, and passionate as Rose.

Though, they two seemingly lived in different worlds. I loved the themes in this novel. The concept of privilege and hierarchy that comes along with it. The balance between rich and poor, opportunity and destitution.

The game was set and played by absolute players. As much as I hate women being pitted against each other, the portrayal was accurate and intense. There was a very dramatic “Mean Girls” element to this book.

Fast-paced and full of twists you never expect, the last several chapters will give you whiplash and leave your eyeballs tired from flying along the pages. An excellent thriller about the lengths a mother will go to for the health, happiness, wellbeing, and safety of her child.

Was this review helpful?