I received an advanced review copy for free through NetGalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Every opinion expressed is my own.

Izzy is constantly being set up by her cousin Josephine, who decides she MUST join a dating app. Izzy obliges, and meets Brodie, a man from across the ocean who shares pretty much the entirety of her interests, personality and bookish humour.

Told in epistulary form, it’s a cute, slow-paced romance. Iwas properly annoyed by Josephine, but Luke (Josephine’s brother) was a well constructed and human character.

Some things were a bit inconsistent to me, and it felt too dragged in the middle, and too rushed in the end, hence the rating.

Overall na enjoyable read, who I believe will please fans of the genre. Perfect to escape a reading slump!

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for sending me this e-arc. My opinion is 100% mine.

Izzy is what i think of a typical 30 year old protagonist in nearly every contemporary romance novel. Shy, a nerd, not good around new people but very bubbly around people she trusts.... quite the cliche.

She eventually began to grow on me, but i never really liked her.
I did like Brodie though, most of the time.
There were times where i was swooning over something he said or did but sometimes it/he was just too much.

The storyline was ok, nothing very special though.
What was special, is that most of the book, like 85%, is written in emails, I loved that!

The beginning was hard work, the middle was perfecr, the ending was slightly over the top, and not very satisfying.

I enjoyed myself while reading but often forget that i was still reading this book (if that makes sense?!). That sums up the whole book and reading experience for me.

This book takes wonderful characters and a delightful story, wraps them in letters, quotes, and all things bookish, and ties them all with a lovely romantic bow. I'd say she seals it with a wax kiss, but I'm afraid Brodie would object.

For lovers of Pepper's Jane by the Book, I've determined that Titus and Brodie are cousins. It'll take a DNA test and a genealogical expert to figure out how, but I'm patient. I can wait.

Full of laugh-out-loud moments, family relationships that are so wonderfully (dare I say it?) AUTHENTIC that it feels as though you've stepped into a real story, and (for those who can stomach them) all the kisses pitter-pattering hearts could desire.

It's You've Got Mail meets The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society meets the Pevensies (#BecauseSiblings) meets Pepper's fabulous wit and wordsmithing. From Andy Griffith's Blue Ridge Mountains to a delightful set of islands in the North Sea, the settings couldn't be more Anne Shirleyishly romantic.

Trying to be really careful here (#becausespoilers) but Pepper did something I don't often (ever?) see in a romance. Where things typically happen one way (and for understandable reasons), she didn't. She didn't let someone take on something that wasn't that someone's responsibility. And... Bravo.

But even if all that weren't enough, there's a subtle but strong faith element that ripped bandaids I didn't know I was wearing off wounds I didn't know I had and exposed them to the healing power of truth... or is that Truth?

And in a rom-com, folks. #BecausePepper.

Run, don't walk and preorder the book. Stockpile tea, scones, and cookie dough ice cream (maybe a bear claw or two... you'll see why). Close the spreadsheets, turn off your phone (trust me on this one), and get ready to settle in for a WONDERFUL read.

So... how great was this book? Let's summarize it this way. Pepper Basham has inspired me to try, again (for like the 50th time) to read and love Tolkein. That she can make me want to love something I've despaired ever tolerating is proof that this book is genius.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I wanted to like this. Everything about it sounded absolutely perfect for my tastes. I love Lord of the Rings and dream of working at a bookstore. However I missed one little sentence when I requested this book. I didn't notice that this was an "epistolary novel." I started this with high hopes, not realizing that the whole thing was in the form of emails and instant messages. I honestly could not stand the format and had to give up fairly quickly. It's a bit embarrassing, but there it is. I think I only got through about 10% before I just could not take it any longer. I'm sure that there are a ton of people that won't mind the format, or may even really enjoy it. Unfortunately I was not one of them. So even though this book had a lot of promise, I just couldn't make my way through it.

I wanted to like this one and tried it a couple times, but I couldn't get past the conversation style. I thought maybe it was just the beginning but then it kept going and I was finding it really hard to concentrate on it. Not sure If i will review because I didn't even get halfway but was sad that I didn't love!

Thank you for allowing me access to this ARC. I receives a complementary copy of this book, opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

This was a brilliant read! Authentically, Izzy is charming, warm, and funny. As an English Literature student I appreciated the references to classics and the quotes shared by Izzy and Brodie. The fact that it is epistolary, told almost exclusively through emails and texts, for this genre of book, work amazing! At times it started to grate on me though in the second half of the book the author does move onto some prose which was refreshing and I got Beth O'Leary 'The Flatshare' vibes! The epistolary style was very in keeping with the literary theme and is certainly unique, though I can see it being an acquired taste for some readers.

The theme of family was particularly heart-warming and was a brilliant sub plot to bring tension to the romance. Equally, Izzy's epiphanies and revelations deepened her character and to see her become empowered to take control of her own future was inspiring!

And oh my gosh the romance! While at times cliché and exaggerated (though I personally didn't mind this) the connection between Izzy and Brodie was heart-stopping! The tension was palpable! I enjoyed that the romance wasn't steamy, and instead was wholesome, in keeping with the vibes of the book.

My only issues were with the pacing. At times I felt like the story was dragging on, it was certainly a longer book than I had been expecting, and because of this it started to get repetitive. For example, Josephine, continued to be negative towards Izzy and Brodie's relationship long after Izzy had moved on past the need for familial support and advice.

Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this book and will definitely be keeping my eye out for more books by Pepper Basham!
Thank you again for granting me access to this ARC.

At first, I was really excited for this book! The nerdiness with a dog named Samwise and other nods had me hooked. I loved the first interactions with people Izzy had on the dating website. But slowly, things went downhill.

First, I love books with different writing formats. So I was excited with the email and text form. However, early on here I felt like it was getting dull and was hoping there would be interludes of normal prose. Or maybe emails from Brodie’s perspective. But for a while, no. And I had then adjusted and was like ok that’s fine this is the style. But then in part 2, we suddenly get Brodie perspective??? And part 2 comes over ⅓ in if not closer to half. Then we also randomly start getting prose and then toward the end it switches almost completely to traditional prose?? It was just confusing.

I also was excited to see Brodie’s perspective but then found myself confused by his writing style. Izzy’s voice is generally great and then Brodie felt awkward and like people don’t actually say or think these things. There also were multiple times that felt like the big climactic point of a romcom but it got resolved so easily.

Finally, this book was sneakily religious. It felt thrown in without real purpose of advancing the plot and didn’t add anything to the characters.

I received my copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Basham creates a delightful story filled with realistic characters & storyline, faith elements, and clean romance - & a touch of humor.

Loved the context and premise of the book. It has some interesting tropes of book lovers, pop culture references and over the top families. The concept of romance and dating is interesting here.

I loved the main protagonist who was quirky and cute. Her growth and journey to find love was quite interesting. While it took me some time to get into the book, her character and opinions on romance was what made me read. The book is written in the format of letters and narration which was a first for me. For me as a reader, I would have preferred a little more of the narration format, especially in the beginning.

Thank you Thomas Nelson Fiction and NetGalley for this eARC in exchange of my honest review.

Unfortunately, I wasn't able to connect with this book. I made it about 25% into this before I decided to DNF. I'm intrigued by nonconventional story formats, and usually, I love reading books that feature text messages, emails, diary entries, etc. But I found the epistolary writing in this novel to be very confusing, more so because of the length of all of the emails and the overuse of PS, PPS, and PPPS at the end of almost all of them. I was expecting the writing to switch from emails to dialogue back to emails, and so forth, but since that wasn't the case, I could feel my attention dwindling on every page. (Though, coincidentally, I think the epistolary format worked really well for the dating app messages.) Had this novel been dialogue-based with emails and dating app messages interspersed throughout, I think I would've enjoyed this a lot more! Unfortunately, the format just wasn't for me and I couldn't continue.

Additionally, I felt like the communication between the characters was a bit outdated for my taste. It might just be the Gen Z in me, but how the characters were speaking/writing was more reminiscent of how the characters in a Jane Austen novel would talk than how people talk now. If the whole point of Josie's meddling behaviors is to push Izzy into the modernized dating app scene, it didn't make sense to me why everyone's exchanges were so outdated.

I appreciate the premise and how much effort Basham put into the epistolary format! This wasn't the book for me, but this is a great book for people who enjoy stories about book lovers, romance, and stories that mainly feature a letter-writing format.

Thank you to Thomas Nelson Fiction and NetGalley for this eARC!

Authentically Izzy follows the journey of Izzy in her search for love and her unexpected discovery of who she truly is.

As much as I love my general format in books, I do appreciate the unique formats that I come across now and then. And Authentically Izzy definitely delivered in that aspect. I loved how different this book was written compared to the normal format. I think it really added to its uniqueness and made this book a much better book to read.

Although I did love the romance in this book between Izzy and Brodie, what caught my attention throughout my read of this book was how Izzy as an individual progressed. Not only did she find the love that she was looking for, but she discovered more about herself that she'd ever known. This book, as well as being a romance, serves as a wonderful self realization book.

Authentically Izzy was the first book I've read by Pepper Basham and as I did like this one, I would love to read more from this author. Not only was this book extremely easy to read, but it also had a very interesting story in general.

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC. All opinions and thoughts are my own.

Authentically Izzy by Pepper Basharm is quite literally all about Izzy and tells her story of her search for love.  This book jumped out at me as usually I love books that are set around bookshops however as this book is told in an epistemolary format so I found it very difficult to follow. Emails, text and conversation in books just didn't hold my attention. 

The story itself is about young adults trying to find their place in the world with their families support this goes for Izzy and the Sutherlands who's 'family own a growing number of bookshops'.
Issy and her love interest Luke enough to survive in real life outside in the real world?.

Many thanks  to NetGalley and the publishe as I recieved a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed are completely my own.

This is my first book by Pepper Basham and I am grateful that I received the complimentary copy and all opinions expressed re entirely my own.

The book tells the story of Izzy a Lord of the Rings fan who is also a hopeless romantic but doesn't go much but her meddling but caring cousin Josephine decides help Izzy by creating a dating profile for her. And things go well when Izzy meets a fellow Lord if the Rings lover who also loves books, family and Lord of the rings. Will this hobbit man be the happy ever after ? Loved the plot, how the story was told and this story doesn't start strong because of the format . It's a different format but an endearing romance.

Thank you Netgalley and Thomas Nelson for providing an e-ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!

This story is adorable. The love and friendship that grows between Izzy and Brodie is beautiful. I love the story's progression and how Izzy learns more about herself and what she wants from the future.

Thanks to the meddling of her cousin Josephine Izzy finds herself on a dating website. There she finds Brodie, a fellow book lover and family man. The only problem? He lives on the other side of the world. Can this relationship that is growing between them work?

I had a lot of trouble getting into the book. At first, it was confusing, and many emails felt redundant. It took me about 100 to 150 pages to get into the story.
Additionally, you do not find many epistolary novels in the form of emails anymore, simply because, realistically, we do not email with our friends and family on a daily basis. We are much more likely to text or call. That was one of my problems with this format. Eventually, it also turned into a 'regular' written story, which were my favourite parts.

I received a complimentary copy of this e-book from Netgalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Authentically, Izzy stands out for its great writing and wonderful collection of book references. The love story is sweet and the heroine is plucky and relatable. The pacing is a little slow and the book is definitely more than a little Hallmark-esque but still an enjoyable read. One thing to note is that this book does contain references to God and church groups. It is not a large part of the story however and still enjoyable even if this is not something you look for in a book. This book is mostly written in an epistolary style that is perfect for fans of The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society if you are able to handle a heavy dose of cheesiness.

You know those stories you read and when you finish you can only think “how cute!”? Well, that's how this reading has been for me. I think most of the time while I was reading I had a smile on my face that I couldn't help, it came out on its own, and when I finished reading I had this feeling that I had read a super cute book and that it had made me happy.

I have to say that despite the fact that I am a big fan of romance, I don't usually read these more tender books, so in a way it has been a bit out of my comfort zone. This has been a tender, funny and simply beautiful read. As I say, I think the best thing about this novel is the good feeling it leaves you with.

Also the format is something that I don't usually read and that depends on the moment I like it or not. The epistolary format has the advantage of being original and a breath of fresh air when reading a different book, but it is also a style that can get tiresome. The latter is not something that has happened to me all the time, but it is true that it happened to me a couple of times that I stopped reading because I was choking a bit on the format. And the logical thing has also happened to me that you want to live some scenes in a more "real" way to enjoy it more.

It was the first book I read by the author and I really liked it. His style is quite easy to read, and in part I think that is why the epistolary format of the book has not "bothered" me (as it has in other books). I want to see what other books he has published and perhaps give another novel a chance, perhaps with a more conventional format and in my style.

Thank you so much to Thomas Nelson for the opportunity to read and review this book prior to release. All opinions are my own.

First of all, this cover is beyond adorable!

When I saw this book was written in letters, I was so excited because I love formats like that! It was a clean and overall cute read, but I did become a little bored sadly.

I think a lot of people will love this book though!

It is available for purchase on November 15th!

So I loved the beginning of this book, I was intrigued and keen to see where it was going but omg I struggled hardcore with the constant emails and texts and messages. I had to keep rereading the messages and who was messaging who and I was getting a bit confused but I think it’s because I’m not used to it so took a second for my head to wrap around it.

I had so much fun reading this book! I love the online relationships, the protective family members, the books, quotes, scenic descriptions...all of it!
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC and a chance to absorb this incredible story!

This was my first Pepper Basham book and I enjoyed it! This was a funny, sweet story and I was impressed with the writing. Thank you to the publisher for an arc. All opinions are my own.