Cover Image: Death on the Isle

Death on the Isle

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Astrid was meant to be evaluating paintings at a mansion on the Isle of Wight not solving a murder but here we are! She's sailed to the Isle to look at nautical themed paintings (there's a whole sailing theme to this) and then finds a body under the pier. The victim was not, in the cozy tradition, well liked, so there are a number of suspects. Astrid makes friends with a loose group of artistically inclined residents and visitors and together they solve the crime. I'd not read the first book so this was a standalone for me and it was fine that way. While the mystery itself was not too tricky, I liked the setting and Astrid is entertaining. Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

DNF - I struggled to engage with the way this was written & ultimately was not very invested in the story.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the first book in this series and had very high hopes for this one, and whilst it didn't have the same feel as the first for me (as it's mainly set in a different area, spoiler alert The Isle Of Wight 😆) and with a new group of characters, the central figure Astrid Swift is great as ever and the cosy crime aspect romps along through country lanes, historic buildings and keeps you entertained and guessing to the end.

Was this review helpful?

This is the second novel in the Astrid Swift series and, after a dramatic insight into what lies ahead on the Isle of Wight, we find Astrid enjoying time on her boat in Hanbury following the adventures that featured in the first book. That is, until her peace is disturbed by a visit from HMRC seeking her assistance with a private art collection located in a property on the Isle of Wight. With her divorce still being finalised and her time at the English Trust at an end, Astrid accepts the job and sets sail.

A competent follow up to the first book; as with ‘The Trust’, the story is jam packed with interesting characters. The four amateur artists Astrid meets while visiting another English Trust property on the island are an eclectic bunch and reminded me a bit of the characters in Richard Osman’s ‘The Thursday Murder Club’ series. There were a couple of characters elsewhere in the book that I would have liked to have got to know a little better, but this does reflect the fact Astrid is only on the island for a short time. The main plots – murders and missing persons – that Astrid and her new found friends take upon themselves to investigate keep the pages turning and there’s also some gentler, more introspective moments. There are also some lovely descriptions of the land and seascapes.

It is suggested towards the end of the book that Astrid won’t be returning to Hanbury and Kath, Cobb and Sheepdip immediately, which is a shame because I’d become somewhat invested in these characters from the first novel, but I also like the idea of Astrid using her new sailing skills and sense of freedom to seek adventures elsewhere. For me, the characters we meet really make this series of books, so I will be looking forward to seeing who Astrid encounters in the next instalment.

Many thanks to the publishers and to NetGalley for the advance copy on which this review is based.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free ARC copy of this via NetGalley and the publishers in return for an unbiased review. I debated giving this 3 stars as a decent story, but it fell a little short, so after careful thought, I’ve rounded it down a bit. It felt as though this was a sailing story with a few crimes thrown in, rather than a murder mystery which features boats. The whole Celeste/Harlow thing could have been bigger, but was almost filler. The development thing had potential, then fizzled out. It felt like all the bits that could have actually been mystery and a bigger role, were sacrificed for showing off about boats and sailing, I felt a bit let down sadly.

Several typos throughout the book, and at one point, Annabelle becomes Cynthia and then back again - this should have been picked up in edits. Overall, it’s an OK book, and I wouldn’t necessarily be averse to reading further ones, but I’ve got plenty others I’d prioritise first.

Was this review helpful?

Art conservator Astrid Swift is waiting for life to return to some sort of normality. After her marriage break up, the death of her favourite uncle, and the small matter of solving a murder or two while working at Sherborne Hall in Dorset, she's also hoping for some peace and quiet. When she's asked to assess an art collection, which was the pride and joy of a recently deceased millionaire, Astrid hurriedly sets sail for the Isle of Wight, in the recently inherited Curlew's Rest to start the assignment.

Although now a boat owner Astrid doesn't consider herself an informed member of the sailing community and is surprised to find herself in the  middle of Cowes Week! Her destination, the Needle's Eye, is a lovely house now empty except for memories and a collection of maritime artwork, which Astrid is delighted to cast her expert eye over. She also connects with an eclectic group of locals who have formed a small art club eager to welcome her as their newest member. Everything in life would be heading in the right direction if only she hadn't also discovered a dead body!

This is Astrid Swift's second outing and she is a much more likeable, less entitled main protagonist this time around. The other main characters have only bit parts but their replacements were a fun group who definitely kept Astrid on her toes. The investigation was entertaining, not as clear cut as I expected, and with the potential to rise again in future episodes of this easy read series. There were signposts leading toward a possible third investigation for Astrid which I will definitely be on the lookout for.

I was able to read an advanced copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and the publishers but the opinions expressed are my own. I really enjoyed this and think it makes a great summer beach or back garden read.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet cozy mystery that was just a good easy read . I loved the setting and characters. I’ll likely read more by this author.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for letting me review this book

Was this review helpful?

I was really pleased to find the second in the Astrid Swift series on NetGalley. I continue to enjoy the fact it takes place in a part of the world I'm reasonably familiar with, even if I've not actually *been* to all of the locations mentioned. I have, however, actually been to the IoW, albeit just a day trip, so this was a nice addition to the series. Even though I'm not a sailor, there's not too much sailing talk, just enough to bring in the nautical history and way of life that permeates this coast of England. I'm learning it's a Pretty Big Deal with a large percentage of the population, so having an MC who sails makes sense and is very much a realistic premise.

Keeping to a sailing theme in this book, Astrid is drawn into a mystery around the death of Victor Leech, a local man she runs into on the street, and who is the local busybody. His body is discovered under the town pier and the only people she can rely on to help is the small, local group of artists she has befriended since she arrived on the Island to value a collection of nautical-themed paintings.

There are a lot of characters in this one and the mystery gets a bit lost for a while, before resurfacing for the group to resolve. Astrid also solves another mystery, one that her client - the daughter of the man who owned the paintings she's valuing - wasn't expecting.

This series is definitely staying on my TBR pile. I like the writing, Astrid and her adventures in Dorset. There are plenty of iconic spots to get into trouble.

Was this review helpful?

The second in the Astrid Swift mystery series. I had trouble getting into this book. There were things that seemed like flashbacks but it was not clear enough. I was also confused because some chapters were like two pages where nothing happened.

Was this review helpful?

.The Trust was absolutely gripping, and Death On The Isle is even better. Astrid Swift sails to to Isle of Wight, slap bang into the middle of Cowes Week to work on the art collection of a late billionaire, and find out what happened to his sailing prodigy daughter who went missing at sea. Her latest case is an intoxicating mix of grit and high society sailing glamour -- a mysterious figure is on her trail as she uses her forensic art skills to solve the death of a local nimby who ends up as crab bait under the pier. Not everyone is what they seem, and there's a good chance the killer will catch her before Astrid works out who is really on her side.

Was this review helpful?

You follow Astrid as she is given a new assignment regarding art on the Isle of Wight. There, a murder occurs and the sees herself being capable of investigating this with a group of people she meets. This group consists of random art lovers who come together to paint or draw. They all set out to investigate the murder and find out the truth.

I had some trouble getting through this book. Some parts of it were actually really boring and I had to make myself continue reading. The last part however, was alright again. Overall, parts of the book were decent but most of it was too elaborately written and not exciting to read at all.

Was this review helpful?

A great continuation of the series. Loved Astrid as a main character and thought the setting was brilliant too. Really looking forward to book 3!

Was this review helpful?

It's high summer and, with the grisly events at Dorset's Sherborne Hall behind her, Astrid Swift sets sail for the Isle of Wight. She's been asked to value a collection of maritime art owned by a recently deceased millionaire.

His surviving daughter has inherited the art along with the family's seafront mansion, The Needle's Eye, and wants to sell up. There are too many memories of her twin sister, a sailing prodigy who went missing at sea three years earlier.

When Victor Leech, the local busybody, is found washed up under the town pier, Astrid thinks lightning has struck twice. She's stumbled on a fresh case that only she and her new art club friends can solve. But getting to the bottom of the unexplained death will draw out powerful new enemies...

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. It was an excellent page turner that I couldn’t put down. It’s full of twists and turns throughout that keel you on the edge of your seat. The characters were interesting, the plot was excellent, and the style of writing was perfect.

Was this review helpful?

Cowes Week Chaos…
The second in the Astrid Swift series of mysteries finds Astrid heading to the Isle of Wight where Cowes Week is in full flow. Her assignment is to value a collection of maritime art owned by a recently deceased millionaire. The discovery of a body begins a catalogue of unforeseeable events and the kind of chaos that only the feisty Astrid can deal with. A cosy mystery with a sharp edge and with a wonderfully eccentric and well drawn cast of characters and laced with a subtle humour, not to mention a storyline that soon becomes impossible to part with. Our protagonist, Astrid, is not immediately likeable but that’s rather the point. The mystery itself is solid and engaging and leads to an entirely satisfying denouement. A one sit read which is wholly enjoyable, thoroughly entertaining and a perfect follow up to the first in this hopefully long running series.

Was this review helpful?

This ARC was provided to me via Kindle, Head of Zeus and by #NetGalley. Opinions expressed are completely my own.


An interesting, enjoyable little read that was interesting throughout.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book. It’s a bit dry and slow but it gets there. The reveal of the killer is unusual. I liked the ending. #DeathontheIsle #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Astrid Swift is on the Isle of Wight, appraising the art collection for the estate of a deceased millionaire. The daughter wants to sell everything, including the island home, lock, stock and barrel, claiming the presumed death of her twin sister has left her with nothing but bad memories of the island. When the body of a local washes ashore, Astrid knows that there’s been way too much death for such a small island, so our intrepid art restorer and her art club buddies set out to uncover the truth. Set amidst the high toned world of Cowe’s Week, one of the most celebrated sailing regattas in the world, Eccelston’s setting and characters make for engrossing reading

Was this review helpful?