I really enjoyed this!! I was worried based on the other reviews I read but I think people were comparing this too much to the author’s other books, which they shouldn’t because this IS different but that’s okay!! This wasn’t as high fantasy as her other books, which I also loved, but I did enjoy the world and my only complaint is that I wish it was longer! The ending was amazing and I loved how unexpected it was. I hope one day she returns to write more in this world, I loved the fantasy mixed with the mystery.

I loved the premise of this book. The world building, the characters, the semi-expected twist at the end- those things were great, in theory. Unfortunately I felt like this book didn't quite hit the mark. It took forever to pull me in, and then when it finally did the book was over. I have so many unanswered questions.

This novella opens with Celeste, a faro dealer in the mining town of Goetia, surveying her table of mostly fellow Fallen, as the descendants of those who lost the rebellion against Heaven are known. Society in the post-Rebellion world is strictly divided between the Fallen and the Elect, the descendants of the righteous, who are in charge of almost everything worth controlling. This includes most industry and the systems of administration that keep the town running.

Celeste could pass in high society due to having inherited her looks from her Elect father, unlike her sister Mariel, who takes after their Fallen mother. While Mariel is a talented singer, racism ensures that she can only make a living performing in saloons and dive bars instead of the opera houses where less talented singers tread the boards. Loyal to a fault, Celeste stays with Mariel in the slums, dealing cards while looking out for her little sister.

So when Mariel is hauled away by the local Elect authorities on suspicion of murder, a frantic Celeste will stop at nothing to free her. It's an ordeal just to discover where she's been taken. Celeste is thus surprised to find that the Virtue who finally lets her in to see her sister is also willing to appoint her as the advocate for Mariel's defense. When Celeste expresses her reservations, Ibrahim assures her that she doesn't need any legal training for the position, as what matters most in the court where Mariel will be tried are the purity of truth and soul.

Since Celeste is no fool, she figures she'd better go about collecting exculpatory evidence as well. Her search, however, finds her testing the very limits of her own senses of both morality and self, as she finds herself entangled in the machinations of greater powers that seek to use her as a pawn in their sinister games.

To be honest, I'm not really sure what I think of this book. I enjoyed the quasi-Western, quasi-steampunk setting, but I don't think I'm in the right frame of mind to care about angels, fallen or otherwise, and their descendants. I did like the noir overtones, and appreciated how Celeste is allowed to be a flawed and occasionally outright awful person in her pursuit of freedom for her sister. The dissection of racism and class was really spot on, but I also feel that this book might have benefited from being expanded into a full novel. It's fine as a novella, but I think that a lot of assumptions were made regarding the reader's familiarity with Christian mythology. Explaining more about the background and science-fantasy systems would have made for a more enjoyable, longer book. That said, it's still quite good as is.

Tread Of Angels by Rebecca Roanhorse was published November 15 2022 by Saga Press and is available from all good booksellers, including <a href="https://bookshop.org/a/15382/9781982166182">Bookshop!</a>

Imagine the wild west in 1883 in Colorado where gold has just been found in the mountains, and small towns have sprung up as people from everywhere are attracted by the chance of striking gold and becoming rich. This is that book, except the mining is not for gold or silver, but for a rare element called Divinity which is in high demand. Humans live alongside with Angels (called Virtues) and Demons (the Fallen who supported Lucifer). Here, however, the Virtues are no better than the Fallen.

Two of the main characters are sisters who work in a busy casino/bar in Goetia, a mining town near the mountain where Divinity was found (washed from the remains of an archangel who fell during the war in Heaven). Mariel is an entertainer, and can't hide that she is a Fallen. The other sister, Celeste, is a dealer in the casino. She can pass as a Virtue but won't because of loyalty to her sister. One night there is a fight in the casino, and when the dust clears, a Virtue is dead and Mariel is accused of murdering him. They had been having an affair and she learned he was getting married (and not to her). Celeste takes on the role of Devil's Advocate for her sister as she believes her innocent, and begins interviewing people hoping to find someone else who had reason to kill the dead man.

This is a novella, only about 200 pages, but the story feels complete. I am hoping for more stories set in this world, and would like to see more of Celeste and some of the other characters. Thank you NetGalley and the publisher Gallery Books for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

I am a big fan of Roanhorse's writing. It always feels gritty, dirt in your teeth kind of good. In Tread of Angels, Roanhorse creates a world of Angels and Demons and places it all in a western setting. The novella follows Celeste as she moves through Elect society investigating the death of Virtue. All of this is to attempt to free her sister, Mariel, who was charged with the murder. Eliciting help from a Virtue and the demon Abraxas who happens to be her ex, she discovers that things aren't always what they seem.

I really liked Tread of Angels. While the book checks in at only 200 pages, it reads like a full length novel. Of course, I wouldn't have hated an extra hundred pages or so. There is plenty of mystery and intrigue in this fantasy western. The characters are interesting, the world building is pretty unique, and of course the racial metaphors are not lost in the story. There are plenty of twists and turns along the way to keep the story moving as well. My only complaint was the romantic element. The heat and tension between Abraxas and Celeste wasn't there for me, but I think this is mostly due to the length of the book. While we know their history, there just isn't enough pages to feel it.

Overall, a good read. It's fast paced, interesting, and kept me guessing.

I just don't think this book was for me. Rebecca Roanhorse has a fantastic writing ability but I just did not find myself caring for the characters or the plot at all. Maybe it was because it WAS a short story and it just felt like it should have been longer, but it just didn't work for me at all. The ending seemed to tie up too quickly and I actually found myself wanting the opposite outcome.

Overall, fairly forgettable for me and one I will not be reaching for again. However, I do want to give Roanhorse another try because I did like her writing style, just not this story.

Roanhorse is a strong writer and is perhaps better suited for longer works. There was a lot of focus on the very interesting setting here, so much so that the plot and characters took a backseat to it. This was an enjoyable and smooth read, but felt like it was missing something.

When everything was resolved it sure felt like the last twenty or so pages were doing a lot of the plot's legwork for it.

I love Rebecca Roanhorse, and this is an absolute knockout piece of literature. I sped through this like I probably shouldn't have, and am so glad I did. A very worthwhile read.

The mood and the setting for this book was the best thing about it! While the plot left a few things to be desired for me, this was the perfect fall read for mood and atmosphere.

The story was a great, quick read! I loved the world, the characters, and the relationships within the story. I also loved how it showed sometimes you lose everything when you try and hold on to one person for too long.

Thank you @sagapress for the #gifted copy of TREAD OF ANGELS!

Full disclosure: I requested this novella without even reading the synopsis on Goodreads. I was just like “oh, Rebecca Roanhorse? SOLD!”

Much to my delight TREAD OF ANGELS is an angelic fantasy set in the Wild West. I absolutely loved the world building and was blown away how Roanhorse sucked me into this world in such a short amount of time. The book is only 200 pages long!

In the world of TREAD OF ANGELS, the world is split into the Elect and the Fallen. The Fallen are descendants of the demons that fought with Lucifer and are treated as a lower caste. Celeste and Mariel are Fallen sisters who are put to the test when Mariel is accused of murdering a high-power Virtue. Celeste is appointed Mariel’s “devil’s advocate” and has just a few days to prove her sister’s innocence.

My main complaint is that I wanted more. I wanted the story to keep going and to spend more time in the world. I found the ending a bit unsatisfying but overall I really enjoyed it. I really hope that Roanhorse will revisit this world in a full-length novel in the future!

Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/5122306296
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/p/CljTUrGpE9L/

A very different and dark fantasy story of a world where angels and demons have fought. The story is set in 1883, where the Virtue class rules everything while the Fallen do the dirty work, like mining the element Divinity which powers their world from the mountains of Colorado. Celeste and Mariel are two sisters who work in the bar/casino, Eden. During a festival, Mariel is dragged off, accused of murdering a Virtue. Celeste is frantic to prove her sister innocent and is named her Devil's advocate but only has a few days to investigate and find the real killer.

Roanhorse has created a unique and fascinating world here. The mystery is intriguing, the characters well-drawn. The big question is how far will Celeste go to free her sister?

I received an arc of this novella yesterday (11/26/22) from the author and publisher and since it had published on 11/15/22, I made a point of reading it asap. It is a great introduction to a new author for me, Rebecca Roanhorse. I will look forward to reading more from this creative writer and hope this is the beginning of a series. My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.

I was provided an ARC of this book from the publisher Gallery Books/Saga Press via Netgalley, all opinions are my own.

I loved this novella. It has a bit of a steampunk vibe while also being a SFF mystery. This could have been a full length novel and I would have loved every minute of it. For only being about 200 pages it packs a full story. I thought the world building was great as was the character development. Normally something suffers due to the shorter nature of novellas but I feel like Roanhorse did a wonderful job with the descriptions and the characters in the short time we spend with them I had a hard time putting this down once I got started.

This follows Celeste who is trying to prove her sister's innocence after a brutal murder takes place at their place of employment. Celeste and her sister Mariel live in a world where Heaven and Hell are very real places and Angels and Demons walk the Earth. As she searches for proof that her sister is innocent, Celeste uncovers secrets that may endanger them both. She must call in favors that may damn her soul and damage relationships of those she loves.

This was full of secrets and lies. At every turn Celeste was trying to outmaneuver someone who was attempting to manipulate her. I highly recommend this dark fantasy. It is a page turner that you wont' want to put down.

Another wonderful story from Roanhorse! I’ll keep reading her work until she stops writing. Her world building is rich, her characters compelling, and the taste of romance in this book was just right for the story.

This story felt to me like a mix of two of my favorite recent stories: The Mirror Visitor and Hadestown, except with Christian mythology instead of Greek.

The steampunk world and the intriguing political system, and the mystery at the heart of the story (a classic whodunnit) made this a swift and thoroughly enjoyable read. I recommend!

3.5 stars

I am grateful to Gallery / Saga Press for sending me an advanced copy of this book for review.

This is another fun one from Rebecca Roanhorse. It was nice and short, intriguing, and fun. The use of Christian lore as inspiration for the fantastical world building in this story was a departure from her other works, where she focused on indigenous lore. I really enjoyed the setting and atmosphere; it had a very dark and ominous feel to it throughout the story. Apart from all the plot's fantastic points, I love the focus on the dynamics between the main character and her sister. The author managed to fit a mystery, complicated family dynamics, complicated romantic relationships, and the corrupt political order of a fantasy world into such few pages!

It was compulsively readable and fun.

I would recommend this to fans of paranormal fantasy, supernatural fantasy, and Rebecca Roanhorse's previous works.

Packs a punch!

This is one of those novellas where I really really REALLY want more. More of this world. More of these characters and more of this painfully delicious storyline.

Celeste is a tortured soul. Torn between her lover Abraxes who is a demon that actually wants her body and soul (and all that entails) for eternity, and her sister Mariel, who’s been put on a pedestal that she refuses to look at closely. There are some killer scenes in this book - who knew demons could be heartbroken?

This story in all its shortness still manages to give us character development in spades. Celeste tips from being the good caring sister,to morally grey, and then downright into the black. She also manages to drag Abraxes into the murk with her - when even a demon is saying you are going to far, you should know you are entering truly evil territory. The side characters are nuanced, then mix in the whole subtext of the power play between the Elect and The Fallen, and it all just leaves me wanting more.

The ending was … very reminiscent of how I felt watching Gone with the Wind. Unbelievable - 4.5/5 Stars.

Here is a quick review of the book: https://www.tiktok.com/@manda.lyn_reads/video/7163434601182989610?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc&web_id=7122485950588552746

When I found out that I received the arc of this book I was so ecstatic; I have loved all of the other Rebecca Roanhorse books I've read in the past. Unfortunately this one fell majorly short.

Set in a wild west setting, we have two sisters, one blamed for a horrible crime and the other trying to prove her innocence. The magic revolves around angels and demons, with our main two characters being outcasts from all groups as they are mixed race.

While the world was extremely interesting to learn about, the characters and plot fell flat. Everything felt predicable, and I was bored through most of the story.

Even with all of that, I am not upset that I read this book. Rebecca Roanhorse weaved through some amazing symbolism that spoke of the treatment and brutality that indigenous people face every day (and have been facing for a long time). Are there other books that have done the same thing? Yes, but this one did a great job of hitting that topic in an impactful way. I will most likely not be recommending this book to people as the plot really had me not enjoying my reading, but there are passages that I saved and will be sharing with people forever.

Thanks to Netgalley and Saga Press for giving me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!

What could have been a very interesting novel was stripped bare of its juiciest parts and left with bare bones shrouded in nice writing. The characters were flat and didn’t have enough screen time to make us care about them or their development (or even understand them apart from the role they played). The world was the barest hint of developed.

I will say I really liked the analysis of Celeste’s mixed heritage and how her Elect-passing looks allow her to enter places a Fallen could never, but the reality of her bloodline means she can never truly belong. I would have liked to see more of her passing privilege in action, with more interactions with other Fallen.

The story didn’t grab me (I’ve never been particularly interested in angels and demons, I guess) and I finished the book without feeling any type of way about it.

Tread of Angels is the story of Celeste, who is a card sharp, and a Fallen. In the city of Goetia, there are descendants of Lucifer and those who rebelled with him, and they are Fallen. They are the lowest class of people, but necessary, as only they can see the element of Divinity, used to power all kinds of neat things. The descendants of those who fought against Lucifer are Elect, and those who run the city of Goetia are Virtues. When Celeste’s sister Mariel is accused of murdering a Virtue, Celeste takes on the role of the Devil’s Advocate to defend her, and many shenanigans come to light.

This was an interesting story, and I quite enjoyed it! It’s quite short, more of a novella, but it was just long enough, I thought, to get the whole story out. I really enjoyed the world of Goetia, which was something like a noir/western feeling place, but with weird technologies that were powered by this new element they call Divinity (mined from the remains of Abbadon). The world reminded me somewhat of Trigun for some reason, so that might help some of you decide if you’d enjoy it.

All told, I liked this one. Read the whole thing in an evening and it was still making me think about it and imagine the world it takes place in over the next couple of days, and into the start of another book. So that is always a good thing!

I have always loved stories with angels and demons mixing with humans in a world that is very nearly like ours. This one is a murder mystery and it's not set in the present. HonestlyI didn't really get when it was set, but I still enjoyed it and I didn't get the murderer even if I could've gotten it. It was very easy to follow even with the world complexity and lots of details just thrown there. It's a novella so there isn't enough space for tons of details but it's still enjoyable. I'd really like another story set in this world.