Member Reviews

Lessons is an extraordinary book written by an extraordinarily gifted writer, and I am grateful to him, Knopf, and NetGalley for providing me an advanced digital copy for my honest review. Lessons is the most recent in a long, celebrated list of books written by Ian McEwan, winner of multiple, prestigious literary awards including the National Book Critics Circle Award, the Booker Prize, and the Whitbread Award.

The story follows the protagonist through the majority of history’s major events, from World War II through the current pandemic, jumping seamlessly between past and present events, always from the protagonist’s point of view. He lives life haphazardly, not seeming to accomplish much, but having a full life nonetheless. We feel his deep emotions as he lives his first few years freely as a British military Captain’s son in colonial Libya, then banished to a boarding school in England where he becomes in thrall to his piano teacher, and later when he’s left by his wife to raise their infant son alone, and on and on throughout his life until he is an old man in his seventies with stepchildren and grandchildren and having lived through multiple losses and deaths, and remembering and reliving and returning to various previous times in his life. Parts of the book are so brilliantly written as to be among the best prose I’ve ever read, while other parts seemed to drag a bit and, to me, could have been cut a bit shorter. Nevertheless, the book in it’s entirety is nothing short of a masterpiece.

Was this review helpful?

I am generally a fan of Ian McEwan's work, but this one is less compelling than usual. The story plods along through multiple character's stories over decades and lacks the energy needed to carry it. At the core is an interesting story idea: a teenage boy manipulated by his piano teacher until he walks squarely in to her seduction plot and how that impacts his life and relationships henceforth.

Was this review helpful?

From famed author Ian McEwan, a heartbreaking book about child sexual abuse and the decades of the ripple effect it has on a person.
Roland’s life spans numerous historical events, but the most affecting moment for him happened during his elementary years when his piano teacher, a young attractive lady, grooms and shapes him into her playtoy. We age along with Roland and witness as his view of those years slowly evolves and he comes to grips with what really happened.
This would be a difficult book to read for a survivor of child sexual abuse. The cleverness of Miss Miriam Cornell and the weakness of young Ian is heartbreaking. She steals his childhood and makes him responsible for what she has done. As his remaining years unfold and he witnesses numerous major moments in history, the aspect that keeps him off balance and unable to live a full and happy life always goes back to those moments with his piano teacher.
Ian also has the uncanny luck to fall in love with a woman who decides she didn’t mean to be a wife and mother. Instead, she’s meant to be an author. She does become an internationally famous author, but at what cost to the husband and child she walked out on?
This is one man’s story; a believable chain of unfortunate events that slowly pushes Ian along thru his years. With tenderness and astoundingly cold accuracy, McEwan dissects a young boy’s life.
Thanks so much to Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I could not connect with the main character. The book is about Roland from his childhood to his senior year, what he lived and past through history. What influeced him and what was influeced by him.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this newest work by Ian McEwan, but didn't. The story follows a man going back through his life against the backdrop of some of modern history's biggest moments following his divorce. It was long. Maybe it tried to put in too much. But something didn't strike a cord with me. If you enjoy overarching, memoir esque stories then you will love this.

Thank you netgalley and publisher for the dARC of this work in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are mine.

Was this review helpful?

The publisher of this book called it a masterpiece. Having read that before I read the book, I had high expectations. Sometimes expectations can be surpassed: this was one of those times. As a new reader to Ian McEwan, I had no preconceives about his writing before this novel.

Lessons is the story of an overly protected, vulnerable child who was sent to an English boarding school at the age of eleven, where his innocence would end. McEwan weaves a story of Roland Baines restless life through adolescence to fatherhood to maturity. Although Roland had multiple talents, his life consisted of lost opportunities and lack of commitment, living hand to mouth much of the time.

Women play a vital role in Roland’s life: a protective mother, an abusive teacher, an absent wife (who leaves him with a seven-month-old baby boy) and his best friend/later wife whose life was cut too short. McEwan give each of these women in-depth characterization: I felt sympathy for the first, revulsion for the second and third, and empathy for the fourth.

One of the reasons that I enjoyed this book was that Roland’s life is presented in relationship to historical events of the day. I am the same age as he, so I remember how I felt as a young teen during the Cuban Missile Crisis, as a young adult when the Berlin Wall fell, and in my 70’s during Covid. There is also considerable back history as Roland tells the stories of his parents and his in-laws.

The depth of this novel is what makes it so appealing. McEwan is a masterful storyteller.
I thank Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group and NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book. My opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Pub date: 9/13/22
Genre: literary fiction
One sentence summary: Lessons follows the life of Roland Baines from post-WWII London to the COVID pandemic.
Trigger warnings: sexual abuse, child abandonment, physical violence

I really respect what McEwan was trying to do with this book - family sagas are some of my favorite books to read, and it's wonderful when writers can capture how people and the world change over time. Unfortunately, there was too much going on in this book for me to really enjoy it. Not only did it cover a huge period of time, it also went into way too much detail about mundane things and jumped around in time a lot, so it was hard to get my bearings as a reader. The long sentences/paragraphs/chapters also didn't help - it was hard to keep everything straight in my mind. I enjoyed the audio narration by Simon McBurney, but the time hops made it difficult to listen and comprehend everything going on.

If you are a literary fiction superfan, you may enjoy this one more than I did.

Thank you to Knopf for my ARC and Libro.fm/Recorded Books for my ALC.

Was this review helpful?

"Lessons" by Ian McEwan is a poetic, linked in history, melancholy tale of a boy's life. I appreciated the world events and various destinations, as well as traumas in his life leaving deep impact, as well influencing the life of the main character. Thank you NetGalley, the author and publisher for the e-copy for review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

🌟LESSONS🌟 by Ian McEwan ~published September 13, 2022

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A superbly-written rumination on childhood, parenthood, cause and effect. Sweeping, and consequently, very long!

Thanks so much to @aaknopf and @netgalley for the gifted advance review copy. All thoughts are my own.

Hi, kids! Let’s learn the alphabet today! A is for Absence. Abandonment. Abuse. (No, not Atonement this time…)

We are introduced to single father Roland Baines and his infant son, Lawrence, as Roland reflects on the absence of the two most crucial women in his life – his missing wife, Alissa, and his sexually abusive ex-piano teacher, Miriam Cornell – and how best to move on from them both. It is beautifully and masterfully written (it’s McEwan, afterall), and Roland’s personal turmoil coils itself around the historical upheavals of the time (the Cuban missile crisis, Chernobyl, the fall of the Berlin Wall, and eventually even Covid). The theme of abandonment is strong and is probably what I will remember most months from now – particularly Alissa’s decision to sever herself from her child, so utterly and completely, believing that it was the only way to fulfill her career ambitions. For adoring this one as much as I did, oddly I don’t have much else to say. Brilliant, but a tad too long. Best read in larger chunks, I think. The ending is hopeful!

This review will be posted on October 5 and I will include a link at that time.

Was this review helpful?

This book follows the life of Roland Baines, his traumas, romantic and family relationships across various historical events, from the World War II to the pandemic.

I’ve found the book slow paced but it is interesting to see those events from Roland’s eyes.
While the prose is beautiful and the book well written, wouldn’t it be from Ian McEwan, the large paragraphs and overall formatting were discouraging, and I would have preferred to read it in the first person.

Thank you Netgalley and Knopf Doubleday Publishinging for the advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Conflicted. I give this high marks mostly on the strength of the prose. The authorial skill is undeniable for me. I was often lost in the sentences that were simple and beautiful. I thought the author was able to make the mundane very compelling.

Having said that... the story... well it's sort of Forest Gumpish (not actually praise from me -- I didn't love Forest Gump) I found myself disconnecting from the actual plot -- which includes a lot of uncomfortable situations. As much as liked the writing I did NOT want to pick up this book, and if I didn't have to give it an honest review, I probably would have dnf'd.

Was this review helpful?

McEwan is back on form after a few wacky recent writing projects. (Nutshell—really? A sentient fetus realizes that there’s a Hamlet-like plot afoot between his mother and uncle to do away with his father?) Though this new novel is absent the electrifying climactic moments of some of his best novels, it’s a sweeping look back at almost a century of major events, told through the lens of a single, somewhat unremarkable life.

Roland Baines is 11 years old in the late 50s when he’s sent to a British public school, as his military father is posted in Libya (and anti-British sentiment is running pretty high due to the Suez crisis). Alone, 2,000 miles from his beloved mum, he’s given piano lessons by a young woman teacher who engages in wildly inappropriate—sexual—behaviour. A few years later, and another crisis, the Cuban missile crisis, launches Roland on a course of action with this teacher whose repercussions send his life veering very much off course from what it might otherwise have been. And so it goes. Roland drifts, travels, has a “lost decade,” and we join him back in London trying to cope with his seven-month-old son alone after his German wife abandons them—just walks out without notice, leaving a “sorry” note behind. The decades roll by, and Roland continues to experience major events (for instance, he happens to be in Berlin when the wall comes down) until we reach the present day, and Roland is a 70-something chap looking back, considering his life.

I said earlier in this review that Roland’s was an unremarkable life, but I think that’s part of McEwan’s point. We most of us do live quite ordinary lives, don’t we? Though we’re all witnesses to and part of historical disruptions, and perhaps domestic disruptions, that affect and shape our lives. I wasn’t enrapt as I read this book, but I’ve not stopped thinking about it since. It’s subtle and very humane in its effects.

Was this review helpful?

I really want to love Lessons but unfortunately it hasn't held my attention. I set it aside when I was 15% in as a "not right now" book. I plan to pick it back up at a later time.

Was this review helpful?

Lessons is the latest from Ian McEwan, famous for Atonement. McEwan's best works, Atonement including, is marked by an aloofness that draws the reader in as a means of getting closer to the characters. This is also true of his less than stellar works, which fail at making the characters intriguing enough to want to get much closer. Lessons unfortunately falls in the latter category. I found it difficult to connect with the characters, and at time a slog to get through. That said, McEwan is incredible at placing his readers in a time and place, and I enjoyed visiting various points in contemporary history.

Was this review helpful?

One of my all-time favorite books is Atonement so I was thrilled to learn that Ian Ewan had recently published a new book. Lessons - ah hah! There must be something to learn from the literal lessons on the piano. However, that was just the beginning of a life spent learning, a life-long learner as we glibly say. It was not a fast read but I did like it.

It has a Forest Gump feel in that he seems to have experienced all the world’s events, one way or the other, from the Berlin Wall coming down to Covid-19. I wonder how autobiographical this is since the author and Roland Baines are the same age at the conclusion of the book. If you’re looking for another book like William Boyd’s Any Human Heart, this isn’t it

Was this review helpful?

I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

This is my first experience with Ian McEwan, and this may be the case of not every book appeals to every person.

There were elements of the book I enjoyed. Ronald Barnes an the experiences he had throughout his life were fascinating. While away at boarding school, Ronald is seduced by his piano teacher and enters into a very inappropriate relationship. The impact of that relationship plays a significant role in his entire life. Ironically, many years later, Ronald’s wife leaves him to pursue her writing career and he is left to raise their young son as a solo parent..

As we follow Ronald’s life, we are exposed to the various historical events occurring in the world and see their impact on Ronald. Many of these events were interesting to see in this vein.

I think this was a good novel but the story line contained too many details and I found myself lost/distracted at times.

Was this review helpful?

This was the first book I've read from this author and I didn't enjoy it as much as I hoped. It was a little hard for me to get involved in the story, and I wasn't a huge fan of the beginning. I'm definitely going to give his other books a try.

Was this review helpful?

I had some difficulty getting into reading Lessons. However, once I got into the rhythm of the story I settled in and enjoyed the lengthy ride to the end. Roland, the main character, is restless, fearful, abandoned and questioning about himself and his relationships with others and the world. We follow him as he learns things about himself and others around him. Lessons is well written, thought provoking and aptly titled.

Was this review helpful?

Lessons by Ian McEwan was covered in my Fall Book Preview, where I share a curated list of the season’s hottest new titles including the books I’ve most enjoyed, the ones I’m most looking forward to reading, and the ones the industry is most excited about. This is a story of love and desire that spans time.
Our Fall Book Preview event is exclusively for members of our MMD Book Club community and What Should I Read Next Patreon “Book Lover” supporters. Our communities also received a printable of all the picks with Lessons' publishing info and release date included.

Was this review helpful?

This book not only shows the characters learning their lessons, it has a few teachings for the reader, as well. The story follows the protagonist, Roland Baines, as he receives a series of harsh life lessons, at the center of each is a woman. There is Miriam, his piano teacher at boarding school, a woman who enters into a manipulative sexual relationship with Roland while he’s still a minor. There is Alissa, the wife who abandons Roland and their seven-month-old child to pursue her writing career. Finally, when a woman, Daphne, comes along with whom he can at last have a healthy relationship with a dependable partner, he has difficulty embracing the relationship because of his earlier experiences. We also witness the intergenerational learning of Alissa, whose mother never made good on her own potential as a writer.

The lessons for the reader are profound. First, after developing an intense and visceral dislike for Alissa because she abandons a baby and seems so oblivious to the suffering her actions have caused (e.g. her husband being suspected of a murder that never happened,) we are reminded that disappearing dads are par for the course; we may think poorly of them, but we rarely have an intense emotional response to such situations. Second, we are offered insight into the “intentional fallacy” – i.e. thinking one knows the author’s intentions and subjective thought processes from what she writes.

I found this to be a powerful story that asks one to confront all manner of intriguing questions. (e.g. If an individual ditches her [or his] family for career, does it make a difference if that person is the best at what she does or if she’s mediocre or if she stinks?) I’d highly recommend this novel for readers of literary fiction.

Was this review helpful?