Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I was having withdrawals from reading cute/uncomplicated romance novels and this one didn't disappoint.

Eli and Leah were so cute together and I loved all of the movies the group had Eli watch during his romantic hero transformation. I did agree with Leah though about how if you need to completely change everything about you for your potential partner to love you then maybe they're not the one for you.

The only thing I wish was different about this book is the pace of it. The storyline felt like it kinda dragged and then the ending was rushed. I wish there was more time for Leah and Eli and that Patrick really got what he deserved in the end. For being so awful throughout the whole book, I wasn't satisfied with how Leah dealt with Patrick. THAT part should have been a grand gesture (and not a good one for him).

Was this review helpful?

Loved this exploration of what we've been taught to expect versus what we really need - how have classic romcoms set us up for success or failure? Jayne Denker perfectly balances hope and grief in this sweet story of finding love in all forms when we open ourselves up to the possibility. It's a great romance but also a story of finding your people, the friends who become family. If you've ever felt lonely, The Rom-Com Agenda will give you hope for a community, and love, waiting for you to find it.

Was this review helpful?

The Rom-Com Agenda is a fun, and sweet read. I read this novel pretty quickly but I found the two main characters, Leah and Eli, to be endearing. I found this book to be very reliant on tropes and as both the name and description would suggest, it does take bits and pieces of popular rom-com movies and weave them into the story. However, I think the characters are strong enough to make this novel a solid read. Overall, I would rate this a 3.5/5 and I would recommend to someone that is looking for something fun and easy to read.

Was this review helpful?

Things to like about this book (the reasons I would recommend it):
- friends-to-lovers - It was done well, without either of the characters falling hard too fast. The pacing for this was good, which made it believable.
- dual perspective (which, if you’ve read any of my other reviews, you know I love…. I don’t think I’ll ever stop liking this, unless someone really botches it)
- found family - Leah was a foster child and comes back to care for her foster mom when her son couldn’t be bothered to; points to her for being an awesome human being and putting up with her foster brother, who is definitely not a prize. The side characters made this book a lot of fun to read.
Things that I didn’t necessarily not like, but annoyed me a little bit:
- quite a few clichés
- Eli’s obsession with getting his ex back when she is so obviously not interested. He’s willing to change everything about him to get her back. How is that worth it? And after way too long, how can he still not move on - they barely spent two months together! This part was just not at all believable.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for granting me a digital copy of the book. The opinions above are my own honest opinions.

Was this review helpful?

Phew! Let’s begin with the fact that it was hard for me to get over the end of this book. I feel like I need more. This book definitely does justice to the title. You will relive the love for certain classic romcoms and it’s chef kiss. It has found family and it’s in the friends to lovers trope (also, small town!). It has it funny moments but it also has moments that leave you thinking about life. There are a couple of characters but is not hard to follow. Eli and Leah were perfect for each other since the beginning. However, it was kind of hard to see him so focused on his ex when Leah was there for him. A worth to read love story, my heart is full.

Like I said on the beginning I would have loved to read a little more of Eli and Leah’s happy ending.

Stars: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spicyness: 🌶🌶
Pub date: Jan. 4, 2023

P.S loved the references of Star Wars @jaynedenkerauthor

Was this review helpful?

This was a typical friends to lovers romance and while usually that is my favourite trope, I wouldn’t say this was one of my favourite versions of it. I did like the book, I just found it a little cliche at times. It was still a really cute story that I think most people will love.

Thank you to NetGallery and St. Martins Press for this eARC!

Was this review helpful?

Mixed feelings here.

Leah Keegan returned to her foster mom’s home to care for her in her last days. She is living in her home (anticipating her mom’s son kicking her out) and working for funds to leave town.

Eli Masterson has just had his heart broken and is looking to win her back. His family/friends decide he needs a total makeover (physical, manners, etc.), and Leah helps by selling him a new wardrobe. He is then pushed into watching rom-coms to learn how to be a sworn-worthy hero. Eli and Leah become friends and begin hanging out (movies, plus ones, etc.).

Will Eli FINALLY get over Victoria and recognize who’s right in front of him? Will Leah stop running away and stay with her new friends/Eli?

First off, the movie references (mostly 80s) are wonderful…great memories. But the storyline would have been better for younger mains. At 30, I found Eli too immature, especially in his reaction to and failure to accept his breakup…but honestly really overall. He did have his sweet, redeeming moments, but they were overshadowed by the specter of his “true love” Victoria. And unfortunately, I didn’t connect with any of the characters. I felt I only saw them superficially, not anything with depth. The writing was fine but just not enough to make up for my other issues.

This is my overview. I’m sure others will enjoy this one without any caveats.

My thanks to the author, NetGalley and St. Martin’s Griffin for providing the free early arc of The Rom-Com Agenda for review. The opinions are strictly my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Rom-Com Agenda is a delightful read full of endearing characters and rom com references. Leah is a former foster kid who feels like she has never belonged anywhere or with anyone. She works a handful of jobs, trying to make enough money to leave town and start over somewhere new. Eli is the opposite- loving mother, older sister who clearly adores him, and a friend group full of unique personalities. Eli is caught up on his ex girlfriend, and his sister and friends decide he needs a complete makeover to get her to take him back. Leah gets drawn in and starts to help with the plan after helping the group while at one of her jobs. As Leah and Eli get to know each other, sparks start to sizzle and both begin to doubt their previous feelings.

The lead characters have amazing chemistry that grows so naturally throughout the story. Their banter is adorable, especially when bantering about all the rom coms Eli’s sister demands that he watch. Leah is a strong, independent female character who is unafraid to call out the makeover plan as unnecessary even as she supports Eli through it. I did want to talk some sense into Eli at times, but luckily he gets where he needs to go in the end! I adored the secondary characters and how they became a found family for Leah, the first family she has really ever known.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press / St. Martin’s Griffin for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion!

Was this review helpful?

The Rom Com Agenda
⭐️⭐️⭐️

🎥This book was your classic rom com, where at points it was almost a bit too cheesy. They even reference a ton of classic rom com movies throughout. Now while parts were a little cliché, and this was a closed door romance, you could feel the connection between Leah and Eli.

🎥While this book wasn’t too different from any book I’ve read before, I did appreciate how I did root for Leah throughout the book, I enjoyed how warm Eli’s friends and family will make you feel.

🎥If you’re interested in an easy going rom com, family and friends who will always have our female and male main character’s back, and an independent female main character, this one is for you! You can check it out when it is released January 10, 2023.

Thank you to Net Galley and St. Martin’s Griffin for a copy of this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Eli just got dumped by his girlfriend of 4 months. She goes on an extended trip to Europe and Eli pines for her back home. To pull him out of his breakup funk, his family and friends decide a makeover is in order. If Eli is so intent on winning Victoria back, he’s going to need a complete overhaul.

Leah has spent the last year taking care of her dying foster mom. Now juggling a dozen different jobs, Leah is trying to save money so she can finally leave Willow Cove behind her. After all, she doesn’t have any reason to stay… until she meets Eli.


Things I liked:
💗 Friends to lovers trope
💗 Found family trope
💗 Eli’s friend group/family
💗 All of the rom-com movie references
💗 Leah’s background + her resilience

Things I didn’t like:
👎🏻 Eli spending so much of the book pining over Victoria
👎🏻 Eli’s wishy-washy feelings towards Leah
👎🏻 The makeover came across as mean at times

Thank you St.Martin’s Press, and NetGalley for an eARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Rom-Com Agenda

- Friends to lovers
- Slow burn
- Found Family
- 80s 90s 00s rom com movie references

This book was fun. It was cute and easy to read. It follows Eli who plans to win back his ex girlfriend who broke up with him and left for Rome. Eli and his friends create an elaborate plan to win his ex back by using rom com movies. Leah just suffered a huge loss and is just trying to get by, until she is reluctantly recruited to help Eli in his plan to get his ex back. She becomes Eli's expert on rom com movies and the two begin a sweet friendship that has developing feelings that feel less like friends and more like love.

Overall I enjoyed this book and all the pop culture references and Eli's friend group. However, I did not like the pacing of the book and all the random side plots. There was too many side characters and the whole point of Eli being so oblivious to leah's feeling was not my fav. The book felt unfinished at points.

A huge thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book. It managed to make me fall in love with the characters right from the start, wich is rare for me. It was everything I needed and more, I simply could not stop smiling.

Please give this one a chance if you love a good romance that will not only warm your heart but also make you care deeply for the characters.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so good and went so much deeper than I expected. Leah is such an amazing character and I really felt her struggles and emotions throughout the novel. Eli was such a sweetheart, misguided at times, but still sweet. I adored the friend group that surrounded Eli (and then Leah) and how authentic their interactions were. Even though this is a romance, Leah and Eli both have growth throughout the story and this book also highlights the foster care system and foster kids. It balances the deeper moments well where they don't feel too heavy but you know they still matter. This was mostly closed door romance (nothing graphic beyond making out) so 1/5 for spice. Really recommend checking this out for a deeper-connecting romance.

I also hope to get more stories from this town and friend group in the future!

Was this review helpful?

This book was so cute and I loved it so much! I really enjoyed it. It was right up my alley. So good.

Was this review helpful?

Eli and Leah. Eli has a failed marriage proposal, months of wallowing, and then his family decides to give him the rom com makeover to try and woo his ex into taking him back and wanting to get married. Leah gets roped into helping with the rom com makeover.

Tropes: found family, friends to lovers
Things I liked: the side characters, Eli (when he wasn't being an oblivious man), Leah
Things I didn't like: Eli spending too much time pining over the ex, Eli going back and forth between Leah and the ex with thoughts/actions

Overall this is a good choice for a rom com lover and an enjoyable read. I voluntarily reviewed an ARC of this book. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to be an early reader.

Was this review helpful?

Poor Eli. Dumped by his girlfriend when she leaves for Rome and turns down his proposal. Into the sulky depths he falls and his friends have had enough of it. If he intends to win her back, he needs a serious makeover. Poor Leah is dragged into the makeover situation by chance and gains a loyal group of friends. Along the way and still sniveling about the lost love, Eli discovers something in Leah and she in him. But the ex is hovering over everything.
It is a cute and fun novel with lots of pushing and shoving Eli and pulling at Leah.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to love and adore this book, but something really held me back. While I enjoyed it overall, and thought it had really redeeming qualities, it all felt just a bit too much throughout the book.

We had a loud friend group - fun, until it felt like too much.
We had the love sick Eli - head over heels Gaga in love with someone he’s known for 4 months who clearly didn’t return the favor, but the entire book is about getting him ready for her return? Felt like too much!
Leah - what a tough life. I loved her story because it added some much needed depth to the story. This part I liked!

Overall, i think this could have been edited a bit more to be less extreme and more real.

Was this review helpful?

3 Stars. As someone who loves rom-coms, I enjoyed the references to some of my favorite movies. The premise was cute and I liked the main characters. I had a hard time enjoying this one. It had a heavier tone than I anticipated from the title, and some things felt a little over-explained, if that makes sense. I also felt like with all of the different side characters, there was just so much going on, If you enjoy a romance that isn't all light and fluffy, you should pick this one up.

Thank you to NetGalley & St, Martin's Press for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This completely predictable but very sweet and satisfying romance is about a man pining for the one that got away. Eli’s siblings push him to watch romantic comedy movies so he can make a grand gesture when Victoria returns from her time abroad and more often than not, their new friend Leah becomes his default practice date. A bit of an introvert (and a bit insecure), the more time Leah spends with Eli, the more sure she is that he is pretty perfect as is, and anyone who didn’t accept him doesn’t deserve him. Eli is confused at how he can be attracted to Leah when he is waiting for the return of a woman he prematurely proposed to.

The story has a lot of the heart, and the allusions to many favorite romantic comedies (and the dissection of them!) is a major plot point,. Lots of fan service for Gen-Xers.

I received a free advance reader’s review copy of #TheRomComAgenda from #NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you @netgalley for the ARC copy. I had so much I didn't like about this book. The characters, plot, romance, EVERYTHING. I found myself struggling with relationship between the MC's - Leah was such a catch from the start, and Eli was way too stuck on another woman that wasn't even worth his time. However, Leah was also incredibly self-deprecating and didn't realize how special she was either. The side characters were frustrating and adding nothing to the plot. I skipped the last 25 pages and read the end because I was that frustrated. It was really bad. I almost didn't finish. Do not recommend.

Was this review helpful?