Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Super fun friends-to-lovers romcom! It hits every beat you want in a rom-com and was cozy and light! Really enjoyed this read and highly recommend it! Thank you to Netgalley and SMP for this ARC in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I didn’t initially think I was a fan of the friends-to-lovers trope, but I’m being persuaded. The Rom-Com agenda is a great contributor. I’m a sucker for found family. This is such an adorable, fun read loaded with all the feels. Highly recommend to anyone who loves a fun, feel-good romcom!

Was this review helpful?

this was such a cute feel good story! this was my first book by this author and i really enjoyed it! the plot and character development was executed very well! The pacing was also done well! not too sped up but also not hyper focusing on certain timeframes!

This story follows Leah and Eli… who somehow live in the same town but never crossed paths! Leah unfortunately overhears the uncomfortable break up that Eli goes through and from that point on, runs into him everywhere! Eli’s family and friends are set out on giving him a physical and personality makeover so he can win back his girlfriend when she comes back from abroad. Because leah works at almost every place in town… she gets to witness all of the “makeover” antics 😂 through this, they form a great friendship… which of course turns to something more!

I loved all the cute famous romcom references and how Eli tried so very hard to watch all the classic 80s movie to help inspire him. The characters growth was so amazing too, on both sides, with Leah, who struggled with feeling like she belonged and having people who cared for her and for Eli, who jumped into things way too fast but had the biggest most caring heart in the world!

the supporting characters also brought this story to life. they were funny and supportive to the main characters. they had their own backstories that we were also rooting for! I hope we can see more of them down the road!

You should read this if you love friends to lovers, found family, small town romance, amazing supporting characters and a cute sassy cat!

Thank you to St. Martin’s Press, NetGalley and Jayne Denker for this Advanced Readers copy in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This story starts with sweet and clueless Eli Masterson and his “girlfriend “ Victoria breaking up and her moving to Rome for a year. Leah Keegan is alone in town after her foster mother dies and while working one of her hundred jobs, Leah stumbles upon Eli and his friends. She finds herself being sucked into their Rom-Com makeover agenda and getting cozy with Eli in the process.
The Rom-Com Agenda is cute, sweet and very predictable. I enjoyed reading it but the constant talk about Victoria and denying feelings for Leah/Eli got to be a lot! I would recommend it for someone looking for a cute, lighthearted read. Thank you so NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for an ARC copy.

Was this review helpful?

I’m a huge fan of rom coms and this book definitely did not disappoint! It was a bit slow at first but the second half of the book was amazing! I love the found family in this book for Leah. When Leah realized she had people to count on, she decided to stay instead of fleeing town. I also loved all the rom com movies mentioned in the book! Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a light closed door (no spice) romance!

Was this review helpful?

A cute, sweet read! I thought the romance was very well-developed, however the characters felt a little flat. The story itself felt a little lacking overall, but it still delivered the fluffy romance it promises.

Was this review helpful?

I’m a fan of the friends-to-lovers trope and the found family trope, so I was really looking forward to reading The Rom-Come Agenda. While parts of this book were enjoyable to read, other parts fell flat for me. Let's talk about it.

We first meet Eli when he’s being dumped by his girlfriend because she thinks he’s moving too fast. After feeling really down about the breakup for several months, his friends decide to help him win his ex back and Leah gets recruited into Eli’s makeover.

What was disappointing to me about this book was just how long and how much Eli obsessed over his ex, even though Leah was obviously a better match for him. When Eli wasn’t obsessing over changing in order to get his ex back, he was a decent character who actually had a personality. I didn't like Eli going back and forth between thinking about getting his ex back and then saying all the sweet things to Leah. Also, the writing was just all right; certain jokes needed to be edited out and certain sub-plots felt undeveloped.

Leah was great. Sure she has some healing to do (who doesn't?), but she's a pretty secure character who has dreams and ambition. She also sees Eli for the great person he is and thinks this whole makeover plan is unnecessary.

I did like Leah and Eli together because they made sense and were good for each other; I wanted them to have their happily ever after even if I didn’t necessarily like how they got there.

Overall, this book was humorous and (mostly) enjoyable as a light read. The meddlesome, but well-meaning, side characters were a fun addition too. Personally, I liked the 80s and 90s romance movie references and the found family aspect in this book the most.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed reading this book. Was hard to put down. Loved the depth of the characters. I loved the ending. Something I wasn't excepting.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin Press for this ARC.

Leah Keegan is ready to leave Willow Cove and never look back. Eli Masterson is determined to win back the love of his life, Victoria, who left for Rome after Eli proposed. Eli thinks that by turning into the ideal man, Victoria will come running back, and somehow Leah ends up helping him.
This includes watching classic rom-coms like Say Anything and Dirty Dancing, among others. As the two spend more and more time together, there’s no denying the spark they feel, but will they dismiss their feelings for each or fall head over heels?

Review: I didn’t hate it. But, I didn’t love it either. I loved the nostalgia of the movies Leah and Eli watched and their banter. I also really enjoyed the secondary characters and would love to read more about them. However, Eli spent far too much of the book being hung up on Victoria and I didn’t love Leah’s storyline of needing to leave Willow Cove. It was a quick, easy read, but not a must read.

Was this review helpful?

This was a cute book with a super fun premise! Love the fact that what Eli needed was right in front of him all along!

Was this review helpful?

The Rom-Com Agenda was a perfect mix of humor, grief, and romance. Our heroine, Leah, is struggling with the grief of the loss of her foster mother, but the grief is more complicated in that she was the sole caregiver of said foster mother when she got sick with cancer. This spoke to me personally, as I recently lost my partner to whom I was a caregiver. I connected with Leah on a different level than I expected to, and it made this novel all the more enjoyable, although difficult. Our hero, Eli, is dense but totally lovable. Naturally, I've dubbed him my newest book boyfriend. He's charming, humble, and funny. The family Leah finds in Eli's friends and family is just fantastic. Their dynamic was so fun and warm, and it made me want to join them and find my own family in them. I loved every single character and I wanted more of them! This is a very solid romance book, and I loved every second of it.

Was this review helpful?

This is my first book by Jayne Denker and I typically love friends to lovers. I was intrigued by the male main character getting a make over. It was a slooow burn and with the mmc still pining over his ex made it a bit hard to stay into it. This book was a good dose of nostalgia for me with all the 80s/90s pop culture references. Overall, it was a decent read and I’d be interested in checking out another book by this author.

Was this review helpful?

This book has a really cute premise but fell flat for me.

The pacing and writing style did not work for me. Also there were too many side plots and side characters. It was just a rollercoaster. It seemed to be a slow burn and then shifted to insta-love within a few sentences.

Some will love this book. It just wasn’t the book for me.

Was this review helpful?

I hate doing this, but I had to DNF. I just could not get into it. I think Eli's character was just excruciating.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for my review.

Was this review helpful?

DNF - This sounded really intriguing with the ode to those culture classic rom-com films but, in the end I was really disengaged because of Eli's behavior. I could not understand acting as he did after a single digit amount of months.....proposing marriage, never listening to said partner when they were clearly uncomfortable with the conversation he kept pushing forward; it was all too much. His chapters felt excruciating because this is meant to be a grown man. Unfortunately, he was severely poorly-adjusted & that just wasn't a cute act to read about. Poor Leah honestly.

Was this review helpful?

This book was fine. The characters were fine. Same for the setting and the plot. I waited for something surprising to happen, but that something never came. Decent comfort read.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really cute idea for a romance! Leah and Eli had a slow burn romance, but I was rooting for them the whole way. I think my only issue with it is that Eli was caught up on his ex for too much of the book and that took away from the romance with Leah in my opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to St Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the e-ARC!

I’m a total sucker for this book, and I really didn’t think I would be. Finding yourself in a small town? Check. Slow burn romance? Check. Many many references to classic rom com movies? Check. Makeover where the character realizes they’re actually awesome (and super lovable) the way they are? CHECK.

I really cared about the characters, and they felt really true to life. I also loved how they both grew and changed through the course of the book, albeit in ways I bet Eli and Leah never would have expected. Definitely recommend this one!

Was this review helpful?

This book is adorable!! The cutest romance I've read in a while!
While slightly predictable, it was a comforting and heartwarming story a girl who finds love and friendship just as she plans to leave town! Usually I don't love friends to lovers, but reading about Leah trying to help the guy she likes get his girl back - even tho his friends say he needs to move on - was just too good to put down!
Leah helps Eli work to get back with his ex - all while falling for him herself! And not just for Eli, but his friends and family too!
This was a wonderful book I would recommend to anyone who loves comfort reads, winter vibes and a good old fashioned love story!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book. The plot was well paced and the characters were well developed. I would recommend this book to others.

Was this review helpful?