Member Reviews

First off I want to thank TOR and Netgalley for providing me an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

NGL - writing this breaks my heart because I’ve been waiting for this sequel for over a year. Given how much I LOVED The Atlas Six this was probably my most anticipated book of the year. Unfortunately, Blake did not manage to write up to the hype she cultivated with this first book of the series. I don’t want to spoil anyone so I’ll try to be as specific as I can without doing so.

One of the things that sucked me into TA6 was the world building and character development. Not only was it incredibly well written and well paced, but it was engaging - more so than almost anything else I’ve read! The magic system was heavily rooted in science to the extent that I could reasonably see how the world we live in now could have been different with a few well placed technological developments. Granted I understand a decent amount about science but I never felt bogged down by Blake’s elaboration - I felt fascinated and respected! The fact that Blake managed to do a lot of describing without condescension was impressive and TA6 was better for it. Given HOW MUCH development occurred in The Atlas Paradox with certain characters learning new things about their abilities, I expected more of the same. That’s on me I guess, because what could have been more of what I loved from TA6 was just pretentious word vomit with no descriptive value.

What’s worse is that by the end of the book we have learned absolutely nothing about the characters we came to love in TA6. They just feel like hollow stereotypes with maybe one defining trait (if they’re lucky) that Blake puppets around to do things just for the sake of wondering what would happen if XYZ. Especially given how much I LOVED these characters, this is a huge disservice to the potential development that could have happened.

My past and biggest critique is that there is… no plot. Literally. If someone asked me what happened in this book I would say 3 words. Even better is the fact that those three words have NO larger purpose from what I can tell. They mean that we end up at more or less the exact same place we were left at the end of TA6 minus maybe 5 pages.

All in all, this book suffers heavily from 2nd-book-in-the-trilogy syndrome and it’s worse for it.

Was this review helpful?

Just like the first book, this was incredible! I couldn't put it down and I am so excited to see it on the shelves of my store and that I can now publicky about it!

Was this review helpful?

The Atlas Paradox is a different beast from The Atlas Six and with no murder plot looming over their heads, one of them lost in time, and study topic decisions looming, the Alexandrian Society initiates find themselves mostly existing quietly amongst themselves for most of this novel. The Atlas Paradox, then, is a naturally slower novel than its predecessor that can seem to wander aimlessly in places, but Olivie Blake's characters and their fascinating interior perspectives kept me from ever growing bored or unsure of this novel. While I do think it suffers mildly from second book syndrome, I had the time of my life with it and I can't wait for The Atlas Complex to drop to see how all of this comes to an end.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. I enjoyed Atlas Six and was excited to get the second book in the series, but I found myself disappointed in this one.

Without the murder plot of the first book, much of the tension drains out of the story. In fact, at about 30 percent in, I thought about just giving up on it. I really missed Libby and her role in the group and found the remaining members tedious a good part of the time. I finished but it was more of a struggle than I anticipated, and I'm not sure I'll go on with the series. Perhaps the final book will save it as middle books are often tough to get right.

Was this review helpful?

A worthy sequel to the first with a slow ramp up to the action. As always, the vibes are impeccable and the characters are complicated and compelling. A very cool blend of science and fantasy, with some interesting food for thought on academia and elitism, though I wish the plot were a bit heftier. All in all, great fun.

Was this review helpful?

Picking up immediately after the first book, this is a book written to be a movie. Not always a bad thing, but not my cup of tea. Good characters and pacing help a lot with the book.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Ms. Blake, and MacMillan/Tor for the opportunity to read an ARC of this title. An honest review was requested but not required.

Wellllll. This is a mixed feelings moment, for sure.

Some things about tAP, I loved: I loved its cerebral quality, I loved the murky nature of intentions and the sly jabs at academia as a festering, cannibalistic, partially sentient devourer. Seems about right. I loved its beautiful prose and its ability to parse human nature.

...and some things, I did NOT love. I wish the characters had done less navel-gazing and more plot. Frankly, there was very little plot here. Lots of thinking, even DEEPER thinking, some short-lived experimenting, lots of snarking, general antagonizing, quite a bit of ennui, but little plot.

Most of the characters spent the bulk of the book sunk into something:
-Parisa: Dalton
-Tristan: existential crisis over not being useful
-Callum: alcohol
-Reina: arguably, an insanity spiral?
-Nico: sleep
-Libby: the past
-Dalton: himself
-Atlas: nefarious plots and hiding in the house
-Ezra: being Ineffective (TM)

... I just wish *someone* would have done something, a little more often. Objectively the book is absolutely beautiful. I saw another reviewer say "style over substance." I think that is an apt description here. I enjoyed it aesthetically but I was vaguely bored by the story itself. Bridge book syndrome, I suppose. Let's hope Atlas #3 will get things moving. All the pieces are in place, certainly. I'll look forward to it.

Was this review helpful?

This is my absolutely favourite fantasy series currently. Blake basically writes magical heists books with lots of action and emotions.
I love the big questions: What do you actually see when you can see through every illusions? Can you see time? And can you control it?

In the first book Libby was my favourite character and that`s why I´m so excited for the next book.

Also didn`t see the plottwists commiing, gasped every time. Except for the love. I expected that and am not disappointed.

I recommend this fantastic series to everyone who loves imagination beyond things possiple.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my god! What was that ???? There is no way the book ended like this ?? I’m shaking! My heart is beating so fast! (I finished the book 2 minutes ago).

everyone knows I had problems with the atlas six even though I enjoyed some of it but THIS! Olivie is a mastermind! This book is so chaotic and mind blowing. Everything is on fire. It’s insane. I always say that the sequels are better than the first book and again I’m correct. The book was 400 pages but nothing was slow. Everything is happening all at once but in a fun way. I loved seeing the characters forming alliances with each other and there this one duo that never in million years I expected them to work together. Nico is still my love. I love reading his thoughts and how *sobs* he feels lost without his other half *iykyk*. I can’t wrap my head around how Olivie wrote two characters who are rivals with intense chemistry but they are not in love ?? But they feel lost without each other ??

Now to Libby. My goddess. I’m so proud of her. It’s her reputation (Taylor swift) era and I can’t. I’m Libby Rhodes fan. Human second.

One of the characters that I found very interesting in this book was Tristan. I enjoyed watching him learn more about his abilities and his dynamic with Nico in this book was comedy.

I can write essays talk about how I feel about this book so let me summarize it: the plot of the book still seems vague but it’s more character driven than the atlas six which was great and made me love the book. Expect the unexpected. Things you think they will happen they won’t. it’s an epic roller coaster.

Was this review helpful?

It’s official, Olivie Blake’s writing is like crack for my soul.
While this book had some issues, I truly don’t care. I am absolutely not waiting patiently for the next one.
I do think this sequel could have benefitted from higher stakes through the middle portion, or at least clearer ones, but I never felt bored as I thrive off the character interactions. I eat up every crumb of pretentiousness and penchant for drama that each of them exude. Everyone is even more unhinged and blinded by their own importance than before, and that’s the whole point. It’s illustrated perfectly through our new character Belen, who I better see on a chapter header in the future or I’ll be very disappointed.
Atlas and Dalton were the biggest mystery I was hoping would be solved in this book in order to create a larger and clearer picture, and by the end it gave me exactly what I needed. Villains are only ever people trying to do what they think is right. How will Atlas or Ezra’s plans change the fate of the world? No one knows, but those with the power to change it are going to find out, for better or for worse.
I was hoping the ending would end on a bigger climax like the first, but it has enough going for it where I can’t say it was underwhelming. I am so ready for Libby to keep blowing things up. Go get em!!!

Was this review helpful?

A worth sequel to “The Atlas Six”. The first section felt a little slow but they action starts picking up. I think Blake’s writing style improved upon the first book.

Was this review helpful?

Starts slow, but definitely picks up speed. I need to reflect on it more before I can fully make sense of it all, but it did what it needed to do.

Was this review helpful?

Picking up exactly where Dark Academia sensation The Atlas Six left off, The Atlas Paradox begins with the new fellows beginning their second year with the Alexandrian Society. With Libby still trapped in the past, Nico and Tristan are desperate to bring her back, while Callum tries to drink himself to death, Parisa explores the secrets withheld from her, and Reina considers exactly how far her powers can be extended. The interpersonal dynamics are less claustrophobic than in the first book - each of the characters is on their own separate path and the interactions are less charged. Libby's path from anxious wreck to force of nature is compelling, while Parisa, Nico, and Tristan get comparatively shortchanged. Reina and Callum develop in an interesting direction that plays into the fears and ambitions of the Forum. Maybe it's the perils of being the second book after a tour-de-force, but Paradox feels somewhat underwhelming and unfinished, setting up a third book while implying "nothing to see here." Do yourself a favor and reread The Atlas Six first - you'll catch much more of the subtle detail work that makes Blake's novels shine that way.

Was this review helpful?

This series needs to have an orgy. That’s the only thing I’m taking away from the second book. Nothing happens for a long time. Not much plot. Many of the pages are characters interacting and drawing conclusions about each other. There’s this odd tension between all of the characters that I feel would end in an orgy.

I still enjoyed reading it, but in the end, I had to think about what happened in the book.

This review is based on an advanced reader copy provided through Netgalley for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This series just wasn't for me. If I hadn't listened to it as an audiobook I probably wouldn't have finished. I felt like the majority of the 400 pages I just read was made up of fluff and nothing really happened. The first half of the book was incredibly boring with literally nothing important seeming to happen. The only things that happen in this book is finding out about Libby and finding what Atlas's plans are/ what he wants to do.

Was this review helpful?

A sequel that kept me on the edge of my seat, much like the first. Wonderful insight to returning characters and a plot with as many twists and turns as you like!

Was this review helpful?

This book was... a choice. After being "meh" about the first book, the second one really felt unneeded and I have no idea what the hype for this series or the author are. Its pretentious for no need and the entire book is giving "pick me" vibes. Pass.

Was this review helpful?

I had been waiting for this sequel since the moment I finished The Atlas Six. With the first book ending on several cliffhangers, The Atlas Paradox picks up where The Atlas Six left off, but throws in more twists and turns. I was left with even more questions than the first book, which is right on brand for this trilogy. I loved the enhanced character development and the new characters. The plot sometimes got confusing with several different storylines going on, which left me eager for the third book to come out.

Was this review helpful?

God. GOD. Olivie Blake is a master at weaving together the smallest of details, the most inconsequential of plots into something that leaves you winded.

I'll do my best to avoid spoilers since this is still a few weeks out from publication! Though I didn't enjoy this one quite as much as The Atlas Six - mostly because it is somehow even slower, almost like starting from scratch - I still greatly adore this world Blake has created.

In The Atlas Paradox, readers will find the story gaining layers of real-world application in-line with their studies and the opposing forces of Atlas, Ezra, and everyone else fighting each other to take hold of power. This book tackles creation myths and time travel and godliness itself. It completely breaks apart your understanding of these characters and their alliances, debuting so many new and interesting groupings that kept me enthralled even when it seemed that nothing was happening.

I do think it gets pretty messy in the middle and there is so much less of them working together or even against each other here that left me disappointed. For a character driven story, The Atlas Paradox is largely solitary, defined not by their interactions with each other but with the independent studies forcing them to reckon with themselves and their own belief systems. Even though it is a lonely read, devoid of most of the interactions I enjoyed in The Atlas Six, they are never not thinking of each other. And the moments characters do get together are the ones that really propel the plot and make that cliffhanger ending so worthwhile.

The characters I enjoyed most were a bit of a surprise. I greatly enjoyed Callum's perspective above all, which is such a shock! I'm so invested in what comes next for him. I also found myself really enthralled in Nico's, and I hope the end means we get a lot more Gideon in the next one. For so, so many reasons. :) Also, Libby's entire story is just off the walls insane. I literally cannot imagine how this all plays out but what a fascinating way to explore her character.

We also finally got the Dalton reveal which was NOT what I expected and seems like it'll be a pretty dangerous spark to whatever happens next.

All in all, even though it took me longer to really get through the first half, the second half was a homerun. I hope the next book brings them all together again because that will really make whatever chaos is coming the perfect storm!

Was this review helpful?

To say that I was obsessed with the first book would be an understatement. I loved the plot, the characters, the world-building, the academia, EVERYTHING. All that said, this sequel was a huge disappointment.

The biggest problem for me was how tension was dealt with in the story. There would be a huge moment of plot that would be left in the air for six chapters while you were reading about random pursuits of other characters (and you read from EVERYONE’S point of view). It made me not care because I was never allowed an ounce of satisfaction.

Also if you loved how certain characters were set up in the first book, then you will be annoyed by this one because they will never speak.

Was this review helpful?