Skip to main content

Member Reviews

(ARC READ FOR NETGALLEY) I love all of Rachel Hawkins other reads! They’re quick and good thrillers! This one is the same, just a little slower to start and a little harder to follow.

2 best friends end up at a Villa in Italy where a murder happened back in the 1970s! Em, recently divorced and healing, starts to dive into the murder mystery of the house and finds out what she believes is the truth! This leads her to write a nonfiction thriller! All the while, the 1970s murder is happening behind the scenes, allowing the stories to run congruent. Both lovers die at the end, whether you know the truth or not about how it really happened!

Rachel Hawkins leaves you seconding guessing what actually happened to Mari’s lover and how Em and Chess are forever stuck together.

Was this review helpful?

I was a little disappointed in this book. I love Rachel Hawkins books and was so excited to get this one. I really enjoyed Reckless Girls and had high hopes for this. I feel like vacations to europe have been done so much lately. I was ready for a unique plot.

Was this review helpful?

I requested this book without even reading what it was about - I will want to read any book written by Rachel Hawkins! I love how this books starts out, two bffs going away on a writing retreat….until one day it’s not so much of a retreat. I also love how the story goes back in time to the 70’s.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book I have read by Rachel Hawkins and I definitely need to read more of her books I really enjoyed reading it and couldn't put it down.

Was this review helpful?

The Villa by Rachel Hawkins (January 3, 2023)

Self-help author Chess Chandler and mystery writer Emily Sheridan have been best friends since childhood. After Emily’s divorce, Chess and Emily rent a majestic villa in Italy and plan to spend the summer writing together. When Emily finds out that the murder of a famous musician happened at the villa, she begins to look for clues about the crime in contemporary literature and music lyrics and in the walls of the house itself.

Hawkins’ The Villa has a clever plot with twists and a good ending. It is atmospheric, has well-developed characters and is a murder mystery that is not gruesome or scary. I enjoyed this book; Hawkins does a great job of keeping the reader guessing until the very end. I would recommend The Villa to readers who enjoyed The Woman in the Window, Daisy Jones and the Six, and Eat, Pray, Love (if only for juxtaposition purposes!).

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for providing an advance reader copy for purpose of unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

You know, I think this is my favorite Rachel Hawkins book yet. Her first novel pulled me in, but the followup left me a little...lacking. However, The Villa has dragged me right back in. I can't wait to see what happens when this hits shelves!

Was this review helpful?

All I can say is that Rachel Hawkins has done it again! I don't know what to say without spoiling the book. It's amazing and an ode to female empowerment. It's thrilling and exciting.

Was this review helpful?

This is my favorite Rachel Hawkin's book so far! It had me hooked from the first page. Then I proceeded to fly through the rest of the book. The alternating timelines were each intriguing with their own unique characters. It was very atmospheric and had a Gothic feel to it. The ending left me thinking about it. I really enjoyed this book and highly recommend it!
Expecting publication is January 3, 2023

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the opportunity to read this advanced digital copy.

Was this review helpful?

CONTENT WARNING: mention of death of a child, grief, murder, mention of suicide, mention of drugs, violence, blood

I’ve become a fan of Rachel Hawkins without even realizing. I’ve read a few of her books and absolutely loved them, and this one looked too good to pass up. So while it isn’t out until January 2023, I figured I’d get a jump on my NetGalley reading while I can.

This book hooked me immediately, and I couldn’t put it down. I flew through this in less than three hours, and literally sat with my nose glued to my Kindle, ignoring everything and everyone around me (including things that needed to get done) so I could see how this ended.

The story is told in two mirrored plot lines, which works really well in this book. Hawkins pulls this off beautifully, and it’s never confusing.

In the present day, we have Emily and Chess, two frenemies—Chess is a fantastically successful self-help author, while Emily is currently at a low in her life. Emily writes a cozy mystery series, but she’s stalled and behind deadline on book 10, she’s going through an ugly divorce after her husband cheated on her, and she’s only just starting to feel better from a mysterious illness that no one had been able to diagnose. So when her oldest friend Chess suggests that they go away for a few weeks to a villa in Italy, Emily decides it might be a good idea. Turns out, the villa is a murder house.

The other timeline is set in 1974, at the same villa, when rock star Noel Gordon invites a rising star of a musician, Pierce Sheldon, his girlfriend Mari, and her stepsister Lana to join him for the summer. Also at the villa is his “entertainment manager” aka drug dealer, Johnnie. But nothing goes as planned when you toss sex, drugs, and rock n’ roll into the mix. By the end of the summer, Pierce is dead, Mari has written a bestselling horror novel, and Lana tops the charts with an album of her own.

The narrative shifts between the two stories, and we’re also treated to snippets of Mari’s novel, which provides clues to what actually happened, as Emily sees it. As the two women in the present day start to dig a little deeper into the history of the villa, they also dig up some secrets from their own, more recent past. And they don’t necessarily like what they see.

I love a good fast-paced story, and there were some twists and turns that I didn’t see coming. There was one or two that I saw coming a mile away, but more importantly, I liked watching the characters evolve throughout the story. Initially, Mari’s story was the more intriguing one, while I didn’t really connect as strongly with Emily. But towards the middle and end of the story, I started finding Emily just as interesting, and looked forward to both aspects of the story, and couldn’t wait to hear all sides of what was happening. All of the characters have no shortage of flaws, but it made them feel more realistic, and while they weren’t necessarily likable, they were relatable.

Overall, this book was easily a one-sitting read, the kind that gets its claws in a reader and doesn’t let go until the shocking end. It’s the kind that keeps me wondering after I’ve finished, and keeps my mind twisted, thinking about what motivates people and what goes on in other people’s minds.This is one that I thoroughly enjoyed and will be recommending highly.

Was this review helpful?

Just finished The Villa by Rachel Hawkins. Don't start this book unless you have cleared your schedule for several hours! You won't want to put it down. Set in idyllic Italy and filled with richly developed characters, this is a gripping novel of love, loss and deceit. Two stories, past and present, intertwine to make a deliciously haunting tale. Told in a fascinating style, this book was thoroughly engaging and entertaining. Well-placed twists and turns kept me guessing. Five stars for this mystery thriller!

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5

This was such an addictive and fun popcorn thriller! I know it’s early for me to be reviewing it but it was entertaining enough that I figured getting it on your radar early would be a good thing. One of the things I’ve come to enjoy the most about this authors books is the way she creates unsettling settings for her books and this was no exception. It flips back and forth between present day when Emily and Chess are vacationing in Italy and then back to the 1970s when Mari spends a summer at the same villa as Emily. I was very drawn to the past timeline because you already know the summer comes to a violent and deadly end but the lead up to the tragedy was so fascinating. The author did a really great job with these two timelines showcasing such similar and parallel experiences but it was still easy to keep things separate in my head. I think I expected a slightly more explosive ending after such a strong lead up but I appreciate what the author was doing and why she made the choices she did. Overall a solid read with a unique edge and very cool throwback vibes.

Was this review helpful?

<i>I received an advanced copy of this book from Net Galley.</i>

So, I love Rachel Hawkins thrillers. I think now that I'm three books in, I can say that definitively. While there were points where it felt like a slow burn and the murder is on a much smaller scale than other books in the genre, I found the intimacy of both time periods gripping. The Villa has a decadent feeling to it, but the way its characters are written keeps it grounded. We're in a million dollar mansion, but we're eating pizza on the couch and watching true crime documentaries together. Anyone who comes in expecting a retelling of Charles Manson will be disappointed, but if you want a clever thriller with multiple nods to gothic horror and classics like Frankenstein with a modern true crime twist, there's nothing better than this book.

It's exactly what I was looking for and I devoured it in about a day.

Was this review helpful?

I'm not sure what category I would put The Villa into. It's labeled as suspense, and to some degree that's true, as Emma uncovers what happened that led to the death of someone staying in the same villa in 1974, and to some degree feels distrustful of her best friend Chess, whom she is staying with at the villa. But it doesn't really feel fully like a mystery or a suspense, despite me wanting to find out what really happened. It feels more like a tragedy about to happen in both story lines. The reader knows this about the early storyline because of Emma's pursuit of it, but you can just feel the intensity ratcheting up between her and Chess. Also part of the storyline is Emma's husband Matt, whom she is separated from after they have a difference of opinion on having a baby. That situation is already acrimonious as he's demanding royalties from the cozy mystery series that Emma writes. The story is interesting and reads quickly, and I enjoyed it. But I can't say that I loved it. It never really felt like Mari or Emma was ever really in danger, and it was more about the relationships of the people staying at the villa. I can't say that any of differences anyone had felt like it justified murder, although the last chapter from Mari at the end creates a thought-provoking conclusion on how the story between Emma and Chess ends. Basically, the book was just not enough of a certain genre to elevate it to an exceptional book for me. A complimentary copy of the book was provided by the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Emily and Chess are childhood best friends who have grown apart but decide to take a trip to Italy to rekindle their friendship. The Villa they rent for the summer has a complicated history, which Emily is drawn to investigating. Jumping from the present to the year 1974, famous rock and roller Noel visits the very same villa with his friends and fellow musician Pierce in hopes to reignite his creative spark to write new music but the infamous trip ends with the murder of one of its occupants. Emily is determined to uncover the villa's sinister past, but the longer they stay there, the more Emily's relationship with Chess is affected. Is it the house and will Chess and Emily's vacation have the same result as Noel's years prior?

This book is what you would get if Daisy Jones & The Six were a mystery/thriller. It was a very slow burn and because of this I had a hard time getting into it until it picked up towards the end as the mystery unfolded. I did enjoy the alternating timelines, but wish we spent more time with Emily and Chess in the present. The ending was solid, but 3 stars due to my overall lack of interest in characters and past storyline.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed most of this book and the two storylines. However, I felt the ending lacked something and felt rushed. I usually enjoy Rachel's books as well.

Was this review helpful?

A great atmospheric thriller told from alternating time lines. Rachel Hawkins delivers two equally compelling storylines, each with intriguing characters and their own unique level of eeriness. Readers are easily transported to the Villa, both past and present, to lay witness to the darkness that can lurk in paradise. Fantastic read.

Thank you to #NetGalley for the ARC of #TheVilla which was read and reviewed voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed The Villa. Truly was shocked by the turn of events and really can’t be sure if I know the truth! Love when a book really makes you think.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this book but the ending felt disappointing. It didn't feel sinister enough to keep with the rest of the book's feeling. Still good, just felt a little rushed and unfinished. Loved the idea of it though!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. I loved The Wife Upstairs so when I got approved for this ARC, I was so excited. But I DNF at 20%. I just couldn’t get into it for some reason. Hopefully I’ll like her next one better.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks for the ARC @netgalley! This was quite the gothic thriller. This is my first book by Rachel Hawkins - now I have to dive into her backlist, as I really enjoyed this one.

Cozy muster author Emily is going through a messy, vicious divorce while struggling to write the latest installment in her series. Her childhood best friend Chess (a spiritual self-help celebrity) invites Emily to spend the summer in Italy with her. The Villa they are staying at has quite the sordid history: in 1974, musician Pierce Sheldon was brutally murdered. The two woman who were staying with him that summer (Lara & Mari) wrote one of the most famous albums of all time while the other wrote a horror novel that became a classic. Both Emily and Chess are inspired by the house’s dark past and soon are at odds with each other.

This novel is told in Emily’s modern perspective and Mari’s summer at the villa in the 70s. This structure works well to keep the reader invested and on their toes. This was such an atmospheric thriller! I want to visit Orvieto Italy now, as Hawkins paints such a vivid picture. The only reason this isn’t a 5⭐️ thriller for me is because I guessed a few of the twists early on, but I was still enthralled. Grab this one when it comes out 01/03/23!

✨Trigger Warnings: Suicide, Drug Use, Child Death

Was this review helpful?