Cover Image: The Gentleman's Book of Vices

The Gentleman's Book of Vices

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

i thought this was a good story, however there were moments it felt more like the two halves of the book were written at very different times and kind of mushed together. Charlie somehow seemed to get more immature as the story went on as well. I know he was meant to be more himself and more free but it didn't translate that way on page.

Was this review helpful?

This book was UNEXPECTEDLY lovely. The book none of us knew we needed to we read it. Just wonderful. Maybe a movie? . Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher!

Was this review helpful?

I read this book a long time ago haha so bear with on the details but I remember loving it!! Both main characters had so much life and depth and had really great chemistry and banter. I loved how this book delved into some deeper themes than a surface level romance book, and each theme was well woven into the context of the setting of the book (Victorian England).

I also really enjoy the stoic character that also happens to be a smutty author trope and that was done really well here! The steamy scenes were also great! This will definitely be book a book I will come back to in the future and helps to cement queer historical romance as one of my favourite genres!

Was this review helpful?

This book was an ok read. The writing was well-done, but I struggled to connect with the characters on a deeper level. Overall, I would call this a solid romance but it's not a favorite. I'd recommend this to anyone looking for a historical gay romance. I previously read the 2nd book in the series and I definitely think this one was better in both writing and plot.

Was this review helpful?

In their first installment of “The Lucky Lovers of London” series author Jess Everlee presents her readers with “The Gentlemen's Book of Vices” as a thank you to Netgalley and the publisher ( Harper Collins), I write this honest review and spoiler alert….. I loved it. Everlee’s characters are vibrant, jovial, and earnest. The novel follows Charlie Price, who though his impending marriage to a woman cannot give up his “vices” that being the local homosexual pub “The Curious Fox”, men and erotic novels. Charlie fits the stereotypical notion of a Victorian dandy, and I love it. Charlie is curious to find the author of whose novels bring so much joy and excitement, however the reality of the era of time he is in, dictates their identity is a secret, and any attention to them, or himself can bring detrimental consequences. Through connections from a close friend brings Charlie the identity of this gifted writer. Enter Miles Montague, a bookseller by day and erotic homosexual novelist by night. The contrasting personalities of the two added to my pleasure in reading their story. Will Charlie move forward with the marriage, or have the courage to live a life for himself ? The relationship with Charlie and Miles is fully explored to explore the emotional nuance of homosexual men during this time and with the magic of the written word present circumstances that may not have been allotted to men of that period. I enjoyed this immensely and recommend the companion novel “A Rulebook for Restless Rogues” as well. As well as the audiobooks narrated fabulously by Tommy Hawthorne. I gave this a strong five out of five stars on goodreads.

Was this review helpful?

Charlie Price is a young guy who is about to be married. Before his marriage, he is determined to get the autograph of the author of is favorite erotic novel. Through his contacts, he finds the man and shows up to request the autograph from the mild mannered owner of a sad bookshop. The meeting does not goes as planned and the owner, one Miles Montague, assume that Mr. Price is there to blackmail him. That could not be further from the truth.

Montague has second thoughts about the way he treated Charlie, so he decides to sign the book and return it to him with a bottle of wine for apology. That little trip results in a rather humorous case of mistaken identity and Miles plays along. He and Charlie end up reviewing Charlie’s collection and well the chemistry between them takes off again. But they are in Charlie’s house, so that won’t do. Charlie is determined to have more time with Miles.

Miles and Charlie start up a rather regular schedule. But there is the little issue of Charlie’s wedding. And of course there is the difficulty with Miles’s failing bookshop. Expectations and obligations that get in their way. Times being what they are, there is no reason to believe that these two can have any sort of HEA. I mean, Miles stories never end that way, so why should theirs? Have no fear! This is a romance and we must get our HEA 🙂

So I really enjoyed the beginning of this book quite a bit. There is a lot of humor and Charlie is a thoroughly entertaining character who has gotten by on his charm so far in life. Miles is a rather dour, sad guy who has inherited the bookshop he cannot part with. Then there is the matter of the intrigue of discovery – of knowing who knows their secrets. There are so many obstacles in their way and neither can see a way around it. Charlies friends at his favorite club watch out for him and try to help – I hope they show up in the next book. All in all, this was really quite the tale. There were some surprises I didn’t see coming. While this didn’t have the polish that some of the other Historicals that I’ve read, this was a really interesting kick-off to a series. I’m interested to see what comes next for these characters and this world. Recommended for historical fans and also for those who enjoy a tale where characters really have to work for their happy ending.

Was this review helpful?

I did like the idea of this, and I felt like Everlee did do some historical research as it pertained to the illegality of homosexuality and homosexual materials, which is a little different than other historical romances. Where I think it fell short are the MCs themselves--Charlie is whiny and Miles is boring and together I don't really root for them.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know how a whole sequel has come and gone in the time it took me to read this ARC, but here we are. I say sequel- the next book isn't truly a sequel, it's just set in this same world and with the same theme of "lucky lovers." But it's a enjoyable world to read and the theme of unlikely couples getting their happily-ever-afters no matter what is just simply good.

This book is full of ups and downs and issues at every turn trying to thwart the promised happy ending. Explicit and kinky sex aside, it's a cozy novel- there's high stakes discussed but it never feels like the characters are ever in real danger. It's not a book that takes itself too seriously, and you shouldn't hold it to that standard: none of the characters are trying to solve homophobia, it's not overly deep about the characters' troubles, and again none of the high-stakes threats are real. Everyone is lucky, everyone is happy in the end, and all the problems are wrapped up nicely.

I do wish there was a bit more emotional depth. I felt like I could only see what the characters were feeling by their actions, and I didn't feel like I was truly in their head. Each chapter notes whose perspective it's told from, so I expected a bit more omniscience regarding what was on everyone's minds

Thanks to NetGalley and Carina Adores for the e-ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for giving me access to the free advanced digital copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

A M/M historical romance where the first half of the book was entertaining but I slowly realized there was not clear plot throughout. It was obvious these two characters would end up together (that's the genre) but it was a lot of build up for something that just felt...anticlimactic? Overall enjoyable and I do look forward to the author's next story.

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Gentleman’s Book of Vices by Jess Everlee was quite good! It’s a historical fiction, where being gay is illegal. Charlie Price is determined to get the autograph of his favorite erotica writer before he has to put away his things and marry a woman. However, once he meets Miles Montague, the two of them have an immediate connection. I really liked the relationship between Charlie and Miles. It was tough seeing them try to be there for each other in a world that makes that very difficult. Prepare for emotion and spice!

Was this review helpful?

And enjoyable read. I will admit my attention sometimes wavered. However, that could be more about my headspace than the book at the time.

I liked the characters and the world we were. The story was smart and witty.

I am definitely interested in revisiting what this author has next.

Was this review helpful?

Oh, the spice! How delicious! While not the most riveting novel in the romance section, it’s fun, cute, and quite steamy. This will be great for Bridgerton fans looking for queer romance, as well as people looking for an easy summer read.

Was this review helpful?

This was an enjoyable queer romance with a good plot that kept the book moving. Having the 2 points of view was nice. I was a little confused by the Jo character, and perhaps she needed to be introduced more in the beginning. She felt like she was very important to the plot (and she was) but kind of drifted in and out.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really fun (and wonderfully steamy!) queer historical with a touch of BDSM. I'm docking a star because the main characters felt a little flat and their backstories seemed hastily added after the fact, rather than an integral part of their arcs and growth, but otherwise, this was a delight.

Was this review helpful?

This one unfortunately was not for me. I found the main characters Charlie and Miles to be dull and I did not care about them very much. I wound up skimming through the majority of the book which is a good indicator that I wasn't very invested in either the characters or the plot, which was also a bit dull.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun, raunchy, and heartwarming novel. I was very invested in the characters and am looking forward to many more books by this author! Readers who enjoy Cat Sebastian novels will likely enjoy this one too.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book, enemies to lovers, secret identity and writing all together. I also liked the compassion when dealing with the women in their lives.

Was this review helpful?

Really charming debut. It felt more situated in it's historical and geographical context than some of the other historical queer romances out there, which - while I'm not always a stickler for accuracy - was really nice. This will be going into my rotation for diverse romance reader's advisory.

Was this review helpful?

This book was average for me. Much of the chemistry felt forced, and the convention of having the 2 men engage in erotic banter and then fade to black for some of the actual love scenes didn't help. Other parts felt a bit twee, like when Miles had to pretend to be a wedding cake baker at the couple's taste testing. Speaking of which, it's one thing for a gentleman who prefers the company of men to be faced with marriage in the theoretical, but it was a bit uncomfortable with the impending wedding looming like a specter. Finally, I hate to be a stickler about things like this, but a lot of the slang Charlie used was anachronistic and/or inappropriate for a man of his social class.

Was this review helpful?