This book was absolutely fantastic. I've already added it to our list for order next year and will recommend it to students.

I sadly did not end up enjoying the first book nor this one. They just weren't for me.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to read this eArc.

This was a fitting end to The Celestial Kingdom duology. I did feel like it dragged and bit in spots and should have been about 50 pages shorter. But the story wraps up neatly.

With how packed the first book was I really didn’t think this book would have a lot left to work with-and I was very wrong! Soooo much happens and I could not put the book down because I just had to know what happened next.

The love triangle unexpectedly continues in heart wrenching ways, major change is coming in the celestial realms, and lots of magical surprises!

I have really enjoyed exploring the unknown-to-me folklore through this Duology.

Full review to come on Goodreads and Amazon. Thank you to the publisher, author, and NetGalley for a review copy.

i really loved the first book of this duology, it was such a unique universe and such endearing characters, just such a good fantasy read. i was eager to pick this one up since i enjoyed the first one so much, but ultimately was left feeling like maybe this wasn’t necessary, or could’ve had more interesting developments.
it felt a bit redundant, the complications felt contrived, and the conversations had between characters felt repetitive and prolonged.
i do really enjoy the writing and the universe building, it’s unique and atmospheric, but the plot and character development was lacking and left me wanting more or just for this book not to have been necessary.

i would definitely read more from this author but i think this story is better as a stand alone, unless you really feel connected to these characters.

A gorgeous continuation of Sue Lynne Tan's story, and a brilliant book on its own. Tan understands fantasy writing, with gorgeously detailed prose and vivid characters. Brilliant work.

So everything I loved about the first book, Daughter of the Mood Goddess, I loved in the second book. The vibrant world and storytelling, the fun YA fantasy aspect (again think ACOTAR without the sex and more lyrical writing), and the action is great!

That said everything I didn’t like about the first book was manifested tenfold in the second. The love triangle that’s not really a love triangle (a la Twilight), and how that wraps up wasn’t very satisfying. Felt performative at best, and honestly contrived. It was apparent who the author wanted and therefore felt forced. The main character is still just as wishy washy and her mother and father were just annoyingly pointless.

So all that said is this a perfect Duology no… but it’s also one I enjoyed reading (even if it both books were a bit too long and could have used some editing down)! Objectively there are flaws but subjectively I just didn’t care in the end and enjoyed it!

Thank you to Harper Voyager via NetGalley for my review copy. All opinions are my own!

i hate when i don't immediately reach for a highly anticipated sequel right off the bat when i know i loved the first book so much.

this was a big let down.

I’m not sure if I can find the words to express my feelings about The Heart of the Sun Warrior by Sue Lynn Tan. This book was such an emotional journey! So many highs and lows intermixed with epic adventure. I loved this glimpse into Chinese mythology with familiar characters who I came to know and love in book one, Daughter of the Moon Goddess. I loved Tan’s gorgeous writing. I loved the themes that filled this book. This was quite the conclusion to this duology and will stick with me for a long time.

*Thank you to Netgalley, Sue Lynn Tan, and Harper Voyager for an e-arc of this book. All opinions are my own.

I just want to start off by saying that book one was amazing and book two was just as good. This book was everything. There was more character development. I thought I already loved them from book one but I somehow love them even more. That's the best thing about reading a series. There was also more world building, like in book one i was thrown into this world and I was so glad to be back.

This series is a 5/5 so far. I highly recommend it.

Incredible sequel to a phenomenal debut! This book had everything- character and relationship growth, plot twists, action, conflict, and resolutions. It was truly a perfect fantasy book.

WOW. I can't believe it's over. I need to go cry somewhere. I also have mixed feelings. Overall, I really enjoyed this, especially as a finale to the whole story, but there was...A LOT happening here. It took a while to pick up and once it did, I felt like so much was happening and my only thought was that meme with the house on fire. That said, I still love Xingyin dearly and will be by her side on any and all her journeys.

This was a beautiful sequel to a beautiful book! I love that I never know where the book will lead with both of these books. It's always so wonderful to be surprised when most books are predictable. I definitely wasn't expecting the love triangle to go that way and I was so happy it did.

I enjoyed this book a lot more than I did the first. The first book was so oddly paced, almost as if four separate books had been abridged into one. For that reason, I didn’t like the first book. But I was invested in the “villain” character (why do the boys I love always end up villains???) so I wanted to complete the series. The plot of this book felt more singular and satisfying. The prose was wonderful as always. I did desire more of the relationships and friendships. We are often told the emotions and states of the relationships, but we don’t actually get to see them bloom first hand.

The writing remains as beautiful as ever with illustrative passages that continue to bewilder the mind with the beauty of Xingyin's realm. I was not sure what to expect from this one, but I am happy I got a chance to read it early even if I am only just now catching up on my backlog of reviews.

I enjoyed Heart of the Sun Warrior more than I did its predecessor. The book has a more traditional structure, and the different parts of the book flow together better. They are more cohesive and feel less like distinct novellas separated by time jumps, which is how I felt about the first one.

If DOTMG establishes Xingyin as a kickass filial daughter, HOTSW focuses on Xingyin trying discover who she is and what she wants. Xingyin finds that what you should want and what your heart wants can be different things. I struggled along beside her, and wanted her to end up with both of her suitors, but ultimately believe she made the right decision.

The Celestial Kingdom duology is a great choice for fans of east Asian mythology, love triangles, and beautiful writing. You can't go wrong with this one.

This is an interesting conclusion to The Celestial Kingdom Duology. Xingyin is back at her mother, the Moon Goddess' home. They still have enemies in the Celestial emperor and must flee their home to stay together and alive. At the same time, Xingyin finds out that her father is alive but sick. This sets in motion her plan to get the elixir of immortality for her father. Xingyin is also warring about who she should choose between Liwei and Wenzhi. This is a beautiful tale with Chinese mythology woven into its core. It also highlights familial love, the power of love, true friendship and honor.

I really enjoy the aesthetic of this series, but I feel as if more could’ve been done in terms of developing these amazing characters. This was my main fault in the first book where it consistently feels as if the main character is a “Mary Sue” as many would put it. If you’re reading this series simply for the vibes, it’s a 10/10. For now, I will give it 4/5

4.5 Stars

A stunning sequel! If you enjoyed the first book, I think you'll enjoy this one as well. I love how original and interesting the plotlines are--this story is unlike anything I've read before. The writing is vivid and powerful, and the characters are well written.

The first story in this series was so beautifully written and full of action. This one was a little slower and, if you are like me, not as enjoyable, because of the focus on the love triangle. Not a fan. Kind of kills the story for me.

But overall it's still a good story and highly recommend reading if you like mythical fantasy.