Member Reviews

Motherless Sallie Kincaid is the daughter of the wealthiest man in a small Virginia town. She idolizes her father who runs the town, but an accident forces her to go live with her aunt for nine years. When she returns to her family home, Sally must grow into a brave, strong, and independent woman and eventually helps run her family business. She must contend with gender inequality, grief, uncovering family secrets, and the moral struggle of making the family money by bootlegging.

Story is full of family secrets and power struggles which deal with inheritance and class.
There are rural moonshine makers and heavy-handed Prohibitionists and of course, a lot of family drama.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Jeannette Walls' memoir <i>The Glass Castle</i> so much that I read it twice. I was so excited when I received the advanced copy of her new book.

A half-orphan Sallie, the daughter of the county Duke, finds herself ousted by her stepmother after an accident occurs involving her stepbrother. She returns nine years later, hoping to reclaim a spot within the family she once lost, which turns out to be much more complicated than she anticipated.

My excitement lasted about as long as the prologue (and I really wanted to love it). It started off great, but I never bonded with Sallie. Or the storyline. Or the writing. And I tried, The dialogues felt heavy-handed at worst and lacking continuity at best. The story felt filled with random moments and descriptions.

But the story is also historical fiction, with the main protagonist being based on Willie Carter Sharpe, the “Queen of the Roanoke Rumrunners.” And I like and appreciate a strong female character, so not all is completely lost. You, like me, may end up skimming a few pages, but you may still learn something.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this new novel by Jeannette Walls. Set during the time of prohibition, it takes a hard look at community, success, and the role of women in the 1920s. Sallie Kincaid is a memorable narrator who blossoms from a young child to a young woman on the page. Definitely worth your time!

Was this review helpful?

Prohibition is the perfect setting for the larger than life main characters and the community they live in. Walls has written a powerful story of a powerful family in the rural South of the 1920's. Sallie has always idolized her charismatic father, even after he exiled her for 9 years at his 3rd wife's demand. When Sallie is called back to run the household as an older teen, she has new eyes to see a bit below the surface of her father's power, but it takes a great deal of daring and danger for her to uncover some of the deepest family secrets. Many of the conflicts depicted have relevance today, and Sallie can serve as an admirable and spunky woman bucking the longheld traditions of community and family. This is a fast-paced novel with lots of action and plenty to think about.

Was this review helpful?

Jeanette Walls' many fans will love her newest. Once again, the details, story, characters, and locale will make readers feel they are there. A treasure for her admirers.

Was this review helpful?

Jeannette Walls's new novel taught me a lot about prohibition in rural Virginia. The Kincaid family is the power of a small town, and Sallie Kincaid is the story's center. Sallie is Duke's daughter and from those two characters flows a long winding tale of money, love, lust, deceit, and violence. Sallie was a brave little girl without a mother to guide her, but she grew into a strong character and always made the right choices when times were tough. I wanted Sallie to love a wonderful man to help shoulder all the responsibility that seemed to find her. She made up her mind at a young age that she would not have a man to lean on or to dictate life for her.

Hang the Moon is a good book. I recommend it to JW fans and those who love history. I never had any interest in the history of prohibition, but I enjoy JW's writing and the skillful way she weaves tales of flawed characters.

Many thanks to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for the advanced copy of the book.

Was this review helpful?

Jeannette Walls is a gifted writer who tackles strong female characters. In this book Sally Kincaid is motherless a young age and thrust in a life filled with colorful family members. This book highlights the times and many stories during the Prohibition. Lawlessness was a fact of life as people struggled to take care of themselves and their families. Her father Duke runs the show until he doesn't which leads to a lot of power grabs from those left behind. Many amusing stories lead to an enjoyable read. #HangTheMoon #JeannetteWalls #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Full Review: https://bakingthroughbookclub.com/2022/12/19/everyone-dies-bootleggers-edition/

**Thank you to Netgalley and Simon & Schuster for the chance to review this book.**

Do you get easily attached to fictional characters? If the answer is “yes,” this might not be the book for you. “Everyone dies” is a BIT of an exaggeration, but not by much.

Best known for her autobiography, The Glass Castle, Jeannette Walls is back with this historical fiction set in Claiborne County, Virginia during the Prohibition Era. Sally Kincaid is the daughter of Hank Kincaid, known simply as “The Duke.” The Duke is the owner behind the most powerful business in the area, The Emporium. The Emporium not only sells goods to everyone in the area, but it is also the center of the county’s bootlegging operations, much to Sally’s chagrin when she finds out. The Duke has his hand in almost everyone’s life. He may sell you goods at his store. He may employ you and pay you with store credit. He may act as your landlord. He may let you pay rent with moonshine, which he then goes on to sell to other people. Either way, there is no doubt who holds the power in Claiborne County. The Duke rules both the financial and political operations of the local area.

The Duke has a rather colorful marriage history, especially for the era in which he lived. His first wife, Belle, was beloved by the town. She gave him a daughter, Mary. However, he soon fell in love with Ann Powell, Sally’s mother, and divorced Belle in order to be with her. Belle and Mary were sent packing, nursing a well-deserved grudge against the Duke. When Sally was three years old, Ann was killed by the Duke during a violent confrontation. He was never arrested. You would think Sally would hate him, but you would be wrong. She worshipped the ground he walked on.

After the Duke killed Ann, he married Jane, an uptight, proper woman who did not like Sally. She gave birth to Sally’s younger brother, Eddie. Eddie was brilliantly smart, but not daring. He was also the heir to the Kincaid fortune as the first-born male of the family. One day, Sally takes Eddie on a ride on her defiance coaster and crashes it, severely injuring him. Jane in her fury insists that Sally go live with her Aunt Faye. The Duke promises that it will only be for a few months, but months turn into years. Finally, when Sally is a teenager, Jane dies from influenza. The Duke permits her to return to her childhood home, The Big House.

Sally had a hard life with Aunt Faye, and she learned what it was like to never have enough money. She also learned how to work hard and never take what you have for granted. I can’t get too far into the storyline because even discussing the other characters gives a hint as to who the “everyone” in “everyone dies” is going to be. However, this is a story about coming to terms with the idealized versions of our parents that we sometimes create as kids. It also highlights Sally’s grit and compassion for other people in stark contrast to those around her who operate based on business principles alone. Finally, Hang the Moon reminds us that desperation can lead to some pretty poor choices, but there is more to a person than the compilation of their mistakes.

While I liked the messages that evolved from this book, I couldn’t get over the multitude of unlikeable characters and constant death. The instability of the story line was jarring at times– you thought the plot was heading down a certain path only for it to suddenly veer in a different direction. After the second or third time that happened, I grew tired of the changes. However, I loved Sally as a character, so she erased many of the grumbles I had. Overall, I would recommend this book to many of my historical fiction-loving friends and encourage them to look up the story of Willie Carter Sharpe, the “Queen of the Roanoke Rumrunners” from which Sally’s character is based.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

Thanks Netgalley for allowing me to read this book. Sallie returns to her families house after being away for many years. There are many changes that have occurred. This book lagged in a few places.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting story of prohibition times. Several twists and turns makes it an interesting read and keeps you wanting to hear more. A great coming of she story featuring a strong female character who overcomes adversity. Family ties and community building feature prominently in the story

Was this review helpful?

Sallie Kincaid is the daughter of the biggest man in a small town, the charismatic Duke Kincaid. Born at the turn of the 20th century into a life of comfort and privilege, Sallie remembers little about her mother who died in a violent argument with the Duke. By the time she is just eight years old, the Duke has remarried and had a son, Eddie. While Sallie is her father’s daughter, sharp-witted and resourceful, Eddie is his mother’s son, timid and cerebral. When Sallie tries to teach young Eddie to be more like their father, her daredevil coaching leads to an accident, and Sallie is cast out. Nine years later, she returns, determined to reclaim her place in the family which is more complicated than Sallie expected, and she enters a world of conflict and lawlessness, and discovers the secrets and scandals that hide in the shadows of the Big House, navigates the factions in the family and town, and finally comes into her own as a bold, sometimes reckless bootlegger.

I have seen the author's previous books reviewed, but this is the first one I have read, and it is so well done that I was up VERY late to finish it because I had to see what happened to the characters. It was a good, complicated family story, but also a good history on Prohibition and the life of bootleggers whose whiskey was often their only source of income.

Was this review helpful?

A new historical fiction title by Jeanette Walls, author of the popular memoir The Glass Castle.
Taking place during the prohibition era in Virginia, Hang the Moon follows the life of Sally Kincaid and her relatives. As the daughter of a big man in a small town, Sally has enjoyed the privileges of a comfortable life. Her life suddenly takes a dark turn when an accident involves her little brother. Sent away to live with distant relatives, Sally doesn't know if she'll ever see her father again. Suddenly an invitation from the main house arrives and Sally returns home, determined to find her place in the family. It seems like the family named is cursed though as a series of incidents befall the family.
When Sally finally takes over the business, she finds herself deeply involved in bootlegging. She does her best to navigate the treacherous curves of country roads, dealing with town folk and her own kin. A more simplistic read than some of Wall's other works, but it feels right based on the characters. A fast-paced read.

Was this review helpful?

The majority of my reading is fiction. Having said that, my favorite book by Miss Walls continues to be her The Glass Castle, which is non-fiction. She is an excellent writer, however, so the genre is of small importance. I used to always skip the acknowledgments in books, but find that I really enjoy seeing if the author based parts of the book on fact, and if so, what. And yes, she has done her research. I enjoyed this book as I hope you will too. Thanks to NetGalley for a complimentary copy of the book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Intriguing story but the plot tended to meander into different avenues and did not allow me to get the full story of characters that I grew to love. Sallie is the main character and daughter of a man who runs the town they live in. When she is involved in an accident with his only son, Sallie is sent away to live with her aunt. Then when her stepmother dies she is brought back home. The book is told in parts during major events that happen in Sallie's life. The problem I have with that is that some of the supporting characters get a raw deal with sawed off storylines that make the plot slightly erratic.

Was this review helpful?

I would have given this a higher rating if the ending had been less open ended. There were many things to like about this book: engaging characters, fiction based on historical facts, the time period (Prohibition), and several strong female characters. However I become less enthused when everything isn't all tied up at the end. I know many readers prefer an open ending because it is more like real life, if this describes you then you will probably enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first book by the author, she’s been on my tbr list, and when I saw this book I jumped at the opportunity to read an early copy.

Unfortunately, I didn’t love this one. During my reading, I never had that “need to read more” vibe that I love in a good book and I plodded through this over a month’s time.

Was this review helpful?

Best selling author Jeanette Wallls takes us back to prohibition with her new move Hang the Moon. Sallie Kincaid had lived a hard life. Her mother dies when she was small and Sallie is then sent away by her father’s new wife. Her father, the charismatic “Duke”, leads a mountain town in Virginia during the prohibition. The Duke runs the county and more or less takes care of the people. When trashed strikes, Sallie finds herself back home as a young woman. More and more tragedy and hardship leaves Sallie now in charge. With much grit and determination and no nonsense ways, Sallie takes on her new position full force.
Walls does an excellent job of developing her characters. All kinds and very unique. That and history thrown in had me enthralled the entire book. This is one of my favorite books of 2022! It’s a must read.
*** huge thanks to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review

Was this review helpful?

When I saw Jeannette Walls had a new book, I was so excited. "The Glass Castle" is on my "everyone must read" list. This book just didn't have "it". I found it to be a bit boring in fact. None of the characters were especially likable or endearing. I was quite disappointed in the story line.

Was this review helpful?

Jeanette Walls' latest book, Hang the Moon, tells the story of headstrong, likable, Sallie Kincaid who is sent away to live with a poor cousin when her stepbrother is accidentally hurt. Her father, Duke, a small town businessman and kingmaker calls her back years later when the stepmother unexpectedly dies to care for that same stepbrother, Sallie takes an interest in the family business and is soon helping her father collect rents and run their store. Sallie hears whispers, but it is upon her father's unexpected death that she really begins to uncover family secrets, feud with a volitale local mountain clan, and run bootleg liquor like a mob boss.

The strength of this book is in its main character, who is likable no matter how crazy the story gets. The weakness is in how many times the Kincaid men's philandering surfaces as a plot point. This is one of those books that is a fun ride while you're in the middle of it, but leaves you feeling like you'd not want to read it again.

Was this review helpful?

Sallie Kincaid is the daughter of a wealthy land and business owner. He doesn’t just rule the home roost but the rural Virginia county folk as well. She lost her mother when she was very young and was later sent away by her step-mother to live with a destitute aunt. She is allowed to return to the family home nine years later to help care for her half-brother.

However, given Sallie’s proclivities and her natural forthright habits, she appears to be more comfortable in an enforcer/collection position than that of nurturing. Through a series of unforeseen tragedies, she is suddenly thrust into the position of heading the Holdings.

The Holdings of course are driven by the illegal sale of spirits, but the mountain people have a stranglehold on their grudges as well as their illegal activities.

The novel tackles a number of issues from complicated family secrets
and the woman’s position in the family to moral and religious passion, bootlegging, and gang wars. Sallie is a strong female protagonist. I applauded her triumphs and understood her attitude. It’s a complex and classic study of a culture peculiar to the area and the time.

The narrative is engaging and highly entertaining, the voice authentic not just to the time but to the geographical area. 4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?