Cover Image: Come Home Safe

Come Home Safe

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This is a very important book, about two young Black children encountering racist police officers. Written by an author with a thorough grounding in the law, this is a textbook (no pun intended) example of what to do when faced with this extremely dangerous threat. As difficult as this was to read, it must have been even harder to write.

My only grouse is that the narrative style and voice didn’t feel authentic as a middle-grade novel.

(Review copy from NetGalley)

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

While I can appreciate this book, I don't think it hits home with me as a target reader as I was searching for a more of a story than I was a history/civil rights lesson. I appreciate this book for all this it teaches its readers but as a narrative it can at times fall a bit flat. It definitely teaches you lifelong lessons and makes you look at. law enforcement in a different light. I think this book is an incredible tool for its intended target reader but for those who are outside of that range it can sometimes be read as long (due to the length of certain scenes). The characters themselves don't feel explored either, but I understand that it may not have been the intended desire with this book.

For any young teenagers, who are situated in USA and identify as black, I believe this to be a valuable tool and is a reminder how systemic racism is and always have been an issue which needs addressing.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this story. The premise is one that always needs to be told. But the writing didn’t feel genuine. As someone who grew up in New York, the dialogue felt very forced.

Was this review helpful?

I often read books I think my students would enjoy. Rarely do I read books I think would be great to study with them. Despite the situation in America being different than in the UK I still think this would be an excellent starting point for a range of discussions. A clear and simple read but underlying all of that are a range of really complex issues to explore. I found the title powerful and moving and the author’s note helpful.

Was this review helpful?

Come Home Safe tells a story all too familiar to many kids and adults across America. Oliva and her older brother Reed have always been taught the rules of how to interact with police should the occasion ever arise. Their parents' main goal has always been to know your rights and simply come home safe. Their knowledge is put to the test in Brian Buckmire's in-your-face real life drama when they are approached on the subway and questioned for a crime they did not commit. What happens during this interaction will forever change their lives.

This book is powerful in all the right ways. It points out important perspectives and also points out some hard truths. I think some very important conversations can be had across all color lines and ages if a lot of people read this book. I think a lot of eyes will be opened if this book if widely read and spoken about!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Blink for providing me a copy of this ARC in exchange for an honest review. All the view is and opinions expressed in this review are purely my own and not affiliated with any brand.

This is a great book for any person of color who might have an encounter with law enforcement. It is full of legal advice that I wish more people knew and would take. It did read a little more like a middle grade novel than a YA but that’s not necessarily a negative.

Was this review helpful?

If you liked The Hate U Give, this book is 100% for you! The book follows two young black teenagers who face the police in two separate stand offs where police brutality is at the full force. Racism, police politics and discrimination are the biggest themes throughout. In parts it was incredibly difficult to read but it is extremely important for everyone to read. It is a really quick read, with a YA writing style so it's easy and fast paced just with difficult topics. I would happily pick up more from this author in the future!

Was this review helpful?

Come Home Safe is an important read. One that I feel sits among other greats of this genre such as "The Hate You Give", 'The Black Kids' and 'Clap When You Land'.

Written authentically and with a writing style that makes it easy to turn pages.

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 43%
It pains me so much to DNF such a promising book, but I'm not in the correct headspace for it at the moment. I liked what I've read so far even though the writing is sometimes disjointed and choppy.
Might continue it later.

Was this review helpful?

If you liked The Hate U Give, then read this!

Come Home Safe was a book that reminds us that as Black people our skin is a threat that we can never take off. Now you can either let that knowledge drown you in sorrow, or accept it and fight against it to the end.

The book is in two parts, each part focuses on one of the siblings, Reed and then Olive. Each sibling has racist interactions with two types of people that are known to hold institutional power over us. The Police and white women.

With these two stories, you're forced to face the harsh realities of being Black, and learn that it doesn't matter how you dress or act, or even how young you are; racism just doesn't care who you are.

Reading this was heart-wrenching, the trauma that these kids face is heart-wrenching, and it's an experience they have to carry for life.

This story was well written and a quick read. There was some repetition in the speech of the characters that I thought was odd at first. But I think after an event like that, the repetition was done purposefully to create a realistic reaction and emphasise the helplessness and confusion of the kids.

This book is also age-appropriate, something to share with young Black teenagers if you want to teach them about their rights in the US and the importance of aiming to Come Home Safe.

Buckmire did a good job with his research. In the Author's Note, he details how he works in the criminal justice system, and talked to parents of different races about how they teach their kids (and how they were taught) to be safe with police. A lot of this was inserted into the book, but the overall message that each parent gave was to come home safe, their kids MUST come home safe. Now you see where the book title comes from.

If this reality cuts too deep for you as a Black, or even Brown, person, I wouldn't suggest reading it. But for others, read and learn. Get comfortable with being uncomfortable.

Was this review helpful?