Skip to main content

Member Reviews

𝗧𝗵𝗶𝗿𝗱 𝗧𝗶𝗺𝗲…was it a charm?! Jury is out.

I loved Book 1 of Finlay - the audio had me laughing out loud countless times over the madcap adventures of Finn and Vero.

I enjoyed Book 2 as their problems with the Russian mob and Findlay’s ex continued.

Book 3 was entertaining buuuuut it required more memory from me than I had at my fingertips about previous books + just like the fictional author Finlay, it needed more steam and romance with her love interest.

And the ending?? While there was some resolution, it wasn’t enough to satisfy me. Aaargh, cliffhangers are not my fave.

Was I entertained? Sure. Will I read book 4? Maybe.

Was this review helpful?

This series has my heart! I could not be more obsessed with Finlay and Vero’s quirky friendship and the hilarious situations they get themselves into. Without giving too much away, this book continues off the cliff hanger from book two and takes place the majority of the time at a civilian police academy training camp 😂

The pacing, wit, and humor in these books is astounding and I can never put them down! I highly recommend this series for anyone, but especially if you like a little suspense and mystery without being scared. I highly recommend reading FINLAY DONOVAN IS KILLING IT and FINLAY DONOVAN KNOCKS ‘EM DEAD to catch up before this releases in January!

Thank you to Minotaur Books for the advanced copy of this book! 🙏🏼

Was this review helpful?

Welcome to another one of my unpopular opinions. Finlay and Vero are up to the same shenanigans as in previous two books, and the book definitely ends with a set up to book 4. I just feel like there should be a bit more growth in the characters and storyline by now , and all the coincidences are just to much - how small a town is this ?

✔️ I enjoyed the relationship between Vero and Javi and some of the smaller characters like Cam and Mrs what’s her name
🔘 the setting of a citizen’s policy academy seemed a little too ludicrous and kinda silly to me

Was this review helpful?

If you enjoyed the first two books in the Finlay Donovan series, get excited for Finlay Donovan Jumps the Gun. It had the same trademark hijinks and humor while still progressing the various storylines. It isn’t all wrapped up with a bow so I assume more books are coming. That said, I didn’t feel like I was totally left hanging. I’ll continue to work my way through this series and look forward to the next.
.
This book comes out Jan 31,2023 so get your hold or preorder in now!
.
Thanks to @netgalley and @stmartinspress for the eARC.
.

Was this review helpful?

I adore the Finlay series, and this was no exception. Finlay is up to her usual antics—this time at a citizens police academy. I think I might be entirely too invested in whether Nick is going to figure out that Finlay is totally sus, or whether literally ANYONE will figure out that real life definitely is a little (ok a lot) reminiscent of Finlay’s books…I was so anxious the entire book!

Elle Cosimano, if you keep writing, I’ll keep reading. I think Finlay is secretly every mom around. Doesn’t really have her stuff together, pretends to for her editor, keeps her kids alive, and does the impossible day after day because she feels like she has to (or it won’t get done).

Was this review helpful?

LOVED LOVED LOVED!! This book along with the previous two were amazing. I can't say enough good things. This was so well written and I just love Finlay and her overall attitude. Vero and Finlay are such a great duo and this book just kept me laughing the entire time! Highly recommend!!

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge fan of the Finlay Donovan series, so I was beyond excited to get an advanced copy of this book! This is the third book in the series, and it’s another wild ride as Finlay tries to balance her life as a writer, a single mom, and an accidental hitwoman for hire. It’s full of action, a little bit of romance, laughs, and more sticky situations that Finlay and her sidekick Vero have to find their way out of.

This book picks up where the second book left off, with Finlay trying to find Easy Clean, the hitman who tried to kill her ex-husband in the last book. She also finds herself in a tough spot when Vero’s troubling past comes back to haunt them both, adding more unsavory characters to the mix. In the midst of it all, Finlay and Vero are offered the chance to take part in a citizen’s police academy, with Finlay’s potential love interest Nick as the commanding officer. This week-long training is no walk in the park, and Finlay and Vero find themselves trying to keep the criminal ties that they’ve found themselves wrapped up in from being discovered, while trying to uncover the identity of Easy Clean…and doing all of it without the cops around them noticing.

I absolutely loved the first book of this series, and enjoyed the second book as well. This book was good, and I laughed at some of the quotes and situations. But I found myself longing for more resolution with the love situation and an end to some of the conflicts that have been introduced in the series. Finlay and Vero seem to find themselves getting into more and more situations, without getting truly caught. That worked in the first book and I feel like it ended fine in the second. But at this point, it’s becoming more of an unlikely outcome…honestly. At some point, things have to come to light. It’s inevitable. Finlay and Vero wouldn’t be this lucky in real life. Adding more conflict and more situations only works for awhile and then readers may get tired of it.

All in all, it’s a 4 star read for me. I still love Finlay and Vero’s friendship, there were lots of funny moments, and I do love Nick. But, I am hoping that everything gets resolved in the next book.

Was this review helpful?

In book 3 of the Finlay Donovan series, Nick has started up a citizen's police academy, and Finlay and her nanny/partner-in-crime Vero have decided to attend. For Finlay, the reason is two-fold. Her book deadline is looming and her editor hates the book as is, and so Finlay needs to do a deep dive into researching some steamy love scenes with a certain detective love interest. Also, this will give Finlay and Vero the perfect cover-up to sleuth out who is blackmailing Feliks and free themselves from the mob's clutches—all the while dodging spies, confronting Vero's past, and juggling the daily trials of parenthood.
I love this series and this book was just as much fun as the previous two books were. There was non-stop action and laughs and I adore Finlay and Vero. I am really rooting for Finlay and Nick to become a couple. I love the over-the-top antics that Finlay and Vero get themselves into.........it reminds me of Stephanie Plum and Lula in the Janet Evanovich books. These books need to be read in order to really get the most out of the series, but they are so good. once you read the first one, you will want to keep going. I highly recommend this one!

Was this review helpful?

4⭐️ to this gem. I was lucky enough to get an ARC through NetGalley. Dear Elle Cosimano, I will read anything you write. Really, if you're looking for a great cozy mystery series, this one is for you. It is impossible not to like Finlay, a newly single mom who finds herself solving crime with her nanny Vero....while trying to write a book, keep her kids alive and prevent her ex from getting murdered (for the kid's sake of course). Definitely start with the beginning of the series if you haven't yet!

Was this review helpful?

Overall, I really enjoyed this book. I loved the first two book in this series and I would probably say this one was my least favorite of the three. I’m a huge fan of Finlay and Vero! I love their personalities and crazy adventures. The storylines are always a little over the top but that’s the point! These books are funny and a great lighthearted break from my usual thrillers. My only negative comment that that by the third book things seem to be getting a little repetitive. And while I enjoy the craziness of their stories I feel like things have gotten a little too unrealistic. These books are fun and unique and I would recommend them to anyone will enjoys lighter thrillers!

Was this review helpful?

Finlay Donovan is back! This is the third installment of the Finlay Donovan books and not really a stand alone book- I think you need to read the other two first to understand what is going on in this book.

This was my least favorite of the three books but as a fan of Finlay Donovan- I still enjoyed it! It seemed to have less action that the previous two- I didn’t love the storyline of Vero and Finlay going to police academy as it was fairly uninteresting. It was still fairly humorous but less so that the previous 2 which I adored! It was a little hard to remember everything that happened in the previous 2 books and while some recaps were included, more would have been helpful.

If you like the series, I think you will still find this book pretty entertaining and enjoyable.

Thank you Netgalley for the advanced reader copy for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you St. Martin's Press & Netgalley for an eARC of Finlay Donovan Jumps the Gun! AHHH! I took this approval as a sign from the heavens that I needed to absolutely binge the currently 3-book series of Finlay Donovan, and I have to say it was well worth it. All are 5-star reads, and Elle seemingly writes an even better book than the last every single time.

Dating. Diapers. And dodging bullets. Who said single moms can't have fun?

Finlay Donovan finds herself in yet another mess with mob boss Feliks who's running the show from behind bars. She's been told to find a contract killer before the cops. But what happens if this killer may be a cop? Luckily, her maybe-yes-maybe-no romance with hot cop Nick resurfaces when he's started up a citizen's police academy. Finay's getting pressure on her next book, and partner-in-crime and babysitter (accountant!) Vero is running from her past.

There's just so much goodness about this book and series, and the audiobooks are fantastic. I'm a thriller lover through and through, but I'd take Finlay over anything else any day. She is witty, sarcastic, funny as hell and JEEZ do I love hot cop Nick. While Finlay juggles the daily trials of parenthood while dodging the police in her not-so-legal scenarios she finds herself in, do yourself a favor and pre-order this one prior to pub day and catch up on the Finlay backlist. Your new obsession awaits!

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 💫 (4.5)

Well I lied in my last review, for the second book in this series ‘Knocks Em Dead’. I said I wouldn’t read a third if she came out with one. Not only did I read the third (this one, ‘Jumps the Gun’) in the series but I can honestly say I’m super excited to read the 4th if/when she comes out with it🤗 I feel like Cosimano went back to her roots & did this one right. Like this time she didn’t rush putting out the next book, she didn’t try so hard (to be funny) on this one. The cheeseball humor was more in line with her first book & was just funny & natural from the author’s brain…like when someone IS funny vs trying to be. This book & the entire series is kind of ridiculous, so you have to go into it knowing that & being ok with it. It’s unrealistic, dumb funny, cheese! But it’s also a book that makes you smile & laugh out loud, while simultaneously being suspenseful & making the reader question who is good/bad. I also love that she put so much more of Vero & her ‘story’ into this, that’s one thing i mentioned in my review of ‘Finlay Donovan Is Killing It’ is that Vero could have her own book so it was nice to have her character & her character’s past be more of the storyline. While the author did wrap up some of the loose ends (yay!😜) she also created some new cliffhangers for Finlay & Vero’s mess so I’m assuming & hoping there will be a 4th installment to this series.

To be honest I tried reading this awhile ago & I couldn’t get past the first chapter, I think too much of what I disliked about book 2 was still in my head & I just wasn’t in the right space mentally to read it & give it a fair shot. I’m so glad I gave it another chance (thanks to a fellow reader, Jayme, for giving me the push I needed to read it!). This was such a fun book, I was actually excited to pick it up whenever I had the chance. If you liked the first Finlay Donovan I’d definitely recommend reading this one (& book 2 for the sake of reading a series)🤗. If you’re reading this review you likely have read my other reviews on the first two books in the series or you’ve read one two or three of the Finlay Donovan books yourself…if that’s not the case these books are romcom meets murder mystery..or something 😜

Thank you NetGalley & the publisher St Martin’s Press for the opportunity to read this in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Short synopsis: Finlay and her nanny Vero are still trying to tie up loose ends from an accidental Murder for Hire. While trying to appease Feliks part of the Russian mob and find the mysterious EasyClean, Finlay and Vero sign up for Citizens Police Academy to find answers.

My thoughts: I think Finlay and Vero are quite the duo. Their banter and shenanigans are hilarious and awkward and their friendship is goals!

I thought the Citizens Police training was a fun addition to the story, and enjoyed seeing Mrs Haggerty a bit more.

I did feel like there were definitely some obstacles that Finlay and Vero faced that resolved a little too easily and they’d be in the next predicament. I would have liked there to be a little more depth to the problems, and not quite as many.

The first scene in the book had me laughing out loud. As a mother of a wild and curious 3 year old, I really hope and pray that I never have to chase him into the men’s bathroom at Walmart and climb under the stall to retrieve him.

Read if you love:
* Funny murder mysteries
* Friendship goals
* Hot cops
* Outrageous situations
* Writers block

Thank you to Minotaur Books and Netgalley for a copy of this book! Publication date is January 31, 2023

Was this review helpful?

I am here for the Finlay Vero friendship and their dark edgy, and darkly funny, adventures and chaos. I might also be here a smidge for Finlay and Nick...
Finlay Donovan Jumps the Gun brings back all that is loved by me from the first two books and adds in a twisty wild plot that did have me guessing and surprised. Elle Cosimano brings effective pacing, welcome scenes and dialogue of romance and humor, and for me an approach that says yes readers can handle the messy edginess of a mystery series for women (it's not all about the cozies!).

This book solidifies this series as one to recommend and I am so glad I got the chance to read and support this with the review copy from St Martin's Press, Minotaur imprint. Thank you for the joy of this book for a big fan!

Was this review helpful?

The third book in this cute series….and that cliff hanger!

I love me some Nick. Tall, dark, and handsome…kinda like my own Nick. 😁

Finlay and Vero are in the middle of some shenanigans again. For a while there I thought Nick would be a bad cop, and THEN I thought it would be Georgia. I never thought the actual bad guy was the bad guy! Nice little wrench thrown in the mix there. These stories are quick to read and always fun. For those that like closed door steam, you would approve of this. For those that like more…sorry!

I am dying for the fourth one to come out right now!! Ugh. Series. Always making me wait to know what happens next.

Was this review helpful?

I cannot tell you how many times I have recommended this series. And how many people love it and borrow the first two books. So obviously when I was approved for the third one, I did a huge happy dance!

I had a bit of trouble remembering all the insane shenanigans Finlay and Vero got into in book #2, but there are a lot a quick reminders to help you out. I read the last book in May so it's been a minute, but I wasn't super confused.

I will say that this book is really easy to read. The chapters aren't too long and it makes me want to just keep reading. And everything flowed nicely. Even though I was so anxious of Finlay's behalf.

Nick is such a good book boyfriend. He's so sweet and innocent and Finlay probably doesn't deserve him, but you can't help but ship them.

I don't want to spoil anything, but man so many twists and turns and if you think you have it figured out trust me - you don't.

More of a 4.5/5 stars. Who likes to rate with half stars? I've found myself doing that more and more.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for sending me an eARC of this novel! It is well established that I love the Finlay Donovan universe. It is full of silly characters and insane events. You would never believe half the things that Finlay and Vero are put through, but that is the fun of it all. With that said, this is definitely my least favorite in the series so far. It felt like a filler from the last book to the next, and while some things were uncovered, it was super slow, which I wouldn't expect. Another note is that Finlay kept talking about how there were moments when the boy and the girl would finally get together in a romance novel, but she never followed through herself! It was very frustrating because there is so much chemistry between Finlay and Nick, and I am dying for them to actually get together for real.

Was this review helpful?

Our favorite dynamic duo, Finlay Donovan and Vero, are back at it again! We are in store for more witty characters and a mystery that'll keep you intrigued all wrapped up in a hilarious package. Book two left us with a cliffhanger and it was fun to see how these two worked to solve the mystery. I loved the character development we got from Nick, and really liked the setting in the police academy.

There were a lot of characters to keep track of and at times I was googling to remember who was who. Cosimano does a good job though to reminding the reader in the first couple of chapters where we were and what had happened in the previous books. Overall I enjoyed this one more than the 2nd and look forward to see what comes next!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a good installment in the series, though I didn't enjoy it quite as much as I did the first two. It didn't feel like there was as much going on, and I didn't think it had it's own storyline, more so a continuation from book two and a set up for book 4. I'm still excited to carry on with the series, and I think the plot for book four seems fun and promising.

Was this review helpful?