Cover Image: Nine Liars

Nine Liars

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

4 stars for the latest installment of the "Truly Devious" series, "Nine Liars"!!! Have read and really enjoyed them all, and this latest is no exception, with the friends getting more mature as we go. This time, Stevie Bell & the gang investigate a 90's cold-case in England at Cambridge, since her bf David is studying in England. Enjoyed the time-lines a lot more in this one and of course, the author's well-known shock twists. I voluntarily read and reviewed a gifted DRC from the publisher & NetGalley and all thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Having not read all of the previous books in this series I thought I would be lost but that was certainly not the case. This was a fun romp through London and the English countryside as Stevie attempts to solve a murder from 1995, find a missing aunt AND spend time with her long distance (but now right in front of her) boyfriend! The Nine were a group of inseparable friends in 1995, they lived, worked and lived together. Their dynamic was a unique one and that all changed when two of them were killed during a game of hide n seek. All these years later some thing unsettle Izzy’s aunt and she is determined to find out the truth, possibly with Stevie’s help. This book was fun, if a bit long, and gave lots of details leading to the solving of the murder.

Was this review helpful?

Very fun read with a clever mystery and likable characters! Although this is a continuation of the Truly Devious world, Nine Liars will definitely appeal to new readers since it’s a standalone story which gives plenty of context for past backstory. With that being said, it did take me some time to get into the past setting since it was so front heavy in the book and didn’t really set up why so much time was taking place there. Also, because of this, it was at times difficult to keep track of the many characters who were part of the mystery. But once Stevie and her friends are on the case the story picked up pace and came together in really clever ways.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an eARC of this title.

Stevie Bell is back! And she’s in London! (I follow Maureen Johnson on Twitter and know she has ties to England; I’ve been waiting for a TD novel set in England!)

Stevie, Nate, Janelle, and Vi convince Dr. Quinn that they should be allowed to do a study abroad trip for a week in London - where David is studying. Of course, Stevie crosses paths with someone who wants her to solve a murder, this time from 1995. Stevie is really feeling the pressure of being The Girl Who Solves Murders, so this book dives into her dealing with that and how it’s affecting her mental health.

Another solid addition to the Truly Devious series. I admit I had to read the big reveal a few times to try to understand how Stevie figured it out. It seemed like a teeny tiny bit of a mental stretch to me (I’m still a bit confused about one or two details), but I rolled with it and overall enjoyed the book.

And the last page…..I think people are going to have a lot of feelings about that!!!

If you like the series, you will definitely want to read this book. If you haven’t read the series, I definitely recommend starting with book one and giving it a try!

Was this review helpful?

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I love Stevie Bell adventures and this is just so perfect. I could not put it down. I was so happy to be back with the gang. This gave me dark academia vibes and I am so here for it. If you are a Stevie and the gang fan read this book.

Was this review helpful?

I read the other books in this series and was excited for this book, but it fell flat for me. I don't know if my mood wasn't conducive to this book or if the story wasn't that great, but compared to the other books in this series, I was a bit disappointed.

Pros:
The mystery was very intriguing. Unlike the other mysteries that Stevie solved, this one had basically no clues, which made it more interesting to see how she would solve it without any familiarity.
I liked the representation of ace individuals with Nate.
I didn't see it coming when Stevie figured out who the killer was. I was very surprised.

Cons:
Stevie seemed more disoriented, disorganized, and all around dysfunctional in this book. She seemed to barely be engaging at school, the fact that she couldn't even dress herself besides a black hoodie was alarming, and no sense of planning for the future. It was just unappealing that Stevie is almost an adult and seems to have decided that if she isn't solving a murder she basically will act like a useless blob.
There was too much descriptions of scenery and the setting in this book. I had to skim several sections because it just went on and on. I get wanting to set the scene for the reader but this was too much. Most of this book barely felt like a mystery and felt like an in-between transition for Stevie and the characters.
Stevie acted so selfishly in this book. Her complete disregard for her friends and their plans for what they were going to do in England was ridiculous. She lied to them knowing that it was putting everyone in jeopardy with the school.
The group was in England for 7 days. During this time Stevie managed to solve a case that had no evidence. This was just really unrealistic and felt like a stretch. Stevie was good at solving cases in the other books but at least she had time and evidence. This time there was nothing to suggest she would be able to solve this case and somehow she did.
All the stuff with David and the will-they-won't-they was unnecessary. Also, the ending and the cliffhanger was not needed.

Overall, this was an okay book. The biggest redeeming quality and what kept me from taking off another star is how surprising it was when Stevie caught the killer. However, many aspects of this book felt unnecessary and like the author was trying to create a transition for the next book(s). I also don't understand why this book ended on a cliffhanger.

Was this review helpful?

Stevie Bell is back and on the case in the this next installment in the Truly Devious series. Stevie and her friends get an opportunity to study abroad in London, and Stevie can't wait to see her boyfriend David, who is also there studying. It's a welcome distraction from trying to figure out what she is going to do with her life after she graduates from Ellingham Academy. While they are sightseeing and trying to stick to a carefully monitored schedule, they get caught up in a murder mystery that took place in 1995. Nine friends were at an English manor house and two were murdered with an axe. The killer was never caught. But that's never stopped Stevie before. A fast-paced whodunnit that will leave you guessing.

Was this review helpful?

Lost a star for a disappointingly slow start, complete with anxiety and uncomfortablenessosity. But! She really brought it back around by the deeply satisfying conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

This was, unfortunately, my least favorite book in the series so far. There was too much focus on Stevie and David's relationship drama (complete with a cliffhanger ending that is meant to be upsetting but that fell flat for me.)

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars. So excited to read this because I absolutely loved book 4. This wasn’t as good. First of all, Nate is my favorite character in this series and he’s barely in this book. And he gets an orientation label which is just woke overkill for me in this series. I am royally pissed about this. Why does everyone need a label?!?! Also, David is garbage, in all books in this series, and especially in book 5. What is the appeal? Another big issue is how much time is spent playing tourist. Just really unnecessary. But, the mystery is excellent. Recounting what happened and Stevie’s wicked mind figuring it out. Stellar. Johnson really shines with this. Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Maureen Johnson and NetGalley for this digital ARC.

Stevie Bell is back and I couldn't be happier! Back for her 5th novel - Stevie travels to London with her friends in tow to visit David. As is her style, she gets wrapped up in a murder mystery with an intriguing storyline. The flashbacks outline what led to a double murder in a woodshed - good thing Stevie is there to put the puzzle together. Be warned... the cliffhanger is epic! Glad this ensures Stevie will be back for #6.

Was this review helpful?

Previous to picking up the Stevie Bell books, I had never read any Maureen Johnson - I was aware of her, but she was primarily publishing YA in a time I felt I had outgrown it as an audience. However, listening to her talk about her books on her podcast, Says Who, around the time The Box in the Woods was coming out, finally got me to pick them up. I started with Box in the Woods and then moved back to Truly Devious. It's possible to go this way, but I don't recommend it.

This is the 5th Stevie Bell book, and the second stand alone novel, although characters and more importantly relationships between characters develop from book to book. So while you could pick this up without reading any other Stevie Bell, you'll might get a little lost as to who's who.

Without spoilers for this book, or character dynamics for other books, this was a fun murder romp, told in Johnson's now consistent style for these mysteries, part flashback/transcript, part present day. I read it in one sitting, about 4 1/2 hours (Sorry Maureen, I know it took a very long time to write and edit), on a rainy Sunday afternoon, which was the perfect setting to read it in. Personally, I'm quite happy about the very end of the book, although I think I might be in the minority on that one.

It was a little slow for Stevie to start getting involved in things, because we had to get to the setting first, but once things picked up, they went along at a good clip. I'm enjoying seeing the character growth between each book, and I'm glad we got some more time with Nate, although more Janelle and Vi please! I especially liked the red herring/not red herring put in about a classic mystery, which foreshadowed part of what happened, without giving the whole thing away.

Looking forward to Stevie Bell 6!

Was this review helpful?

Another fabulous mystery featuring Stevie Bell! The English setting, fast pace, and fantastic side characters were all a hit! Didn’t entirely love some of Stevie’s character this time around (her friends are very forgiving). However, a solid addition to one of my favorite series of all time! Brutal cliffhanger, but overall a must read!

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this title from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own and were not affected by the free copy.

Stevie Bell is at it again, but this time, she's going international! Stevie is having a rough semester; she has no new cases, she can't decide where she's applying to college, and her boyfriend is studying in London. But when David asks Stevie and her friends to come to London, she jumps at the chance to see him again. David's friend Izzy, introduces Stevie to an unsolved double murder, where two college students were killed with ax while playing a game of hide-and-seek.

I've been on a big murder mystery kick lately, so I finally decided to read this series. So far, I've enjoyed it enough that I read straight through and requested this ARC. I do like these standalones better than the original three books.

So, for the good. I enjoyed the mystery portion. It was engaging, interesting, and kept the plot moving forward. I appreciate the portrayal of Stevie's anxiety, it's nice to see some accurate representation.

Unfortunately, I liked most of the side characters more than I liked Stevie. I did not enjoy her character regression. She went from being a very independent person, to being dependent on David, so much that she can't even focus on homework long enough to read a full paragraph and begins lying to her friends. David was also irksome. However, I love Janelle and Vi, and I deeply connected with Nate's revelation.

All in all, I still enjoyed the book, and with that cliffhanger, there will definitely be another book, which I will likely read.

Was this review helpful?

I've been loving this series, so I'm always happy to see another installment. Nine Liars presents a new mystery for Stevie to solve, as well as a host of anxieties for her to deal with. Not only is she dealing with her first long distance relationship, it's also time for college applications (and Stevie has no idea what she wants to do with her life). When David calls and invites Stevie and her closest friends to do a week long "study abroad" in London, she jumps at the chance to get away.

If you've been enjoying Stevie's adventures so far then you'll likely be happy with Nine Liars as well. For me, this one was a little less fun to read then the previous book since Stevie is mostly a big ball of anxiety who can't stop obsessing about David (and to a lesser extent, the future). This is completely realistic and understandable, just a little less fun for me, personally.

One warning, Nine Liars ends on a bit of a cliffhanger. On the plus side, this means we're definitely getting another Stevie Bell book. Of course reading the ARC means I have even longer to wait before I get to the resolution! Overall this continues to be a great YA mystery series, and I'll be happy to stick with it as long as Johnson wants to keep writing.

Was this review helpful?

This was on par with the first Truly Devious in terms of how much I enjoyed it- I have such a book-hangover now!
I do not understand why the publisher has put the pub date In the wild timeless zone of the week before the new year. This book deserves all the love and hype and would have been the perfect autumnal read.

If you’ve already been reading the Truly Devious series I know I won’t have to convince you to read this one. But I can tell you that it crackles with mystery and charm. Stevie and her friends serve up more earnest awkwardness, love, unbridled joy, navigating the transition out of high school, and of course murders to be solved.
A bit of a warning- this ends on a cliffhanger. I may have screamed internally for a good fifteen minutes once I finished the book.

Was this review helpful?

Another fun mystery featuring Stevie Bell. Unpredictable and twisty and a moody, manor setting, make this the perfect book for fall. And the cliffhanger was brutal!

Was this review helpful?

I don’t even know what to think?? I am thrilled that we have another mystery with Stevie and the gang and that we got a chance to travel to London for all of the British mystery vibes. It was a good fast-paced read like we have come to expect. However, I thought the mystery was a little bit less developed than the previous books. It felt squashed into such a short time period (1 week) and was never fully explained. This left the ending not quite as satisfying as the others. And the last couple pages just has me mad! All of that being said, it was still a fantastic book and everything we hoped for out of another Truly Devious mystery. Thanks to NetGalley for the super early ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I’m a Truly Devious addict so I will read anything put out by Maureen. I was so excited to see more of the story continuing. Stevie is a senior this year and having a tough time feeling like she is the only one not sure what she wants to do with her life. David studying over in London isn’t helping the situation at all. When they come up with a plan for all of them to go for a quick study abroad. Once she gets there David has set up a surprise for her. Another murder mystery, this time a double. Murder in a woodshed. Nine friends went to a country estate but only seven came back. Someone is lying and years later it’s time for the truth to come out. Stevie does what she does best and sets out to figure things out. For fans it’s going to be yet another book you love that leaves us on a cliffhanger too which means more books!!!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much for the chance to read this new release in one of my favourite series early!!!!

Unfortunately, it was not my favourite installment. I still enjoyed it and read it very quickly, but it did not live up to the previous four books for me. The central mystery that Stevie is solving, the murder of 2 friends in a country home in England, was atmospheric but not particularly compelling, and sometimes difficult to follow given there were nine different people involved and we're very rapidly introduced to them all.

Aside from that, David continued to irk me deeply and I would like to punch his face. Stevie also felt a little bit less sympathetic here, normally I feel teary about how much I connect with her but something felt a bit missing here.

Again - I still love the Truly Devious series and this was not a bad book - it just could have been better.

Was this review helpful?