Cover Image: Lying in the Deep

Lying in the Deep

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Diana Urban for providing me with a complimentary digital ARC for Lying in the Deep coming out May 2, 2023. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Jade is having a rough time after being dumped by her boyfriend Silas in a text. He cheats on her with her best friend Lainey. Jade couldn't be more ready to start the adventure of a lifetime—11 countries in 4 months, all from the luxurious Campus on Board ship. She can’t wait to get away from those that hurt her.

But then Jade discovers the backstabbing couple are joining her on the cruise. She meets new friends on board who help her enjoy her time, but her obsession with the cheaters grows and festers, leading to a murder at sea. And as her friends begin to drop dead, Jade and her new crush begin an investigation to find the murderer. Will they find the killer in time or will they be trapped at sea?

I wasn’t expecting to get this book, but I was so excited for it! The plot about a murder on a cruise sounded so fun. This is the first book I’ve read by this author and I definitely want to check out other books. I loved the book and I’m obsessed with it! It was a little longer than I thought, but I thought it was action packed and full of mystery. It moved fast. I really enjoyed the characters and thought most of them were fleshed out. Jade was an interesting character. I definitely felt for her, but I think she had a strong personality. There were a couple storylines that I would’ve liked to see tidied up a little more, but maybe there will be a second book?

I would recommend this to anyone who enjoys college murder mysteries at sea!

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
4/5 STARS

This is a YA thriller set on a ship.

Similar Books:
One of Us is Lying
We Were Liars

Synopsis:
Jade decides to take a semester at sea, traveling to 11 countries in 4 months. When her ex boyfriend and ex best friend show up on the same ship, it gets awkward. To make things worse, students start disappearing and showing up dead. Now Jade hopes she isn’t next and races to find the killer on board.

This was a fun YA mystery/ thriller. I like the setting on a ship because everything is contained. It was fun to try and guess who the killer was. Some things were predictable, but there were a few twists and turns that were not. Besides the mystery aspect, there is also college relationship drama and a sort of love triangle.

I would read more from this author!

Thank you to Penguin Teen for the ARC! 🛳️

Was this review helpful?

What a book! The cover certainly doesn't do it justice. What looks like an airport paperback is really a well written YA mystery.

The backdrop is a semester at sea - the mystery is who killed the very unlikeable Lainey. Lainey is a very wealthy, very spoiled young woman who controls most rooms and wins most awards. Plenty of people on the boat might want her dead, perhaps Jade most of all. Jade is worried that she will be blamed - her ex best friend did steal her boyfriend after all. Can she solve the mystery before someone else dies?

Really loved it, lots of thrills and not too much angst - great story and settting!
#PenguinGroup #PenguinYA

Was this review helpful?

This was so different than Diana Urban's other two books (which I also loved) but in the best way! I loved the studying at sea aspect of this book! It's the perfect place to write a murder mystery, knowing there is no escape for anyone. She has mastered writing fun, twisty thrillers with an ending you don't see coming! Though I was able to predict a few things in this book, definitely didn't have it all figured out. I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to all YA readers and even adults!

Was this review helpful?

Super enjoyable and fast paced. Read this in under 6 hours and had absolute no idea how it would end. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Jade has joined in on the Campus on Board ship for the adventure of a lifetime- 11 countries in 4 months. What she did not expect was her ex best friend and ex boyfriend to be present on board as well. And then someone ends up missing and presumed murdered. As they are stuck out to sea more mysterious things keep happening. Jade and her new crush Felix set out to try to solve the mystery.

This book had an opening that captured my attention right away. The middle of the story was a little slow, but the last part of the book picked back up again. I would say this is more of a suspense rather than a thriller because it wasn't as fast paced as a usual thriller. I loved the setting of the cruise ship and felt like I had been transported worlds away to the sea. The book had a lot of twists and turns, some a little predictable, but I wasn't ever able to fully work out the details so still had the element of surprise. The book also focuses on betrayal of friends and heartbreak.

This was a great young adult read and if you enjoy that genre I think you will really enjoy this one.

Thanks to Netgalley and PENGUIN GROUP Penguin Young Readers Group, Razorbill for a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I had a lot of fun reading this locked room mystery aboard a cruise ship. There were lots of twists and turns to keep you guessing from the beginning to the end about what has happened and even what the true mystery is. Instead of being just one question, there are plenty and not all of them track back to the same solution. I also really enjoyed the portrayal of a friendship break up in this book, between Lainey and Jade. It felt very real between them that Jade was more upset about Lainey than about Silas and that those wounds are deeper than any other.

I also was a big fan of the characters that round out the book. Divya and Navya were really interesting to read about with their familial problems, Miguel and Tate each had their own big hurdles to overcome, and Felix was a fun highlight. I always love a brooding love interest.

ARC provided by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC in exchange for my honest review!

This one was WILD. I haven’t read any other Diana Urban but this was truly a crazy one. I didn’t know what to expect but I didn’t see most of this coming at the end. The middle of the book was losing me cause it took way too long for a murder to pop up but when it did it got so exciting!

I liked Jade as a main character but she was heavy sympathy bait. The person who every bad thing happens to for no reason. The side characters were interesting too and I was really trying to figure out who the killer was. You have to thrown in some obvious red herrings so there’s multiple suspects. I always try to go for the most unobvious person and even though I was kinda right I was no where close. This was impressive in its run around. I’ll have to read some more of Diana’s books after this.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a smart YA retelling of Death on the Nile, meets Hulu's Dopesick series. The claustrophobic atmosphere on the cruise ship where murders take place is well-executed with fast pacing and a whodunnit mystery that piques your interest from the beginning.

Although I didn't like the main characters at first, and the love triangle part of the story made me roll my eyes, the second half of the book, with increasing pressure and escalating suspense, made me invest in them. The book contains amazing references to Death on the Nile, but the author chose a European setting with a younger adult storyline.

My favorite part of the book is the last quarter. I liked how things were resolved, and how all the plot holes were filled with reasonable explanations.

The book opens with a murder scene at one of the ship's cabins, then we move backward as the characters are introduced. The main character, Jade, is a scholarship student who double-majored, smart, and insecure. She is still nursing a heartbreak and betrayal after her boyfriend Silas left her with a text and blocked her, deciding to date her best friend Lainey, the daughter of a pharmaceutical mogul. Jade realizes that the two of them are shoving their relationship into her face by joining the luxurious Campus on Board ship, which includes 11 countries in 4 months.

Her dreamy educational European vacation is about to turn into a nightmare. She is not the only one having problems with Lainey. Her new circle of friends, including Miguel, an aspiring influencer who is losing his followers, Tate, who blames Lainey's father for the death of her mother, and Felix, who is brooding but also charismatic, and accepts a fake dating arrangement with Jade to get a reaction from the perfect couple who are talking trash behind Lainey's back.

Then, a shocking murder occurs, reminding us of the murder scene from Death on the Nile, with a small change: the murder weapon is a letter opener instead of a small gun. Jade finds herself as one of the prime suspects of the presumed murder case. She has little time to prove her innocence before the ship reaches the next port. She teams up with Felix to find out what really happened, and as their time is about to run out, more people on board are found dead. Jade has to find the killer faster before becoming the next victim.

Overall, this book is definitely a fast-paced and intriguing read that can be enjoyed in one sitting.

Many thanks to NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Penguin Young Readers Group/Razorbill for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange for my honest thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

I received a digital copy of Lying in the Deep via NetGalley to read and review.

First, I’m glad I read this after going on a cruise and not before or during. Second, I couldn’t imagine doing a study abroad type thing on a cruise ship. It definitely made for a good story that took me about a day to finish.

Murders are happening on a cruise ship and our main character needs to find out what actually happened because she knows that she’s a suspect. I had suspicions about who did it…until the twist came out and then I figured it out.

4 stars for a quick read that held my interest and throwing me for a loop!

Was this review helpful?

Reviewed for NetGalley:

Jade, heading out for a four month, semester at sea, program while nursing the loss of her best friend and ex….who also end up on the same ship.

I had high hopes for this one, but just didn’t live up to the hype. Never connected with the main character or any secondary characters. Just didn’t really care what happened next.

Was this review helpful?

Lying in the Deep is a fast-paced, unputdownable cruise ship thriller that I read in 2 days, and thoroughly enjoyed.

Jade is looking forward to a semester at sea after her boyfriend and best friend both dumped her and got together with no explanation. But uh oh, they’re on the ship, too—and we know from the start that at some point, someone gets murdered. We soon meet some colorful characters, all of whom are suspects and red herrings, and follow Jade as she tries and fails to ignore her ex and ex-BFF on the ship and at various European ports. Urban expertly lays out the events leading up to the murder and gets us instantly on Jade’s side as she grapples with confusion and betrayal. She also expertly lays out the clues to the killer—then pulls the rug out from under you. I was certain I had the killer sussed out from pretty early on—and I was wrong!

The setting, characters, and plot were all top-notch here. Love love loved it, and can’t wait for more from Diana Urban.

Was this review helpful?

I remember dreaming of participating in a semester at sea when I was young. This was a great book to get a feel for that now that I'm an adult. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC for the purpose of this review. Three stars. It became a bit long toward the middle and so many characters were involved.

Was this review helpful?

A fairly solid murder mystery. My only complaint was that a lot of the characters read a high schoolers rather than college kids. I do also wish the murdery part of the book had been gotten to a little quicker.

The ending was a bit of a twist, which made it fun. I do think Silas’s motives for things were a bit off. Like there really wasn’t much reason for him to get so angry that he “accidentally” murdered Tate.

I do wish there had been an epilogue where Jade and Felix got to reunite.

Was this review helpful?

This is the second book I’ve picked up from Diana Urban, and the second one I’ve really enjoyed!

Lying in the Deep was twisty, suspenseful and intense. This book opened incredibly strongly, and continued to be enthralling throughout.

I did not see all the twists and reveals in this book, I was genuinely surprised — but in a good way! I loved how all these little side storylines collided together. I sort of guessed the *big* twist, but didn’t guess all of the moving parts fully, so I was genuinely surprised.

This book had good writing, an engaging plot, fascinating characters, and a shocking — but satisfying — ending.

Overall, I really enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a big fan of young adult murder mystery novels - I read a lot (!) of them. And the fact that it only took me two days to read the book was a good indicator that I liked it.
The setting on the ship and the city descriptions were some of my favorite aspects of the novel. I also enjoyed the humor of the "bad boy" character, which is not always the case for me with that type of character. I normally don’t like bad boys, but I really liked Felix.
The first half of the book focused heavily on feelings of hurt, such as lost love, broken family, and the betrayal of former friends, which was unexpected for a murder mystery book but still managed to entertain me. The writing style was smooth and suited the young characters, making it easy for me to fly through the book in two days.
Although the main character was a touch too whiny for my taste due to her breakup and hurt feelings, I understand that this is a common trait for young adults and teens. And let's face it, weren't we all a little overdramatic when we were young? At least I was.
One thing that confused/surprised me was that the murder didn't happen until about halfway through the book (although it was the hook in the blurb) which was a bit later than I expected for a murder mystery. However, the lead-up to the murder kept me entertained, as the main character repeatedly confronted herself with the betrayal of her former friends and got angry about it. After the murder occurred, the book picked up pace and remained suspenseful throughout.
Although I knew early on who the killer was and why, I thought the reveal was well-executed and it will probably come as a big surprise to many readers who haven't read as many ya mystery novels as I have.

There is one small thing tho that bothered me a bit. I found the portrayal of the gay influencer to be an unnecessary stereotype that almost bordered on insulting. He was portrayed as a complete stereotype of a gay man - he loved makeup, loved gossiping, the way he spoke, and so on. As I gay man myself it felt a bit cringe. Sure, some of us are like that - and that is perfectly fine. But the way it was portrait here felt a bit too one-dimensional. At least for my personal taste.

Overall, I had a lot of fun with this novel and would recommend it to fans of YA murder mysteries. You’ll have a good time.

Was this review helpful?

Diana has once again proven that she is a force to be reckoned with in the YA Thriller genre! (Or any genre for that matter!) Urban’s third stand along novel will keep you up all night reading, wondering what twist she is going to throw at you next. If you’re wondering what kind of twist I am talking about, think Karen M McManus but on steroids!

Lying in the deep follows Jade, our main character, as she embarks on a semester at sea. This is something she deserves after her boyfriend broke up with her over text for her best friend and then was blocked by the both of them. She’s gonna have 4 months, and 11 countries, to get over the heartbreak. Or so she thought. Lainey and Silas both decide to still join Campus on Board for the summer and Lainey is not holding back on the death glares. Jade’s obsession with finding out why they both dropped her at the drop of a dime makes her suspect number one when on of the students is killed. She must team up with her fake boyfriend to clear her name, while trying to keep them both alive in the process. Bodies are being found around every corner. Who’s next?

The amount of twist and turns this book took had me on the edge of my seat for the entire time I was reading. I felt connected to Jade on a few different levels because of how great Diana wrote the emotions behind what she was feeling. Being dumbed over text has got to be rough to begin with but when he does it to get together with your best friend? She handled it better than I would have. The suspense was set up earlier in the book then expected. A series of events that, on their own seem innocent, is what really sets up the mystery. I can’t really say much more without spoiling the book, but the last…five-ish pages left my jaw on the ground! Be sure to check out Diana’s Instagram below for pre order information (which includes a GREAT pre order gift!) Lying in the Deep from Penguin Random House releases May 2nd 2023.

Was this review helpful?

Jade was best friends with Lainey in college and she had a loving boyfriend until the ultimate betrayel happen. While doing a summer internship at Laineys dad company, Silas and Lainey hook up and got together leaving Jade heart broken.

Jade trying to get over everything boarded a ship to spend a semester as sea only to find out both Lainey and Silas were are the ship to. She was determined to find out what happened them in any way possible. But no one would expect to Lainey room splattered and blood in what looked like expected murder. But no the less Jade was determined to find out who did this to Lainey.

There was so many plot twist and turns and once I thought I had something figured out, I was proven wrong. Was definitely kept me guessing the very end

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. Filled with plot twists, and mystery this kept me hooked till the very end! I loved the character development and backgrounds, it felt like I could be sitting next to them in the same room. You know when authors make such a hateable character but on purpose? Lainey was that. I started out with this sort of ‘burning’ sense of hatred for her right when the book started, but over time there were reveals and who knew she would turn out as one of my favorite characters?! The ending felt almost cliché, the murderer was predictable in the “it’s not who you think” sense, but then again, aren’t they all? Some scenes felt unnecessary and were dragging out the plot, but overall this is one of the better YA murder mysteries. I definitely think it’s a step up from “All Your Twisted Secrets” as the ending is much more intricate. I’d recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a complicated murder mystery!

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars.

I love any book that involves any type of schooling abroad. And on a ship? Yes, please.

Lying in the Deep was really fun! It was one giant mystery. First, the mystery of Jade’s falling out with Lainey and Silas. Then, the mystery of the murder.

My only complaint with this book was that I felt it was too long and had a lot of unnecessary detail before it got interested. It took me about halfway through the book the get hooked.

There were a lot of fun twists and I definitely wasn’t expecting the ending.

Was this review helpful?