Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Mazey Eddings has quickly become one of my favorite romance authors. I fell in love immediately with the characters in The Plus One and was so satisfied with the way they fell in love with each other. This book was thoughtful and steamy and just an all around treat. Thank you so much St. Martins Press and Netgalley for my ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was AMAZING! Included so much mental health rep including PTSD, anxiety, and many other perspectives I miss in romance novels! I loved how much of an emphasis was placed on self-healing, it resonated with me so much!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars- This book was on my must reads for 2023, so I was ecstatic when I got an ARC!
Indira finds out her boyfriend has been cheating on her right before her brother’s wedding. Jude, Indira’s brother’s best friend, is her nemesis.. and is also back in town for the wedding. They are forced to spend a ~lot~ of time together, both of them dealing with their own issues- Indira with her ex, and Jude with PTSD. They quickly realize they need each others help, and come up with the plan to be each other’s fake date to the wedding.

This book has fake dating, forced proximity, and does a good job grappling with mental health and it’s effects on life. It made me squeal and laugh out loud- I definitely recommend! A big shout out to St. Martin’s Press and @netgalley for the ARC, be sure to pick this one up on April 4th!

Was this review helpful?

First and foremost, I adore all of Mazey Eddings’ books and this one was no different!

The Plus One follows Indira’s story as she decides to get back at an ex by fake dating her brother’s best friend. Once a mortal enemy of Indira’s, Jude returns from giving medical treatment to those in war-torn countries with some major demons threatening to drown him. Indira’s sassy, but sunny attitude is like a breath of fresh air for him. The two lean on each other and find love and security in an unexpected place.

I want to be friends with Indira Papadakis! I can’t get enough of this circle of friends and love how Indira’s story played out. I would highly recommend reading the other 2 books in the series before diving into The Plus One, but it isn’t totally necessary. I really have no complaints. It was romantic, spicy, and a total feel-good. 5 Stars!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! Mazey Eddings has become an auto-read author for me with this series. I love how tactfully and insightfully she handles mental health while also maintaining the lighthearted vibes and HEA I look for in a romance. I literally thought, “wait, is Mazey a therapist?” as I was reading this then learned from her acknowledgments that her insight is based on personal trauma and subsequent therapy; her vulnerability shines in this novel. Beyond the mental health aspect, this was a deliciously slow burn (until it wasn’t) with great steam and even better friendships. Listen, I know they’re all happy and things are tied up nicely, but Thu is my fave in the girl gang… Mazey, please, I am begging you to give Thu a book. Thank you for your consideration. 😊

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for the opportunity to read this book before its release day on april 18.

I did not know the book was the third in the series but by the time i realized it i was in too deep to go back. This is the frist book i read by this author and will definitely will be going back to read book 1 & 2.
This story features:
Childhood nemeses-to-lovers ,Fake dating , your older brother’s best friend, only one bed (tent), FEELINGS. ANGST , Characters learning how to discuss and process trauma & mentions of PTSD
Our story begins with Jude & Indira who have known each other since they were kids, they meet since jude is best friends with Indira’s brother. The hate has been present since day one. Now hate, is a strong word, i would say its more like I-dont-like-you-and- i-will-make-fun-of-you-and-roast-until-i-die which is honestly one of my favorite thropes to read.
Jude is back for his best friends wedding in 6 weeks and Indira has to stay with her brother since she is unexpectedly single after a peanut butter accident. They slowly start to torture each other and to spend more time together. I honestly loved how their relationship changed and it didnt feel forced. The sory moved on a realistic pace.
MazeyEddings writes a lovely story that features a touch of comedy that makes it for a fun read. She also handles the PTSD of jude in a realistic and respectful way.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you SO much for the chance to read this incredible book early!

I began this book two days ago and found myself in the infamous struggle of wanting to read because it was so good and trying NOT to read in order to savor it. I loved how the characters were human, with real issues that I could relate to, and watching them fall in love was just the best. Thanks to Mazey Eddings for writing such a beautiful, realistic, and terribly romantic story! 5 out of 5 shining stars!!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to @stmartinspress and @netgalley I was able to devour THE PLUS ONE (Pub 04.04). This is the 3rd Mazey Eddings book I’ve read and it’s safe to say I’m a fan- of both the author and the person. ⁣

WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW:⁣
- Enemies to lovers⁣
- Best friends brother ⁣
- Fake dating & forced proximity⁣
- Past trauma and active healing. ⁣
- Parental abandonment⁣
- Mental health representation- PTSD and anxiety attacks⁣
- Tender, honest and vulnerable conversations.⁣

It had the elements I’ve come to appreciate in Eddings books: Funny and full of sharp dialogue. Authentic and incredibly heartwarming with characters that were layered and authentic. But this book felt heavier with even more depth than previous books in the “series”. It is no doubt due to my personal connection to a loved one with PTSD. ⁣

Once again Mazey crafts characters whose experiences jump through the page right into my heart. The tenderness between Indira and Jude- oh.my.goodness. It was perfection and a reminder that everyone deserves to be loved for exactly who they are.⁣

Romance with heft.

Was this review helpful?

I adored this story and series from start to finish. At the moment, I’m too emotional to write a long review, but it was yet another five-star book by the incredible Mazey Eddings. Each story tackles mental health in an honest way that is so rare to find represented. Mazey is truly a gift to the romance genre. I look forward to reading her books for many years to come.

Read this even if you hate romance for Jude & Indira's discussions on mental health. They were truly insightful.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve read all three of the Brush With Love books and have appreciated the author’s dip into mental health and how one deals with various issues. She handles them delicately and shows us the deep down feelings, with words, actions and descriptions that make you feel the character’s angst, tears and joy.
This enemies, to friends, to lovers book is witty, snippy and fun. I enjoyed following Indira and Jude through their relationship and the way Indira is able to help Jude open up and see we are all flawed and also help him see the way forward. I loved how this normalizes therapy, mental heath and seeking help when needed.
The big turn off for me is allllll the sex. Having read her other books before, I’m not surprised, but just don’t feel I need to read this over and over and over again…so I tend skim/fast forward to the more important parts. Out of the three in this trilogy, I think A Brush With Love was the best, this is second and Lizzie Blake was third.
Thanks to Net Galley for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

Not gonna lie, this was hard to read. But in a good way, I swear! Both Jude and Indira have so much to work through, both together and separately. At different points of the book, I could feel their anxiety becoming my anxiety. Fortunately it was easy for me to step away from, but I think that’s a sign of really good writing. This book is also filled with so much joy! Meeting Collin and Jeremy, Maria and Don, and our friends from the previous books made me so, so happy - Lizzie Blake will always be my favorite chaotic Care Bear.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

Ok I’m going to be honest…I wasn’t expecting to love this book as much as I did. I LOVED THIS BOOK. The characters and the emotional depth we got from all of them was amazing. Also the banter was amazing!!! I loved Jude and Indira. I normally am not a huge enemies to lovers fan, just because I have read so much of it. But this was done incredibly.

Another thing I really enjoyed about this book is the fact that mental health is such a huge factor. It’s such an important part that a lot of people don’t realize and I feel that Mazey did such a great job at bringing it to light.

Guys I also want to point out the tension in this book. And don’t be fooled by the cover because Jude’s dirty mouth leaves nothing to the imagination…

Can’t wait to read more of her books. If you have gotten this far. Then read this book now!!!!

Was this review helpful?

I had not read the first two books in the A Brush With Love series, so I went back and read the first two books, and very much enjoyed them both! Each book is a stand-alone that has characters that cross over, however, each book centers around a different friend, so if you don’t want to spoil the ending of the previous books, read them in order. I highly recommend all three of the books in this series!

Now for The Plus One, the first half of the book flew by for me- I would have given this a 5/5 if it continued to fly. I enjoyed both of the characters development, and loved how real Jude was. It isn’t often that you see PTSD and real emotions written out for male characters to feel real feelings. When these types of emotions come up in romance, it’s almost always the female character with the issue, so it was very refreshing and realistic to see the other side for once. The writing was real and authentic, and definitely did Jude justice. Until… they got together. When the switch happened, it no longer felt realistic to me. They went cold to hot to “we are officially tougher and everyone should know” so quickly without any problems at all. It didn’t feel real. It was so hard for me to buy into the story after that, it kind of fell apart in my mind. I still finished the book, but I read a chapter or two a day and finished it a few weeks later, instead of reading it all in one sitting like I did with the first two novels in the series.

I would read another book in this series, and I enjoyed the first half of the book sincerely, so I gave this 3/5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

This is everything I want out of a romance novel!

Indira and Jude have been enemies since, well, forever. We meet Indira when she thinks her life is great - she has a great boyfriend Indira seems to have her life together: fantastic boyfriend, amazing job as a therapist and fantastic friend group. Well, when she walks in on her boyfriend in a peanut butter-filled sexual situation with another woman, that all comes crashing down. She's now moved in with her brother and his future husband before their wedding - and her arch nemesis Jude is in town.

Poor Jude - he is a stunningly handsome man battling mental health distress - he's a doctor on leave from the NHS, where he's treated (and lost) people in battle-torn areas. He struggles with emotional breakdowns and reactions to loud, unplanned situations. But Indira, his best friend Collin's sister, can help him through that. In fact, they can help each other. Jude is willing to pretend to be Indira's girlfriend at Collin's wedding so that she doesn't have to be alone when her cheating ex is flaunting his new girl.

And therein lies the perfect romance novel - chemistry, fun banter, passionate sexy scenes, a strong friendship - forced proximity, frenemies, the like. And this isn't your surface-level romance, but instead it shows that love can blossom even when life might seem at its lowest, and that people who struggle with mental health (myself included) aren't unlovable at all.

Thank you NetGalley and St, Martin’s Press for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Hate-to-love
Brother’s best friend
Fake dating
Forced proximity
Mental health rep (including therapy)
Diverse cast
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

TW: PTSD, cheating, abandonment

Note: Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

2023 is apparently the year I’m going to read only good ARCs (manifesting this, at least!).✨ This is the second romance ARC I’ve read this year that I’ve absolutely adored. ❤️
This is my first Mazey Eddings novel, and I will pick up her prior publications ASAP. I was afraid that not reading the first two books in this series would impact my feelings about Jude and Indira’s story. Gladly, that was not the case! This novel can absolutely be read as a standalone.
Jude and Indira warmed my heart. The tropes in this book suit this couple perfectly. Their snarky banter genuinely made me laugh and swoon. It was impossible not to feel the connection between these two. Indira is a cynical and witty FMC who isn’t afraid to speak her mind. Jude, her brother’s best friend, isn’t afraid to give it back to her. Jude and Indira are known among their friends and family for hating each other. As both characters face their own set of challenges, they both know that one thing will remain the same… Their hate for one another. Their feelings for one another become a comfort amid the changes they face. In many ways, this is a grump/grump romance, and I’m honestly here for it. 😂
I felt that a majority of this book was from Jude’s POV. It may be the only romance I’ve read that is a majority MMC narrative, but it worked well in this book. Jude’s POV is essential in understanding the mental health issues he faces.
This is one of my favorite romance books with mental health representation. There were so many opportunities for this topic to be misrepresented in this story, but the author did not disappoint. Before I read the author’s note at the end of the book, I wondered if Jude’s experience was personal to Eddings, as the depiction of his illness was so spot on. I also love how the author didn’t romanticize his illness. Nor did she ignore the stigma that healthcare providers living with mental illness face from those in their own field. I feel the way Jude was treated by his medical peers is sadly a very true reality for those in his position.
Indira might be my new favorite snarky FMC. She used her snarky personality as a shield in this book which could have hindered me from getting to know her characters. Yet, her POV chapters included many scenes of her speaking with her psychiatrist. As a psychiatrist herself, Indira, understood the importance of taking care of her own mental health so she could help her patients. Again, I loved the MH rep in this book.

P.S. - I hardly ever give 3rd person romance novels 5 stars… This story was really just THAT GOOD.

Mark your calendar. The Plus One is released on April 4th, 2023!

Was this review helpful?

Wow, this was fantastic! Mazey Eddings will be an insta-buy for me from now on.

Indira and Jude were childhood enemies, but when Jude is back in town and they both wind up living at Indira's brother's house temporarily, they are thrust back into each other's lives. Both Jude and Indira are dealing with trauma, and together they help each other through it. Along the way, they realize the hate they have felt for each other all these years might just be love, now that they are adults.

I really appreciated that Eddings didn't phone it in with dealing with Jude's trauma. This wasn't insta-love, but two people who really knew each other recognizing the maturity and growth and blossoming into a real relationship. Indira doesn't try to swoop in and "fix" Jude even though she is a trained psychiatrist. There were some very heavy topics in this book but it never felt trite.

I really believed that Indira and Jude could fall for each other, and they came together in a gradual way that made sense. Also, the spice level was excellent. This is open door in the best way. :)

If you're looking for a spicy, quality contemporary romance, this is a perfect book for you. I expect to see this one on many best-of lists in the future.

Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for the free ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars

The premise of the book was really interesting. It had "enemies to lovers", "brothers best friend" and "fake dating" tropes all mixed together. However, the follow through was a bit bland. It started of strong with great banter between the two love interests but it all went downhill from there. The timeline was a bit cloudy in that the characters hated each other one day and then the next day one of them would say something sappy to the other and they would like each other again. This happened multiple times. I will say the commentary on PTSD was pretty good, However, I don't know how well it fit in with the overall storyline. Like it would be graphic love scenes followed by Jude having a breakdown and threatening to break up with Indira and then she would calm him down and in the span of a few minutes the conflict is resolved. I think that's what dropped this book down to a 2.5 for me...the awkward pacing. Also...the characters are around 30 years old? The dialogue is a bit juvenile for characters that are fully matured. For example...in one scene they have a tickle fight...it made me cringe (the main character mentions WWE smackdown for some reason). I genuinely had to stop reading for a bit after some of the scenes in this book. Finally, the actual plot has no real value expect just revealing what Jude's backstory was the whole book. for majority of the book I was just wondering what the actual conflict would be only to find out it's just Jude gaining the courage he needs to help himself and his mental health (which is a great message in and of itself but I feel like this book did a poor job of keeping the reader interested long enough to actually care when all of this occurred). Anyway, if you do enjoy this author's other books (I haven't read them so I'm not sure if its a similar writing style and pace) then I guess you would like this one too. However...I will say the romance is kind of pushed aside to deal with deeper issues halfway through.

Thanks NetGalley and the publishers for the e-arc!

Was this review helpful?

Yes yes yes! I love books written by Mazey Eddings! If you have never read anything by this author, you are seriously missing out! Every book she writes seems to have a main character with a difficult issue they inherently overcome. In this case, I’d say the main theme was PTSD and trauma.

I feel like a lot of authors make it so that the female protagonist is the one dealing with the more prominent issue, but what I loved is that the PTSD is from Jude. My heart hurt and broke for him and his rawness. I loved how supportive Indira was when Jude was having his moments. All the while, she is dealing with her own issues after her boyfriend cheated on her.

This book was handled with so much care and I really respected that. I loved how it showed that even as a psychiatrist, Indira was still in therapy for herself and made time for mental health.

The only reason this book was a 4/5 is I wished the ending would’ve been slightly different but I loved it nevertheless!

I can’t wait to see what Eddings comes up with next!

Was this review helpful?

Read if you like:
✔️ Enemies to lovers
✔️ Brother's best friend trope
✔️ Forced proximity
✔️ Spice 🌶️
✔️ Mental health representation
✔️ A Brush With Love and Lizzie Blake's Best Mistake

I was thrilled to receive an eARC of The Plus One so soon after finishing Lizzie Blake's Best Mistake, which I loved. (Thanks, NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press!)

This is the third book in the Brush With Love series and it follows Indira, Lizzie's best friend from high school, and her brother's best friend Jude, who has recently returned from spending three years as a doctor overseas. When Indira catches her boyfriend with another woman, she temporarily moves in with her brother Collin and his fiancé Jeremy, who are getting married in a month. Unbeknownst to her, Jude is also staying there while on leave from his job as a doctor in conflict-ridden zones around the world.

I loved getting to know Indira more. She appeared in the first two books in the Brush With Love series, but only briefly. She is now a practicing psychiatrist going through her own therapy to process anxiety and childhood trauma. She is crazy smart, snarky, and independent but doesn’t like being alone. I really enjoyed her dynamic with Jude, who is battling his own mental health issues. They think they hate each other but will quickly realize their feelings are different than what they expected (much to the horror of Indira’s brother/Jude’s best friend).

Once again, Mazey Eddings did a wonderful job depicting mental health issues while also writing a fun and sometimes-steamy romance between complex characters who grow because of and with each other. It's sweet, sexy, emotional, and heartwarming. You don’t necessarily have to read this series in order, but I highly recommend all three of Mazey’s books! This one doesn't come out until April 4, so you might as well read the first two while you're waiting. 😉

Was this review helpful?

<b>once again a silly little romcom has seen right though me and left me crying profusely :)</b>
<br />I just want to put judeindy in a bubble and protect from any harm in the world they deserve so much. them and this book hold a special place in my heart 🫂❤️‍🩹
<br />I cant wait for you guys to read this emotional rollercoaster because mazey eddings has done it again <3
despite all the emotion the spice caught me off guard as well immaculate🧍‍♀️
<br />thank you netgallery and st martins press for this arc!!
<br />————————————————————
<br />*me going through my emails*
*sees one from net gallery*
*reads this*
<i>Thank you so much for downloading a copy of Mazey Eddings' last novel, LIZZIE BLAKE'S BEST MISTAKE. As a fan of Mazey's, I'm so excited for you to be one of the first to read her next romance novel, THE PLUS ONE, coming from St. Martin's Griffin on April 4, 2023. </i>
<br />CRYING SCREAMING SHAKINGNAHSWNBDVEEVE HELP ME YALLJSWBNE
IM GONNA CRY STOP

Was this review helpful?