Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The year is 1939. Against the backdrop of a tumultuous, war-torn London, sisters Hazel and Flora Linden escape as often as they can into a magic world all their own--Whisperwood. In the whimsical world of Whisperwood, there are no bomb threats or impending calls for evacuation; no message from the battlefields that their father will not return home to them. Before long, Hazel and Flora are evacuated to a quaint, rural village to live with Bridie Aberdeen and her young son, Henry.

And there, away from the horrors of World War II, Flora disappears into thin air.

Set in a dual-timeline of 1939 and 1960 London, "The Secret Book of Flora Lea" is what devoted Patti Callahan Henry readers have come to love from her: a modern story with an undercurrent of mystery that leans on flashbacks from the past as the true story comes to light.

Despite its allure as part-historical fiction and part-modern fairytale, "The Secret Book of Flora Lea" was lacking in execution for me. Even with Henry's well-researched and descriptive writing, I felt she tried to do too much with the story and in doing so, left her ensemble of characters without much emotional depth. The story itself developed in a way that simultaneously felt slow and predictable, but then suddenly rushed and disjointed.

An overall refreshing, redemptive story of lost sisterhood, I'd recommend to readers wanting to breeze through a story that doesn't require much of them. I wanted so badly to love this, but found it overall fine.

Was this review helpful?

WOW, just WOW!!! I do expect a well-written, colorful book from Ms. Callahan Henry and she has delivered it once again. This time the reader gets a story about two girls, Flora and Hazel. They were sent from their mom and home in London at the start of the Blitz, They enjoyed where they were staying, but missed their mom and home. Hazel had made up a make-believe land named Whisperwood (reminds me of Narnia) and escaped there whenever life got too much. Life was as good as it could get with food rations, missing their mom, and living in a strange place with new friends, until everything fell apart...Flora disappeared.

In the modern timeline of 1960, we find Hazel, still not over the day her sister disappeared, but she has a fiance', a new job, and a lovely home. She just can't get over the guilt she has over the day Flora disappeared.

I won't tell you anymore so I don't spoil anything for you, I just want you to know that this book is worth your time. The text is so descriptive that you can visualize the settings and you will feel the emotions. I do believe this is my new favorite by Patti Callahan Henry.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first Patti Callahan Henry book and it did not disappoint! I loved this book. It had all the elements I love in a story - historical fiction, fairytales, magic, etc. I did take off 1/2 a star because I felt some parts were a bit slower and lost my attention for a bit.

This story is told over two timelines, one being 1939/1940 during WWII and the other being 20 years later. This is the story of Hazel Linden and her lost sister, Flora.

The writing was stunning and so magical. I found myself completely enamored by Hazel and Flora from the very beginning. The amount of tears this book pulled from me - loved it.
I usually have a hard time with endings in books, but this one was wrapped up nicely (in a beautiful red ribbon). I would highly recommend this book and I plan to read from this author again.

Thank you to Netgalley and Atria Books for an advance e-copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This book combines books, storytelling, war, loss and a mystery. Hazel's sister disappeared during her time in the English countryside after being sent there during Operation Pied Piper. The mystery unfolds when Hazel gets her hands on a first edition book while at her job at a rare books store. Hazel begins to find herself during this quest for the truth. I had not previously read much about Operation Pied Piper and thought the telling of that part of the story was interesting. I learned something new. The author has created an enjoyable read that I would recommend for lovers of historical fiction and books. I certainly wish I could visit that bookstore!

Was this review helpful?

In the middle of WWII sisters Hazel & Flora are sent to the countryside to escape London. They find refuge in the house of Bridie & her son, Harry. Hazel & Flora take comfort in the imaginary word of Whisperwood, a story Hazel has created. Everything seems magical until the disappearance of Flora. Years later, Hazel finds a rare first edition book by an American author containing her story. Is Flora alive? Did she write this book? A story unfolds full of twists and turns that keeps the reader guessing what happened to Flora. I could not put this book down. Readers of historical fiction will enjoy the dual storyline. The book is just magical and the characters are so easy to love. My favorite book of 2023!

Was this review helpful?

During the bombing of London many families send their children to live in the country with strangers in order to keep them safe. The evacuation was called Operation Pied Piper. During this time a little five year old girl went missing and 20 years later her disappearance still haunts her mother and sister. When a fairy tale, that only the two sisters knew about is published in a new book, there is renewed hope that the girl, Flora Lea, may still be alive.
I am a big fan of WWII historical fiction and The Secret Book of Flora Lea does fit into that category. The novel seemed to be a bit drawn out for me at times but it was an interesting story and the outcome was not predictable.

Was this review helpful?

Can a story Hazel created have the power to bring home her missing sister?

Hazel & her younger sister Flora were two of the millions of children evacuated from population-dense areas of England in WWII - they ended up a long train ride away from their London home, in the quaint town of Oxfordshire with a kind woman named Bridie & her son Harry. As the war wages on, the girls are safe in the idyllic countryside next to a beautiful river; Hazel “takes” Flora to their secret imaginary fairytale land, Whisperwood, whenever life becomes a little too much. But one day after months in the countryside, Flora goes missing.

Twenty years in the future, Flora’s fate is still unknown - Hazel has done her best to simultaneously watch for clues about her sister’s whereabouts while living her own life. Hazel has a pleasant job at a bookstore but has taken a more prestigious position with an auction house, & is getting more serious with her boyfriend, Barnaby. On her last day at the bookstore, she opens a first edition of Whisperwood and the River of Stars - the story is remarkably similar to the one she used to tell Flora, & has told no one else. Can Flora still be alive? Is she the mysterious author? Much to Barnaby’s dismay, Hazel’s life is upended as she does everything in her power to dredge up the past & find the truth about the book’s origins & her sister’s fate.

This book has its share of heartache, but the overall feeling at the end is magic: how nature & storytelling are healing. The fact that Whisperwood helped them get through the war is a testament to how art is such a necessary part of life. Also I loved all of the references to J. R. R. Tolkien, Narnia, Alice in Wonderland, & Virginia Woolf. This was my first book by this author & I’m going to have to catch up on her earlier novels while also looking out for any future publications.

Thank you to NetGalley & Atria for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

What a wonderful journey, The Secret Book took me on throughout the 300 pages. The heartbreak of the evacuation of children from London, the relationships of love between numerous characters and the the revelations at the end rendered all day reading sessions to finish with anticipation.The clear writing creates perfect visuals of the events, which add to the quality of the story. Switching from wartime to 1960 added to the suspense. Feel the pain and the love of these in these situations and enjoy it as I did .

Was this review helpful?

In the back room of a British rare books shop, Hazel unwraps an American book about a magical land that she created with her little sister Flora, twenty years ago. The same magical land that she blames for the loss of her sister, who went missing one day from the countryside and has long been presumed drowned in the Thames. The strange thing is, neither Hazel nor Flora ever told anyone about Whisperwood, so how can this book be so precise in its details? Could Flora be alive?

I absolutely loved this book! It is heartwarming and rich in detail, with a steady pace and well-written characters. I enjoyed the setting as well; despite having read plenty of WWII fiction, I've not read much about Operation Pied Piper, or really much of anything detailing the separation of British children from their parents during the war. Hazel and Flora's experiences were generally positive, though contrasting them with Kelty's did bring a dose of reality to the story.

Hazel's journey to the truth made for an excellent story, and I definitely recommend this book to anyone that loves historical fiction! Thank you to Patti Callahan Henry, Atria Books, and NetGalley for my advance digital copy.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Atria Books for this advance readers copy, in exchange for a fair review. The Secret Book of Flora Lea is a story told in dual timelines about Hazel and Flora Lea Linden. During WWII, Hazel and Flora were forced to evacuate from their home in London to the countryside and to distract her sister from reality, Hazel invents fantastical stories about a magical land. However, Flora tragically disappears one afternoon. In present day, our story opens with Hazel discovering a book about this magical land, therefore begging the question did her long lost sister write the book and is she alive?

The mystery at the heart of this book kept me so interested and I absolutely flew through this story to find out how it ends! The dual timelines of the story kept it moving at a quick pace and made it enjoyable to breeze through. I do also want to acknowledge that while this book was a quick read for me and I did enjoy it, the story was not lighthearted, as it does cover very sad topics and the horrors of living through war.

Ultimately, I did think that the final twist in the story seemed a bit too neat and coincidental to fully buy into. However, with that being said, once we learn about that twist and the fate of our characters, I did feel very satisfied with how the story ended!

I would recommend this book to historical fiction fans and think that it would make for a great book club pick!

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited to get this book through @netgalley. I love Pattie Callahan Henry’s historical fiction and I was very happy to be able to get a chance to review this book early.

This is a dual timeline historical fiction novel where we follow fourteen-year old Hazel in war-torn London of 1939, where she and five-year-old sister are evacuated to a rural village to escape the bombings which everyone fears will come. And then the story picks up twenty years later after Hazel discovers a book which describes Whisperwood and the River of Stars, a story she invented for her lost sister.

I loved following Hazel in the 1960s and uncovering the mystery of what happened to her sister. The timeline set during WWII so perfectly describes the magic that can come from stories and the reasons we tell them. This novel reminded me of The Forgotten Garden by Kate Morton, in a good way, since both books center around forgotten and cherished fairy tales.

If you like being reminded of your childhood where fairy tales seemed real, this would be a great book to read. I was happy to inhabit this world.

Was this review helpful?

I just finished the ACR for The Secret Book of Flora Lea by Patti Callahan Henry. I LOVED it!

A rare book, a child-spun fairy tale, long-suffered secrets, and a missing child guide this charming story down a river of mystery, suspense, and salvation.

The story drifts between two timelines in the life of Hazel Linden, 1939 in London at war and 1960 in London at a book story. Hazel is happy with her life, a dream job at Sotheby’s is waiting and her engagement is pending. She is packing up her things to leave her long-held job at a cozy rare bookstore. One last task, unpack boxes for the latest rare book arrivals. Who would have known that the book with a red ribbon would change the direction her happy life was flowing and drag her back to her past where memories are painful, and secrets are abundant.

In 1939, millions of British children were evacuated from war-torn London for their safety. Living in a tiny hamlet, Hazel and her sister, Floral Lea were two such children. Their new lives were filled with outdoor adventures and child-spun fairy tales. They were the lucky ones. They were staying with a wonderful family. Until one day, Flora Lea disappears.

Twenty years later, Hazel charters a course to find out what happened to Flora Lea and how her child-spun story of Whisperwood landed literally in her lap. Who knows the secret story she crafted with her five-year old sister? Who wrote the book? Is Flora Lea still alive?

I love how Hazel’s character developed on her journey. She grew not only as a woman, but also into the person she was supposed TO BE before Flora Lea was lost.

I loved the final sentences of the book, ‘In the unmapped realm in your own soul, I hope all of you find the land made just and exactly for you.’ I wish this for all the readers of this enchanting story.

The Publication date for this book is May 2, 2023. Be sure to pre-order to have your copy on Day 1!

Four and half Stars

Thank you NetGallery and Altria Books, the publisher, for sharing an advanced copy in exchange for a fair and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Truly, anything Patti Callahan Henry writes is going to be good. She is a wonderful storyteller who weaves the present and the past together beautifully.

Was this review helpful?

I have loved everything Patti writes and this book is no exception! Amazing storyline with incredible characters! Could not put it down. Highly highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

I loved this story!! I was hooked from the very beginning and never wanted put it down. Henry’s research was evident and much appreciated, it enriched the story all the more – it actually had me begin to research the period and England's WWII Pied Piper Program. I thought the author did a wonderful job taking us, the readers, on a journey along with Hazel to uncover the truth about her sister’s disappearance while also revealing the truth about what really matters in one’s life and learning to be honest with oneself. In addition to a well-thought-out storyline, Henry did a wonderful job developing the characters – I was rooting for all of them, especially Hazel! Although I was excited to unlock the mysteries Henry carefully presents to us, I was equally sad for the story to end – the characters and Whisperwood have remained with me well after completing the story. I highly recommend this book to readers that love a good historical mystery mixed in with some romance.... and set in England.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Simon and Schuster and netgalley for providing me an arc copy of The Secret Book of Flora Lea. Two sister escape the country side in operation pied piper. Hazel the older sister tells stories to Flora in order to comfort her. Flora goes missing winds up in writing the story of Whisperwoods. Twenty years later Hazel finds the book. Patti Callahan is an amazing writer with her vibrant details I could picture exactly what was happening.

Was this review helpful?

Stunning and I could not stop reading. I was transported to another time and place.
Many thanks to Atria and to NetGalley for providing me with a galley in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a wonderful story that crosses many genres. It’s part historical fiction, part mystery and part coming-of-age with a touch of romance. I loved the two time periods of the 1940s and the 1960s. I found the WWII parts so heartbreakingly sad, especially the evacuation of small children who don’t understand what’s going on.

The idea of a story inside a story was magical and the relationship between sisters Flora and Hazel was special, to say the least. I fully understood it because like Flora I have a sister who is much older than I am. All the elements of the book were woven together seamlessly creating emotions that had me hurting for everyone involved. I could clearly picture the descriptions in my mind’s eye, the blitz in London, the safer countryside, the planes flying overhead and even the magical land of Whisperwood.

The book was well-researched and felt true to life. All the characters were relatable and their behaviour made them feel like real people. For the most part, I really enjoyed getting to know them. This was such a special book about family, first love, stories, the ravages of war on families, and the power of one’s imagination. What a great premise and it was executed beautifully.

Was this review helpful?

I recieved a copy of The Secret Book of Flora Lea by Simon and Schuster last week. I started it late on Sunday and finished it in the wee morning on Friday. What a wonderful and beautiful book about never giving up on what you know in your heart is true. The book takes you from the first weeks before the war where Hazel and her little sister Flora are living in Boomsbury, London and are soon evactuated to Bainsby, on the outskirts of Oxford. The are choosen by Birdie and her son Harry to live with them during the reminder of the war. To calm her sister Flora, Hazel makes up a story about Whisperwoods and magical doors only they can see. 20 years later Hazel is still searching for her lost sister that went missing one afternoon. Never giving up on hope she comes across a rare children's book with orignal illustrations from an American writer about Whisperwood. This discovery leads Hazel trying to locate the author and track down anyone form her past who might have heard Flora talk about Whisperwood. This book was just a delight and when you think that Hazel has finally found Flora the book takes another twist and turn. A must read for anyone who loves a good mystery, historical fiction read.

Was this review helpful?

The Secret Book of Flora Lea is part fairytale, part mystery and part historical fiction. Book lovers will be instantly drawn into the life of bookseller Hazel Linden who discovers a mysterious book that tells the story of an imaginary land called Whisperwood.

Set in England and told in alternating timelines of 1939 and 1960, Patty Callahan Henry expertly braids together this magical historical fiction book. In 1939, Hazel is 14 and her younger sister, Flora Lea is 5. The sisters are evacuated from London at the start of World War II to a rural village in the countryside. In order to distract her little sister from homesickness and news of the war, Hazel creates a story about a fictitious world that only the two of them share. Hazel takes her role as big sister to heart until a tragedy makes her question her ability to keep her sister safe. Twenty years later, Hazel finds a book written by an American author the tells her secret story of Whisperwood.

The beautifully written characters and compelling plot kept me engrossed in this story. An emotional, heartwarming and hopeful family story about sisterhood, war, love and hope.

Thanks to NetGalley and Atria books for the opportunity to review this title before its release.

Was this review helpful?