Cover Image: A History of Burning

A History of Burning

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thank you NetGalley for providing an early copy for me in exchange for my honest review.

For fans of Homegoing by Yaa Gyasi, this is an ambitious multigenerational saga that follows one family over a century and across three continents. It is a mashup of historical fiction, found family, and immigrant story. This is more of a character driven novel but with plenty of plot, especially as the novel progresses, to keep it interesting. Each of the characters is well fleshed out and you get to see how the prior generation’s choices and traumas impact the lives of their children and grandchildren.

I would have liked to have a family tree at the beginning to reference to keep the relationships all straight and a glossary for the non- English words..

Overall I really enjoyed it and recommend it for fans of historical fiction and character driven novels.

Was this review helpful?

Oza, a debut author, portrays herself a superb chronicler as she weaves a multigenerational saga of an Indian family and its descendants. Beginning in 1890, one meets Pirbhai who as a young man is seeking work to help support his mother and ill sister. Essentially tricked into servitude by signing a contract with his thumbprint, he is shipped away to East Africa working on building a railroad under harsh circumstances by the British. When an opportunity came to leave his life and rebuild in Kampala, Uganda he takes his family only to experience more colonial rule and the merging of Black and Asian cultures. As activists propelled their words into the air of self rule and freedom from colonial domination, a change occurs with the rise of Idi Amin and military dictatorship. Under these political upheavals, Asians experienced increasing racism, and the family shatters into three separate continents Bombay, Uganda and Toronto where the latter immigrants must re- build their lives again. Subsequent to moving to Canada a lie is perpetuated that will have rippling effects. Throughout this chronicle, the overwhelming love of family, of loss, secrets, sacrifice, and separation tints the landscape while the author also introduces a colorful ambience of the environment, mores, and food habits of the families. I found it rather slow going in the beginning but midway it gained steam. I also wish there was a glossary because there were many non English words that I couldn't decipher the meaning; I felt that knowing the definition would have greatly benefited the novel. The characters' resilience and hope helped make this epic collage alot easier to digest as their heartbreaking lives threatened to exhaust me. There is much food for thought in this pitch perfect prose. Time to consume.

Was this review helpful?

This book hooked me and then it changed me. The writing is so engaging. The point of views are very clever and unique. Each decision made is reflected in the next persons point of view, allowing the readers to see the path taken and now actions and our past inform the future. It also made the flow of time throughout the book feel like a documentary but with inside eyes. getting to know each character intimately through many eyes. Another thing I loved about this book is it's rich and colorful descriptions, you are dipped wholly into their lives and culture. it gave me an opportunity to learn. And for that this book exceeded my expectations. A History of Burning is a riveting family saga about Exile, Determination, and survival. Please read it, it is one of my favorite pieces of literature I have ever had the pleasure of reading.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for providing an early copy for me in exchange for my honest review.

I Liked but did not love this book. Generally this is my favorite type of story, but it didn't work as well in this instance.
Some of the story line was well done, maybe could have been edited back a little bit, but in other areas the story jumped with little explaination. For example when Kiya was Pregnant with Meetu she reconnected with her sister (AWESOME) but they both were concerned about how their parents would react. Next chapter Meetu is a full on toddler. No reaction for the parents, which would have been culturally relevant.

Also left unfinished, in my opinion was the branch of the story with Latika. The story line drops her, but does pick her up, again, but does not tie up loose ends. I don't know how her story ends, or even happens in the middle. This is a lost opportunity, for this part of the story would be very interesting, Latika was a strong character when she was featured. And finally Hari. His struggle toward the end could have been more fleshed out. We could have heard his sisters and grandparents tell him what they could but instead his frustrated behaviors are what was discussed in the novel.

Over all It was a good read, but left me wanting in some ways.

Was this review helpful?

This is quite an incredible debut novel by Janika Oza chronicling several generations of one family across several countries (indeed, continents!). Told from multiple perspectives over several decades, the reader follows Pirbhai and his children, grandchildren and great grandchildren as they are forcibly uprooted from one country to another (India, Uganda, the UK and Canada). In each new place, they rebuild and try to create a sense of home and community while establishing roots for their children. Among the many characters, each shows strength in different ways while still being very real, fallible beings. Throughout this book, I was struck by Oza's deft writing where you witness relationships grow and develop over time - the conflicts, the different ways individuals show compassion and love and the underlying belief in family. This is not the typical immigrant story and I appreciate its many layers showing that the immigrant or Asian experience is not a monolith. There are many events depicted in the book that are horrifying, depressing and heartbreaking, but ultimately I felt a strong sense of hope for what lies ahead as well as great appreciation and gratitude for what those before us have accomplished.

Janika Oza is one to watch! Many thanks to NetGalley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This book is really wonderful. If you like multigenerational family stories, if you like historical fiction, if you like learning about times and places in history you haven’t read about before, I think you will like A History of Burning. This story starts in 1898 with a boy who is taken from India to Uganda to work on a railway for the British, and proceeds to follow his children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren, and their lives in Uganda and Toronto. The characters in this book are very well fleshed out and I really grew to care about each of them. There is a thread of loss/misplacement, and the silence that comes with family secrets that persists through the generations, but still a feeling of hope. The ending was perfect. Very happy I read this book!

Was this review helpful?

I love multigenerational stories. I find it the best way to dive deep into the characters from many sides. And this one does not disappoint. One that will keep me thinking for a long time. And this story from a debit author, I can’t wait to see more from them!

Was this review helpful?

This novel pulled at me, working its way deeper into me with each page I read. This one will stay with me for a long time.

I am astounded that this is a debut author - Ms. Oza is immensely talented and I look forward to reading more of her future works.



Thank you to Grand Central Publishing and NetGalley for the DRC!

Was this review helpful?

If you loved Pachinko, Homegoing, Tomorrow, Tomorrow, Tomorrow or Half of a Yellow Sun this is a book for you! It's hard to believe that Janika Oza is a debut author! She has skilfully woven together a generational saga that expands over continents and includes vivid descriptions of foods and traditions.

The book starts with the story of Pirbhai, a young Indian boy looking for work who is essentially kidnapped and forced into a labor camp in East Africa. The majority of the story, however, focuses upon his three grandchildren as they navigate the political uprisings in Uganda and make personal decisions on based on their experiences.
This novel is going to be well read and very much talked about! Grab it when you can!
#Ahistoryofburning #jankikaOza #GrandCentral Publishing

Was this review helpful?

This was a great multigenerational family saga. I loved the continuation of the story and callbacks to earlier parts of it throughout the writing.

Was this review helpful?

Not quite perfect, but so darn close. Just loved this book -- traces of Poisonwood Bible, The Namesake and yes, the beloved Cutting for Stone. A multigenerational story that starts in India when a young man sets out for work to improve his families circumstances...it ends in Toronto generations later with history repeating itself many times in many ways in between. I loved this family and all the characters. Their secrets, traditions, dreams, struggles and the distance that occurs between parents and children and among siblings were so vivid and heart-wrenching. This book will not be published until May but put it on your list now. Not to be missed -- my only (small) critique is a slightly unsatisfying ending. But I find that so often with a really good book, that I don't think I can even be objective if this is me just wanting more or if it is a fair criticism. Can't wait to talk about this one with all my book-loving BFFs.

Was this review helpful?

In "A History of Burning", Janika Oza lays out a multi-generational story following one family and the trials and tribulations each generation endures. Starting in the early 1900s, young Pirbhai is taken from his home in India, tricked into becoming a laborer for the East African Railway in Uganda. Despite his homesickness, he's able to escape and is taken in by a sympathetic family, learning to live in a whole new country where he's considered an outsider. Nonetheless, Pirbhai is able to grow his own family in Kampala, and watches as Uganda moves forward towards independence under the military dictatorship of Idi Amin.

Pirbhai's three children include his son Vinod, who comes to marry Radhi, and the two have three children of their own: Latika, Mayuri, and Kiya. The novel focuses the bulk of its time focused on these 3 daughters as their lives are completely changed due to the political upheavals in Uganda, where Asians are slowly but forcibly racially discriminated and the family eventually splinters. Latika and her husband Arun are political activists, and her loyalty to her cause and her husband forces her to stay behind. Mayuri, the middle daughter, is deemed safe at a medical school in Bombay. The remainder of the family flees to Toronto where they're forced to start their lives over again, although with the lie that Latika's son, Harilal, is Vinod's and Radhi's son. The final portion of the book follows Hari's transition out of childhood as he learns the truth of his parents, including his mother's eventual location in Great Britain, and follows the family as they try to stay together against all odds.

I had no historical context going into this novel, and while there were moments of confusion where I struggled to understand the events occurring in the first half of this novel in Uganda, Oza is able to present these in a way that's understandable to all readers, including the complex caste system and the communities of Indians in Africa. As a first generation immigrant myself, the second half of the novel felt the most familiar to me, reading about Vinod's and Radhi's struggles to find footing in Toronto, their daughters individual attempts to make their own lives and careers, and Hari's own confusion over his identity and family.

All throughout the novel, Oza highlights the changing face of racism and discrimination, countered by one family's love and dedication to each other. Her writing is fluid and adaptable, taking on the perspectives of different generations and family members to lay out what happens across the following century, dotted with moments of reflection and poignancy. I'm incredibly impressed that this is the work of a debut author, and am sure many will come to love this novel after its publication in May 2023!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed a History of Burning. I loved the multi-generational tale, looking at the Indian community in Uganda. I loved the themes of resilience, family, loss, and heartbreak. It was well done and sucked me in.

Was this review helpful?

This already has lots of high ratings and reviews and I can see why. Oza is a talented writer, and this will satisfy many, especially those that like family sagas.

Thanks very much for the free ARC for review!!

Was this review helpful?

The cover caught my attention! Love the vivid colors, the writing kept me around. I love a good family saga. Multigenerational storytelling, good character building and bold. A bit heavy.

Was this review helpful?

This book was intense and deep. It follows several generations displaced by various governments all over the world.

Publisher Blurb:
Pirbhai's children, born and raised under the jacaranda trees and searing sun of Kampala during the waning days of British colonial rule. As Uganda moves towards independence and military dictatorship, Pirbhai's granddaughters, are three sisters coming of age in a divided nation. As they each forge their own path for a future, they must carry the silence of the history they've inherited. Later, under a brutal regime and the South Asian expulsion, the family has no choice but to flee, and in the chaos, they leave something devastating behind.

Review:
For a debut novel this one is fantastic though it did start slow, and it took me a while to become invested. The second half of the book was well developed and kept me wanting. This story is beautiful and intricately woven. This book is full of family, sacrifice, and heartbreak, but its told beautifully.

If you were a fan of Pachinko then make sure to check this one our on May 2nd of 2023. Thank you to Grand Central Publishing, and @netgalley for allowing me early access to this audio book in exchange for this honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is a multi-generational "saga" that takes place across about a hundred years and multiple continents but primarily centers on Indian migrant community in Uganda.

A story like this is hard to pull off. The inevitable downside of trying to cover 100 years in 350 odd pages is that the author has to rush through some time periods and some characters are not developed fully because they will be inconsequential when the next time jump happens.

The time skipping in tied to major national or international events and how they impact the primary characters in the book (of that time). However, due to the time-crunch, we rush through what is a seminal event for the character. The first 80 odd years go by fast and then we spent a fair amount of time in the 1970s/80s to wrap up the story.

The author certainly has talent and would have served the readers well by concentrating on the time period of the first 30-40 years only as very little literature exists on the subject of forced migration of the Indian diaspora in the second half of the nineteenth century. As it is laid out, the book didn't really work for me but I would like to read the future works of the author as the kinks are worked out.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this family saga - I felt that the last half / 2/3 were the strongest and most compelling. I loved being able to revisit some of the family members through different times and the way their loved ones came back through memories or reminiscing. I had no idea about the history of Asians in Uganda and learned a lot from this novel. Looking forward to more by this author.

Was this review helpful?

A History of Burning is a multi-generational story about what it means to be a stranger in your own land. It is also a tale of refugees and the trials of making a new life. The story starts with Pirbhai who, at a young age, becomes slave laborer for the British building a railroad in Africa. His decision to stay in Africa after he becomes free will reverberate through the following generations. I was not familiar with this history and learned a lot reading this book. It is wonderfully crafted and you will get emotionally involved with this family. Past trauma tends to affect how future generations react to situations.

This book will stay with me for a long time and I look forward to the next book by Janika Oza. I would highly recommend it. What a wonderful story. One of the best I have read this year.

Thank you to #netgalley, #JanikaOza and #GrandCentralPublishing for a copy of this book.
#AHistoryofBurning

Was this review helpful?

I received a free e-arc of this book through Netgalley.
This is an epic look through several generations of a family displaced by various governments all over the world as some people fight to be free of discrimination and colonial rule. It shows how discrimination has changed from one group to another depending on who is in charge. Also, it captures some of the family dynamics of people who are grieving and take it out on each other.

Was this review helpful?