Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Mystery, Suspense and Romance! What a great story by Manda Collins. Poppy and Joshua were great characters in their own right and fantastic together. Their banter was hilarious and the trust they had in each other amazing. The mystery was definitely well thought out and while I had a guess who the killer could be I was still pleasantly surprised by the way it was resolved. The inclusion of a secret society and tunnels was great and I really did not see that tunnel scene coming. Especially the romantic scene that came directly after. I do think it would have been nice to see a bit more about Poppy's childhood. It felt like she just came out and told everyone and we as readers didn't get the chance to feel the emotions behind her experiences since it was stated so plainly. There were also points in the book that seemed outrageous but it was still enjoyable. I wish the epilogue was longer so we could really see them together and happy now that all of the excitement was over. The scene was cute but not as satisfying as it could have been. Overall I found the story incredibly enjoyable but wish there was a little more time for them to focus on the romance rather than just the mystery. All of these things don't take away from my enjoyment of the story and I will probably read the rest of the series.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun read! If I'm bring honest, I have not read the first two books in the series before reading this one. They are all separate characters, so you don't really need to read the others to enjoy the one, and enjoy it I did. I read the premise and figured I'd give it a go. I'm not usually one for period romances, but I decided to give this one a try, and I'm glad that I did. It was a fun romance/murder mystery with a tiny bit of spice, but was an overall satisfying read. I'll probably go back and read the first two in the series at some point as well!
*3.5 stars rounded up

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 rounded up.

This Manda Collins series is so wonderful with its strong, smart, capable heroines and their handsome men! The first half of this particular book was bogged down a bit in scattered details about the murder mystery that could use a bit of tightening up. However, the last half when the clues started to come together and make sense… and the romance heated up, the novel became a page turner for me.

Give me a regency romance with a fake engagement and toss in a murder mystery and you’ve got me hooked!

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I was expecting more from this book, but I still really enjoyed it. I think it was very cute and well done, but lacking some depth. I still recommend this series to people though!

Was this review helpful?

A cozy historical romance with a dash of murder mystery? Yes, please!

This is the third book in the very entertaining “Ladies Most Scandalous” series by Manda Collins. Although it can be read as a standalone, I hope you’ll treat yourself to the whole series. It’s the perfect blend of romance and mystery. In addition to delightful banter, swoony romance, engrossing mystery, this series celebrates empowering female friendship.

To avoid marriage to an odious man, Poppy Delamere flees from home and is living incognito as Flora Deaver, secretary to Lady Katherine (heroine from book 1). However, when Poppy’s half-sister is accused of murdering her husband, Poppy returns home and join forces with the Duke of Langham to clear her sister’s name and discover the identity of the real killer. The only catch is Poppy has to enter a sham betrothal with Langham. Lucky girl!

I enjoyed Poppy and Langham’s banter in the last book. The chemistry between them was palpable. Langham has all the traits I love in a hero: kind, loving, and honorable. I love how supportive and protective he is of Poppy. There is an endearing scene in which he concedes that Poppy is smarter than him. Likewise, there is another sweet scene in which Poppy eases Langham’s claustrophobia. Poppy is a lovely heroine. Sharp-witted, independent, fiercely loyal to those she loves, Poppy is a combination of strength and vulnerability. I love how their relationship blossomed from friendship to love. Furthermore, get ready for some cave shenanigans.

Blackmail, murder, disappearance, a secret society—it’s all happening in a small village called Little Kidding! This was such a fun read. I was hooked from start to end. Also, the mystery element never overshadowed the romance. And that’s exactly how I like it!

I highly recommend this book for fans of romance and historical mysteries. Can’t wait for the next one!

A big thank you to Netgalley and Forever (Grand Central Publishing) for allowing me the opportunity to read an e-ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third book of the series, but the first one I have read. I loved it!! I definitely got Pride and Prejudice and Nancy Drew vibes, which are my favorites. The story never felt slow or forced at all. I really enjoyed reading this!

Was this review helpful?

Such a great story! Love the enemies to lovers and fake engagement tropes and they are both done well here. The secret society (and it’s real connections) is so intriguing. Going back to read the others in this series ASAP.

Was this review helpful?

Apparently, third time IS the charm. I am so pleased that one of the couples in this series finally delivered on their promise of crisp banter and swoony chemistry. Because, for me, the previous couples fell flat as a pancake on cement. This installment is also generally free of what previously came across to me as "man-hating" feminism.

The mystery mostly held my interest because it's fairly well-balanced with the romance. But in keeping with the light genre, it's a fairly transparent mystery that honestly kind of drags until the murderer is pulled out of a hat at the end.

But there's nothing behind Langham having claustrophobia, even if mildly; it's only used to set-up the sex scene and is never an issue for the character or couple before or after that. Definitely felt a bit checklist-y. Orgasmic tokenism anyone?

Was this review helpful?

A Spinster's Guide to Danger and Dukes is a fun addition to the Lady's Guide series. She writes a great mix of banter, romance, and mystery. We always buy her for our library.

Was this review helpful?

When Poppy sees in the paper that her sister is under suspicion for murdering her husband she drops everything and rushes to her side. Or rather she tries to. An unfortunate mishap puts her in the path of the duke of Langham whom she has always despised, but quickly redeems himself. They come up with a plan Poppy will pretend to be his fiancé and he will help her clear her sisters name. Here starts their adventure.

I have liked all the books in this series so far. I was not sure I was going to like this one in the being because of Poppy's behavior, but she quickly seemed to change for the better. This book was a wonderful quick read with an interesting mystery. I would highly recommend this series.

Was this review helpful?

“A Spinster’s Guide to Danger and Dukes” is the third book in Manda Collins’ wonderful series about bold women in Victorian England. The previous books introduced Kate and Caro who publish a newspaper that specializes in issues for women, such as how to keep safe while on the street and where crimes against women have occurred in London…nothing was was being published in more traditional newspapers of the day. “Spinsters’” focuses on Kate’s and Caro’s secretary/fact-checker/admin manager, Flora Deaver. The first page reveals that Flora is really Poppy Delamere, daughter of a vicar who died when she was very young and step-daughter of a Barron…in short, she’s a “lady” not a middle class orphan. The deception was necessary because she’s escaped the dastardly Barron and his plan to marry her off to his secretary two years before and had not had any contact with her family since. What she didn’t know was that the Barron had substituted her stepsister to marry the secretary and was shocked to see an article in the newspaper about her stepsister being accused of killing her husband. Poppy runs to the train station to go help her stepsister but her purse is stollen, she has no money and is forced to accept a ride in Joshua, the Duke of Langham’s private car. They are not friend but Langham promises to help Poopy clear her sister is she will pose as his fiancée at a house party organized by his grandmother who has invited eligible young ladies to encourage her grandson to marry soon. A murder investigation, a secret society, and family dramas may push Poppy and Joshua to think about making the fake engagement a real one. But will they prove her sister’s innocence, deal with the cruel Barron, and deal with an illegitimate financial scheme at the same time???

Was this review helpful?

I read this book at the suggestion by the moderator on another romance author's site. I liked the characters and the plot twists. I will look for other books by this author,

I already posted my review on GoodReads. This was my first review of a Net Galley book.

Was this review helpful?

Manda Collins has continued her fantastic "A Lady's Guide" series with her third novel, "A Spinster's Guide to Danger and Dukes." Just like the previous books, Collins writes with humor, a compelling storyline, and palpable romantic chemistry. This particular novel focuses on Poppy, whose sister has been wrongly accused of murdering her villainous husband. In order to get to the truth of the matter, she must rely on someone with power: Joshua, the Duke of Langham. Joshua has his own favor to ask: to get his grandmother off his back about him securing a wife. They decide to work together to solve both of their problems, only to discover that maybe they actually have real feelings for each other after all?

I enjoyed the sweet romance between Poppy and Joshua. The actual mystery was a little overdrawn and I thought the cultic practices were strange, but I still enjoyed this book overall. I also enjoyed getting updates on some well-loved characters from the previous books. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

• Historical Romantic Suspense (Historical Romance meets Cozy Murder Mystery)
• Feisty, fun and independent heroine (Poppy / with cameos from Kate and Caro!)
• Betrothal of Convenience / Fake Relationship
• Strong, supportive female friendship
• Banter and some slow burn romance
• An intriguing who-dun-it, that was satisfying to unravel as the ultimate who and why

This has been such a fantastic series and helped me to discover a whole other genre / subgenre of reading that I didn’t even know I needed and loved: Historical Romantic Suspense (aka Historical Romance meets Cozy Murder Mystery). Having read the first two books, I was eager to return to the Lady’s Guide team and read about Poppy’s story. I was interested to see how things would pan out when I realized that Langham was her counterpart in this book given my first impressions in the other books. However, I was really pleasantly surprised and very quickly 100% onboard for Langham and Poppy.

Once again, Ms. Collins delivered a clever, charming story that kept me riveted. I had my thoughts, guesses, and suspicions throughout but found solving the mystery and unraveling the particulars alongside our intrepid crew highly satisfying once again. Another delightful read and I can only hope we will get some more in the series – I’m not ready to say goodbye to our crew. One I will definitely be adding a physical copy of to my home library.

Thank you to Netgalley and Read Forever Pub / Grand Central Publishing for the opportunity to read an early copy! All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the advance reader copy of this novel. I enjoyed this historical fiction where it was an enemies to lovers trope. The easy banter between Poppy and Latham was delightful. The added mystery component to the book added to the enjoyment factor for me. I also liked how the author has set up for the next book #3 with Lord Adrian and the governess. I didn't like the sex in this book and felt it was absolutely unnecessary and skipped that whole part. That really soured this book for me. A great read otherwise.

Was this review helpful?

Charming, charming, charming! Manda Collins writes such lovely stories and A Spinster’s Guide to Danger and Dukes does not disappoint. Having met Poppy in previous books I’m so happy for her to get her HEA! Collins does a great job of adding mystery to our romance (which is my preference!) I was very happy to see all of the ladies reunite in the final act. Female friendships are so important to all romance novels! Please keep them coming Manda Collins!

Thank you #Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Another charming addition to the Ladies Most Scandalous series! Poppy is a feisty heroine and fun to see her come into her own after appearing as a minor character in earlier books. Langham really redeemed himself in this book after appearing not particularly appealing on his first appearances in the series, but his inner life and distinctive character traits really distinguished him from the typical MC. As with the other books, the mystery plot felt secondary to the romance (which is not a complaint!) and was relatively easy for the reader to solve before it unraveled in the book itself. Lots of fun secondary characters in this book, and it feels like Collins is able to create a very full world without ever losing track of the main characters and their driving plot. Overall, a fun read with just the right amount of steam.

Was this review helpful?

I accidentally posted another books review here, and Net Galley won't let me remove it. I will update this when I am ready to review. Sorry!

Was this review helpful?

What do you get when a Duke avoiding marriage and crime-solving spinster quite literally collide? A compelling engagement-of-convenience mystery! Langham, a handsome Duke, attempts to avoid his duty to marry and Poppy, an independent woman, strives to clear her sister’s name of murder. Will the two accomplish their goals? What will happen along the way?

I loved the dynamic between Langham and Poppy! A period piece murder mystery?? Yes please!

Was this review helpful?

3 Stars Although I haven’t read the previous books in this series of interconnected standalones, I thoroughly enjoyed A Spinster’s Guide to Danger and Dukes. Part romance and part murder mystery, the book never felt slow or lacked action, which I feel like happens more often than not in historical romance books (unfortunately). I appreciated that the book jumped right into the action with the main characters literally running into each other instead of taking too much time explaining the background of the characters and what had happened to them up until that point. This was a relatively quick and easy read, and I definitely recommend if you are looking for a cute historical romance.

Was this review helpful?