Same Time Next Summer by Annabel Monaghan

Sam and Wyatt had a bad break up when they were teenagers, and ever since, Sam does not like to go back to the place that reminds her of their relationship the most, her dad's home in Long Island. However, Sam heads back to that fateful place with her fiancé and low and behold, guess who she runs into. That's right, her childhood sweetheart, Wyatt, the one who broke her heart.

I really enjoyed the surfing scenes and the summer atmosphere! I can totally understand pining for someone after all those years, but I just wish we saw more connection between Sam and Wyatt in the past timeline. What was it that made them love each other so much? It would have been more convincing if there had been some sort of spark between Sam and Wyatt, such as a touch of the hand or a longing gaze between them. I want to swoon over a couple. It read a little bit YA because the relationship and the overall story did not go as deep as it potentially could have. The writing style was smooth and flowed nicely.

It was a nice, sweet story, and I recommend it to anyone seeking a quick, summer romance.

Thank you Netgalley and Penguin Group Putnam, GP Putnam's Sons for the ARC.

Same Time Next Summer is the ultimate summer read. I loved that this was an adorable romance, it also tackled some tough family issues. I really enjoyed getting to know Sam and coming to realize what she really wanted her life to look like instead of what she thought it should be.

I'll keep it short and sweet since there are a lot of layers to this book, but it's a quick read and would be easy to spoil if I say too much! This is definitely one to pack in your beach bag and read in your favorite vacation spot. And if you're not going on vacation, this sweet read will transport you to the beach.

Thank you Putnam Books and NetGalley for the eARC!

I loved this book. We all have a first love, the first person for whom we felt that all consuming feeling when it seems no one else could ever be as important. This book is so beautifully written, it brought back the bittersweet memories I have of being a teenager in love.

The story is about Samantha (Sam) and Wyatt. It’s told from a now and then perspective, we see how strongly they felt about each other as teenagers and again as adults despite Sam’s pending marriage.

I loved reading about the places on Long Island where they spent time, the beach descriptions were so detailed I felt like I was there. I highly recommended this book, 5 stars.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed as in this review are completely my own.

I LOVED THIS BOOK!!! It was just what I needed. I loved the past romance and the friends come together it was so sweet and I can't wait to read more by Annabel Monaghan.

Sam has finally figured things out. She has a job she loves, a successful doctor who wants to marry her, and a beach house on Long Island that might be the perfect wedding venue. But as soon as Sam arrives on the island, she runs into her high school sweetheart...the one who broke her heart thirteen summers ago. Sam's chemistry with her old flame is undeniable, but will being around him risk everything she has worked so hard to build?

I read and loved Annabel Monaghan's debut novel last summer, so her follow-up was one of my most-anticipated reads this season, and it did not disappoint! Monaghan nails the second-chance romance trope: Wyatt is a dreamboat guitar player who still hold a candle for Sam, and Sam's fiance, Jack, is the perfect Hallmark movie 'villain': he is uptight, he only reads pretentious literature, and he won't stop telling everyone to wear sunscreen! Monaghan's second novel also includes stellar side characters. Sam's grandparents are a great source of comic relief throughout the book and Gracie is a gem.


This novel is well-executed and witty. I don't know why more bookstagrammers aren't raving about this author. Fans of Hallmark movies and closed door romance should read this book. It is perfect for the beach!

Thank you @netgalley and @penguinrandomhouse for my early e-galley!

I went into this one expecting to love this one just as much if not more than Nora Goes Off Script. I tried multiple times to read this one, but it didn't hold my attention and my mind was drifting elsewhere. I'm giving this one three stars for the simple fact that I don't think it's the story itself, and I am choosing to listen on audio. I will share my review on IG @storybookcorner once my Libby hold comes in from the library. I look forward to listening to this one.

Same Time Next Summer ☀️

This book is perfect for anyone who doesn’t have it all figured out quite yet. Sam is getting married to Jack; but doesn’t really have an interest in wedding planning. She’s recently made a big mistake at work and she’s still trying to understand the consequences.

They go to her family’s beach house out in Long Island and she’s worried over Jack’s reaction. He likes neatness and order and her family is full of artists and love to collect things. Once she arrives, she finds out Wyatt is next door; he was her first love and it ended terribly. Sam has spent a lot of time thinking about him over the years after they lost contact. She’s with Jack now; she can’t think about Wyatt.

Wyatt is back in LI for the week and he’s now a big shot music writer in Los Angeles. But funny how being home reminds you of when you’re 17, and your first love. The book flashes back to the summer they got together and the present day. It’s clear Sam and Jack don’t have much in common and that Wyatt is her true love. I will say the driving event of their breakup was a little bit of a letdown and I had an alternate plot (that didn’t happen) that would have stirred up more drama. All in all, I thought it was a cute and fast book perfect for the beach.

Many thanks to @putnambooks and @annabelmonaghan for my gifted copy.

Ooh the finest of the fine - wish I had been on the beach when I read this. Much of the book takes place in Long Island, NY and that just upped the ante for me - familiar and relatable. Love the now and then of the telling - it added sense and maturity to what might otherwise have been syrupy and sophomoric. Can you feel the heat? Can you feel the burn? Can you feel the pain? Yeah, I could and that is really good writing.

The humor is so perfect - reading the same sex scene six times and wondering about the position of body parts and how many hands are there groping around - you had to be there - you can’t help but snort. But the heartbreak and angst were equally gripping and hollowing - really good writing.

Love the characters, especially the ones who just had to throw in their whatever’s. Loved Sam and her ability to disassemble and reassemble and get lost and then found. So in love with Wyatt and what is wrong SamIam - open your eyes, figure it out - we all have.

Annabel Monaghan is going to the top of my list. Thank you G.P Putnam’s Sons and NetGalley for a copy.

This was an enjoyable book. However I didn’t feel the connection as heavily as I was hoping to between the two MC.

I loved Nora Goes off Script. This book didn’t land in the same way. The reader is rooting for Sam and Wyatt, but there’s a lot of backstory. I wanted more present. Jack was so dull- I think it would have been interesting if it was more of a triangle. It was a fun summer read.

Another hit from Annabel Monaghan! Sam and Wyatt found a place in my heart almost immediately. The characters are so fleshed out and the beach house so real that I was right there along with them. Just a story full of perfectly imperfect people who made mistakes and are living with them.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an advanced copy. This was such a sweet coming home book. I liked that the main character had to really take a look at herself and push herself out of her comfort zone to decide what was important to her.

I was excited to read Same Time Next Summer because it has a seaside/beach setting and one of my favorite tropes, second chance romance. It sounded like a perfect summer read. I liked the book, but I didn't love it. The second chance romance was underwhelming, and there was not much relationship growth. Because the book is mostly written from Sam's POV, we don't get to know what Wyatt feels or thinks. So at times, it felt like he wasn't interested in rekindling his relationship with Sam. I enjoyed reading chapters from the past when Sam and Wyatt were teenagers. They were more romantic than the present timeline. I recommend this Same Time Next Summer to those who enjoy low angst, closed-door romance.

I thoroughly enjoyed Annabel Monaghan's latest book, SAME TIME NEXT SUMMER. Once again, Monaghan skillfully weaves together captivating romantic tales set in charming locations. In this new story, Sam Holloway and her fiancé embark on a trip to her family's beach house on Long Island to make arrangements for their upcoming wedding. Unexpectedly, Sam's former high school flame, who now resides in Los Angeles, returns to town for a local music festival. The combination of the picturesque setting, memorable characters, and the beautifully crafted storyline makes this book a wonderful choice for a summer vacation read!

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

I was very excited to get a copy of Annabel Monaghan’s newest novel because her debut Nora Goes Off Script was one of my favorites from 2022. This is the story of Sam and Wyatt who grew up going to neighboring beach houses on Long Island. They thought their summer romance would turn into a lifelong love until one event changed everything. Flash forward to when they’re thirty years old and Sam returns to the beach with her fiancé Jack to check out wedding venues. You guessed it…Wyatt just happens to be visiting at the same time. Reconnecting with Wyatt makes Sam reevaluate everything about her life as she relives those teenage summer memories.

This was a quick read that I enjoyed but probably won’t really remember. It was well written and I liked the characters but the storyline just seemed too cliche. It didn’t seem to have the same zing as Nora did. It would still make for a great beach read if you’re looking for something light and fun. This hardly had any language but then she would throw in a random f bomb here and there (why?🤷🏼‍♀️), mild steam.

Sam and Wyatt had a terrible breakup as teens. Sam's avoided her favorite place since, her family's beach house. She only stays a few days a year and refuses to stay for a longer duration. She's also refused to bring her fiancé, Jack along, until now. But Wyatt unexpectedly shows up and Sam isn't sure she can handle the situation.

If you are looking for a great summer read then look no further. Same Time Next Summer is the perfect second chance romance that would be great to take to the beach or lounging next to the pool!

This book perfectly captures the feel of that first love, summers at the beach, first heartbreak and what it means to stand up for what you really want out of life.

I loved Sam and Wyatt❤️. Their chemistry was undeniable but it was grounded in a true friendship that was wonderful to see play out. And let’s talk about the setting! I loved the summer vibes, days at the beach and the small town atmosphere.

This will definitely be one of my favorites of the summer!

If you find yourself in search of a light romance for vacation give Annabel Monaghan's books a try. Her latest has a flawed main character who is a little problematic. The main focus of the book is Samantha's return to her family's lake house with her fiancée in tow to scope out a possible wedding venue on Long Island. Of course, it wouldn't be a romance without the long-lost love living next door. Monaghan does a good job building the tension between the two guys and Samantha and there is a good amount of humor mixed in to keep it light. I could relate to the feeling of nostalgia when she returns to her childhood escape and the memories she had with her first love, Wyatt. There was a "will they or won't they" vibe as she navigated the feelings his return brought back into the mix. It's got both the teenage love story and the adult romance for all readers' preferences. I think I liked Nora Goes Off Script just a tiny bit more, but this book is pretty good.

Same Time Next Summer was a really cute read, but I didn’t think there was anything too special about it. It was cute and entertaining but I don’t think it’s a book that will stay in my memory for too long. Thank you netgalley for my free review copy.

☀️THE summer read you NEED!☀️

Same Time Next Summer by @annabelmonaghan was EVERYTHING! Just like Nora Goes Off Script, I could not put this down! Totally compulsive read. I was a little nervous going into this because I held Nora on a pedal stool, but this did not disappoint. It gave me major Every Summer After vibes, so I definitely recommend for anyone who enjoyed that one. Annabel Monaghan has officially claimed a spot as a go-to author for me!

I’m a sucker for second chance romance and first love stories. I also loved that this was closed door and very little language. Definitely recommend!

Thank you @putnambooks for my #gifted copy!

#meetmeinthestacks