Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Play the Fool was a fun mystery full of quirky characters! The tarot cards added a unique aspect to the story. I didn’t love the romance plot, but I liked Katie even though she frustrated me at times. Overall, this was an entertaining book!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a delight read! Play the Fool follows tarot-reader-extraordinaire Katie True as she accidentally finds herself in the middle of a murder investigation. There’s some history of family tumult she sifts through, and the neurodivergent rep was both implicit and called out by name yet so obvious to anyone who’s neurospicy or loves a neurospicy person. It was actually kind of genius; Chern was basically talking to those ND readers and giving us a nod, telling us our realities are valid and relatable and “normal” and don’t even need to be pathologized or diagnosed or labeled because it’s just as normal and acceptable as can be to have a neurospicy brain. I ADORED this element of Play the Fool!

I also loved the crime-solving element. I will say, every once in a while I got a little lost in all of the sub-plots that every once in a while felt extraneous. And, to be honest, I saw the ending coming after one sentence in the first maybe quarter of the book. But that didn’t really bum me out, because it felt like I, too, got to put together pieces of the puzzle. It felt good to get it at least somewhat right! And it felt good to follow Katie’s journey. Katie’s brother, Owen, is, I would say, autistic, and Katie is definitely reading ADHD, with her penchant for side quests and loathing of doing monotonous routine things. I loved the way she honored her authentic self and didn’t give into familial pressures just because it would have looked good on the outside. As a ND person and mama to ND kiddos, I respected this representation and piece of the storyline SO much.

It’s hard to write good ND rep, and Chern really did a great job! This is a fun, twisty murder mystery with a little hint of romance. I’m so glad I got to read this e-arc! Thanks so much to the publisher and NetGalley. Can’t wait to read more Lina Chern!

Was this review helpful?

A cute, cozy mystery with a quirky cast of characters! Katie True is a tarot card reader stuck at a dead end job when she gets caught up in a murder mystery after seeing a picture of her friend’s body. Yes, some parts were a little unrealistic but I think if you just go with the flow you will enjoy it too. The one issue I had is that there was a lot of time spent on discussing how Katie is suck at a dead-end job, has no ambition, etc and there was not a lot of time spent on development of her character other than opportunities being dropped in her lap at the end of the story. I don’t feel like she changed at all! That being said, I found the story overall enjoyable and am glad I picked it up!

Was this review helpful?

Katie True feels is a little lost and is floundering through life, working at the mall at a job she doesn't enjoy. There she meets Marley, a woman who seems to have everything together and they form a friendship bond. Soon though, a stranger walks into Katie's place of employment and after sneaking a glance at his phone Katie learns that Marley is dead. She has been shot. But I digress, why was Katie looking at this man's phone? She is a tarot card reader and she wanted more information on the man so he would believe her reading, because she doesn't believe in herself. But Marley believed in her, so Katie takes this information about Marley's death to the cops. Determined to find Marley's killer she doesn't just leave the truth finding to the cops but instead searches for the facts herself, and this lands her in big trouble. If you are a fan of the Stephanie Plum books by Janet Evanovich I think you will really enjoy Katie's quest to find Marley's killer. Katie's tarot reading skills pops up regularly throughout the book and I found this to be a very clever way to sprinkle insight. If you are not familiar with the tarot do not let this stop you from enjoying the book as Lina Chern does a good job at describing the cards and their meaning. While I found the investigation to be a little unbelievable, I thoroughly enjoyed the story and Katie's growth journey. 3-1/2 stars rounded up to 4.

Thank you NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for my copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A fresh, witty mystery featuring a snarky tarot reader-turned-amateur detective. It's funny, fast-paced, and full of heart. A delightful twist on classic mysteries.

Was this review helpful?

3 stars- Good, not great. Wish the plot was more fleshed out. thanks netgalley & the publisher for the arc in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

I loved the tarot aspect of this. I love reading tarot! However to do feel thw story could have been a little more fleshed out.

Was this review helpful?

This was a good read! I loved the Tarot card aspect i just felt like at some point it did start to rush and feel like complete so I wish it felt smoother and flowed better. The first part of the book was great!

Was this review helpful?

I have received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

“People have no idea, sometimes, why they do things. If they knew, they wouldn’t get stuck doing the same things over and over.”


Play the Fool seemed like it would be a pretty interesting book. I'll admit that I don't know much about tarot cards, meaning absolutely nothing, so I was kind of intrigued to see where this would go. After meeting Katie, I just had a feeling I was going to like this girl. She was entertaining, and I wanted to know more about her connection to her cards.

Then, about halfway (ish) into the book, I just sort of stopped caring about what was going on. I wasn't really connecting to the storyline or the characters anymore. The romance fell flat for me, but maybe the sequel in this series will make me interested. The mystery, police, drama, and the overall case just had me rolling my eyes. This might be a "me" problem, though, and not necessarily the book.

In the end, I was intrigued before starting it. Then after, I just kind of felt okay. It had cute moments.

Was this review helpful?

Katie is a mess of a character, but she knows she’s a mess and can grow. There are parts where she makes a wise decision but then makes a stupid decision not long after. She beats herself up over the consequences of her stupidity because she can’t get away with anything. I couldn’t help but cheer for her to make better decisions. Her growing relationship with Jamie is sweet. All the supporting characters are interesting, and Jamie is one of them. His backstory and patience with Katie made me like him as a romantic partner for Katie. The mystery is intriguing, but the suspects were a little too stereotypical bad guys.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for this ARC!

First let me say that I LOVE this cover, very attention grabbing and mainly the reason I requested this book. I went into Play The Fool blind and unfortunately I didn’t love it.

I think it started off very interesting but the plot seemed to move too fast in the first 25% and then by 50% I was left feeling lost. The twist totally threw me for a loop and I had trouble connecting with the characters.

All and all, this book did make me chuckle a few times and it was definitely a cozy mystery!

Was this review helpful?

I was not invested in any of the characters. Katie and the others fell flat for me; I just kept reading for the storyline. And even that didn't redeem the novel in my eyes.

Thank you, Netgalley, for the opportunity to read this novel in exchange for a free and unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a cute cozy mystery. Katie is a very amateur sleuth/ fortune teller who gets into a lot of messes trying to solve her friend’s murder. I figured out the ending but still had an enjoyable time reading the

Was this review helpful?

Play the Fool is a fun and interesting murder mystery novel about Katie True, a young woman whose workplace friend ends up dead and Katie decides it’s up to her to figure out what happened.. Katie reads tarot cards and in the midst of trying to really get the knowledge on this beat up looking man, she discovers her friend is dead and sets out on a mission to uncover the truth about what happened. She ends up deep diving and getting involved with a crime family and learning her friend may not have been who she thought she was.

I enjoyed the beginning of the book a lot. It was different. You don’t get too many tarot card readers in novels. The little romance plot was also cute and kept me interested. I wish we could have gotten more tarot card readings or something more with that in the book instead of her just “seeing” the cards flash in her mind every time she was in a situation. I also wish we got a little more romance and feelings out there for the romance side of things. But all in all it was a decent book and kept me reading till the end. It just didn’t have me on the edge of my seat and while I didn’t expect the ending, it still kind of fell flat for me.

I want to thank NetGalley and Penguin Random House for the this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Lina Chern's Play the Fool stands out in the young adult genre with its unique blend of humor, heart, and a profound exploration of identity through the lens of the performing arts. This novel captures the essence of adolescence in a way that feels both refreshing and relatable, making it a must-read for anyone navigating the complexities of growing up.

The story follows a young protagonist who finds solace and self-discovery in the vibrant world of theater. As she grapples with the pressures of fitting in and the desire to pursue her passions, readers embark on a journey that highlights the transformative power of creativity. Chern's portrayal of the performing arts as a sanctuary is particularly compelling, showcasing how art can serve as both an escape and a means of confronting one’s true self.

One of the book's strengths lies in its vibrant character development. The protagonist is multi-dimensional, with relatable insecurities and aspirations that resonate deeply with readers. Chern skillfully crafts a supporting cast that adds richness to the narrative, exploring the dynamics of friendship, loyalty, and the challenges that accompany the pursuit of one’s dreams. The relationships are nuanced, reflecting the highs and lows of teenage life without succumbing to cliché.

Chern’s writing is engaging and accessible, balancing humor with poignancy. The pacing is well-structured, allowing for moments of introspection alongside lively scenes that keep the reader invested. The author’s ability to weave in themes of self-acceptance and the importance of community makes the story not only entertaining but also meaningful.

However, while the novel excels in character development and thematic depth, some readers may find certain plot points predictable. The journey of self-discovery is a familiar trope in young adult literature, and although Chern infuses her voice into the narrative, some moments may feel reminiscent of other stories in the genre.

Play the Fool is a delightful and thought-provoking read that encourages readers to embrace their individuality and pursue their passions. Lina Chern has crafted a story that resonates with the challenges of adolescence while celebrating the power of creativity. This book is perfect for young adults and anyone who appreciates a heartfelt exploration of identity and friendship. If you’re seeking a novel that balances humor with emotional depth, Play the Fool is certainly worth picking up.

Was this review helpful?

Centered around a fairly niche activity such as tarot card reading is definitely an attention grabber. However, this book started out well but ended quite flat. The mystery and tie in to the story was a little confusing, but overall not a bad book.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for providing the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

So this book... I really really liked it in the beginning, but towards the end... I was not.

The beginning with the main character was entertaining, a struggling palm reader that gets a client that may have murdered his girl friend... who she's .... SO EXCITING.. But the twist was soooooooo meh and the main character's whining got so out of hand.

By 50% of the book, I was sort of bored. I just wanted to find out what happened and be done and when I finally did. I was sort of disappointed.

Overall, interesting concept, but the author sort of tripped on the conflict resolution and ending....

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Lina Chern, Bantam, and NetGalley for an eARC of Play the Fool!

Play the fool is a fun, murder mystery with an interesting cast of characters. The book follows Katie, a tarot card reader, as she tries to solve the murder of her best friend, Marley. Katie gets close to a police officer and soon they are sharing information and getting into all sorts of hijinks.

The characters are flawed but likeable and I definitely found myself rooting even for some of the "bad guys". I had a few laugh out loud moments and also a few moments that nearly brought me to tears. Some of the situations involving family and friendships were incredibly relatable.

This book is fast paced and I got through it in just a couple days. I found that I wanted to keep reading, not just to find out about what happened to Marley, but also to see how Katie would proceed with her investigation and what boundaries she would push.

Overall I really enjoyed this book and would give it 4 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Play the Fool by Lina Chern. Pub Date: March 28, 2023. Rating: 3 stars. With a storyline around tarot card reading, this novel takes the main character Katie and turns her world upside down when she thinks her friend Marley is dead following a reading. This novel is a race to figure out how and why this happened. She is an amateur sleuth who makes mistakes along the way, but overall the pace of the story flowed well. I would not call this a cozy mystery, but it does have some elements of cozy in it. All of the characters in the story were fun and fresh which helped with story building. I think this book is perfect if you are looking for a palate cleanser that packs a little bit of punch. Thanks to #netgalley and #randomhousepublishinggroup for this e-arc in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Man I really tore through this one. It's surprising because I thought it started off pretty bumpy. In the first 10%, I was thinking, "Ugh. This seems like it's gonna be a slog to get through." Well I'm happy to report that I was absolutely wrong!

I'm not sure what it was, but the mystery totally hooked me. I only started suspecting what happened about 75% in and I actually liked suspecting it, because it pushed me to get the reveal quicker to see if I was right.

I also love to see some neurodiversity rep in the books I read so I loved that I had no clue going in that she would have an autistic brother. Not only that, but a fully capable autistic brother who is accepted just as he is. She doesn't ever make up excuses for him or acts embarrassed of him. (I also think she was coded as ADHD without overly implying it.) Their relationship was lovely and it was really sweet that he kind of saw her place as a safe haven where he could just be himself.

As for the mystery - it definitely had several red herrings that got me. But I enjoyed that they tricked me! Showed me that this book had something else up its sleeve that I wasn't seeing yet. It was a good time, a fun ride, and I think it's a really positive start for a debut author.

Was this review helpful?