In the Whimbrel House Series, Charlie Holmberg creatively melds historical fiction, magic and the real world. I enjoyed this sequel even more than the first book. The characters developed significantly and felt less stiff. The plot was whimsical and sweet.

Thank you to Net Galley and 47 North for this ARC.

Thank you Charlie N. Holmberg, 47North and NetGalley for allowing me to read this ARC e-book. This is book 2 in the Whimbrel House series, that said I read this book as a stand alone and while I always recommend reading books in a series in order I had no problem catching up and understanding the story without having read the first. Merritt Fernsby has inherited the estate and despite Hulda Larkin (the house tamer) calming the house something is still going on within the estate. This book includes multiperson perspectives and I love how the story was told. It was a great magical/fantasy type read and I'm off to read the first one while hoping this wont be the end of the series.

Thank you NetGalley and 47North for the Arc. I leave my honest review here!

This is the second book of Whimbrel House series. I really love the first book and so excited when I know there is the second one! I really wish to see more Merrit and Hulda development with their relationship. But honestly, for me this book is not as good as the first one.

After epic problem with another powerful wizard in the first book, I can’t compare the problem here with the first one. We get another wizard who wants to be like Silas but I didn’t think it delivered well. At first we focused on how Merrit suddenly got magic in him, alongside with what happen in BIKER, we will see how Merrit try to face his past and learn his magic. And I lost all the found family aspect here. Despite we got Owein as a dog now, I’m not really happy to see their development as family. With Merrit struggling with his new magic, everything is different in Whimbrel House.

The relationship between Hulda and Merrit is not really that good at first. Mostly because of Hulda who always so stiff and didn’t know what to do with her professionalism or her relationship with Merrit. I annoyed with her at first and pity Merrit who always honest with his feeling. Fortunately, Hulda trying to change for better. She become more concerned with Merrit and help him with his problem. But, I still don’t really like how Hulda kind of “obsessed” with Myra after what happen in the first book.

Nothing really special with the conflict and it end well. I think the second book is not necessary to read. If you read the first book and want to stop it doesn’t matter. Because the conflict at first book clearly finish and leave no cliffhanger. And with the ending of this book I think there will be more story from Whimbrel House. But, I’m not really sure whether I want to continue it or not.

I give this book 3 ⭐! I really recommend the first book and if you want to continue seeing Merrit and Hulda, I still recommend to read this one!

Enchanting, as always. A definite easy read for me! This book brought me back into the world of the series without the lengthy exposition of the first, getting back into the drama quickly.

Watch out for this author, everyone. :)

This author continues to impress me, so much so, I'm rushing for her next book! Charlie Holmberg has a way of blending adventure with a sweet romance without losing interest or slowing down a book. I love the way the characters interact, building the relationship and friendship alongside the main storyline, and how she weaves this whole new universe where magic is normal, but not so far from our own lives that we get lost. She is the perfect author to curl up with on a snowy day, but just as good to read on a beach chair in the sun. I have yet to be disappointed by one of her books, and I've read over 6 now!

Keeper of Enchanted Rooms was a recent favorite read, with a fun and creative setting that stuck in my mind for a long time. What a treat to return again to Holmberg's reimagined Rhode Island of the mid 1800s, where boats and other vehicles are powered by magic. The soul of a young boy that was trapped in the walls of Whimbrel House in the first book is now in a dog and makes for some amusing antics, while also tying the household together emotionally. What started as a supposedly haunted house is now a home for an unconventional family that is still learning about themselves and where they fit in the world. While many authors do a fine job of world-building, Holmberg always injects hers with a little something extra, which in this case I can only think of as being 'homey charm.' Thanks to Netgalley and 47North for this engaging ARC.

Actual Rating: 3.5⭐

Heir of Uncertain Magic is the sequel to Keeper of Enchanted Rooms, as soon as I was finished with the first book I immediately start to read the sequel.
I was very excited to read this book, sadly some things are not what I expected.

Let’s talk about the good things first.
The writing style is the same as the first book which I really like, the POV also has a new addition – Owein, in a body of a dog. His POV is adorable and very interesting, I wish there’s more of his POV in this book.

Hulda and Merritt’s relationship is also developing in this book after confessing to each other their real feelings. However, I feel slightly frustrated sometimes with Hulda in their relationship.
I also like seeing how Merritt’s grow and break free from the past that has haunted him for many years. I feel happy for him to finally brave himself and accept his magic powers.

However, the vibes of this book feels different than the first book. This sequel doesn’t have the cozy, whimsical and found family aspect from the first book which is something that I miss.
The plot also has a slower pacing compare to the first book, the progress is slow and it feels a bit dragging at some points.

Overall, it’s still a pretty good story with a quite satisfying ending.
I’m looking forward to see where the story will go from here cause there’s still some questions that needed answers and a new problem might have been waiting for them ….

I received an advanced review copy for free through Netgalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Huge thank you to the publisher and the author!

Another great book from Charlie N. Holmberg. This is a very quick read (I read almost the entire book in one day). I loved returning to all the wonderful characters from the first book. There was a nice mix of emotional drama as well as the main plot. I loved learning more about the magic. I've heard it said that Holmberg's books can sometimes be hit or miss, but this one is definitely a hit! I can't wait to see what Hulda and Merritt do next!

This novel is the second in the Whimbrel House series; the first being The Keeper of Enchanted Rooms. The mischievous magic that upset the balance of Whimbrel House has been tamed by Hulda. But what does that mean for Merritt Fernsby? The romance, magic and intrigue continue in this 2nd book of the series.

*Thank you to NetGalley and 47North for his e-arc.*

Thank you to 47North and NetGalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This is the second book in the Whimbrel House series. This book takes place only about a week after the end of Keeper of Enchanted Rooms.

I loved this continuation of the story. I don’t want to give anything away in this review, in case you read it, but it was so good! It’s historical fantasy that takes place in 1846 New England. There’s magic, mystery, suspense, self discovery and reflection and growth, courting romance, quirky/fun/loving characters, and hilarious moments. I’m obsessed with Hulda and Merritt, and this story contains such a unique and fun magic system that I can’t get enough of! I highly recommend this series.

I am so excited that this series is supposed to be 6 books. Can’t wait to see what Charlie has cooked up for these characters in the next book!

Returning to the world of Keeper of Enchanted Rooms, we pick up where the previous story left off, diving back into the world of magic, and the desperate schemes of those who want to control it. Old questions are answered, new questions arise, and what is going to become of Heir of Uncertain Magic?

Ok, so the good stuff first. I love the world of everyday magic that's fading out and the pressure that adds to the characters trying to keep it alive. I love the nobility aspect and tracing heritage through the magic.

I super duper appreciate that the author took the magic system set up in the first book and expanded on it in a way that made sense, organically, throughout the story! SOOO many sequels seem to not do the follow up thing correctly. This aspect was a nail on the head for me. 10/10 well done. Give me more!!

The multiple protagonists are all genuinely likable people that charm with their sincere efforts. And each one feels like their own unique person. One in particular--I won't say who, but if you read the story, you'll know--I became extra attached to and became worried that might mean they might be headed for a tragic ending. I won't spoil things for you about what happens exactly, but their character arc was my favorite.

The romance is sweet, but turned up a notch in this book. Nothing explicit but some suggestive stuff--I didn't mind. lol

There were some dramatic twists I wasn't expecting and I had audible reactions to. The climax had an interesting logic behind it, and I SO appreciate a smart plot ending.

Okay, so the stuff I didn't like as much:

The antagonist seemed a little one-dimensional for me. I wish I could've gotten to know their drive just like we got to know Silas Hogwood in the previous story. I feel like I didn't fully know the WHY behind their schemes, and I like to know the why.

The story dragged a little here and rushed a little there for me. There were parts I thought could've been wrapped up in a quicker fashion, and there were other bits I wish were explored a little more. See above.

And that's it. Those are my likes and dislikes. Overall, a very enjoyable read, and I am SO looking forwards to (hopefully) more books in the world where we can get to know even MORE of the magic and unravel some more of the questions that this book brings up. Especially the HUGE one at the end! (NO, it's not a cliffhanger...just a big ol' tease) 4 stars.

Heir of Uncertain Magic picks up where Keeper of Enchanted Rooms left off. Merritt's newly discovered magic is having debilitating effects on him. Myra has disappeared, leaving Hulda in a tough spot with BIKER. And Owein is now a dog instead of an enchanted house. An unenchanted house has no need of BIKER.

This is a great ending to the duology. Merritt has to confront his past instead of burying it inside, a lesson we could all learn. Hulda has to accept she is worthy of love, another great lesson. Other themes include sacrifice, betrayal, and facing fears.

I enjoyed this book and would recommend it to everyone.

Whimbrel House is becoming a favorite, like the other Charlie N. Holmberg's series I read. This is an excellent addition: a compelling story with a well plotted world buidling and great characters.
The author is an excellent storyteller and never disappoints.
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this arc, all opinions are mine

It’s been three months since I read “Keeper of Enchanted Rooms” and I had so missed these characters and the many different types of magic in their world.

Merritt and his former housekeeper, Helda, continue to grow their feelings for each other, although Helda is still reserved and at times unsure of how to proceed. Her friend and former boss, Myra, has left BIKER a mess and the magical institute now finds itself under investigation and in search of a new director.

While no longer dealing to manage an enchanted home, Merritt is struggling to decipher the magical powers he recently became aware of and learn more about his genealogical background.

Through these challenges, Merritt and Helda continue to care for their friends living at Whimbrel House. My favorite character in this book was Owein, formerly a young boy now turned into a loving mutt, who can communicate with Merritt. He was curious about the world, unconditionally loyal, and I could really feel his love and care for others, especially Merritt.

Charlie Holmberg’s follow up “Heir of Uncertain Magic” did not disappoint and although I liked it slightly less than the first book I am really hoping more in the series are coming! The writing is beautiful, the setting truly imaginative, and the characters intricately developed to the point that I miss them already.

Charlie N. Holmberg really is a lovely writer. This series has a similar vibe to the Spellbreaker duology. The old-timey, pearl-clutchy, spinsterish, or well on her way to it, MC is a particular favourite of mine. She does the plain Jane character well. There's no suddenly taking off the glasses and becoming some stereotypical stunner. The love interest finds her attractive because attraction is highly subjective and relative. It's very sweet.

Charlie does romance without any raunch, but I didn't feel like I was missing anything. The plot is good, the characters are dynamic and interesting, and the magic system is fascinating. There are intriguing mysteries that keep you guessing

Hulda and Merritt are such a sweet couple, and they go through a lot in this book. Merritt in particular hits a lot of highs and lows. I sincerely hope this series continues, which is hinted at toward the end. I've grown quite fond of these characters, and I'd like to see where their adventure takes us next.

Oh, I do have a complaint. Charlie, you were pushing it with the Owein lifespan commentary. I gasped. I was like.. she wouldn't. Would she? She better not.

You better not.

One man is on a journey to unravel his magical lineage in the next spellbinding novel of the Whimbrel House series by Amazon Charts and Wall Street Journal bestselling author Charlie N. Holmberg.

This was an amazing sequel to Keeper Of Enchanted Rooms. There was so much packed I to this book and I loved every bit of it. Our two main characters both struggled with personal, emotional struggles that played out beautifully. I also love the subtle slow burn romance between the two. Then at its heart is a mystery that ultimately keeps you guessing til the end. @cnholmberg has done another excellent job with this second installment of Whimbrel House. Highly recommend for fantasy book lovers.

Thank you to @netgalley and 47 North Publishing for letting me preview this ARC.

This was a great follow-up to Keeper of Enchanted Rooms!

I am so lucky I've received both of these on @netgalley as I have loved them both!

I was so happy to dive back into this magical, historical world, with these endearing characters! I absolutely love the characters, the plot hooked me immediately (as it did in the first book), and the magical elements are included perfectly.

This was a wonderful follow-up and this is a duology I highly recommend for a magical, wonderful story with a captivating plot that will keep you turning the pages!

I received this Ebook A.R.C. of Heir of Uncertain Magic by Charlie N. Holmberg in exchange for my honest review. Thank you to NetGalley, 47North Publishing, Charlie N. Holmberg and all applicable parties for the opportunity to read and review this work.



**Trigger Warnings**
References to abandonment and neglect in familial circumstances, the occult and magic, and time periods where all parties did not receive equal rights.


This book picks up just weeks after the first installment, Keeper of Enchanted Rooms by Charlie N. Holmberg. When we last saw Merritt and Hulda, they had rescued Owein (now inhabiting the vessel of a cute little mutt) from the diabolical Silas Hogwood–and in doing so, killed him. Silas had been working with the head of the BIKER institute to enchant dwellings and homes for their organization as a way to keep the need for persons of magical pedigree–hence, Hulda and the other housekeepers and maids that tend to magical homes. From here we are introduced to the London branch. They’re sneaky and underhanded, looking for Silas Hogwod for reason beyond human comprehension, meanwhile Myra (the former head of BIKER–who resigned and vanished without a trace) is operating a secret facility meant to somehow extract magic from cadavers and placentas to be reintroduced to hosts as a way to preserve magical DNA.

My favorite thing about this book boils down to the author not making magic a bandaid for every minor inconvenience. We see this so often in fantasy novels these days, that it is beyond refreshing that Charlie keeps things more realistic and gives our protagonists limitations with their abilities. I.E. Hulda’s abilities regarding augury are often vague with major holes in the visions, and she is often remarking to Merritt that she can’t just “see” whatever the outcome is when she so desires. We’ve also seen Merritt struggling to understand and control his magic–it doesn’t just “click” so that he can save the day.


I am absolutely thrilled to have been able to read this A.R.C, and I adored every twist and turn. I love little doggy Owein and the entire family dynamic of Whimbrel House. If you're looking for a cozy little novel, with magical realism and a beautiful found family dynamic, I’d definitely recommend picking up this series by Charlie N. Holmberg. It’s absolutely 4 stars for me and I can’t wait to grab my physical copy this April!

I received an advanced readers copy of this book through net galley in exchange for my honest opinions.
Early this year I was on a quest for cozy fantasy books. So basically an easy read with no violence described in gory detail, no sex scenes and mild fantasy elements. Which lead me to the first book in this series. (Because my library did not yet have it available- I bought it and hoped not to be disappointed- and I wasn’t, I loved it and couldn’t wait for the second one to be out!)
I jumped at the chance to read the second one early when I saw it available. This one just as good as the first one. All my favorite characters returned especially Owein. We got to delve deeper into the back story of Merritt and also the inner workings of BIKER/LIKER.
I love how fiercely protective each character is over their little found family, and how each is able to use their gifts to help each other. I love the building romance, it’s just the right amount. And I think the mystery of Silas Hogwood and how it spreads out like a spider web just perfect.
I’m looking forward to more in this series!

Heir of Uncertain Magic by Charlie N. Holmberg follows in the footsteps of its predecessor, Keeper of Enchanted Rooms. Merritt Fernsby knows now that he has magic--actually fairly powerful magic, and a good deal of it given the dilution of magic through the years and the fact his family wasn't actively marrying to cultivate it--and is now grappling with both it and the fallout from learning that being a bastard is the entire reason he was disowned and cast out. Hulda Larkin, temporary housekeeper turned friend turned romantic partner, is seeking to understand why her former boss Myra Haigh has fled and no one can find her while simultaneously trying to fend off adversaries from overtaking BIKER--her workplace.

This book is a very different beast than the first one, given that most of the setting involved the enchanted house, which is now a regular house but with a wizardy dog instead. It also involves the mystery of Myra's actions and whereabouts, which may be a little tougher to get into given that readers only had vague contact with her in the first book and a goodly portion of it was unpleasant because of her role in Silas Hogwood's presence and threat.

I understand why people might not love it as much as the first; the trajectory has changed and the world is expanding beyond the house and its island, with the hint of a third book and the implication that it may spread even further, possibly to another country. It was a little slower to get involved on my end, but the pages began to fall away for me by the middle or last third of it. Merritt and Hulda's relationship is so sweet, too, and I enjoy his teasing and cheek with her while still being careful and gentle seeing as she's never entertained a man. I didn't love it as well as the first myself, but I'd still do 3.5 and round up, as it's worth it.

I received a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.