Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The Quiet Tenant is a propulsive story told from the voices of three women, “the girl in the shed,” Emily, and Cecilia. This novel is slow in revealing its clues and details, and I think that’s why some don’t like it. It’s a novel that asks what you would do if you were her?

Was this review helpful?

What a great, suspenseful book! I loved this one through and through. Captivating plot, characters you root for, and a cunning villain. Loved it!

Was this review helpful?

Her name is Rachel. Except it isn’t. She has been forced to assume the name and identity of a person she isn’t for the last 5 years as she has been held prisoner in a shed. She doesn’t understand why he hasn’t killed her. She knows he has killed before. She also knows he will do it again. She will do whatever it takes to stay alive. There are rules. She just must follow them.

This was super different than most other serial killer books. Told from the perspectives of the girl kept in the shed, the killer, the other victims, the potential victim/girlfriend and the killers daughter…it is a wild ride. I appreciated each of the perspectives and they were all woven together very well. I am left with some unanswered questions, but overall this was a solid read!

Was this review helpful?

A slow-paced thriller. I have to say, I usually like my thrillers to be a bit tenser and faster but this was a nice change of pace for me.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this book. I listened to the audiobook and I was hooked from the beginning. I think I held my breath for the entire ending. I don't remember ever reading a book that had me biting my nails before.

Was this review helpful?

This book wasn't that great. I kept waiting for a twist, or something big to happen, but it just never did. It wasn't awful, just a bit slow for my taste.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you @AAKnopf for the free book! #aaknopfpartner
Ok, I am usually not interested in serial killer books but The Quiet Tenant was fantastic! This one is different. It’s told from the victim’s point of view, the one who is still alive. Rachel has been held prisoner inside a shed for 5 years. Her captor, Aiden, has a teenage daughter and is a beloved member of the community. No one suspects him, not even his new girlfriend.

I think the reason I liked this one is because it reads like a literary fiction novel. We know he’s a bad guy who does bad things but we don’t get graphic details. It’s more suspenseful than scary. It doesn’t have the shock factor of a thriller, reads more like psychological suspense. We really get into the head of this woman who has been locked away from everything for years, and what that does to a person. And her desire to survive.

I really enjoyed this one, couldn’t put it down.

Was this review helpful?

We are following 3 different character perspectives of women who all know a serial killer. His daughter, a woman falling in love with him, and the woman he didn't kill. With these three perspectives, we are able to see how serial killers can live seemingly "normal" lives and how charming and manipulative they are.

I was very excited about the description of this book. Seeing things through three different lenses could really expand on the psychological terror of a serial killer. During the first 1/4 of the book, I kept that excited feeling, but as the book went on, I lost it. The first thing that I wasn't able to connect with was the 2nd person perspectives. It just didn't add anything to the story for me. I also did not enjoy the clipped style of writing. It's hard for me to get invested when I'm reading something that has short, simple sentences.

I did enjoy some of the reflective moments the woman he did not kill had through the book, but I wasn't expecting that this would be something that would seem to be the main focus. I expected creepy, unsettling, and scary. It felt like it dragged sometimes. I felt like I was reading it to get to the good part, but never got there. It had moments that made me want to turn pages, but overall, I felt it fell flat for what I expected.

I would like to thank Net Galley and Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor for allowing me to read and review this novel.

Was this review helpful?

what a fantastic debut from Michallon! she fully immerses you in the mind of a kidnapped woman who has been held captive for 5 years - it can be a difficult read but I was so enthralled all the way through. if you were thrilled by the opening chapter of Local Woman Missing, or enjoyed the concept of Girl A but were ultimately bored by it; The Quiet Tenant might just be up your alley.

Was this review helpful?

I’m not sure what it was but I just did not like this book. The characters didn’t seem fleshed out. Most gripping at the end but too little too late.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for letting me read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

The Quiet Tenant will leave you wondering if you ever really know people in your community..Aidan Thomas is a respected husband and father living in a small town in New York State. When Aidan's wife gets cancer and dies, his life and that of his daughter changes forever. Aidan's new problem is the woman he's held captive in the shed in his backyard for the past 5 years as his in-laws want him and his daughter to move out of the house they own. They've never liked Aidan and want their house back now that their daughter is dead.

Aidan finds a new house to rent and leaves the old one behind. He decides to take his captive, Rachel, to the new house and introduce her as a friend who needs help. Aidan's daughter, Cecilia, doesn't really understand why this woman lives in their house but she comes to accept it. Aidan keeps Rachel handcuffed to the radiator during the day while he's at work and Cecilia is at school. He allows her to come down for dinner with strict instructions. Since Rachel has lived in a shed for 5 years this is a luxury that she wasn't sure she'd experience again. She's used to going to the bathroom in a bucket, bathing from a soapy bucket, and eating whatever leftovers Aidan could bring her without anyone noticing.

Rachel isn't Aidan's only victim. She's the lucky one that he didn't kill. Aidan has dark secrets that no one would ever guess. He's been following women, photographing them, and eventually killing them. Aidan keeps the photos and mementos in boxes in the basement. The basement door is always locked so that no one can see his treasures. Aidan stops by a local restaurant/bar a couple of times a week. He's attracted to the bartender, Emily, and she is attracted to him. They kiss one night and then start texting one another daily. Rachel and Cecilia notice how attentive Aidan has become to his phone while they're watching tv and movies after dinner. Rachel likes him distracted and hopes he will make a mistake that will allow her to escape.

Will Rachel ever escape and return to her real life and real name? Will Aidan finally be caught and brought to justice? What will happen to Cecilia? Will Emily figure out what Aidan really is? The Quiet Tenant is a book that will have you yelling at Rachel to run and escape multiple times. I rate The Quiet Tenant 4 stars as it's a very suspenseful read. I'd like to thank NetGalley and Knopf for an advanced copy of The Quiet Tenant in exchange for a fair review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was reminiscent of “Room” with a kidnapped victim who was being depicted while in captivity. I found it interesting although a little slow at times. This was a smart mystery, that was quite likeable. 3.5 stars ⭐️ rounded up.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book. "Pulse-pounding thriller", is an accurate description. It reminded me of the movie, "Room". "The Quiet Tenant" is a creepy book that will stay with you long after you read it. It was very creatively written and told through the alternating perspective of the women Aiden was involved with. I highly recommend it if you enjoy psychological thrillers.
I received thisI loved this book. "Pulse-pounding thriller", is an accurate description. It reminded me of the movie, "Room". "The Quiet Tenant" is a creepy book that will stay with you long after you read it. It was very creatively written and told through the alternating perspective of the women Aiden was involved with. I highly recommend it if you enjoy psychological thrillers.
I received this galley from Net Galley. galley from Net Galley.

Was this review helpful?

Get ready for the thrill of the year. Concise prose, nail biting plot, page turning chapters. Trust me when I say you won’t be able to put down this examination of a serial killer and the women in his life.

Aidan Thomas looks like the typical family man on the outside. He’s a recent widow with a teenage daughter, beloved in his town, but he’s harboring some deep secrets, one of which is a very quiet tenant.

It was timely that I read this one as they announced the arrest of the Gilgo beach murderer nearby where I live. They’ve been on the hunt for this serial killer for over ten years and finally made an arrest. To know he was a married man with a daughter was just as creepy as this book.

Was this review helpful?

I very much enjoyed reading this debut novel. It kept me guessing. I loved reading it from the different women’s perspectives.

At first, I thought it was going to be a lot like the book “Room”. However, that thought didn’t last long.

This book was fast paced and things changed quickly. I found it fascinating to see how Aiden was perceived differently by the different people in his life.

I would highly recommend this book to anyone who likes stories about serial killers and women who have perseverance and strength.

Thank you to NetGalley and Knopf Publishing for providing me an ARC of this book in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

It took a few chapters for this psychological thriller to grab me, but once it did, all hope was lost. This is an engrossing, terrifying read, and it felt just a little too believable, because the monster in this story is real. They exist out there, and sometimes it’s the one you would never suspect. The story grabs you and never lets go. The chapters are very short and most are written in the first person, which sometimes became confusing. I kept getting the main characters mixed up until some details were clarified. It’s nonstop suspense that at some points had me sitting at the edge of my seat without realizing it. Thank you very much to NetGalley and Knopf for the digital advanced reading copy I was provided. This read was definitely worth my time!

Was this review helpful?

I really, really enjoyed this book. This book is told from multiple characters viewpoints. It is a page turner that will have you strategizing, guessing, hoping and praying for the individuals involved in this crazy plot. The story is so outlandish to imagine happening in real life that it kind of messes with your brain. I highly recommend this book. So much in fact that I think I will reread it which I rarely do.

Was this review helpful?

I was hesitant to read this because I was concerned it would be too graphic but the author did a good job of creating a psychological suspense story without alienating readers. Well done.

Was this review helpful?

What a wonderful, fresh take on the serial killer suspense. Highly recommend. Thank you for the opportunity to review!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a wild ride! It was way outside my usual, following a woman who is kidnapped by a serial killer but has somehow managed to stay alive for the last 5 years. Disturbing and a little too real with the current serial killer in the news, but an interesting thriller.

Was this review helpful?