Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I think the story itself depicts the resilience of women, especially within a family - the closeness that can be attained and just threw the knowledge of things left unsaid. It was a very beautiful story. I really liked following the different stories.

Was this review helpful?

***3.5 Stars rounded Up to 4***

Mini Review...

One of my MOST highly anticipated reads of 2023 by one of my all time favorite authors, I could not wait to get my hands on a copy! and since I've always listened to Acevedo's books while reading along, I couldn't break tradition. If you haven't done so already, you should absolutely treat your ears to Acevedo's narrative style and join the many readers who simply adore this author's storytelling/voice. This is Acevedo's first adult fiction debut and we follow the six women of the Marte family in past + present timelines between Santo Domingo and New York City. Sisters Flor, Matilde, Pastora, and Camila have gathered to organize a living wake for Flor. The Oldest of the sisters has always had a close relationship with death, experiencing premonitions at a very young age that predicted which family members were close to passing. After watching a documentary of a man having a living wake with his loved ones present, Flor decided she would have one for herself. This story is slow paced as we get to know the sisters and some of their offspring, cousins Ona and Yadi also have chapters of their own as they navigate their mother/aunts live funeral. 

There's something comforting in reading one of Acevedo's books and I believe it's because family is always at their core. Also, as a Latina woman myself having grown up in a large family there is one universal truth and that is...everyone is deeply invested in everyone elses lives for better or worse. Matilde is dealing with a husband who is always having an affair and this time has taken his extra marital activities much further. Pastora is tired of seeing Matilde put up with her philandering husband and wants her to end her marriage. She's also trying to get to the bottom of the reasoning behind Flor's live wake. Camila is the youngest and most forgotten of the sisters and she's grown tired of that. Flor's daughter Ona is struggling with fertility issues and wanting more than anything to have a child with her husband. Pastora's daughter Yadi has her world rocked when her boyfriend from her teenage years returns after having been in prison for some years. 

I found some of these women's stories to be  more compelling than others but can appreciate what Acevedo set out to achieve. It was during the scenes that took place back in Santo Domingo where you can see where and why these ladies have unhealed generational trauma and wounds to heal. Although they're all deeply woven with one another, six lives to follow can get chaotic and sometimes I found myself getting lost. I felt some women were better developed than others and this led to some blending in of voices and difficulty keeping the story lines straight. Even though we Know Camila is sick of being the forgotten one, I still felt she pretty much was forgotten in this story which seemed like a missed opportunity. If you enjoy reading slower paced stories with a strong focus on family dynamics paired with a unique storytelling voice, you can't go wrong with Elizabeth Acevedo. 

Favorite POV's: Matilde and Yadi

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this, after loving Acevedo's other books so much, but this book dragged for me and I had to force myself to finish it. Too many characters, too many side plots, and not enough action to move forward. Also, the ending was not enough closure for me. I think I'll stick to Acevedo's YA from now on, because she does it masterfully.

Was this review helpful?

A slow read with a large cast of characters. Takes a bit to get into it, but I really enjoyed this book! So many great characters, and I generally love each of their storylines and where they go. Love the writing style.Thanks to netgalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review, sorry it took me so long to actually read it!

Was this review helpful?

I love this author so much. But for the life of me I could not get into this book. There were so many characters at times it was hard to keep up. In effort to give the book another shot I even tried listening to the audio but it never connected for me. I am giving this author grace because there were some parts I liked such as the powers that each woman in the family possessed but beyond that the story did not come together for me.

Was this review helpful?

Its always a blessing to be able to know all ones siblings and get through all of them and how their family evolved. Especially when there is such an anchor in the abilities that they shared. It was wonderfully written and there was beautiful prose.
My issue is that although the family has an anchor the book seems to somehow lack some grounding. The characters didn't quite grip me into the fold like I needed them to. And I have found that I am a character person, so although the plot is great, the characters need to move me.

Not saying that this is bad in any way, this is a really well written and will be enjoyed by many, but somehow fell flat for me. And thats ok. Elizabeth Acevedo has many other works that I truly have enjoyed, and I will continue to read her works.

Thank you to Netgalley and Ecco for an e-copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you @netgalley for the review copy of this book! Family Lore is Elizabeth Acevedo's first novel for adults! It tells the story of a family of women originally from the Dominican Republic- with the plot taking place both there, and in the larger NYC area. Each member of the family is going through their own self-discovery and reckoning, but the plot primarily hinges on one of the Marte sisters, Flor, organizing a living wake for herself. Through the last-minute planning of this living wake, and through to the event itself, we learn more about each of the Marte sisters (Flor, Matilde, Pastora, and Camila), their special "gifts" (aka a little dopple of magical realism), and the modern struggles of the two daughters in the family, cousins Ona and Yadi. As many families are, they are too mixed up in each other's business, especially when it comes to each other's love lives, but their nosiness is out of love and the desire to protect. We loved the weaving of this story together through the perspectives of the various family members, and the slow revelations that emerged from this way of telling the story. The cultural aspects of this book, even despite some of the less-than-savory machismo experienced back in the Dominican, make this a great read for #nationalhispanicheritagemonth!

Was this review helpful?

Such a magnificent work of art! Acevedo just has a way with words and hearing the audiobook in her actual voice just made it even better. At first I did find the multiple POVs a little daunting but once I referred to the family tree a couple of times, I was fully in it! This family’s stories were woven together so beautifully. I wanted to adopt a tía or two as my own but they all had something to teach us. I read this weeks ago and I can’t stop thinking about it!

Was this review helpful?

I was kindly sent the arc before pub date but was not able to read it before then. I then received the audio from Libby and I loved how Elizabeth Acevedo narrated her own book. This is a genre outside of what we know to be of Acevedo’s work. I enjoyed the step outside the genre but at times I felt disconnected from the story. Acevedo always wrote a story that is beautifully told and vivid to imagine. I also suggest reading and listening to the story for a better experience. I did enjoy the story but like I said I felt disconnected at times (I blame my mood reading)

Was this review helpful?

I unfortunately couldn't really get into this book and ended up DNF-ing around halfway through. I thought it was well-written and I liked the concept of tying family members together in these different timelines, but it ultimately unfortunately was not for me.

Giving it 3 stars because I don't want to give a book 1 star that I didn't actually end up finishing.

Was this review helpful?

I love Elizabeth Acevedo's writing and her characters are so deeply memorable. This was an admirable effort for a first step into Adult fiction. I do think that writing for a young adult audience is her strength and this didn't quite live up to her previous novels for me. I look forward to reading anything she writes next.

Was this review helpful?

I ADORE Elizabeth Acevedo but… I have veryyyyy complicated feelings about this one. While I enjoyed the aspects of sisterhood & family, I sometimes found myself not as invested as I wanted to be with these characters. Again, love Acevedo but I’m not sure I loved this one as much as her other novels. It would probably really work for some people but unfortunately I am not one of them

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge fan of Elizabeth Acevedo's ya stories, but her newest adult novel just did not sit the same with me. There were so many characters, POV, and time changes that I struggled to keep everything together. Additionally, some of the characters seemed to have random, meant to be shocking?, powers or histories that I couldn't line up with the story line; the storyline seemed to be more hearing the backgrounds and troubles of various characters rather than any kind of plot. If you are more of a character-driven fan, I am sure you will enjoy this story more than me.

Was this review helpful?

Fun, heartwarming, unique, and magical. Acevedo creates magical realism that rugs at your heart strings and makes you want to call your family members more. The ending was everything and more, and the characters jumped off the page (every page). Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Family Lore by Elizabeth Acevedo

A great family saga filled with unique characters and situations, plus a little magical realism thrown in.

I liked the connectivity between different members of the family, how they saw themselves and each other.

Thanks to @netgalley and @eccobooks for this advanced copy!

#BookReview #Bookstagram #ElizabethAcevedo #FamilyLore #EccoBooks #BookishLife #Reading #Bibliophile #BookPhotography #BookRecommendations #InstaBooks #BookNerd #FamilySaga #MagicalRealism #LatinaCharacters

Was this review helpful?

Family Lore was such a pleasant surprise for me! I typically really struggle with magical realism, but this was such a fantastic take on the genre. The cast of characters in this generational drama was VAST, but I thought Acevedo did a phenomenal job delving into their respective lives, and I was truly invested in all of their stories. The only thing that didn't quite work for me was the resolution. There was so much build up to those final chapters, and I felt like the end was just a little anticlimactic. It had so much potential to be truly powerful and heartwrenching, and it just didn't quite get there for me. This was my first book by the author, and I'm looking forward to reading Acevedo's other works. Thank you to NetGalley and HarperCollins for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Genre: Magical Realism/Contemporary

Format: Audio

4🌟 - I liked it!

Thank you @eccobooks for the #gifted copy and @librofm for the complimentary audio!

A story of multigenerational women, a touch of magic, and woven with culture paired with poetic prose. I loved reading @acevedowrites adult debut, and thought the audio was done well!

Stories of women, motherhood, and sisterhood are always so meaningful and impactful, and I loved reading it through the lens of a Latinx author.

Such a strong family saga that fans of Acevedo will enjoy and be surprised by her adult book in the best kind of way 💙

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautifully written book about family, love and loss. Heartbreaking in some sections but these brave women will make you cheer for them during the good times, cry during the hard times and be ready to fight during the mad times! Elizabeth Acevedo brought all of the magic from her YA writing to her first adult fiction book. I hope there's more where this one came from!

Was this review helpful?

Having been raised with three sisters living next door to my grandparents, I definitely related to this multi-generational female-driven book. It’s covers themes of family, sisterly bonds, secrets, and history. I am a big fan of these types of books. The book is told from multiple POVs and across different timelines. Between that and the frequency Spanish, it can be difficult to keep up with who is saying what, but the overall tone and premise of the book were enjoyable. I fell in love with the characters and truly wished for them to get all they were hoping for.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't hate this book but I didn't love it either. Hence the 2 stars. The premise was interesting but the writing seemed disjointed in a lot of places so it was hard to follow. Also scattered throughout were sentences written in Spanish that I did not understand so I feel I lost part of the story by not knowing Spanish.

Was this review helpful?