Cover Image: Magic Has No Borders

Magic Has No Borders

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

4.5 stars

Reading this book felt like a hug to me. A number of diverse voices went into the making of this book—my favourite part was how the book was a love letter to South Asians. That it was not a book for all, but for a very specific audience in mind. I have quite a complicated relationship with anthologies, usually reading them for the one or two authors contributing, and rarely for the idea. But this was different, I was hooked through every story, and all of them were equally enjoyable to breeze through!

Thank you NetGalley and HarperCollins Children's Books, for presenting me with an ARC of this book in exchange for a honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great introduction to the myths of this region. I really enjoyed diving into them and learning more about all of these cultures.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and HarperTeen for providing me with an eARC of this book to read and review.
I love short stories. I also love magic. I'm happy I requested this one.
Mostly I love how I learned a bit about lore from other cultures. It was full of South Asian magic
Each story was a short fast read. And each one was unique.
I'm glad I was able to read this one as it was fun and fast.
Would definitely recommend to anyone who loves a little magic!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a review copy of this book.

I love seeing anthologies like this that focus on people from one area of the world. We need more diverse anthologies like this.

Most of the stories I really liked, but some I was just not a fan of. I like that some of the stories have an author's note after that explains a bit about the source inspiration.

Was this review helpful?

This is amazing! I was able to read the first few excerpts before having to go back to reality, and I have some author backlist's to read! Such a great way to introduce myself to new authors. I definitely can't wait to read even more from them!

Was this review helpful?

This is a lovely collection of retellings & reinterpretation, and was such fun to read.

"Read MAGIC HAS NO BORDERS a Collection of Magical South Asian Tales, edited by Samira Ahmed & Sona Charaipotra, if you love: short stories, myths, legends, diverse voices, reincarnation, retellings, gods, heros, villains, defining yourself, representation, twists, turns & love."

Was this review helpful?

Magic Has No Borders is an amazing anthology and collection of short stories by publishing's top South Asian authors. I loved how all the stories featured in this anthology covered all corners of South Asian mythology, ranging from stories with romance and heartbreak, to stories about family and friendship, to stories about life lessons and self-discovery. So many myths and legends get lost in the South Asian community, so I greatly appreciate Samira Ahmed and Sona Charaipotra for arranging this anthology to keep the stories of our culture and religions alive!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for giving me an ARC in exchange for an honest review. 3.2 stars

Kiss Me Goodbye by Tracey Baptiste: 2 stars-
The concept of gods and hosts was interesting, but I felt confused for some of the story. I didn’t like the school setting, but I usually never do. I was confused in the end on why it was implied that Ronnie liked Jay and Kala when she showed no interest in the beginning that I saw. I thought only Jay and Kala liked each other, but then Ronnie came along, seemingly out of nowhere. The ending with the gods was the best part.

Chudail by Nikita Gill: 4 stars-
This was a good story. I loved that the main character is a reader. I like that the Chudail was something that everyone believed in; usually creatures (or in this case the woman as the story describes her) aren’t believed to be real, so this was a nice surprise. I loved the history of the town. The story the grandmother told was interesting. I was confused about why the sacrifice changed things in the end.

A Goddess of Fire and Blood by Tanaz Bhathena: 3 stars-
I liked that this story centered around a prophecy, magic, and gods. This story is really sad because of the characters being locked up and mistreated. The ending was good.

Infinite Drift by Olivia Chadha: 3 stars-
This story was interesting. The fact that Archana had her memory of her death wiped by people called Drift Riders before the story even began was cool. I liked the world, but wished there was more of a backstory. I also liked that the point of the story was that Archana was on a mission. I felt a little confused in the end though, but I appreciated the context of the authors note.

Dismantle the Sun by Sangu Mandanna: 4 stars-
This story was really good. I liked that Vira was a warrior. The Destoyer and Vira had an interesting father-daughter relationship. I liked that the Destroyer thought that him telling Vira who to kill, and then Vira killing people might be wrong and that he might need to stop. I liked Masha and that she gave Vira perspective on her purpose.

Shamsuddin-Jalal by Tahir Abrar: 3 stars-
Jinn are always interesting to read about. I liked the story within that Jalal told about the women in a relationship, and how there was a question at the end of the story. I liked the ending.

The Collector by Sona Charaipotra: 3 stars-
This was a solid story. I liked that the story talked about objects like jewels and the legends of their world. The puppets were interesting and creepy, in my opinion. I liked what was revealed about the souls and the prophecy.

Unraveled by Preeti Chhibber: 3 stars-
This story was interesting. I liked the magic in this world. The story picked up when the characters were in the forest and the setting and Sarsh was an intriguing character. I liked reading Shweta’s arc.

She Who Answers by Shreya Ila Anasuya: 3 stars-
This was good. I liked that there were goddesses in this story. I also liked to hear the beliefs they all have because of their faith in their gods. I liked that these goddesses actually helped when called upon as well. Usually stories of gods have gods that don’t listen to the people, so it was a nice twist.

The Hawk’s Reason by Naz Kutub: 3 stars-
This story was good. I liked that the problems these characters faced were wars. I liked that there was a prophecy. I didn’t love the insta-love, but I liked the forbidden aspect of their relationship. I liked the end.

Poetry of Earth by Swati Teerdhala: 3 stars-
This story was solid. I didn’t like the school setting, but the fact that she was punished to go to high school was funny. I liked how this story talked about books and writing. I liked the relationship.

Mirch, Masala, and Magic by Nafiza Azad: 4 stars-
I enjoyed this story. I loved that magic and food were talked about and a great part of the story. The plot was intriguing. I really liked the family. The end was great.

Daughter of the Sun by Sayantani DasGupta: 4 stars-
This was great. I liked that this story talked about reincarnation and breaking cycles. I liked the talk of differences of gender in society. I really loved what the characters chose in the end.

What the Winds Stole by Sabaa Tahir: 4 stars-
This story was so intriguing. I liked reading about Hiba being cursed to stay at the lake. The world was interesting. I like that Sule helped her. I like that Sule brought out her good side again after she was hurt in the past. I liked what she did for him in the end.

Was this review helpful?

4.25/5 ⭐️

This was an incredible anthology of South Asian myths, legends, and magic written by South Asian authors. I loved learning more about the different folklore within the South Asian diaspora as a folklore lover. This has definitely become one of my favorite anthologies that I’ve read so far.

My favorite stories were The Hawk’s Reason by Naz Kutub, Poetry of the Earth by Swati Teerdhala, The Collector by Sona Charaipotra, and What the Winds Stole by Sabaa Tahir.

Please note that I am not an ownvoices South Asian reviewer so please look for those reviews!

Was this review helpful?

As this title is published by HarperTeen, an imprint of HarperCollins, I will be withholding my review of the title in support of the HarperCollins Union strike. I look forward to reviewing this title once HarperCollins has met the union at the bargaining table and agreed to a fair contract.

Was this review helpful?

The stories were so good. You can see each writers unique story telling as they take you into 14 different stories. Truly was captivating.

Was this review helpful?

this was a such a lovely anthology, full of South Asian magic, appreciation, and love from the deep myths of our cultures to the every day practices and pieces of ourselves and make us South Asian. i loved every story!

Was this review helpful?

I truly loved these beautiful stories. The descriptions were so vivid I found myself sucked into each tale. Definitely didn’t want them to be over. I will keep an eye out on when this title becomes available. I highly recommend everyone check it out!

Thanks to NetGalley and the Publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, HarperCollins Children’s Books, and HarperTeen for the opportunity to read an advanced reader's copy of this book for an honest review. (Publish Date: May 23, 2023)

“Magic Has No Borders” is a collection of short stories from South Asian folklore, legends, and epics reimagined for a modern YA audience.

I really enjoyed that no two stories were alike in this book. It contained 14 different stories from 14 different authors. Each story had at least one magical element, and I was excited to discover so many new stories and interesting characters in just one book!

While I did enjoy some stories more than others, I think that was the point of this collection – to reach a wide audience of readers with varied interests.

Overall, I would definitely recommend this book to older teens and young adults as it contains some sexual content not suitable for younger readers.

Was this review helpful?

this was a great fantasy and science fiction teen anthology, it had a great collection of stories and authors. Each story was what I was hoping for from the authors and each one was really well done. Each one was strong and beautifully written, I had two favorites The Hawk’s Reason By Naz Kutub and A Goddess of Fire and Blood By Tanaz Bhathena. I'm glad I got to read this and hope to read more from this company.

"Witch, Amira had heard the guards call this queen in private. Demon, for her black eyes and the streaks of blue in her midnight hair. Yet from what Amira had heard the other girls say, Balram-putri Juhi, a former princess of Samudra, was really King Lohar’s prize—the spoils in Ambar’s brutal three-year war with the southern kingdom, which had ended with a peace treaty that had made Juhi its living, breathing collateral."

Was this review helpful?