Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A sweet YA contemporary about chasing your dreams, first love, and staying true to yourself. Light, hopeful, and totally heartwarming. Great for a quick, feel-good read.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very painful read. I would not recommend it.

I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really sweet YA read for teens especially who love fashion and theatre. This was not your typical happily ever after kind of story but was the perfect amount of high school romance you would expect from two seventeen year olds.

Was this review helpful?

Alison Schaffir’s *Your Dream For Me* offers a light, creative coming-of-age tale about passion, self-discovery, and the threads that hold relationships together. With its relatable protagonist and a unique premise combining fashion and theater, the story provides a charming look at a high schooler pursuing her dreams while navigating the ups and downs of teenage relationships.

Scarlett is an engaging main character whose dream of becoming a fashion designer sets her apart from her theatrically inclined parents. Her introverted nature and desire to stay out of the spotlight feel authentic, making her a relatable protagonist for readers who have ever felt overshadowed or uncertain of their place in a larger picture.

The novel shines in its exploration of Scarlett’s burgeoning creativity and determination to build a strong portfolio for her dream school, the Fashion Institute of Technology. Her journey into the world of costume design, guided by her crush Nathaniel and her experiences in the school’s drama program, is both fun and inspiring. The descriptions of her designs and her passion for fashion bring color and vibrancy to the narrative.

Nathaniel, Scarlett’s love interest, is charming but doesn’t feel as developed as he could be. While his initial encouragement of Scarlett is sweet, his later withdrawal and their romantic subplot lack depth, making their connection feel more like a convenient plot device than a fully fleshed-out relationship.

The friendship between Scarlett and Macie, however, is a highlight. Their bond is genuine and nuanced, and the conflict they face after a distressing event adds emotional weight to the story. Scarlett’s efforts to mend their relationship showcase her growth and maturity, even as she faces external challenges like a rival trying to tarnish her reputation.

Despite its strengths, the novel stumbles in pacing and depth. Some of the conflicts—particularly Nathaniel’s pulling away and the rivalry subplot—feel underdeveloped, leaving the resolutions somewhat unsatisfying. Additionally, the story’s focus on Scarlett’s journey is occasionally overshadowed by predictable high school drama.

Overall, *Your Dream For Me* is a sweet, if slightly uneven, story about following your passion and staying true to yourself. Fans of YA contemporary novels with creative protagonists, like *Fangirl* by Rainbow Rowell or *Love, Life, and the List* by Kasie West, will likely enjoy Scarlett’s journey. While it doesn’t fully reach its potential, it’s an enjoyable read for anyone who dreams of turning their passion into reality.

Was this review helpful?

Your Dream For Me is a cute nostalgic YA romance; if you enjoy reading about high school crushes or even want to relive it through a book, this is the one for you. As someone who studied fashion design, I related to the FMC so much. However, I was really hoping for HEA, but that was not the case for the ending; it certainly left me a bit confused. overall this was a very cute, sweet read.

Thank you so much to netgalley and the publisher for this e-arc

Was this review helpful?

This book has me very conflicted... was it written by 1 author?

0% - 40%: I wanted nothing more than to DNF this book. It was so cringy, poorly written, and hard to continue reading. It was very obvious that the author was just elongating sentences to hit a word/page goal. There were too many words and no teenager talks like that!

40% - The End: Suddenly there is a shift and the writing gets better? It felt as if another write took over, or maybe the first part of the book was never revised! It still wasn't great, but at least it made more sense. Still, the plot got lost.

How is a girl going to try to get into FIT with no sewing experience? You can sew by hand! This book made it seem like we would follow Scarlett along for her journey of getting into her dream college, but instead we got a whole lot of drama filled high school days that had really nothing to do with her future.

Overall, this book felt like it was written by a 25 year old imagining how a 17 year old would live. I know it's a YA book, but some parts felt too mature for younger teens, while other parts felt too childish for older teens. Also, wtf was up with Macie just taking the threat from Ashton and allowing herself to be walked all over? She is supposed to be sassy and confident, but then she gets taken advantage of and just allows it? Then her best friend Scarlett jumps in and keeps being violent, but nobody reports the assaulter?!? The more that I think about it, the more frustrated I get. Such a bad image to show young and impressionable teens.

Not worth the read. 2 stars only because the writing got a little better over time and I liked how the end wasn't a forced HEA.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Level Best Books | Independent Book Publishers Association (IBPA), Members' Titles and Netgalley for the advanced copy of this book. While I found it to be an average read for me, I did enjoy Scarlett and her passion for fashion. I like that, in general, YA books follow a clear narrative arc, and this book was no different. I did find it a bit run of the mill, which isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Was this review helpful?

No matter what your age, if you went to high school and fell in love for the first time you will relate to this book! The characters are relatable, lovable and strike a familiar chord with the drama that is unique to high school. Truly a fun and delightful read! Definitely recommend!

Thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Your Dream For Me is a cute YA romance novel. I liked the nostalgia of it - it reminded me of being in high school and having a crush on someone. WHile some people didn't like the ending, I thought it was realistic and true to my time in high school. I also loved the pieces of the fashion world and wish there was more. The character development was good, I felt like I understood the characters. I just didn't love the book - I think maybe it was Scarlett's immaturity (I realize she is young but she acted way younger sometimes). But it was an easy YA romance read.

Was this review helpful?

This is more of a young adult story for those wanting to go in knowing what to expect.

We meet fmc 17 year old Scarlet with a penchant for fashion but a strong aversion to the spotlight. She is absorbed in the school costume racks when she inadvertently comes across Nathaniel Wilder an extremely talented theatre student.

I struggled with this as I felt it was almost too YA for me. Pretty arguments, internal dialogue all didn’t do it for me unfortunately. I will consider books from this author again in the future.

Was this review helpful?

This was decent. However, I did notice that there was not a HEA. I really wanted there to be a HEA, but there unfortunately wasn't which I really didn't enjoy about it. For this reason, I have given it 3 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing a free copy in exchange of an honest review.

Well, I really wanted to like this book but I feel like Scarlett is too immature and childish? Don’t get me wrong I know that she was 17, I mean I have been 17 after all but I feel that her inner monologue is just too young? It felt like reading a 14 year old’s thoughts instead. Also the ending was just not it.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't entirely realize this was YA when I requested it, but that's totally fine - I still enjoy the occasional YA book. That being said, this book felt almost... younger than YA? The protagonist felt like she was 12/13 rather than 17. Maybe I'm just not the target demographic for this book and it skewed my review, however I read another YA book in the past few weeks that I thoroughly enjoyed. I really enjoyed the premise of the book but felt like the overall themes could be explored more.

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 16%. Felt like it could be a super quick read but I just couldn't do it. The writing is just TOO YA for me. Very basic and childish.

Was this review helpful?

I unfortunately didn't have the time to get to reading it before it archived! Though I will pick it up in the future.
So please disregard the low rating as Netgalley forces me to put one down with my review.

Was this review helpful?

"Unraveled Dreams" is a YA novel that seamlessly weaves together themes of ambition, friendship, and self-discovery. Seventeen-year-old Scarlett, with her passion for fashion and aversion to the spotlight, is a relatable and endearing protagonist. Her journey from sneaking into the school's costume shop to pursuing her dream of becoming a renowned fashion designer is both inspiring and heartwarming.

The author's adept storytelling introduces Nathaniel Wilder, a talented theater student who becomes an unexpected source of inspiration for Scarlett. Their budding friendship adds depth to the narrative as Scarlett navigates the challenges of mastering sewing skills and balancing her passion for fashion with her desire to be closer to Nathaniel for the school play.

As Scarlett's designs begin to take shape, the novel takes an unexpected turn with a distressing event involving her best friend, Macie, which tests their friendship and causes Nathaniel to pull away. The author skillfully builds tension as Scarlett faces not only personal setbacks but also external challenges, including a rival intent on tarnishing her reputation.

What sets "Unraveled Dreams" apart is its portrayal of resilience and determination in the face of adversity. Scarlett's unwavering spirit and newfound sewing skills serve as a testament to the power of pursuing one's dreams, even when faced with obstacles. The novel's engaging plot and well-developed characters kept me invested from start to finish, rooting for Scarlett every step of the way.

The only reason I am giving this book a 3 stars is because at times it felt so juvenile.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun YA contemporary romance. I loved Scarlett’s character and her growth throughout the book. I would definitely recommend for fans of theater or fashion design.

Was this review helpful?

If you’re looking to relive your middle school love life, this is a good book. It has the most important plot line, the monologue of a thirteen year old.

Was this review helpful?

I felt like I was reading the inner monologue of a 13 year old. This was not a fun experience. This reminds me of why I generally dont gravitate much towards YA romance.

Was this review helpful?

This was a super cute book, definitely meant for the you get YA readers.
Scarlett was an interesting FMC, I appreciated that she had someone teach her to sew as opposed to going onto YouTube or another external source. L.
Overall it was a sweet book and I would read a sequel if one is to be released.

Was this review helpful?