Cover Image: Wannabe

Wannabe

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I am a huge pop culture happy hour fan and a fan of pop culture in general. I really loved reading about all the different pop culture influences that Aisha Harris has in her life. It made me think about what influences I had and I just really enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 34%

I thought this book was going to be more of a general look at how 90s pop culture shaped a generation, but I was very wrong. I guess that's on me for not doing enough research about it. But I'm also just not sure who this book is written for. I grew up just a few years after Harris, but felt almost no connection at all to her experiences. Granted, I am white and the first couple chapters at least largely focus on her experiences as a Black woman, so I can only assume this will hit better among a Black audience raised in the 90s. Either way, these essays didn't really warrant the publishing of a whole book in my opinion.

Was this review helpful?

NPR Podcaster Aisha Harris discusses pop culture thru the lens of her experience. I really like her as a podcast host, but I wanted this book to be way less dry and have many more pop culture references.

Was this review helpful?

In this collection, Aisha Harris combines memoir with essays on pop culture as a Black woman growing up in the 90s. I liked it overall, particularly her thoughts on Child Free vs motherhood

Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Wannabe by Aisha Harris was an absolute romp of a read. It was a lot of fun and extremely insightful -- both on a personal and broadly pop-cultural level. I loved Harris' unique voice and the fresh look she brought to an ongoing conversation.

Was this review helpful?

With a slightly slow start, this book was still a definitive five star read! I’ve probably never said this before, but this is a book that I could imagine writing. And not because I’m in anyway as good a storyteller as Aisha Harris, but because every single thing on her mind and every single pop culture reference she brings to the table has been a thought in my brain. I guess I’ve never felt so SEEN by an author. I’m a big fan of Aisha’s contribution to Pop Culture Happy Hour and her writing here is infused with wit and honesty that makes it just a very compelling read. Her chapter on being childfree by choice was really powerful. I read through it twice! Would recommend this book to fans of humorous essays, or fans of popular culture generally. There’s something for everyone here, and it will feed that elder millennial inside all of us! I want to thank NetGalley for a preview of this wonderful book.

Was this review helpful?

I love any kind of pop culture criticism memoirs, and the author weaves in her own experiences thoughtfully and delightfully. It made me consider things from a very different perspective, and at times an uncomfortable one, but that's a good thing. It's very well written, entertaining, and reads quickly. I did think a lot of the references might make it somewhat dated, and I wasn't familiar with a lot of the media referenced, so I think I might have gotten more from it if I was.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fantastic collection of essays! I went in expecting some humorous takes on pop culture (also fun for me) and was pleasantly surprised to get a collection of deeply thought-provoking essays on identity, Blackness, and the impact of movies, TV, and celebrity. Aisha Harris is such a gifted writer and I really appreciated the call backs and themes that made it a cohesive collection.

Was this review helpful?

A memoir in essays through the lens of pop culture criticism is catnip for me, so this was mostly a hit. I love the podcast Aisha Harris co-hosts on NPR, Pop Culture Happy Hour. All four of the main hosts are fantastic, so I was excited to read Harris's book. I would love for someone closer to my age to write a book like this, because I feel like all I ever read is the millennial perspective, and as a Gen X person, my pop culture memories go way beyond the 90s. Harris's book is definitely more pop culture than memoir, especially in the later essays. A couple of the essays didn't really land for me. In one, she warns you that she's going to give spoilers about a movie, and then she returns to that topic throughout the essay. This is fine on a brief weekly podcast, which I can fast-forward or skip altogether, but I didn't like having to skip the rest of an essay. The other essay that annoyed me was the one about choosing not to have children. I certainly believe it's everyone's prerogative to make these choices, and since I had my first child at 36 and wasn't sure I was going to be a parent, I had to hear all the annoying comments and questions for many years (especially because I'd been married since I was 21). I want everyone to leave everyone else alone about this topic, forever and always, but that includes wanting childless-by-choice people to stop believing they're superior to people who have chosen parenthood, and Harris is most definitely in that camp. She also includes laughable assertions that she can speak with authority about being a parent because she loves her dogs and because she is a daughter and has parents. Ok.... She also made a point of not liking that people state that they're a parent in their social media profiles. It's hard for me to imagine how anyone could care so much about that choice that they had to tell everyone in a book how much they do not care about it. Even though that essay felt a bit like a trainwreck, the rest of them were quite good!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! Aisha Harris presents us with nine polished jewels of essays about the complex ways in which pop culture affects how we see ourselves, and how other people see us. The opening essay is as close to perfect a thing as I will ever see: interweaving nuanced threads dealing with names, identity, memory, and the weight of fragmented histories. She is equally skilled at the deep analysis of individual pop culture texts through close reading, and at looking at broader media trends over decades. I learned so much about the pop culture I have already explored and loved, and have received many directional tips for the future exploration of entertainment. I loved this!

Was this review helpful?

Personally I felt this book of essays was 3.5 stars, as I was expecting a much lighter look at the pop culture that similarly shaped my world, but I’m rounding up because Aisha Harris is an excellent writer who often challenges us to take a closer look at Black representation in tv and movies. I was surprisingly not familiar with Harris, who is well-known through NPR, Slate, and various podcasts and essays, but I love how her degrees are in theatre and cinema studies. Her knowledge of pop culture is deep and the references excellent. We definitely grew up around the same time period, and though I’m older with a different perspective of mid-90s pop culture, I enjoyed her analyses. And seriously, I love the title and the fact that she states the song’s opening is one of the most classic pop lyrics ever.

Thank you to NetGalley and HarperOne for kindly providing an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I love the range of topics discussed in this. I only had the chance to skim a lot of the chapters but enjoyed Aisha’s writing style a lot! excellent commentary and well put together.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure what to expect when I was first approved to read this book, but I can tell you that I was not disappointed after I finished reading. I did not know who Aisha Harris was, but I definitely love her writing style and her voice and I love her now! This book connects pop culture and current times so well. I would definitely recommend this book to my patrons!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and HarperOne for an ARC of this title.

What a fantastic collection of essays. This does a thing I love where an essay will get a little freewheeling and connect 2-3 events/pieces of pop culture that don't feel connected at first glance and then show you how a line connecting them's always been there. I would have picked this up for the essay talking about Disney's self-cannibalization alone.

Was this review helpful?

I have always been the type of person who likes to think deeply about my entertainment. I can spend hours thinking (and talking, if anyone lets me) about the ways strategy has evolved on Survivor or the various histories and influences that go into a single Beyonce costume. But for a long time, pop culture criticism and analogy came from only one perspective - white men at least a generation removed from me.

So, reading Aisha Harris’ essays warmed my soul in a way I didn’t know I needed. But it truly moved me to have the same level of merit I’ve seen applied to Bruce Springsteen again and again applied to The Spice Girls. Her essays track her own journey towards self-acceptance through the pop culture she has loved and hated. She dissects everything from The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn to Zola through a lens of race, gender and millennial angst. Harris has already made a name for herself as one of our smartest cultural critics, and this only cements her voice further.

And I may just print out her essay on why she doesn’t want to have kids to hand out whenever I’m asked about it.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to HarperOne and Netgalley for this eARC!

In Wannabe, Aisha Harris uses her exceptional knowledge of pop culture to discuss a variety of deep topics affecting the modern millennial. From the Black Best Friend, to the abundance of remakes, Harris is able to examine how our society impacts us, and how we are impacted by society. This entire book is worth the read, as there is not a bad essay in the bunch. No matter if you have seen/heard the reference Harris is referencing, Harris writes in a way that makes her point understandable. She is able to write about complicated topics in (somewhat) lighthearted ways, without avoiding the topics' darker aspects. She also sprinkles in enough embarrassing stories about her youth, that you truly feel comfortable getting into the nitty gritty alongside her.

As a lover of pop culture, I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Harris has written for Slate and currently works for NPR, and she is a strong and engaging writer. I would recommend this to any and all millennials!

Was this review helpful?

A long-time listener of the PopCulture Happy Hour podcast, I was familiar with Aisha Harris and looking forward to reading this deep dive into pop culture. It was even better than I expected - with thoughtful insights on the role pop culture and entertainment play in our society and the effects it has on so many aspects of our lives. This book covers topics such as representation, racism, the choice to be child free, and more - while drawing parallels from the last several decades of pop culture.

Was this review helpful?

As a co-host of the NPR show, Pop Culture Happy Hour, author Aisha Harris is a well known critic. This collection of essays that explore themes such as racism, representation, parenting and trauma in today’s television, movies and music. Aisha makes some really good points and while I never felt particularly shamed for enjoying some of my favorite entertainment, it did give me a lot to consider while watching.

I received a digital Advanced Review Copy of this book from the Publisher through NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

To tell you the truth, I had no idea who Aisha Harris was until I read this awesome book. She is a fantastic writer. I truly enjoyed every essay in this collection. I also loved that she named her book after the beloved Spice Girls song from my childhood. Harris references a lot of pop culture tidbits, and I absolutely loved every second of it. She talks about everything such as The Little Mermaid, New Girl, Johnny Depp and Amber Heard, the black friend trope, and the Megyn Kelly incident (Black Santa), and how all these facets of pop culture relate to her early adulthood and beyond. This book is fun, down-to-earth, refreshing, and brutally honest. She never shies away from sensitive topics such a race and domestic abuse. I'm definitley a fan of Aisha Harris now!

Was this review helpful?

Aisha Harris, best known (at least by me) as one of the hosts of the NPR podcast Pop Culture Happy Hour dives into how pop culture has influenced the woman she has become in her new memoir Wannabe: Reckonings with the Pop Culture That Shapes Me. As we are somewhat similar in age, I found many of the culture timepoints she notes to be quite resonant in my life as well. She also highlights a lot about Black pop cultural moments and how they have affected her and her writing. She weighs the balance of wanting to support Black artists who can struggle to break out while also wanting to be able to critique their work. Some off the chapters are more introspective/memoir-y (her dating history, her decision to not have children, how some pieces she has written have affected her personally), while others read more like cultural critiques (the emphasis on intellectual property in media these days, the trope of the black girl friend over the years in TV/movies). I felt like the book may have come together more cohesively if she focused one way or another. Overall, I appreciated her insights on how culture has affected her life choices and how she interacts with others, and also how these insights have affected her cultural writing through the years. I did not know much about Aisha's background coming into this book (really only knew her from the podcast), so this was lovely.

Thank you to HarperOne via NetGalley for the advance reader copy in exchange for honest review.

Was this review helpful?