Skip to main content

Member Reviews

4.25 stars

A murder mystery set on a secluded island, with teenagers playing the roles of 1920's movie characters, sounds right up my alley!

I fell right into this story and had a fabulous time figuring out the character's motives and secrets. Each person has a lot going on under the surface and unraveling everything was a lot of fun. There are flashbacks to show us the relationships among the teens and give us glimpses into what they're hiding. Each piece that fell into place was exciting and it felt like a race to the end.

The ending was surprising, but did leave some things undone. I also wanted a bit more to be happening now, rather than most of the action being in the past.

This was great and twisty and I loved reading it!

I voluntarily read and reviewed this book. All opinions are my own. Thank you to G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers and NetGalley for the copy.

Was this review helpful?

I had a really hard time getting into this one. I didn’t feel like I could connect with any of the characters. The story felt kind of dragged out and not believable.

Was this review helpful?

I did not read this one due to the Goodreads ratings dropping below a 4. I am screening books for our Battle of the Books list, and that is one of our criteria. I think it had a lot of promise initially, but it hasn’t held up as time went on.

Was this review helpful?

I hated everything about this. The characters, the constant time shifts, the multiple narratives, everything. And when I got to the acknowledgments and learned how much the author liked Twilight, I wished I’d known that going on because this was just awful. How hard is it to create characters who are remotely likable? I always liked YA for its ability to deal with real issues in a way that gave insights into life for teens. This is not realistic and the characters are not remotely like real people. It’s this kind of book that makes people think YA is trash.

Was this review helpful?

I just read this book in 5 days and omg it was an amazing debut! I got since this book for me to read and review but all thoughts and opions are my own. But once again thank you to Penguin Teen for sending me an e-arc & a finished copy months/weeks in advance. Let's begin shall we?
So we follow our 2 main character name Kassadiy and Isadole (short for Izzy). They are two best friends in high school getting ready to graduate! Kassady deciedes she wants to take izzy and six of her friends to this famous mansion that one of thier favorite movie from the 1920's and so they had to wear/lose their cellphones so they can fit the theme.
I would describe this book as One of us is lying meets Gets Out! The reason why is because everyone is lying when one of them ends up dead, and by one of them I mean Izzy's friend Blaine! I didn't see the twist and turns coming, I had a hard time putting the book down when I got to the halfway mark. To be fair though the two different timelines were a bit confusing to me but it was nice that the author had a heading to let us know what timeline we are in...
I was shocked at the end becauase chapter 40 hit me in my feels because I had multiple ppl with cancer so I was totally crying in my weekly vlog I was making. I won't say who or why for spoilers but look up content warnings and just enjoy the ride! 4/5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

Everything about this story felt entirely implausible, yet it kept my attention easily and I couldn’t stop reading to find out how everything would end. I suppose when you have the kind of money these characters (well, their families) have (except one, of course, because there has to be the one scholarship kid who attends the fancy private school because her mom is a teacher) you can live as though rules/laws don’t apply to you, but still… A weeklong 1920’s themed graduation party with no cell phones? No 18 year old is planning that, or agreeing to attend. The tropes were troping non-stop throughout the story, and I kinda hated the ending. There were too many twists, which again made the story just feel impossible, and the shift in perspective (from first-person to third-person) throughout the story were a bit hard to follow.

I was entertained by this, but it won’t be one I push people to read or revisit in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I have to admit I was a little surprised to discover this book is a debut. Going for a well written locked room mystery for a debut is bold, but clearly a smart decision because this mystery was well done. I do have to say it is a bit of a slow burn mystery with more adolescent drama than action. I thought the twists were well done even if they weren’t so twisty I didn’t have a good idea what was coming. Izzy and her best friend Kassidy have always loved old movies. As a graduation present and a final hurrah Kassidy rents out a house about to become a museum that was featured in one of their favorite movies for a 1920’s themed week long party with her best friend Izzy, her boyfriend Blaine and several of their friends. Armed with authentic costumes and period activities and lacking cell phones the teens discover there are some unresolved issues between them but all of that stops mattering and matters more than ever when Blaine is discovered dead.

Was this review helpful?

I am so glad I got the chance to read this book! I really enjoyed this thriller that included the bonus of a foreboding setting on an isolated island during a storm. A group of recently graduated HS seniors head this private island for a week of glamorous 1920's dress-up and end up embroiled in a murder when one them is brutally killed. The story is full of twists and turns right up until the end. I can often figure out mysteries before the end but with this book I did not have a clue!!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you @penguinteen for sending me a #gifted copy of this book #PRHAInfluencer

I also had the pleasure of listening to the audiobook courtesy of @prhaudio thank you!

Title : Suddenly a Murder
Author: Lauren Muñoz
Narrator: Diana Bustelo

Book thoughts :

Suddenly a Murder is a YA murder mystery, where everyone is a suspect when one friend gets murdered at a 1920s themed party.
I love me a good locked room mystery.
This book was interesting to me. I knew immediately who the killer was BUT the motive is what had me dying. I was very vocal with my shock. When I think about it I’m still saying holy shit Ms. Muñoz! That’s a twist i didn’t see coming. I loved the ending. I know that some people might not like it but I found it very satisfying.

I loved the Latinx representation in this.
I’m always happy when I see myself represented in a book.

Overall I really enjoyed this debut and I plan to read more in the future.


Audiobook thoughts:

This audiobook was 9 hours and 17 minutes long.
The narrator Diana Bustelo did such an amazing job. I absolutely loved her as Izzy. She made the audiobook go by so quick.
I will be on the lookout for more audiobooks by her.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this! It's always interesting reading books written about teenagers when I'm technically old enough to be their parent, but I liked the premise- 7 teens celebrate graduation from private school but going to an old house and acting like it's the 1920s. It depends on the host family having gobs of money to supply the outfits and staff and food, but from the wealth that these families have, it's not out of the realm of possibility.

The main present-day narration is first person from Izzy, a young woman with a complicated family situation and she knows a secret about Blaine, the young man who is murdered. She's best friends with Blaine's friend Kassidy (the spelling of this bothered me but I've seen names spelled like this in truth). In between most of the present-day chapters are third person chapters from events that have happened in the past few months and allows us to get to know the other characters/suspects. The first time the switch in narration happened, it was quite jarring but I got used to it. I'm not sure how else it could have been done, because it's important to gain insight into why each "friend" had reasons to murder Blaine.

Because I guessed all but one of the twists, this book felt a little long but I still enjoyed it. I'd definitely read more of Munoz's books in the future. Thanks for the chance to read this!

Was this review helpful?

This is one of those books where, even though I finished it a few months ago, I remember it so vividly because I was hooked from start to finish!

I mentioned in a previous post that this book is marketed as a YA version of Knives Out, and that was an incredibly accurate description! We had a big shot detective who showed up uninvited, a glamorous locked-room setting, and a suspicious cast of characters who all had motive and opportunity. The fabulous wealth of these teens is tempered by our main character Izzy, a Latina student who was only able to attend their fancy private school because her mom is a teacher there. Izzy had her own secrets to hide and ended up helping and hindering the official investigation whenever it fit her agenda. Some parts of this book were quite dark, which pleasantly surprised me; I wasn't expecting that level of intensity from a YA book.

I was immediately swept up in the glitz and glamour of the island manor setting while trying to keep track of all the secrets and motives. Not spoiling anything, but Muñoz had a clever way of keeping Izzy up-to-date on the investigation so that the reader doesn't feel limited by her 1st person POV. Rather, it felt like we were solving the mystery alongside her as the plot thickened and the lies were revealed one by one. The ending was a wild ride and there was one aspect of it that I would have done differently, but it didn't detract from my overall enjoyment. Again, I can't say much without revealing too much, so you'll have to experience this one for yourself! I can't wait to see what Muñoz writes next after this fun, twisty debut.

Was this review helpful?

I love a good mystery/thriller! They break up my fantasy streaks and give me that shock factor I enjoy when the culprit comes to light. The blurb for this one sounded intriguing since it involved a manor with a 1920’s theme party. My kind of vibes! Unfortunately, I found myself not interested in the plot or the characters.

The book is told from different timelines but they all stem around Izzy Morales and her family. She is a gifted student who had an opportunity to go to a good school because of her mom who was a teacher there. This is the case for some kids in the real world and was definitely a good parallel. I liked that Izzy cared for her sister so much and would do anything to help her. Sisterly bonds are very important to me. I have probably said that a lot in other reviews, ha. It is obviously still true. For someone that would be considered smart she didn’t always think through the choices she made leading up to the trip to the manor and while there.

I wouldn’t say the characters had a lot of depth and this does tend to happen with mysteries. The book usually centers around the plot. That is fine because sometimes the plot carries the book but it didn’t for me here and so I was just missing a connection from both. The pacing was rather slow and I didn’t see myself caring for the plot until it got closer to the big reveal. Although, I felt like the ending was a bit anticlimactic and open-ended which is literally the worst combo for me!

Overall, this was just okay. I don’t have much to say about it since I didn’t connect with it.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Penguin for this arc
You put enough rich kids in a room with a scholarship kid, there's going to be a murder. It's a basic bookish fact at this point.
Suddenly a Murder follows the tried and true premise of a group of rich friends (and one not so rich) going on a getaway to celebrate graduation. Lies, betrayal, and infidelity threaten the group dynamic, but when one of them is murdered everything comes to light.
Diversity in books is always a treat to read, one of the reasons I was excited to read Suddenly a Murder is that BIPOC authors typically can be counted on to have a great cast of characters with BIPOC voices. Izzy's experience with race, her Father's deportation, and how she views herself is one aspect that I loved the most during reading.
The beginning is a bit clunky to get through, the writing at times just felt awkward. I did consider DNF-ing the book with how much I was struggling with it, but I am glad I stuck with it because it improved. The more I kept reading the more I enjoyed it, with the final chunk of the book having the strongest writing and most immersive reading experience.
There are a lot of different characters and at times they blend together with how similar they are in terms of "rich, privileged, spoiled". I do believe the plot would have been stronger with less voices.
I would have liked to have seen the whole book, or at least a pov or two from Pilar. She is easily the most interesting and engaging character, to the point where she was outshining the "main characters". I would sooner read and enjoy a book following her adventures, her character is just so much more fleshed out then others.
The flashbacks account for about half of the book, and felt jarring with the shifting of going from first person in the present to third in the past. I wish there were less flashbacks or less people.I don't think a book should rely so heavily on flashbacks to set the tension and reveals as much as it does in this one.
I have mixed feelings about the romance. I don't think there is enough chemistry between the characters for it to have felt real.
The reveal wasn't a surprise, though other secrets that are uncovered are a huge shock. The question I want to pose is as follows: Were there enough bread crumbs leading to the big secret, or was it so out of left field with no evidence to support it that it feels cheap and out of nowhere?
While I don't love this book, I did have a mostly enjoyable experience. I say if the premise intrigues you, give it a try and see what you think! This is Lauren Muñoz's debut novel, and I would read further books from her.
The cover is very poor, it feels very dated in terms of design and composition. I do not like it, nor would I pick it up if I saw it in a bookstore.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the Arc! When I requested this book I didn't realize that it was categorized as Young Adult (YA). I used to be all about YA in my younger days, but it just reads too juvenile for me. Overall, it is a decent book-I just am not a fan of writers having teenagers talk and behave like people in their 30s. My kids are going to love this one though!

Was this review helpful?

You don't find a locked room mystery geared for the YA audience very often. Throw in a 1920s themed party for of privileged teenagers (with, of course, the one who isn't) in Maine and you have me hooked. There is a lot of teenage drama. But it wouldn't be a YA book if there wasn't.

There are a number of characters and it is told from different pov so it can be difficult to remember everyone and get a feeling for their personalities. As the book moved along it became clearer. Also, after you read the first chapter you are going to think that it is obvious who the killer is but don't let that put you off. Things aren't as they first appear.

This was very enjoyable. I definitely recommend it for people who enjoy locked room mysteries, deadly graduations, and good storytelling.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in return for an honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Suddenly a Murder is a YA murder mystery novel where everyone is a suspect when one friend gets murdered at a 1920s themed party.

This story is full of glitz and glam, mystery and murder! The mystery aspect of the book was really interesting to me! The story kept hopping around and would tell you little bits here and there but always kept you guessing until the very end!

I think there was definitely a point where I thought each person could have been the murderer!

I'd recommend Suddenly a Murder to anyone who wants to read a twisty YA murder mystery novel!

Was this review helpful?

I always love me a locked room mystery and a private island with no way off the boat works really well for those ! Add in a 1920s themed costume party and 7 high school students celebrating their recent graduation ! What could go wrong … oops one of them is dead and one of them is a killer!

This one stated off a bit slow for me but then picked up about 20% in . I enjoyed the story and the few twists that were thrown in - although I did figure out the “ who done it “ pretty early on . I loved the friendship between Izzy and Kass 🥰 i feel like we rarely read about good friendships in YA thrillers

Was this review helpful?

Lauren Munoz has created a really interesting twist on a locked room period mystery. Izzy's mother teaches at the very expensive, prestigious school they attend, where she became best friends with Kassidy. Kassidy and Izzy are obsessed with Marla Nevercross, a film actress from the 1920s, regularly watching her films while wearing period clothing and speculating on how glamourous life was like in the jazz age.Kassidy is very wealthy so she convinces her parents to rent Ashwood Manor, a Nevercross' newly restored mansion on it's own private island, for a week long party for herself and six of her friends. When the friends arrive, Kassidy springs the final surprise: they are too spend the week living in the 1920s- period clothes provided, hairstyles and makeup tips provided, and all their modern items, including electronics, are confiscated. Although there are initial grumblings, all the young adults are pleased at being independent adults, with staff provided to see to their needs. So, seven friends on an island, their only outside contact a landline and a daily ferry. When Blaine, Kassidy's boyfriend is murdered, brutally stabbed in the shower, the friend's are shocked. However, it turns out everyone had a motive for wanting Blaine gone. Police are summoned and the staff are quickly dismissed as suspects, and the unravelling of whodunnit begins. The writing is fast paced, but some of the character's motivation for murder seemed a little thin and the conclusion a little too pat, Considering how traumatic the events would be, the character's seemed somewhat subdued and flimsy in their reactions. The detective seemed like a female Poirot, but perhaps that was intended as homage. It was a quick fun read. I received a eadvance copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book kept me guessing the entire time.

My brain was convinced it was one person but was also thoroughly confused because surely it could not be that simple. Of course, it wasn’t.

The characters were all interesting and, for an ensemble cast, decently fleshed out.

Essentially, this story had a little bit of everything. Friendship, romance, betrayal, mystery, and murder. It was a delightful cocktail, and I’d be interested in checking out any of the author’s future work.

Was this review helpful?

This book was overall an average murder mystery in my opinion. It was enjoyable enough that I finished it rather quickly but I wasn't blown away by any of the reveals throughout the book. I did really love the 1920s classic murder mystery atmosphere though.
💎
The characters were mediocre and I didn't hate the MC Izzy but I wasn't really rooting for her either. She was actually kind of annoying at times. Also, I've noticed I don't really like reading about rich people 😆 so maybe that was part of the problem.
💎
I did enjoy learning everyone's secrets and seeing how everything fit together but the way it was delivered doesn't give the reader much of a chance to figure anything out for themselves.
💎
The ending wasn't necessarily shocking but was a bit emotional and not quite how I expected it to go.
💎
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for providing me with an e-ARC in exchange for honest review.

Was this review helpful?