Cover Image: Guardians of Dawn: Zhara

Guardians of Dawn: Zhara

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thank you, NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I had high hopes!

This started so well that about 20-40% in, I was already recommending the book to friends. Then it went downhill from there…

It became so repetitive after a while. Always the mocking of the prince and his lack of knowledge, the repetitive reminders of Zhara’s protection and family and the reason why she can’t fully give herself to her magic. I’m all for a complex universe, but the multiplication of names, side stories and terminology made it so that the story just became quite dense. And let me not get started on the writing that was soooo slow-paced.

To be honest, about halfway through, I had decided to DNF it. I told myself I’d read a couple more chapters to decide and behold, the story sprung to life again. Only to die a slow death that was the reveal of the plot and the ending of the book. I understand that the ending is the way it is to set up the reader for a sequel, but if it is written as densely as this book, there is no need for any setup. I will not dive into that universe again.

Was this review helpful?

This was comped to Cinder and Sailor Moon - two things I have really enjoyed in the past - so I was looking forward to this.

I wasn't a fan. I pretty much disliked the whole cast of characters. The felt very shallow and very 2023 for a book set in a fantastical (mildly historical) East Asia. The only character I didn't dislike was the cat. Sajah was awesome.
Besides the cat, I did really love the world and the lore that S. Jae-Jones created, but I do wish it had been a bit more in depth.

Overall it felt like this book was relying too heavily on it's comps to get the vibes across than the actual words of the book. I was just left really wanting and really disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

Loved the magic in this story, and wonderful world building as well. I can't wait to read more by this author!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the advanced copy NetGalley and publishers! I really enjoyed this one. I ended up listening to the audiobook from my library. I was very quickly hooked into the story and invested in the characters. It was a fun and enjoyable fantasy.

Was this review helpful?

Charming, fun adventurous world with Cinderella vibes! I loved reading to this book. There’s not very many Ya books that I love anymore but I was never bored!

Was this review helpful?

I did not finish this one, it was not for me, I couldn't relate to the characters, and just did not care for the story.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

Just okay for me. Loved the mythology but the story wasn’t that engaging. Dialogue needs improvement and too much exposition.

Was this review helpful?

Didn't give me enough Sailor Moon vibes.

The portrayal of the characters in the story seemed to be lacking in depth, as they appeared to be one-dimensional and failed to exhibit any complexity or nuance. This made it difficult for me to empathize with them and affected my overall engagement with the story. Additionally, the plot's pacing felt slow, and at times, it seemed to drag on.

Good idea and concept, but wasn't well executed. Overall, just an okay read.

*** Thank you to NetGalley, S. Jae-Jones, St. Martin's Press, and Wednesday Books for graciously sending me a copy of the novel to review. As always, all thoughts are my own.***

Was this review helpful?

This book was a solid 3 that I enjoyed, but honestly don't remember a huge amount about (I'm writing this 5 months after the fact). The characters didn't stick with me and I recall struggling to connect with them. A lot of it was predictable. I would not compare this with Cinder, which was overall a better book.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars
I love fantasy, especially mythology, so I was so excited to read this, but the execution made me regret reading it.
An overall boring read, it lacked the type of writing that made you want to stay up all night. I don't know exactly what it is about this story or the style that makes it so hard to stay engaged with, but I largely attribute my dislike to the writing. The dialogue was very cheesy at times, and there is a lot of telling rather then showing that occurs in this book. The characters were hard to like, and the disability rep is quite frankly terrible. Suzhan was infantilized numerous times, and it feels like the author has no idea what it is actually like to live as a blind person. She is treated more as an invalid then an actual person. It reads more of an after thought then something that was put genuine time and research into.
The characters just feel so...I can't even put into words what is so wrong with them. They are fleshed out, and have different characteristics, they just feel dull. A book about fantasy and magic should never feel dull.
I did enjoy the world-building and all the magic, that was very fun to read.
It becomes very obvious within the first few chapters what is going to happen. While that is not unusual for books, instead of being excited by the journey from point a to point b, it lacked substance.
There is a lot of queer rep, in that the characters that are queer seem to flirt with everything that moves.
It has taken me an inordinate amount of time to slog through this book. I received it as an ARC through Netgalley, and heavily considered dnf-ing it several times.
I personally would not recommend this, nor I will I be reading the next book in the series. At this time I don't think the authors' writing style is for me either.
This is a winning cover, it is absolutely gorgeous, and a lot of people will definitely buy this for how pretty it looks. The composition and design work seamlessly, and I love the font used.
Thank you netgalley for this ARC

Was this review helpful?

The one word I can think of describe this book is this:

Silly.

And that’s not necessarily bad, just don’t go in to this expecting it to be serious. This book relies heavily on the characters sharing one brain cell between them, often as they all often completely miss the obvious. I mean really, something could smack them in the face and they’d still be confused.

Sometimes the silliness did get a little irritating and I found the supposed “humour” to not be funny, as well as feeling tired at how the plot relied so heavily on the characters being so oblivious to literally everything.

But you know, it was fun! The plot was interesting and well paced. I think the world building and back story somehow simultaneously had tons of detail and not enough — things got a bit confusing! And often times I felt the writing was a little clunky, and I had to go back and re-read paragraphs of text before my brain could process what it was trying to tell me (maybe the one brain cell thing was rubbing off on me?).

The ending also left a lot unexplained / rushed. And not in a “you’ll find more out in the sequel” kind of way, but a “quick we are at the end” kind of way. Tons of things were just dumped on page and then it ended, leaving me scratching my head trying to process it all.

All in all, this was a decent read although I did have my issues with it. I will acknowledge that I’m not the target audience for this, and why I enjoy many YA books, I really felt that in this. But still, I liked it and I’ll likely read the second book (but I won’t be rushing).

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure what to expect, I was surprised by one of the authors previous works and was excited to try this one out. This has lots of vibes that I enjoyed from other series, so I am excited to see what is to come as well. I find myself in love with the main character and watching her become who she is meant to be. The magic system and world building were beautiful and make me really excited to see what's to come. A little slow to start, but I was in love regardless.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for the ARC!

The synopsis of this book sounded really interested and I was thrilled when I saw that I was approved for the arc! That being said when I actually got around to reading it I was a bit disappointed.

The Asian mythology and setting were spectacular and the world seemed so beautiful. The FMC Zara is a magician in a world where magic is outlawed. It's got some Cinderella themes and sailor moon vibes.

The story felt really really slow at times and a little too juvenile for my liking. That being said I thought the concept was unique and I'm looking forward to the next book!

Was this review helpful?

A rich fantasy where magic is outlawed and simply being a magician is punishable by death.

Magic was outlawed years ago by the infamous Warlord to rid the realm of abominations--magicians who become possessed and transform into terrible creatures. Zhara is a magician in hiding within the Morning Realms. After her father was put to death, Zhara's cruel stepmother kept her hidden and put her to use as a servant in their household. However, there are rumors circling around the city of Zanhei that monsters are returning.

Meanwhile, Han--the Royal Heir to the Morning Realms--is searching for the mysterious group called the Guardians of Dawn to get help for her little brother whose powers grow ever unstable. After a chance encounter with each other, Han and Zhara join forces with the Guardians of Dawn to put a stop to these monsters and whoever is creating them.

Overall, Guardians of Dawn: Zhara was a good read and rich with folklore.

Was this review helpful?

This book is like an Asian fantasy version of Tangled or Cinderella, with a manipulative, abusive stepmother in a land where magic is illegal and a young woman must hide her gift to stay alive. Yet Zhara can't resist the urge to try to help others using what little she knows, as she feverishly searches for more, and an evil blight begins upon the land’s children. She runs into Prince Han, who is also curious about unearthing the mysteries of the Guardians of Dawn, why his mother was really killed, and how to protect his younger brother, who is starting to show a forbidden ability to conjure magic, an ability which could get him killed.
This is a fantasy book for those who enjoy teen or young adult fantasy suspense books in a world where magic is forbidden and a young girl and the prince secretly try to solve why and save the kingdom.

Was this review helpful?

I’ll have to start this review with a confession, I have not read S. Jae-Jones’ Wintersong duology. After reading Zhara, I will 100% be tracking down a copy of the duology though because I definitely want to read more of S. Jae-Jones’ work after this!

Zhara starts off with an authors note explaining the use of language, and most notably why ‘they’ is used to refer to people in the first introduction. I really loved the way it was used in general, and we meet a couple of non-binary characters within the story which was some lovely representation, especially as one of these characters, Xu, is one of the recurring, most adorable characters.

The story itself is one that keeps your interest, but its driven by a whole cast of amazing characters and, one of my personal weaknesses, a big dash of found family.

Zhara has spent most of her life living with her stepmother and stepsister, following her father being executed for being a magician. She has a job working within the apothecary, but since she feels indebted to her stepmother, for not revealing her own magic, she gives all of her wages to her stepmother and sleeps in the kitchen instead, in a very Cinderella-type of living.

But Zhara has her books, and so the beginning of the story starts out with her heading to the bookshop to buy the latest installment of her favourite romance series. Lo and behold, this is where she bumps into a mysterious, attractive character who she goes on to refer as “Master Plum Blossom”. Master Plum Blossom is an extremely endearing character throughout, and most of my giggles (as with Zhara’s giggles) were aimed at him. I won’t say too much about him, but his scenes with Zhara were utterly adorable.

The story itself is driven by instances of magicians turning into monsters, and our main cast tries to investigate this and attempt to find a cure for it, with the past instances requiring death to end the abomination. Alongside this, Zhara’s stepsister, Suzhan, is being forced to marry so that their family can get out of debt. Zhara obviously loves Suzhan, and this leads to several emotional moments between them.

In terms of representation, alongside non-binary we have a blind side character (Suzhan, slightly in keeping with Cinderella there) and a lesbian character (I won’t talk about them but they are an excellent character, so feisty and flirty). We’re also treated to a couple of animal companions, and they were used in the story in an excellent way.

There are a lot of happy moments throughout, but S. Jae-Jones has teamed this up with complex world-building and some heavy themes (including genocide, and some cases of parental abuse). My heartstrings were tugged at many times and I just really can’t wait to read book two!

Was this review helpful?

This read young, almost middle grade, at times — mainly in the romance scenes. Example line: “He noted her admiring gaze and puffed out his chest, strutting a little as they walked.” (This is the love interest, not some fool the author is making fun of.) And so much blushing!

This read more mature (and enjoyable) everywhere else, though. It’s a China-inspired fantasy and the villains are the real-life Golden Horde (c. 1250-1500 AD). The world is queer norm, with a bi main character, nonbinary and sapphic secondary characters, and an important off-page character referred to as dual-gender. The action and magic scenes were pretty good as well.

I believe each book in this series is going to focus on a different Guardian of Dawn. With that setup (different main characters who hopefully will be less calf-love-lorn), I’m interested enough to give the next book a try.

Was this review helpful?

4 stars for meeting expectations of Sailor Moon/Cinderella vibes. This was written in more of a middle school novel way but I get why it was moved up to a YA for some of the dirty jokes written in. I co-read this with the audiobook, which was wonderfully narrated, and if one is not good with Asian pronunciation for names, I would say give it a go. In all this was a wonderful beginning to a longer series that could be read as a stand-alone if one ignores the last chapter and only reads to the epilogue. I, though, look forward to reading the next in the Guardians of Dawn series.

Was this review helpful?

Guardians of Dawn: Zhara by S. Jae-Jones is an epic adventure that weaves together Korean Fantasy and Magic in a sweeping tale of heroics and sacrifice. The story is full of interesting characters and side plots but I most liked Zhara and Han and their friendship and adorable love of romance stories! They were intriguing characters and it was fun to see the layers of their personalities peel back with each chapter. The monsters in the book were so cool and I loved how the author incorporated mythological creatures from Korean fables. The worldbuilding was detailed and unique and I'd love to read more of this series.

Was this review helpful?

This was a little slow to start for me but once the first bit of excitement started I couldn’t stop. I loved the fantasy aspect of this and the story it told.

Was this review helpful?