Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Woowwwwe omg a story that stays with you!! A friend told me this was a beauty and he beast retelling before I started reading it but it's so much more it's multiple fairy tales woven into one! Infact one of my fav parts is our main man Casamir and the mirror yes a magic mirror! Plus at that beginning it starts with a frog show was actually a prince but our female main character Gesela has to kill him to break her village of a curse, when she does 5 elvin prince show up and banish her to live with the 7th brother "the beast" who is actually hot AF. He makes her a deal if she can guess his name in 7 days he'll let her go but theirs a catch she has to speak it in love. Yup that's right you caught some Rumpelstiltskin in there also! The passion and longing in this books is felt as if you are there Scarlett has an amazing way of making you feel like you are living the life of her characters, the way she world builds without boring you is unmatched as a reader there is a fine line between wanting to see the world im entering and an author who goes a Little too crazy and makes you want to DNF. Scarlett nails world building like no other author can it's just incredible, you truly need to experience it to believe it.

Was this review helpful?

Mountains Made of Glass is a retelling that takes elements of multiple fairytales, such as Beauty and the Beast and Rumplestiltskin, and makes a wholly unique story.
I enjoyed Gesela and the elven king’s relationship, but like most books under 300 pages, it just felt too short. There were a couple of storylines that felt like they wrapped up too quickly. Also, fast burn romance is not my favorite. Overall, I enjoyed it though and I will continue the series.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really awkward read - there’s no progression at all between characters it’s just smut. It was barely a fantasy, basically a plain romance because of how little plot there was.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a mesmerizing tale that weaves together myth and magic, creating a world where gods and mortals collide in an epic battle for power and love. St. Clair's exquisite prose and vivid imagery transport readers to a realm where every page brims with intrigue and emotion. With its richly drawn characters and gripping plot twists, this novel is a captivating journey that will leave readers eagerly awaiting the next installment.

Was this review helpful?

Took me a bit to get into this one, I did enjoy it though, but compared to her A Touch of Darkness series, this one wasn’t my favourite. Looking forward to reading more of Clair’s work. She is a goddess at writing smut 🤭

Was this review helpful?

Scarlett St. Clair is really great at writing an atmospheric setting, especially something like a fairytale. Everything from the forest to the magic to the talking mirror. The vibes were there but unfortunately the romance and overall plot was severely lacking.

The connection felt so rushed and forced between these two characters and I just felt like this had the potential to be so much more than what it was. Sometimes, even the sequencing of scenes didn’t make logical sense so it did not feel very cohesive. I am a little bummed about this one.

2.5 ⭐️
3.5 🌶

Was this review helpful?

This was honestly disappointing. The story had such promise, but it felt rushed and surface-level. The characters have valid personalities and very little character development.

Was this review helpful?

This was the first of the prolific Scarlett St. Clair's books I've read.

Mountains Made of Glass was a bit of a mashup of several fairy tales, including The Frog Prince, Rumplestiltskin, and Beauty and the Beast. Gesela is banished to live with the most beastly of the Elven princes, and a forced proximity romance ensues. The world-building had more of a "snippets of fairy tales" vibe than I am used to seeing in fantasy novels. The ending was solid with no cliff-hangers.

Was this review helpful?

What an interesting fairytale! I like the creativeness of the plot paired with traditional fairytale themes. There were a few parts that were clunky but otherwise the pacing was okay. The characters were likable enough, and the prince truly did shine at the end. There I are some graphic spicy parts, but definitely not how some other reviews made it out to seem.

Thanks for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately I needed to DNF this book 22% of the way in. The sexual content was too much for me. I thought that I would be okay. However, I just need a bit more plot and less sexual or spicy.

Thank you for the ARC copy. I would love to read more books in the future from this publisher. I just think this was not my cup of tea. Thanks again!
I just rated it a one however will not be posting a review on goodreads or anywhere else.

Was this review helpful?

I usually love BatB retellings..: had high hopes for this one, given its promising premise, but ultimately, I found it to be just okay rather than exceptional. I don’t like insta-smut and even smutty books need to be fleshed out to be classified as romance or fantasy rather than straight up erotica.

Was this review helpful?

If you enjoy beauty and the beast retellings with inst-lust and smut on page then I for sure recommend this book. I think that unfortunately I'm a bit fatigued by these themes and so it was a miss for me. But I would still recommend this book if you're in a mood to read any of the above tropes! It was also sadly a DNF for me because of my theme fatigue.

Was this review helpful?

Scarlett St. Clair is a powerhouse of a romantasy writer. She’s prolific and beloved, and I hadn’t read anything by her up to this point. So I was excited to check this book out when I was approached by the publisher for a potential review. I won’t lie, I was especially excited to check out a novella and one that is pulling from various fairytales. I best know St. Clair through references to her “Hades and Persephone” series, and that’s a tough one to get right, so I felt more confident with a fairytale re-telling as an initial entry point to this author’s work.

After now reading this book, I feel like I’m just as unclear on whether or not St. Clair’s books are for me or not. That said, I can now easily understand the appeal for many romantasy fans. Let’s start with that part. Right away, the style of writing appealed to me. There was a nice balance between quick pacing and descriptive prose. The author had clearly read a bunch of fairytales and had no problem capturing the correct tone, writing a story that felt both whimsical and beautiful at times, and violent and disturbing at others. I especially liked just how many fairytale sources were all drawn upon to craft this story. The author even included a note with more details on all of the points of inspiration she pulled upon when writing this book, which I found fascinating.

I also really enjoyed the dialogue and much of the inner monologues we saw from both the hero and the heroine. And while I enjoyed Gesela, Casamir’s chapters turned out to be the most fun. There were a bunch of side characters with whom he interacted, and I loved the ridiculousness of their scenes attempting to point out to their great Fae lord just how inept his attempts at wooing Gesala really were. There was also a captured fairytale prince whose own story veered off into some truly surprising directions.

However, almost from the very start, I struggled with the balance being struck here between plot and spicy scenes. In that…there really was no balance and it was predominantly the latter. No judgement, of course, to readers who are happy with books that lean more in this direction, but for me, I still have fairly high expectations as far as plot goes for my romantasy books. I still want a story, you see. And while yes, there was one here, it was sometimes hard to keep sight of it through all of the insta-lust we had going on.

I was especially put off when, during the very first scene between Gesala and Casamir, we have Gesala completely losing her wits and falling into immediate lust over this complete stranger. And not just “oh, he’s good looking” lust, we’re talking “let’s jump in bed now!” lust. From there, I felt like there were numerous moments where any of the tension or build to the actual love story were undercut by these moments of straight spice. And at a certain point, it became so comical how often Gesala was ending up in contrived situations where she was naked that I started counting. Which really isn’t what I want from a story: to be so distracted by some sort of silliness that I start counting.

I’m not quite sure where to go from here. Reading between all of the spicy scenes, there was a lot to like about this book. I thought the characterization was great, the dialogue was witty and often hilarious, and the fairytale inspiration was spot on. I just didn’t like how much the spicy scenes seemed to overshadow any actual story that was being drawn. The author’s note said she plans on writing stories for all of the other Fae brothers, so maybe I’ll check out the next one of those and go from there. That said, if you enjoy romantasy books with insta-lust/lots of spice, this may be for you. But if you’re looking for more story or plotting to hold things together, this one is on the weaker side.

Rating 7: A bit of a hit or miss reading experience, I really enjoyed the story we had here, but unfortunately the plot often fell to the wayside in lieu of romance scenes.

(Link will go live on The Library Ladies blog on March 27)

Was this review helpful?

Mountains Made of Glass by Scarlett St. Clair
.
This is a fairytale tellings that entwines attributes from many fairytales into one story. Gesela lives in a vaillage that suffers many curses. When it is her turn to break a curse she finds herself swept away into a world full of magic, fairies and an Elven prince who is under his own curse.
.
What I liked:
-I liked trying to figure out what fairytale each new part of the story was influenced by. However after about 5 or 6 chapters I was totally drawn into the story and completely forgot about comparisons.
-Gesela had a great spunky personality. She was a character that made it easy for me to root for her.
-I loved that last chapter. 😈😈😈
.
4⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I’m excited for more, the author plans on doing 6 more books for the Elven Prince’s brothers. Looking forward to them!

Was this review helpful?

I don’t know what I read. But it wasn’t what I was expecting and honestly I shouldn’t read this book. Like for the life of me I don’t remember what this book was about. And that’s terrible. Usually I know what I read but with this book, I just don’t.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately I ended up DNFing at 40%. I couldn’t get into it which is shocking because I have loved Scarlett’s past novels. The plot was all over the place.

Was this review helpful?

I found this fairy tale retelling just ok and I think the biggest drawbacks was that it was a short story so that made it hard for the author to convey a compelling story when so much world building and character building needed to happen to make it great and that just wasnt there in such a short story

Was this review helpful?

I could not get into this one so I sadly was not the right reader but I greatly appreciate the chance to try it early!

Was this review helpful?

3/5 Stars

This was just an okay read for me. I liked the story well enough, I liked the characters and the atmosphere of the book was great. I think I just wanted more from this book. My expectations were just too high and that is my own fault because I enjoyed previous books by this author. Overall I would still recommend reading it as I said I did enjoy and have a good time reading it.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge fan of St. Clair and her longer novels always fit the bill. This wasn't a favorite of mine but I'm convinced it's because it needed a bit more length to fully grow. I definitely enjoyed it but was left wanting more. I'll be continuing for sure.

Was this review helpful?