Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The Witch is Back by Sophie H. Morgan was definitely an enjoyable story.
It was a quick read and entertaining from the beginning.
A sweet, charming and witchy read with the best tropes ever from former childhood sweethearts to fake dating…. What’s not to love.?
This light-hearted romantic comedy stole my heart.
My first time reading Morgan’s work and I’ve gotta say I’m very pleased.
The Witch is Back was a funny, magical, and swoon worthy romance.

"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own."

Thank You NetGalley and Harlequin for your generosity and gifting me a copy of this amazing eARC!

Was this review helpful?

It felt like all of the character development was tied up in the world building, which was, in itself, clunky and protracted. Also most of the background people are just kind of gross and unlikable.

Was this review helpful?

Magical, romantic, tense and heartwarming! 🔮 🖤 🐾 🥮 🍻
Sophie H. Morgan put a spell on me with this novel! I was hooked from first page and read it in one sitting. I loved learning about the magic system, family rankings and familiars while also trying to uncover the mystery of the curse. Super fun, quick read that will make you swoon!

Was this review helpful?

Emma moved to Chicago after getting dumped by her fiancé’, and over the last seven years she has learned to be a stronger witch and a stronger woman. Her mother thinks she is still a disappointing daughter, but if Emma can avoid going home, then she can enjoy having two terrific friends and the developing relationship with her long-lost half-sister, and ignore the Wicked Witch.

Except one day, the bast… er, Bastion, that is, returns. The ex-fiancé. He “needs” to marry her. Not “wants”. And sadly, after explaining why, she may have to say yes. Dear reader, what follows is delightful storytelling. I adored this story and wish that there was magically more of the series ready to read, right this minute. I will be looking for Book 2!

I know your inquiring mind is wondering why I rated this four stars instead of five. The ‘he did this, she did that’ got a bit overlong. I felt like this rehashed some of the same story too often without breaking new ground. I, like Leah and Sloane, also would have liked to see more magic or more of the magic world on the other side of the portal. This is witches and warlocks and magic! Let’s see some magic! We did, but I would like more. Conversely, I appreciated the touch of the forbidden in knowing Leah and Sloane were not allowed to discuss magic or they were they were not supposed to know anything about that world.

Was this review helpful?

Fun and easy romantic read! A shy innocent young witch, with an evil witch for a mother, has to learn to trust the warlock that broke off their engagement years before. Great for fans of the Ex Hex.

Was this review helpful?

Seven years ago, mediocre witch Emma Bluewater escaped from the rigid, stifling, power hungry New Orleans witch society when her fiancé and best friend abruptly fled without leaving any explanations. Shy Emma has now found her place thousands of miles away in Chicago where she owns a bar with her two closest friends. She spends her time baking, volunteering at the animal shelter and hanging out with her younger half-sister. Everything in her calm, orderly life suddenly starts to unravel when her erstwhile fiancé Bastian Truenote waltzes back into her life. He desperately needs her assistance and requests that they resume their engagement in order to help cure his sick mother. But these former friends turned enemies are keeping some very big secrets, even as they start to realize they have some more than friendly feelings. Can they learn to trust each other and turn their engagement of convenience into something real or are they doomed to repeat their past mistakes?

This book was sweet, witchy goodness. Low angst, light, fluffy and fun! Emma is painfully shy, partly her nature and partly from years of mental abuse at the hands of her mother. She’s kind, loyal, fiercely protective of those she loves, but extremely distrustful of outsiders. Bastian is outgoing, a little flighty and irresponsible, funny and devoted to his family. Emma and Bastian balance each other out and bring out the best in each other. Morgan really shows how strong their bond once was and why they feel so deeply betrayed by the other. It’s great character development. Watching them change, grow and find their way back was magical. Morgan’s world building is strong and creative. I’d love to see a second book in the series where she can build on the foundations of the first.

Was this review helpful?

Cute witchy romance. Former childhood friends, Emma and Bastian were arranged marriage fiancés until Bastian disappeared withoiut a word and broke her heart. Emma has built a new life for herself far away from witch society (and her controlling mother), until Bastian returns and begs Emma to honor their marriage contract. But both have secrets and trust issues, so it remains to be seen whether the pair can become friends again as Emma agrees to wed Bastian to save his mother from the curse clause activated when the pair didn't wed in time.

I really enjoyed this story, I like friends to lovers - especially when one secretly loves the other. And both leads were likable, even taking into account Bastian's abandonment. I also liked Emma's friends and wouldn't mind seeing another story set in this world.

ARC courtesy of the publisher via NetGalley, this is an unpaid review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Harlequin and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of The Witch is Back!

This was such a cute, witchy rom-com! The story was so intriguing and unique, and I absolutely devoured it. Emma and Bastian’s relationship was so charming and fun, and the romance was *chefs kiss*. I loved getting to see Emma’s character development throughout the course of the story, and I truly feel like all of the side characters added so much to the story.

This story features so many tropes, so there is definitely something in this book for you! The most note-worthy tropes are childhood-friends-to-lovers, enemies-to-lovers, arranged marriage, and second-chance. There’s also some spice!

I highly recommend this book if you’re looking for a fun, magical witchy rom-com!

Was this review helpful?

Morgan has created an amazing story that takes place in the worlds of witch high society in New Orleans and everyday humankind in Chicago. The Witch is Back has a supernatural mystery, childhood friends who are trying to figure out their relationship as adults and lots of family drama. Emma and Bastion grew up together and were committed by their parents to an arranged marriage. On the verge of an engagement, Bastion ran away with no explanation. When Bastion returns, Emma has created a new life for herself in Chicago outside the witch community. Both are bitter about the events leading to their separation and are reluctant to trust each other. Because supernatural contracts - including the one for Bastion's and Emma's engagement - are truly binding, they agree to move forward and, as part of the process, to live together. I really enjoyed these childhood best friends rediscovering what they liked about each other and appreciating how they have changed and grown up. Theirs is a true love story - including the need for compromise, loyalty and passion. The book is a page turner; I was unable to put it down until I finished.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely devoured this book! Read it in basically one sitting. I just couldn't get enough. Witchy rom coms are my soft spot and I thought this one delivered in all the right ways. It was sweet and charming and the characters were so relatable (even though they have magic). I would love for there to be other books following the other characters because I want more of this group of people!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Harlequin and Net Galley for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of The Witch is Back by Sophie Morgan!

I loved that this book had so many tropes: friends-to-enemies-to-lovers, second chances, and arranged marriages galore! I love a good witchy story, and this one was great. I loved seeing Bastian be so understanding of Emma and her personality. The world building was great, and the supporting characters added fun commentary, and I hope we can see their stories in the future.

Definitely recommend if you are looking for a fun, cute, steamy witchy read!

Was this review helpful?

Great, well-written fantasy story! Emma is a shy witch with weak skills. Her mother is a mean bully. Bastion is the charming, magically powerful son of a socially desirable witch family. Their parents entered into a magically binding marriage contract for Emma and Bastion when they were young. Bastion later left their community suddenly with no explanation, leaving Emma to face the resulting gossip. Jumping forward, Emma escaped her mother and now lives in the human world. She owns a bar with two friends. Emma chose the location of the bar in order to develop a relationship with her secret half-sister. Bastion is eventually forced to return. Emma and Bastion agree to honor the marriage contract, to avoid the consequences of breaking it. Both of them keep secrets to themselves, as they rediscover their friendship and eventually fall in love. All of the plot lines weave together beautifully. The book has romance, magic, witchy politics, adult heat, family dynamics, cute animal familiars, some surprising plot twists and more. Highly recommended! I received an advance copy for free and am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited about reading this book because I've been into witchy or paranormal romance books. The problem is that this book didn't have enough witch or paranormal elements for me. I felt like the magic components were a secondary part of the story. If the magical element was taken it, this could have been a story about an arranged marriage between two families. I really wanted more about magic, but it was really lacking.


I was really put off by the character of Emma's mom. I think that there should have been a warning about the abuse that her mom put on her. It was really difficult to read about how her mom locked her away and kept her from food when she was younger and she also constantly criticized everything about her. The mother's words were deeply upsetting. I also think that Bastian wasn't very kind to Emma. He called her stupid, more than once, and I couldn't get over that.

I couldn't see the connection between Emma and Bastian. It felt forced, and I wasn't really rooting for them. I wish that there was more of the side characters. Overall, I would have liked more romance, magic, and witch elements.

Thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin for an ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This one surprised me - I’m not a huge sappy romance fan. I do like the addition of magic and also the bad mother premise. This one may seem very romance-y on the outside but it goes very deep into a relationship that has flaws but is worth exploring and understanding. Two people who have to look at their lives and the choices they have made. For me to keep reading and finishing this says a lot to the great writing. It is well worth it!

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this from netgalley in exchange for a review.
This book took me a bit to get really get into, but I’m glad I stuck with it.

Emma is a witch living away from her family, running a bar with her witch bff, and a human, enjoying getting to know the secret half sister she found out about after her father died, and trying to avoid her family and high witch society.

Until her contracted fiancé returns. Bastian left when Emma turned 21 leaving a note saying he couldn’t marry her, despite him being her best friend growing up and her humongous crush on him. Now he’s back and wants to fulfill the marriage contract. What is Emma going to do?

Well, the happy ever after definitely happens for Emma and Bastian, but not without a lot of bumps along the way, including a silence hex, Emma’s extremely horrible mother, and some humans who shouldn’t know about witches. I really enjoyed the minor characters in the book, and am hoping that there’s more in this universe so I can learn more about them. My only major complaint is that I felt Emma’s mother deserved worse.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read the book.

This is my second ‘witch’ book- just shows me more that these stories are not my thing. Can’t get into the writing, or characters ect. Not for me.

Was this review helpful?

I was provided with an eARC of this book in exchange for a fair review.

I mostly enjoyed this book. The premise was fun and Emma and Bas made good MCs. I liked the dual POV, too. I liked the magical tattoo thing, which was a fun bit of the magic system. I also loved Chester, the familiar. Sometimes the characters were a little frustrating, but mostly I liked them very much. I’d def read more from this author, because obv we need Kole & Leah’s story, and Tia’s!

Was this review helpful?

🌸 I love romcoms and this book hit all the right notes for me. Start with a friends to lovers trope, mix in a fake dating premise, sprinkle in some magic and it is *chef’s kiss*. The characters were well written, the story was well paced and the storyline flowed nicely. I felt like both Emma and Bastian grew as characters throughout the book and even though they were hard headed and annoying at times, I was still cheering for them in the end. If you’re looking for a spice factor, I’d give it a mild on the salsa scale.

I would definitely recommend keeping this on your radar for when it releases in August! It would be a great witchy read to start off the fall season

Was this review helpful?

A huge thank you to Sophie H, Morgan, Harlequin, and NetGalley for an eARC in exchange for my honest opinion. The Witch is Back comes out August 15, 2023!

Childhood sweethearts, Emma and Bastian, have been in a magical engagement contract for years and everyone was expecting a wedding date announcement. That is until Bastian left with only a one sentence note that he left with his parents. Seven years later Emma is doing great, she has mostly escaped from under her strict mother and is now running a bar with her two best friends. So yes everything is going great until Bastian walks through her bar's doors and pretend to act like nothing happened. After a welcome home party that turns into an engagement party, Emma finds out that is order to save Bastian's mother they have to fulfill the magical contract and get married. Will the two be able to work through their pasts to work towards a bright and magical future.

From the first sentence of The Witch is Back I could not put it down, let's just say I stayed up way to late reading it. The writing was fast-paced, humorous, angsty and romantic. Emma was a shy and strong main female character, who goes through quite a bit of emotional and character development. Bastian was a very layer character who thought he was betrayed by his best friend but stepped up when his mom was sick. Were both characters flawed in their own special ways, absolutely. That being said even when faced with circumstances and odds that weren't great they did what she thought she had to do to defend the people they cared about. I really enjoyed watching work through their past, and there were really great soft moments that made their romance so believable. Honestly if you love second-chance romances that involve freaking witches, The Witch is Back is for sure the book for you.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't like this one. I felt like the author was working way too hard to write a fantasy/witch book and you could tell. Also, the characters were unlikeable and don't even get me started on the misogyny.

Was this review helpful?