Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A fun twist on some very dark topics.

When I started reading this book I really didn't know what to expect. But from the rave reviews I'd read about Tender Is the Flesh, I was excited. The range of stories included in Nineteen Claws and a Blackbird definitely kept me turning the pages, intrigued what the next one would reveal. They were short and entertaining, and the pace was steady. Her descriptions are vivid and occasionally very disturbing, as I discovered in Roberto. A story about a young girl who has a rabbit between her legs. Even though the topics were dark, the author's voice brought a sense of levity to certain scenes. Like in Teicher vs. Nietzche, a man dealing with his ex-girlfriend's cat is surprised to learn it has murderous intentions. There were a couple of stories I found to be on the slower side, but overall this is an enjoyable book, and definitely one to pick up when you want a change of pace.

3/5⭐️⭐️⭐️

For readers who want something unique and surprising, a glimpse into darkness with a twist of humor.

Was this review helpful?

A fantastic collection of weird, funny and almost perfect short stories. I loved every single one.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

In any collection of literary works, some are of more interest and/or appeal than others. These short stories are all dark and unusual; many have children as the viewpoint character. The disturbing and unsettling topics covered in the stories are presented in vivid and precise language that draws the reader into the scene.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Scribner for the e-ARC of this book.
I really had to push through this one to finish. I was so excited to get an ARC of this book, but it was a bit of a disappointment. A few of the stories were a bit creepy, but out of twenty only a few I will remember. Sadly, only a 2.5 star. I will read this author again, but this one just did not hit the mark.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first Agustina Bazterrica book, and I was pleasantly surprised. The stories are dark, and bizarre. It’s unique and imaginative, and I actually really enjoyed reading this book.

Was this review helpful?

This was a different type of read for me. Not sure it’s my cup of tea. It was more of weird fiction short stories and not really horror. I’m sure it had an audience that would love it.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Tender is the Flesh and couldn’t not put it down. With this book it was the opposite. I had to force myself to finish it. I just wasn’t connected to the stories and maybe it’s because I was expecting stories as gruesome as Tender is the Flesh.

The writing was wonderful and melodic at times. I will definitely try again, now that I know what to expect.

Was this review helpful?

This is a cleverly written collection that will speak to a very diverse audience. Did it speak to me personally? It did more often than not and that surprised me. Thankfully.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, this collection of short stories went really dark! I totally wasn't expecting to feel so unsettled after reading them but there is something so unique about the style of writing, and the way that the stories are pushed so close to the point of too much, before pulling you right back. If I had to pick a favourite it would have to be The Solitary Ones - I haven't been able to stop thinking about this one. It was such a creepy idea and the fact that it was set on a train and in the subway gave an added layer of claustrophobia to an already tense story. I also think it would make an amazing film, the atmosphere created (even when they were plunged into complete darkness) was just incredible!

Was this review helpful?

I loved Tender is the Flesh by this same author. This collection not so much. It seemed as though the author was trying to be very philosophical and profound and it just fell flat. Every story felt like I was reading a chapter somewhere in a book and I had no idea what was going on and nothing made sense or had enough to give me any clarity.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and (publisher) for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

Nineteen Claws and a Black Bird is a book of short stories rooted in obscurity, in grotesque, strange metaphor and symbolism. Sometimes they were so strange that I had no idea what was going on. Stories like, "Architecture" or "The Wolfs Breath" are most notable in this category. Even now, their purpose, message, and plot are lost on me. But in stories like, “Anita and Happiness” or “Earth” and “The Solitary Ones” where there was more plot clarity, I was completely engrossed in the narrators internal reasonings/thoughts, the relationships and characters, and the irregularity of these worlds and their scenarios. Even in stories that started out unclear, like “Mary Carminum”, slowly revealed an insane, incredibly engaging plot.

Perspective allowed some really interesting exploration of tough topics like child abuse and death. I think of "The Dead" first, in which the speaker is a kid who wants to be with his dead mother 'on the moon' but is stuck with his abusive and neglectful father. I interpreted this story as being a really intense representation of grief mystifying reality. This was only possible because the speaker was too small to understand things as they are. The legs of a woman become spiders. Cremated remains become evil he can't cleanse out. And the solution to all this is sad and somewhat gory. As a reader who is incredibly intrigued by this plot, I really wished this was longer actually! I believe this for a handful of other stories here too. As a writer, I think the ending was really genius and this was just a glimpse into what could be a much bigger story. However, all in all, I appreciated the brevity of each story. Most of them had some insane openers and satisfying endings, making them easier to get through. Stories that had very distinct plot and characters had great momentum and speed.

My ultimate criticism though is that I don’t feel that the blurb efficiently summarizes what this book is and does not give an adequate warning to some of its content. As for funny, I think there is very little humor here. Candy Pink was the only one that was distinctly funny, though I still read this one as more depressing! I can see glimpses of it in certain stories, but it often comes through the delusions of the speaker (which I usually read as mental illness or mental deterioration and therefore, did not consider it funny). “Dark” also really doesn’t begin to encapsulate some of these stories. There’s body horror and blood in a lot of these. But most of darker content is insinuated. Things like suicide, rape, and child abuse are often explored through metaphor and symbolism. Other times it’s very blatant, but the details are left out, which I appreciated. And a few select times, it is giving lots of detail actually, which I didn’t love so much. I will say Candy Pink, in my opinion, is one of the more detailed stories. I don’t think these details and themes are bad by any means but I think it should be made a bit clearer somehow that it’s tackling some heavy stuff.

I read Tender is the Flesh a few years ago which I enjoyed. And I can say this is so incredibly different from it, in the best way possible. Sure, they share similarities in their gruesomeness, in metaphor. But the writing and lyricism of this was completely unexpected. While I do feel that Bazterrica flourishes in long form, these short stories felt experimental and fresh. I think some of these stories could stand to be more fleshed out and detailed, while some of them would do better with just some clarity. Overall though, it was an interesting read that showed me a different form of writing from this author I already know and love. I’m super grateful I got to read it.

Was this review helpful?

a creepy collection with creative prose - i never read tender is the flesh and this one def made me curious to check it out. that said, more stories fell flat for me than not which was a bummer. the ones that were strong were Rly strong but the ones that weren't sort of ruined it for everyone !! also some big trigger warnings for violence, SA, etc in this one, def explored themes i wasn't expecting. i could appreciate the 'shock' of 'going there' and didn't have a problem with those themes being explored personally, but def some fricked up content at times!

Was this review helpful?

I thank the publisher for allowing me to read this translated story early.
I am a massive fan of Agustina's work 'Tender is the Flesh,' a horror short story book by them? Sign me up! Except this was a big flop. It is actually from 2020, and the writing is far from what we read in TITF. I had to DNF; I was taken aback by Roberto's story, an unnecessary and no warning of a child being molested by their teacher on a page; it felt like shock value. The writing was painfully written out every detail to the point where half was out of space thoughts and nothing happening. It was easy to get stuck on a not even 200-page book taking me 2 hours to get 20% through. None of the stories I read were horror and were too short to make a impact on the readers. I would only recommend this book if you get it at the library. Otherwise, you probably won't like how much money you spend on something you won't reread.

Was this review helpful?

What a wild ride! I love Bazterrica's writing style and ability to weave together darkness and humor. Each story had a lingering sense of unease which was balanced with moments of unexpected laughter.

"Candy Pink" was a standout for me. This story follows a woman as she navigates the aftermath of a difficult breakup, struggling to come to terms with her own emotions. Through her razor-sharp wit and insightful observations, Bazterrica unveils the universal truths hidden within the intimate moments of heartbreak. Other favorites for me include "Anita and Happiness" and "The Solitary Ones".

If you were a fan of Tender is the Flesh, I would definitely recommend checking this out!

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick read full of bazaar, entertaining stories. If you're a fan of weird but beautifully written short stories, I would definitely check this one out!!

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited hear about the book after reading Tender is the flesh and it did not disappoint! Loved this collection! Love this author’s style of writing. My favorite was Mary Carminum.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun horror read! Nineteen Claws and A Black Bird is a collection of short horror stories each having their own vibe and pov style (1st person, 3rd person, and even 2nd person pov). Dont be put off by the book starting out in 2nd person because it changes each chapter. Each story was super unique and not like anything else Ive read before and most I couldn't even begin to predict how it would end. A few of the stories I found a bit lackluster, while others were lighthearted and funny, eerie and grim or just straight WTF did I just read. Some chapters focus more on body horror but many were more that were strange and closer to a literary/psychological horror (my favorite kind). It was a super fun and fast read overall!

Was this review helpful?

Inventive, immersive, creepy, and fun. Sometimes I struggle with short story collections when they don't feel cohesive, but I eagerly turned the pages. Bazterrica is a breath of fresh air.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this book!
This book was a haunting, captivating, mesmerizing look into all the weird gory parts of the human condition, even for me, someone who does not read horror. I'll admit, some of it totally went over my head, but even so, I enjoyed chilling in the minds of other people. It's always fun for me to explore the world from other perspectives, fictitious or not. I love the way Bazterrica writes, the lyrical descriptions and striking sentences make it difficult to take my eyes off the page. Luckily, being a short story collection, you can easily take a break between stories and it's good if you can only find a couple minutes in your day to read.
I loved how creative this carefully crafted collection was, but was certainly confused by some of it, thus I'm giving it 4/5 stars. Definitely worth a try, this might just be your cup of tea if you love horror.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Scribner and NetGalley for this advanced digital copy. I absolutely loved Tender Is The Flesh and Augustina’s unique writing style. Unfortunately It really didn’t work for me in short story form. It was a bit too poetic maybe? Very descriptive with a lot of metaphors. In a longer form that works for me and I really enjoy it. It short form it often left me confused and wondering, is she talking about this person being an actual eagle or is it a metaphor? A few stories I flat out had no clue what was happening but there were a couple great ones! There was a quote in one story that said “You’re always confusing me with your strange, deep sentences.” And that is how I felt about a lot of this book. Definitely some trigger warnings here. Death, suicide, child sexual abuse etc. This had a few great standouts that I was wishing were longer but all in all this was a bit of a miss for me.

Was this review helpful?