Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was beautifull written and it's not just the ancient egyptian history, the vibrant archeological atmosphere, or the mysterious characters with questionable motives. As far as a first book in a series goes, this has everything you need - fun setting, engaging plot, likeable characters, and great writing - to get invested in the story and, with that ending, i know I'm hooked and cant wait for the sequel!!

Was this review helpful?

This book is so magical. The atmosphere is everything. The protagonist, Inez, is a wonderfully interesting woman. She embarks on a journey to the mystical Egypt to uncover the truth about her parents.

While I found this book more magical and mystical than gothic, the development is phenomenal. The mystery is well done and intricately crafted. Inez’s relationship with her uncle’s man, Whit, is also infuriatingly intriguing.

I highly recommend this book to everyone. It is phenomenal.

Was this review helpful?

🄱🄾🄾🄺 🅁🄴🅅🄸🄴🅆📚
What The River Knows (ARC)
@isabelwriter09
4.75⭐️

Release Date: 10/31/2023
Happy Release Day! 🎉

Inez belongs in the 19th century high society Buenos Aires. She has everything she could possibly want. All except her parents, who have been traveling for the most part of her life. But when she receives a package from her father, one with ancient magic that have seeped into her, and news of her parents' deaths, she knew she had to find the truth. She sails to Cairo for answers, but gets thwarted by his uncle's annoyingly handsome assistant. Secrets run deep, and Inez risks being a pawn to this archeological and familial whirlwind.

Oh. My. Gosh. This is another one of those books I was ranting about a few weeks ago.

Immediately into the first few chapters, it was already interesting and fascinating. There's this immediate mystery to her parents' deaths, the "dig" and the significance of the ring that was sent to her. I will say, it's like watching a movie in my head when Inez initially came to Egypt and had to escape a couple of people (ahem, Whit) and hurdles! Now let's talk about Whit. What a big fat flirt! The banter and interactions between Inez and Whit were so entertaining and it made my heart happy reading about them. The romance was clean but the teasing was amazing! Very apt for the 1800s.

This book mostly has Inez's POV but every few chapters, there are very short sections of Whit's POV and they are a delight! Sometimes they're just one word or sentence and they made me laugh! His comments matched his personality so much! But I definitely got a mysterious and brooding vibe from him. About 20% of the book, the plot picks up very quickly. The plot is unpredictable and deceitful.

THE ENDING! MASSIVE REVEAL AND CLIFFHANGER! I cannot believe it ended how it did! I seriously need the next book RIGHT NOW!!! I died. DEATH BY PLOT!!!

There was so much happening. There's adventure, magic, romance, mystery - you would think that it's trying too hard to do a lot at once. But it was so well written that the author made it work. Love!

Thank you @stmartinspress and @netgalley for a free e-copy in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I loved absolutely everything about What the River Knows. The history, the magic, the romance - it is all so good!

Inez is a force of nature, and I love her with every fiber of my being. She and Whit had fantastic banter, and the simmering tension, phew!!

I’d like everyone to read this and then have to suffer waiting for book 2 right along with me.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Isabel Ibañez for providing me with a complimentary digital ARC for What the River Knows coming out October 31, 2023. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own. 


This is the first book I’ve read from this author. I’ve been obsessed with ancient Egypt for a long time so a book set in the 1800s about discovering ancient tombs in Egypt sounded amazing. I thought the magic aspect was done really well. The magic had rules that I felt were explained well. The writing was just so amazing! I absolutely loved the characters! I thought they had layers and complexities to them. Inez and Whit were by far my favorite characters. I loved that they came from two different worlds and had to work together. It’s very much like the Mummy, which I loved. It was 400 pages, but it didn’t feel long and it held my attention the entire time. I can’t wait for book 2 to be released!

I would recommend this to anyone who enjoys books about ancient Egypt, Victorian Era and magic.

Was this review helpful?

: 3.5 / 5

Publication Date: October 31, 2023

I want to thank St. Martin’s Press, Wednesday Books and Net Galley for allowing me to get an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!

The prologue did a great job at establishing the catalyst for the rest of this story. We find ourselves in Argentina with Inez and her aunt and cousins.

One of the coolest aspects of this story, was the vivid descriptions of Egypt from Alexandria to Cairo and beyond. The atmosphere surrounding the markets of Egypt and even archaeological sites were truly enchanting. I also loved the fact that Spanish was sprinkled in from time to time.

As for my reservations, there’s quite a few. This feels like it’s a younger tone to almost all of the story except for the final chapters which I found jarring my violent and out of the blue. The Whit POV being used so inconsistently was also frustrating. Additionally, the ending felt abrupt. I kept going back and forth on the final pages to make sure I hadn’t missed something because it felt like a scene that ended prematurely. Some of the “twists” were very predictable.

Overall I wanted more from this book. I really had such high hopes and I just don’t think this first book in the series quite did it for me. While it’s written in a way that’s both beautiful and accessible I still was hoping for more.

Would recommend for those who are fans of
- Historical fiction
- Egyptian history
- Enemies to friends?
- Dual POVs

⚠️ colonization

Was this review helpful?

This is such a beautiful book! This historical fantasy follows 19-year old Inez as she tries to uncover the truth about her parents’ deaths. Her uncle has hired Whitford Hayes to stop her in her search. Also, the old magic she is imbued with is pulling her towards something that will reveal more than she is prepared for.

There is banter, delicious slow burn, secrets, and mysteries! I loved it, especially how strong Inez is as a character. She is proactive, curious, and determined. Watching her story unfold was incredible.

Was this review helpful?

What the River Knows had me hooked from the very first page. It was filled with great imagery and adventure, Egyptian history and archeology, secrets, lies, and intrigue. Our main characters are strong and fearless and the banter and slow-burn between them is *chefs kiss*.

Isabel Ibañez has spinned a story full of so many secrets, she gives us morsels throughout and I second guesssed myself a few times when trying to figure out where the story was taking us.

Inez Olivera is full of determination and a risk taker. She’s the “act now and think about the consequences later” type. She has a huge heart and cares deeply for her family.

When she loses her parents she doesn’t think twice about leaving the comfort of her upper class home to find out what truly happened to them. She seeks answers, and never expects the adventure that awaits her.

The slow burning love story left me wanting more, just the way I like it. Whitford Hayes is that broody, mysterious love interest that we know is full of secrets. The need to know more is what pulls Inez in. Their interactions and growing relationship was another adventure on its own.

“He was the kind of person who could charm someone while robbing them blind.”

I fell in love with this story! If you love historical fantasies paired with secrets and intrigue, fun banter, a sprinkle of magic, and a good slow-burn romance, then be sure to pick this one up.


*A huge thanks to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for providing me with an eARC for review. All thoughts are my own.*

Was this review helpful?

The setting and story were right up my alley, taking place in Egypt with magic and a mystery… sign me up. The pacing was a little slow but the story itself was lovely and beautifully written. I cannot wait for the sequel.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Isabel Ibañez, and St. Martin's Press and Wednesday Books for the opportunity to read this book early. I have loved Isabel's previous works, so What The River Knows has been one of my most anticipated reads of the year.
This book did not disappoint. The immersive world building, and colourful characters left me wanting more. Luckily, there will be a sequel.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and St Martens Press for the eARC of What the River Knows.

Unfortunately .. I’m DNFing at 52%. I don’t want to, I’ve come so far and I hate to have wasted the time.. but I’m not enjoying myself.

This had a LOT of promise. Initially I thought it was so cool and unique to have a fantasy like this. Such a refreshing setting and idea.

Within the first 10% I was unsure. The letter from her uncle really just.. gave away the entire plot to me. Instantly. “Your parents are dead, I am in charge of your trust” like oh.. that’s not suspicious. Then it literally takes her until 50% in to be like “dear god, I think my uncle might have killed my parents! Maybe… my money has something to do with this!!” Which she puts together after.. she finds two other letters.

I thought okay, well the love story seems like it’ll keep me tethered. No. It’s been the same dynamic this whole time really.

Also if there is going to be marketing that this is, in part, a fantasy.. I would expect more of a fantasy element to be involved by the halfway mark. I’m reading this slowly because I’m obviously not into it, so five hours in, and the magic is literally just tingly feelings and flashbacks, a shoe that turns into a lantern. And she has a connection with Cleopatra? What a.. really special snowflake she is for some reason.

It reads like a historical fiction. Obviously a lot of research went into the setting both in location and time. From what I can tell the author has a lot of respect for Egypt. I will say, the environment, culture, and history of colonialism seemed well flushed out. I would genuinely enjoy trying out some Egyptian food some time based off the descriptions of that.

Plot/motivation wise.. I don’t care about her parents death anymore, not really sure why she does either enough to be making these uncharacteristically risky (wasn’t she like super sheltered and proper) and realistically super stupid (girl you’re gonna die) decisions to find out what happened. They were selfish and absent people, so it seems.

But the MAIN REASON I am DNFing is because one of my biggest book icks is when I notice the same phrases or key elements being mentioned too frequently. At first it was how often Mr Hayes was drinking from his flask. Like uhh it’s giving ~alcoholism~ not “this man is hurt and is trying to numb the pain” which is what I think it was going for. Multiple times she said or thought he should have some bread to soak it up. Then, constantly describing the color of his hair. It was a reddish brown, brown with a hint of red in the light, now a dark brown when wet.. and then his blue eyes- both of these things it was at one point 3x in a chapter or once on a page on consecutive pages. So his whole personality was those two physical qualities, booze, not telling her anything, and flirting to redirect. Once I got to the third “he leaned against the wall, crossing his arms and his legs at the ankles” it was a wrap for me.

It just wasn’t developing enough for me to continue to dedicate hours to, when I have an extensive TBR. I don’t have time for a
book slump, which I see on the horizon. And to find out from other reviews it ends on a cliffhanger? Why not just…make this book more fulfilled. Like I said, genuinely awesome idea. Probably should have just kept the bones of it and made it a normal historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

The story and cover immediately captured my interest. I was very excited when I received an ARC, The Mummy is a beloved film and the more I can read stories like it, the better! Unfortunately, my anticipation was in conflict with the actual reading experience. It was an interesting historical setting but the dialogue felt very modern between the characters and within the main character's first person narrative. I found the characters likeable enough. Inez and Whit are good pair and I am most intrigued by their development. The magic system is pretty simple--which is fine since it didn't complicate the story. The pacing was very drawn out, perhaps a critique on setup for a sequel affecting development. It is worth mentioning that the art alongside the book is beautiful. I wish it had It would have been featured within the pages since the main character, like the author, has an artist background and it was ever evident in the visual styling of the writing. It could have added to the reading experience.

Was this review helpful?

YALLLL I LOVE THIS BOOK. I've been in a YA funk ever since Covid and I've not been able to find a YA book that has truly gripped me and kept me engaged. This book follows Inez, a nineteen year old Bolivian-Argentinian who years to be in Egypt with her parents. Her parents are archeologists who spend 6 months of the year in Egypt while Inez stays back with her aunt and her cousins. Inez has a curious spirit, so when she gets a letter from her uncle in Egypt that her parents are MIA and considered dead, she knows she must go to Egypt to find out whatever she can.

The research that had to have gone into this story is absolutely astounding. The Egyptian culture and history are ever-present in the story in a way that had me feeling I was immersed in the streets of Cairo myself. The descriptions were so vivid and the stories were so haunting that I couldn't help but fall for every aspect of the plot.

I loved the characters. Inez's uncle made me want to strangle him a few times, but I ended up kind of liking him toward the end of the book. Elvira, Inez's cousin, was such a calming presence even though she wasn't active in the story for the long. She acted as a sister to Inez who had no siblings, only her mother and father.

Inez was such a determined, curious, and loving female main character who would stop at nothing to figure out what happened to her parents. I rooted for her along the whole journey because I had to admire her determination she had to find her parents. Whit was a smart, protective, and cunning character who had me swooning since his first time on page!! As I've gotten older, it takes a lot for me to swoon over a character, especially YA. HOWEVER! Whitford Hayes did the unthinkable and had me swooning over his protective nature and willingness to do whatever to protect Inez from danger. Like, c'mon. Who DIDN'T swoon over that button!!

Can we just talk about that ending??? The last chapter already had me super excited for the next book but then that epilogue! What a crazy ending that I'm still not sure what means, so I am beyond excited for the next book.

I received this as an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

The Mummy meets Death on the Nile in this glittering historical fantasy set in nineteenth century Egypt. Steeped in adventure, romance, and ancient magic, this is a story I couldn’t put down.

First, I must say - I AM UNWELL. The tension… the adrenaline… the agony… the HEAT… and the cliffhanger… 🫠 I may or may not have already looked to see when we get the next book… that’s how desperate I am for these characters and this story.

I absolutely love the setting of this story and the world building did not disappoint. The imagery was vibrant and vivid, and the plot kept me on the edge of my seat the entire time. Seriously. The whole time. The adventure and the mystery and the secrets are beautifully woven together

But let’s talk about this romance…. THE ANGST. THE TENSION. THE YEARNING. I am gone for Inez and Whit. They have my heart. I was enamored from the moment they met each other and now I am so invested in their stories, that my heart aches to know what happens next.

Overall: Read. This. Book. PLEASE. It’s catapulted to my top three reads of the year, and I’m already dying to have the next book in my hands.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC of this novel (of which I actually finished before publication date....which has not been my norm lately) anyways 4/5 stars.

I fell in love with this the same way I did with Ibanez's other work to where I wasn't sure at the beginning but then the lush writing and story telling and beautifully crafted histories and stories drew me in. The combination of archaeology and the late 1800s and murder (?) mysteries and like...Indiana Jones vibes really just was *chef's kiss*

Inez is a headstrong character who comes from high society in Buenos Aires...and ends up on an archeological dig. It's important to note her status though, because it accounts for a lot of the things in the book. Her mysterious uncle....the hunt for cleopatra's tomb....magical artifacts....there's just so many things about this I loved.

Oh, and Whit. We can't forget Whit. Or the tension between him and Inez. I would like one Whit, please.

The only things I didn't like were that I DIDN'T KNOW THIS WAS A SERIES?? and also...there were maybe a bit too many twists and revelations at the end. I felt like my head was spinning and some of them were just....meh. Will I be reading the next book? absolutely.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press, Wednesday Books for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for an honest review.

4/5 stars

This book synopsis had me intrigued. I always love Egyptian history so I was excited to see a book incorporate this. I didn’t expect to fall in love with the characters! The author weaved a fun story that kept me interested!

Inez takes after her parents for her sense of adventure. I enjoyed that she went after what she wanted and wasn’t afraid to take risks!

Whit was such a fun character and I enjoyed getting to know him and watch his banter! His countenance held so many secrets I was excited to find out more.

That ending! Did not expect that and I really enjoyed it (even if I’m dying for book 2)! My own complaint is the pacing. It was very slow in the beginning setting up the world. Which was needed but I wish it was broke up a bit. It felt like a lot of knowledge dump at times.

Was this review helpful?

Adventure, romance, magic and Egyptian tombs, all of my favorites! This story had good pacing, was funny and I was surprised with many of the events that happened. I know the main character is portrayed as very curious and inquisitive, but at times I was like, ‘stop worrying already!’. But towards the end of the book I see that she had all the resin to be worried. I didn’t know this book is part of a sequel, so eager to read the next book.

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the Advanced copy of this book. This review was written voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

eARC Review: What The River Knows by Isabel Ibañez

Pub Date: October 31st 2023

My Rating: 4.5/5 stars

Thank you to Netgalley and Wednesday Books for an early copy of this book to review!

My Thoughts: Everyone has a subject that they are strangely interested in and obsessed with. Ancient Egypt has always fascinated me so when I saw this on Netgalley I knew I had to request it. The author did a great job of creating an atmospheric book for the reader to get lost in. I felt like I was with the characters in Egypt during the late 1800s. Along with the magical atmosphere, I loved the characters and the story itself. I’m so glad there was romance because I am for sure a romance girly. The mystery plot line had me guessing until the end, and I can’t wait for the sequel to see where it goes!

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5 ⭐

Having a newborn makes reading these days a little challenging. So when a book comes along and makes you forget about how tired you are and keeps you up late at night when you should be catching up on sleep, you know it's a good one.

Isabel Ibañez draws you right into the lush world of Egypt as Inez, our main character tries to solve a personal mystery. So many times I felt like I was walking down the streets of Cairo myself. The fantasy elements in this are more along the lines of magical realism, where random objects in the world hold magical properties. We have love, adventure and betrayals up the wazoo!

If you're like me, and you loved National Treasure or the Mummy, prepare to have your boots knocked off. There's plenty of twists and turns and that ending, OMG!

I hope this book picks up steam because it deserves every bit of positive attention. If you liked Divine Rivals (another banger imo), then I think you'll love What the River Knows.

Thank you Netgalley and St. Martins Press for a copy of this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

What the River knows is a fun YA fantasy heavy on the archeology vibes and light on the magic. When Inez learns her parents are presumed dead on an expedition in Egypt, she travels there from her home in Buenos Aires to find out what happened to them. The problem is she has no idea who to trust.

I found this story entertaining. It is interesting to see the relationship between England and Egypt as seen through the eyes of the main character, and the story certainly problematizes the way Egyptian artifacts were excavated and sold to westerners instead of staying in Egypt. I also liked the suspense and romance in this book- I did have a hard time warming to the FMC though- she is headstrong, but often in ways that are not very smart, and things that seemed obvious to me as a reader were not the case with her. It is hard to root for someone who is their own worst enemy. I also wasn't a huge fan of the ending- I knew there would be more to come, but the particular turn it takes was frustrating.

Will I still want want to read the next book? Yes, yes I will.

Many thanks to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for an eARC of this book in exchange for this fair review.

Was this review helpful?