Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you, NetGalley, for this book.

Clara’s town of Grimm Hollow is next to the Grimm Forest, which normally isn’t a problem. But when a townsperson is murdered, the Forest closes itself off to the townspeople, who still try to enter but become Lost.

Clara and her friends find a loophole and safely enter the Forest in an attempt to find the Lost. Through many trials, they meet some of their townspeople who have forgotten their true identities. And an enormous wolf follows them.

This book was a really fun take on a variety of fairy tales, mostly Little Red Riding Hood, but many others are blended in. This was a really creative book, and I definitely recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

An eerie, dark and subversive fairytale that wraps many classic storybook heroes together in an enchanted forest where their happily-ever-afters have gone horribly wrong, and protagonist Clara sets out to make things right again. This novel is mostly action and adventure based, with a heavy emotional motivation guiding our main characters through their journeys to try and change what seem to be cruel fates. While I had fun, I found the pacing to be a bit odd and the happenstances of the magical forest to be a bit too convenient. The writing was repetitive at times, reminding us of Clara's goal and her reasons behind her actions - the book of fortunes, her grandmothers' cards, the red rampion. Many phrases grinded into the reader's brain so we don't forget when it ultimately all comes together for a conclusion, and it was just a tag heavy on the hand-holding. I did adore the friends-to-lovers plot and the overarching theme of love and being true to one's heart's desires. The concept of the titular Forest Grimm is fairly straightforward, and I hope the sequel provides more insight behind the curse and leans more into the fairytales-gone-wrong aspect.

Was this review helpful?

Was in the mood for a YA fantasy, and looked through my unfortunately long. past due Netgalley TBR. The Forest Grimm was a wonderful, part one of a duology that features fairytale characters in a reimagined setting. 5-stars because it's memorable and I want to read the second part!

Things that made this book an amazing read: 
-Clara. The main character can get a bit repetitive with her seemingly tragic life, but she's otherwise everything I want in a main character: she's headstrong, apologetic when necessary, adventurous, and kind. She's the kind of character that I'd want to be, and I would have wanted to be her if I read this book 20 years ago.  
- a slowburn romance: this is very YA, middle grade. No long makeout sessions, so don't go in expecting it. But the romance is sweet and has a great build.
- The use of fairytale characters. I won't give a spoiler, but fairytale characters aren't fairytales in their traditional sense- there is no real awareness of stories like Hansel and Gretel, Cinderella, Little Red Riding Hood, but there is a framework for it in the story.

The ending is an ending in that many issues get resolved, but this is obviously part 1 of a duology. I guess one benefit of reading this book late is that the conclusion is already out and looks like it is just as good!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 rounded up

I actually really enjoyed this fresh take on fairytales. We are following a village that has been blessed by the nearby forest and it's magic with a book that can grant a heart's true desires. However, one day when someone uses the book to murder a fellow villager, the forest turns on them and curses them - crops are dying, the book is gone, and people are going missing.

One of the lost people is Clara (our FMC's) mother. Clara is determined to enter the forest and find her mother no matter the cost. Mix in a little bit of star crossed lovers, fairy tale retellings, and tarot card magic and you've got The Forest Grimm.

I liked the way the fairytale retellings were redone, we often see them as straight retellings but I feel like this book did a good job on twisting in the Grimm Brother's side of things and used them as the obstacles of the story rather than the heroes. The Forest Grimm itself is also a really unique setting.

I also enjoyed our main characters, I wish we had gotten a bit more from Clara & Henni's friendship - it started off so well then somewhat faltered through out the book. I also enjoyed the romance aspect.

The ending was enough to make me want to read the sequel, so I call that a win!

I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoyed the Once Upon a Time tv show or just enjoys a darker twist on their favorite fairytales.

Was this review helpful?

The Forest Grimm is a moody, beautifully atmospheric YA fantasy that blends familiar Grimm motifs into a fresh, forest-based quest. It's perfect if you crave dark fairy-tale vibes and a slow-burn journey. Expect some exposition-heavy setup and character development that may not appeal to everyone-but if atmospheric adventure and fairytale homage are your thing, it's worth the plunge.

Was this review helpful?

Another fairytale foray that only left me lukewarm. I just feel like the stakes of the plot did not hold up- nor did I care about the characters enough to be that invested in the outcome. Overall, somewhat disappointing.

Was this review helpful?

Finally a book that acknowledges how completely unhinged Grimm's fairy tales are! And does it with romance, lush descriptions (it made me forget that wool is itchy!), adventure, and only the amount of cannibalism you could reasonably expect!

Was this review helpful?

I was very excited about this book because I really enjoyed the authors previous Bone Crier duology. However, while the concept was good, the execution wasn’t there. The fairy tales weren’t well integrated and didn’t flow well into the storyline. I did appreciate that she leaned into the creepy parts of Grimm tales. I didn’t feel connected or attached to the characters, they lacked depth. This is also definitely a younger YA book which may have hindered my enjoyment. I am disappointed and will not be continuing the series.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t know why, but I just could not get into this book despite multiple attempts. Sadly, I had to DNF. It just wasn’t for me.

Was this review helpful?

This book was very enjoyable. I liked all the characters and the side characters.
The story did drag a little but all the twists on various fairytales were fun!

Thanks NetGalley and Wednesday books for the chance to read this!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press/Wednesday Books, and Katheryn Purdie for an advanced copy of The Forest Grimm in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

This was such an interesting, unique take on the fairytale retelling genre. It had so many of Grimm’s original tales woven together to create a phenomenal story of family and the lengths that some will go to to save the people they love. The writing was lush and atmospheric and twisted. I loved that the characters had flaws, but I still rooted for them to succeed on their journey. And the ending! I cannot wait to pick up the next book to find out what happens.

Was this review helpful?

This YA fantasy is based on a magical forest where fairy tales come to life and lure the local townspeople in to play the characters. Clara's mother disappeared into the forest along with her best friend's sister, and they attempt to rescue their family members along with the sister's fiance. As the trio attempts to survive the forest, find their loved ones, and break the forest's curse, battling fire swamp levels of danger.

Great world-building and character development. I would say this has a bit of light horror, a la T. Kingfisher.

Was this review helpful?

A dark and eerie mashup of fairy tales, this was more interesting in theory than on paper. It was a great premise and the mashup of such well-known fairytales was fun. I would read the sequel just to see what happens but I'm not rushing to find it.

Thank you to St. Martin's Press, Wednesday Books and NetGalley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really fun read with the mashup of fairytales! I really enjoy Kathryn Purdie's books. This was fast paced and a fun read. I enjoyed the small amount of romance (there is no spice). It was fun to read a YA book that focused on the wood's curse. I loved that on their adventure Henri, Axel and Clara run into familiar fairy tale characters. Loved the found family aspect and the world. I will def. read the second book soon! Thank you for the e-arc and so sorry for how late I am reading and reviewing.

Was this review helpful?

This novel is a retelling of many fairytales! I love the twists in each of them! I did think that this story felt like many short stories combined into one but it was still a great read! I love how it ended with a cliffhanger! I can’t wait for a sequel! This novel is sure to please fans of Marissa Meyer!

Was this review helpful?

Twisted fairytales!

Clara is determined to save her lost mother from the Forest Grimm where she wandered into three years ago. Her best friends Axel and Henni join Clara and they want to save Henni’s lost sister also. The Forest Grimm changed when a curse happened in Grimm Hollow and twisted the magic that used to be helpful to the villagers. The three are in danger of becoming lost themselves because the Forest moves and changes. They are surrounded by creatures who want to cause them harm. They can only trust each other and hope that trust is enough to save them.

Likes/dislikes: Axel’s gift for finding silver linings in any situation is charming. I enjoyed the story of the young ghost, Ollie. It adds a bit of spookiness and melancholy. The author wove a creepy tale of twisted magic.
Mature content: PG for kissing.
Language: PG for 3 swears.
Violence: PG for death.
Ethnicity: falls to white.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately time lapsed on this and I was unable to fit it into my reading schedule so I will have to refrain from commenting and reviewing on it.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Wednesday books for the arc.

DNF 15% in.

I really enjoyed Kathryn Purdie's bone crier's moon duet so I was excited for this one but sadly this one didn't work as well for me. Part of the issue is I requested this when I still really enjoyed YA and I have become very pick about my YA and this one didn't work for me. I also just couldn't connect with the characters and didn't care for them which made me feel like I was just forcing myself through this one.

Was this review helpful?

I am here for all of the retellings with fairy tales and "The Forest Grimm" was no different. I started drawn into this story with the cover and the title. Clara sets out to find a magical book that she hopes will reverse the curse on her village, but the one obstacle on this quest is the enchanted forest. The way Kathryn Purdie wove together a number of tales and components from the tales kept me on my toes as I read. I couldn't wait to see how the next detail was going to go. I also couldn't help but root for Clara and Axel throughout as they worked together to decipher what was real and how they were going to continue on their quest. Thank you to Wednesday Books for a copy! All thoughts and opinions are my own!

Was this review helpful?

DNF at like 53% :( heartbreaking I was really excited for this I heard great things but ultimately not for me I guess.

Was this review helpful?