Member Reviews

Review is posted to social link here on Goodreads, includes content warnings:

Was this review helpful?

In 1951, Edie and Lucy become friends. They are 15 and lives in small town Ludthorpe. But Lucy has a secret and she disappears. The book jumps to 2018 and Edie still lives in Ludthorpe but has some memory issues. One day she sees Lucy, still 15 walking down the road. Nobody will believe her. There's a lot Edie gets confused about these days. A lot she finds difficult to remember. But what she does know is this: she must find out what happened to Lucy, all those years ago . . .

Was this review helpful?

Didn't finish this, was not at all what I expected from the synopsis. Certainly not bad, but don't feel that we need this in our collection.

Was this review helpful?

Extremely well done. One Puzzling Afternoon takes the story of Edie, told in two timelines, and makes it a one woman show. One storyline is when Lucy is a teenager in high school, the other when she is in her eighties and showing signs of dementia.

The story was a little bit of a slow start for me but by halfway through I was invested. Edie simply refuses to give up her search for answers about Lucy’s disappearance despite everyone around her dismissing her because of her condition.

I think the author did a great job and handled dementia with care. She showed how hard it can be to have the condition and to love someone who has it.

I don’t always gravitate to mysteries but I will absolutely be recommending this story to others—it’s a gem. Absorbing and absolutely underrated.

Was this review helpful?

A unique take on the elderly sleuth cozy mystery trope, with thoughtful things to say about memory and how the past interacts with the present.

Was this review helpful?

As publisher, I requested One Puzzling Afternoon for background reading for a review on BookBrowse. See link to the review

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this bit of a unique spin on the dual timelines and unreliable narrator. I found it clever that the narrative moved fluidly through the timelines as it was playing out in Edie's mind - and the juxtaposition of her reliability in each timeline. I was sympathetic to Edie's character and appreciated her determination to "solve" the mystery of Lucy's disappearance amidst her growing awareness of her worsening dementia. Some twists and turns I didn't see coming for sure - and it held my attention right up to the final reveal.

Was this review helpful?

Have you ever had a memory so vivid you swear it just happened? That's the heart of One Puzzling Afternoon by Emily Critchley!

Edie, an octogenarian grappling with dementia, is haunted by a sighting of her childhood friend Lucy who vanished decades ago. But no one believes her, attributing it to her fading mind.

Determined to uncover the truth, Edie embarks on a journey through past and present, piecing together fragments of a long-buried secret. Is Lucy truly alive? What happened all those years ago? Can Edie solve the puzzle before it's too late?

This captivating novel is a mix of:

Mystery: Unravel the layers of suspense as Edie chases the truth amidst doubt and disbelief. ️‍♀️
Family drama: Explore the complex dynamics of family secrets and the impact they have across generations.
Coming-of-age: Witness Edie's personal growth as she confronts her past and rediscovers her strength.
Emotional journey: Prepare to be touched by Edie's resilience, vulnerability, and the bittersweet nature of memory.
If you enjoy:

Stories that twist and turn, keeping you guessing
Exploring the complexities of aging and memory
Characters who defy expectations and find new purpose
Heartfelt explorations of family and friendship
Then "One Puzzling Afternoon" is a must-read!

Was this review helpful?

Super dark, so you need to be in the right mood for this, but it works if you are! I love reading about forbidden relationships but could be a trigger for others!

Was this review helpful?

When your 84 year old memory is failing, how do you find a friend that went missing when you were 15?

One of the best books I have had the pleasure of reading. This move between the past and the present but does so flawlessly. Highly recommend this beautiful and at times heartbreaking debut book to anyone wanting a good story. Great selection for bookclubs.

I sincerely hope to see more by Emily Critchley as she has a gift.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the E-book advanced edition in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

"Perhaps it's enough to be in this moment.”

My thoughts: This book was a great intriguing mystery with all the secrets close to bring completely forgotton, with the only person alive who knows them suffering with memory loss! This book had a different setting to it and characters you love and love to hate! I definitely suggest to check this one out! Please check for trigger warnings!

I give One puzzling afternoon by Emily Critchley ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

In 1951, Edie Green lives in a small English town with her widowed mother, who conducts seances in the evenings to make ends meet. Edie is unpopular and lonely. When she sees something forbidden involving wealthy, pretty and popular Lucy, she mentions it to the girl. Immediately, Lucy brings Edie into her confidence. Edie is pleased to have a new friend, but the secret she knows starts to get out of hand. And then Lucy disappears.

In 2018, Edie is still living in the same small town. One day, she thinks she sees her old friend Lucy, and she can’t shake her worry about her. Whatever happened to her? The mystery has never been solved. While Edie is getting confused about a lot in her life, she knows this: she has to figure out what happened. She owes it to Lucy.

One Puzzling Afternoon is a mystery as well as a window into the mind of a woman with ever-worsening dementia. Edie is frustrating her family and befuddling strangers, and she is determined that her life is fine; they are all wrong about her memory. She is also very determined to make sure everyone listens to what she has to say about a 60-year-old case of a missing friend. If she could just remember…

The story alternates between the present and the past, as pieces of Edie’s memory are dislodged and float to the surface. This novel is billed as similar to Elizabeth Is Missing, which it is, but the difference is that in this book there’s no question that a character is missing, and in the other, it’s only the unreliable narrator who thinks the friend is missing. Both are good. I feel this was somewhat more straightforward, as it led toward a solid resolution of a mystery.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks for the eGalley to review!

I must warn readers first and foremost that a huge plot point for this story is a full-grown, married teacher having an "affair" with his 15-year-old student. Aside from the grooming and statutory rape, he's also emotionally abusive. There is also multiple kinds of abuse happening to Edie's mother by her stepfather, a section about abortion, and other traumas.

Other than that, this was an interesting read. It goes back and forth between 2018 with "present day" Edie and 1951 with fifteen-year-old Edie. 2018 Edie is an unreliable narrator, her dementia making her forget things immediately after telling them to us. Like I said, it's an interesting read, as it gives us a look into how this disease can affect the thought process. 1951 Edie remembers everything, telling us as though transcribed directly from her diary. She tells the events that happened up to Lucy's disappearance and afterwards straight and in a matter-of-fact way, while 2018 Edie is all over the place as she struggles to remember not just her attempts to remember what happened to Lucy nearly 70 years ago, but what happened literally a minute ago. She's trying desperately to solve her disappearance so she can prove that she's capable of continuing to live independently.

I had many theories as to what happened to Lucy, and while two of them turned out to be correct at the same time, the actual series of events is different than I had thought they'd go! It was actually quite surprising. I must admit, the first half of the book was quite slow and hard to get myself motivated to continue, but the second half I read all in one sitting. I just had to know if any of my theories were correct! As for the ending, I felt not upset, per se, but maybe sad. It's supposed to be an ending and epilogue with a happier note, but I just feel sad for Lucy.

So tl;dr, an interesting read, yes, but also a sad one. I'm glad to have read it, though.

Was this review helpful?

The day Edie saw Lucie Theddle, she started remembering the things she had forgotten. Lucie disappeared years ago when the girls were young, and now, at 82, Edie's dementia riddled brain sees Lucie and vows to tell the truth of what happens. If she can remember the secret she was keeping. As Edie's family begins making the painful decision to move Edie into their home and relocate, Edie is more determined than ever to maintain her independence and avenge her friend.

Told in the present with 82-year-old Edie suffering from dementia and in the past when teenage Edie was befriended by popular Lucie until her disappearance, the puzzle-piece flashes Edie remembers slowly come together and the whole truth is finally revealed regarding Lucie's untimely disappearance.

This was a fun, unique read. My heart broke for poor Edie and her family with the difficult decisions they are being forced to make, and for the burden of the secret she kept for all these years. Great read and an engaging story line.

Was this review helpful?

When Edie sees her friend Lucy Theddle outside the post office, confusion threatens to overwhelm her. The last time the 82 year old Edie saw her friend was when they were teenagers and yet, Lucy looks exactly the same as she did the day she disappeared. Determined to solve her friend’s disappearance before dementia strips away her remaining memories, Edie confides in her family, but quickly realizes she must uncover the mystery on her own.
One Puzzling Afternoon is told in a dual timeline between present day and the 1950s when Edie & Lucy’s friendship begins. Overall, I enjoyed the story and found Edie’s present-day plight against an unseen disease absolutely heart-wrenching, although Emily Critchley handled the topic well. This novel is perfect for those who enjoy a true mystery, a story that feels authentic from page one and a novel examining the bonds of friendship.
*Thank you to Sourcebooks and Netgalley for providing this eARC in exchange for my honest review.

**Review also posted to

Was this review helpful?

In 1951, fifteen-year-old Edie Green discovers a secret that initiates a tenuous friendship with popular Lucy Theddle. However, Lucy goes missing, and in 2018, eighty-four-year-old Edie spots her on the streets, unchanged since 67 years ago, prompting her to reopen the cold case despite her faltering memory.

The book's vibe captivated me from the start, with the dual timeline working seamlessly. The '50s atmosphere, viewed through Edie's innocent eyes, was perfectly captured. Edie's role as an unreliable narrator in 2018 added an intriguing layer.

All characters were uniquely crafted, displaying complex motivations and emotions, surrounded by a hint of mysticism that gave the narrative a fairytale quality. While the plot wasn't mind-blowing and the story's direction was predictable, it didn't diminish my enjoyment. The 1951 timeline held the most allure, although I anticipated the reveal in 2018 and looked forward to their convergence.

The pacing could have been adjusted slightly, offering more insight into Edie's home life and extending both timelines for a more comprehensive conclusion. Nevertheless, the characters and immersive setting made it an engaging read. I'd recommend it, especially to fans of historical young adult mysteries.

Was this review helpful?

"One Puzzling Afternoon" is a bittersweet tale of the lasting impact of early friendship across decades. There are two timelines, 1951 post-World War II and 2018. It begins with an unlikely friendship between two young girls. There is an affair between a schoolgirl and a married teacher with unseen repercussions, a girl gone missing and never found, and her best friend, now an old woman with dementia, who is convinced that the answers are buried in her somewhere. I recommend "One Puzzling Afternoon" to readers who enjoy mysteries and family dramas.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked Edie. Both her young and old versions. I just wanted to give her a hug. I appreciated looking through the world through Edie's memory confused eyes. My Mom has dementia and it allowed me to step into her shoes for a moment. I could relate to her son and granddaughter.

Told in dual timelines of the present when Edie is in her 80s and the past when she was just 15 and her friend went missing. In the present, Edie goes on a quest to find out what happened all those years ago. But she's at a disadvantage with her memory. I was wrapped up in the mystery and learning more about Edie's quirky and somewhat heartbreaking youth.

This was a great change of pace read for me.

Was this review helpful?

i enjoyed this book very much, loved the positive representation of mental disability, the beginning was a bit boring and the end needs a bit of work but overall it was a great book

Was this review helpful?

Set in 1951 and 2018 in a fictional English village, One Puzzling Afternoon unspools the events leading up to the disappearance of fifteen-year-old Lucy. The story’s told through patchy memories of Lucy’s friend Edie, now that Edie is eighty-two and suffering from dementia. Elderly Edie is suddenly struck by the need to find Lucy to demonstrate to her son that she is still capable of living independently. The reader stays sympathetic to Edie and her mystery-solving mission even while recognizing with growing certainty that Edie has already lost the battle for independence. But however irrational her justification to herself is, her need to know what happened to Lucy has a deeper, emotionally driven source that becomes more compelling as the novel proceeds. Critchley succeeds in depicting Edie’s dementia realistically, with all the inherent frustrations for her and everyone around her, while keeping the reader solidly on Edie’s side.

The twisty, emotionally complex, character-driven mystery at the novel’s heart provides page-turning forward momentum. The gentle, loving depiction of Edie, both as a lonely, wounded teenager and slipping adult, adds depth without cliché or oversimplification. Critchley explores the repercussions when a teenager compels a friend to keep a dangerous secret as well as the corroding effect of that promise as it ripples across Edie’s life, however well lived. A passage from the first chapter shows Critchley’s graceful style while introducing both these themes and the central focus on memory: “I…pop one of the tiny disks in my mouth. The taste is sweet and soapy. They remind me of spring flowers and warm days, of cycling down to the sea with the sun on my face, of secret whispers and kept promises.”

Was this review helpful?