Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This is a character driven story. We follow three women. One is a professor who went through a recent break up, one is an RA who is working towards buying her own home, and the last is a student who is having a hard time making friends and having the college life experience.
I was enjoying the slice of college life and all the pettiness, anxiousness, awkwardness surrounding it. So I was surprised by the last 20 % of the book and the dark turn it took.
All the characters felt real. They had flaws, some were unlikable but I think that's what being human is, we all have an unpleasant side. There's also many great discussions on ethics, morals, race, wealth, discrimination, all centered around dorm life.
I don't think this book will be a favorite for the majority since it's more of a character study with little plot.
I thought it was great.

Was this review helpful?

Similar to Kiley Reid's previous book Such a Fun Age (which I really enjoyed), Come & Get It discusses issues on socioeconomic classes, racism/ethnicity, and LGBTQ representation. Taking place mostly around University of Arkansas between different characters POVs, we learn about a group of women living around the campus and the micro/macro aggressions that affect their relationships and conflicts. While I didn't find much of a solid plot in this book, I enjoyed the character development. I read this on audio via Libro.fm and on my kindle; I personally enjoyed the audio version better of this book.

Thank you NetGalley for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and G.P. Putnam’s Sons for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I raved about Kiley Reid’s debut so I was very excited to read her second book. This story has a relatively large cast of characters so it took me a bit to warm up to them. Millie is a residential assistant (RA) saving up to buy her first home. Agatha is a visiting professor who has just ended a relationship. Kennedy is a student living in the dorm where Millie is the RA. If this sounds a little busy, it is.

An inappropriate relationship eventually develops between two of the main characters that didn’t feel completely fleshed out to me. I loved the themes of this book, and I think they are important ones, but felt that there were too many characters for me to fully develop a connection with any of them.

I must mention that I started this book on audio and then switched to reading because I couldn’t keep all the characters and dialogue straight. I definitely enjoyed the book a lot more than the audio version.

The plot was rather amorphous for me but overall I did enjoy the climax of the book. Reid writes well about the complexities of class, race and sexuality. Her dialogue is extremely realistic. Her sharp focus on social satire is where her strength lies. I am glad I finished this book and definitely look forward to Reid’s future stories.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited to read this, as I did enjoy Such a Fun Age. However, i just don't think this one was for me unfortunately. I did end up DNF'ing it. I just couldn't connect with any of the characters, nor did I like the lack of plot. Those who like character-driven books would enjoy this.

Was this review helpful?

This was not my favorite! I loved Such a Fun Age and can see that this is a logical next novel...meaning that it feels like the same author wrote it...I just didn't connect with it as much as I did her first. There were so many characters!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed Reid’s previous novel and was looking forward to this one, however I struggled with this book. Mainly I felt it zig-zagged from character to character without a true plot focus.
There was potential, I’d get to the end of a chapter and think “okay joy it’s going to come together” and then it went in another direction.
Thank you to the publisher for the opportunity to read an early copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

As Kiley Reid's debut novel Such a Fun Age was so good and popular, her follow-up novel was of course going to bring a lot of anticipation along with it. Come and Get it takes place at a college, primarily in an unpopular dorm, where Millie Cousins, a returning RA after taking a year off from school to care for her mother, interacts with her fellow RAs and students she is advising. Insert Agatha Paul, a visiting professor who is working on a book about weddings, who interviews some of the students in the dorm and finds herself fascinated with their non-wedding related opinions/interactions. After this interaction, an alternate idea springs up in Agatha's mind, and Millie is intrigued and wants to help.

This book contains some similar vibes as her debut novel, in that the college is very white, and Millie, who is Black has to deal with overt and systemic racism. There are also themes around class differences and acceptance of queerness. I will say this book does not have that much of a propelling plot- there are a lot of students as well as RAs and other side characters that are introduced, some of which had potential to be quite interesting, but I found the backstories spread too thin to engage with many of the characters. Some of the propelling plot points (a prank gone wrong, retaliation, a secret relationship, etc.) were not all the novel or interesting. I know Reid can write a great character, which is why I found this disappointing, especially as I could get shades of interest from characters, but there were just too many of them and there could have been fewer, allowing more of an introspection into their backgrounds and actions.

Thank you to Penguin Group Putnam, G.P. Putnam's Sons via NetGalley for the advance reader copy in exchange for honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was very excited for Kiley Reid’s sophomore release after enjoying Such a Fun Age, however this book was not the right book for me right now. It is a character driven story that is lacking plot, with the exception of the last 15% of the novel. I found myself unable to root for any of the characters and felt that each of them were so flawed, without any material growth or development. The characters do seem fitting of a campus novel, driven by self-centered, self-benefiting motives. While I was disappointed with this read, I would be interested in hearing what my reader friends thought of it. Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing access to a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Wow- so this book has no plot. Like, none. I don’t think one even kind of developed until I was about 70-75% into it. So I’m not really sure how to go about my review here. The author is funny and rights come kind of interesting characters, but that didn’t really save the story for me. I definitely enjoyed her debut novel more.

Was this review helpful?

Come and Get It, Kiley Reid's second novel after Such a Fun Age, is a unique campus novel following a professor and several students at a Southern university. It didn't immediately hook me the way Reid's writing did with her first book, which starts on such a big note, and did take me a while to get into. I think the book might have also benefitted from a tighter focus. That said, Reid is such a talented writer when it comes to sharp observation about race, class, power, and generational difference - I was amused from the start by the conversation about weddings and the thoughts that provoked to the interesting dynamics with Millie. Reid is also skilled at making the reader have many, many feelings about the actions and thoughts of her characters, and making you think more about those. This would be a great book club choice for a group willing to dig in.

Was this review helpful?

Come & Get It is the much anticipated sophomore novel from Kiley Reid. It's set primarily on a college campus and follows multiple women as they navigate tricky situations. Many of these situations make you question the morality of the actions being taken. It's a character driven novel that won't be for all as its very slow going with everything coming together at the end. Personally, I enjoyed Come & Get It more than Such a Fun Age.

This is a perfect book for book clubs ripe with multiple discussion areas.

Thank you to Putnam Books and Netgalley for a copy in exchange for review consideration.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited to receive an advanced copy of Come & Get it by Kiley Reid. I really enjoyed Such a Fun Age when I read that book.
Come & Get It is a character-driven novel set at the University of Arkansas. The main character Millie is a resident advisor (RA) in a college dormitory. She meets Agatha, a traveling professor who claims to be researching weddings and wanting to interview some college students. Agatha instead is intrigued by the idea of the underclassmen and their financial habits. She ends up writing profiles of some different students for a magazine reflecting how they think about and use money. Agatha and Millie’s relationship becomes blurry and crosses the line to romantic creating a further ethical dilemma.
Unfortunately, this book just didn’t work for me. Initially I was intrigued by the path I though the book was going to take – profiling different students and their financial habits; however, this was not actually the point of the book. While I didn’t dislike anything in particular about this book, I just didn’t find myself connecting to the story. I didn’t feel drawn to the story or the characters. Agatha’s character was particularly unlikeable to me as I felt that she was taking advantage of Millie. Millie’s character was the only one that I found to be likable. I felt that this book had great potential, but the plot was lacking.

Was this review helpful?

A well written, page turner about the intertwining lives of a professor and students on the campus of a southern university. Themes of money, power, sex, and racism drive the characters and the plot.
I really enjoyed reading this book and found it hard to put down. The characters are realistically flawed, making frustrating and questionable choices throughout the novel, which makes it difficult to like them (although I did care about what happened to each of them in the end). There was a carelessness with which the characters treated each other that made me reflect on the complexity of our internal lives.
Reid writes a compelling and thoughtful story about relationships with money and each other. I’d definitely recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

I suspect Reid's sophomore effort will suffer in comparison to Such a Fun Age. It's a common issue among new authors. But I did enjoy this - Reid has a particular talent for capturing the contemporary age and the newest adult generation. She is adept at finding current social issues like systemic racism and classism in the tiny and the mundane. Her characters feel real and they make me smile and sympathize though I am a good deal older than they. Entertaining and thoughtful is a welcome combination always.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Putnam for the ARC of Come and Get It. I was excited about this one as I loved Kiley Reid’s debut. Similar to Such a Fun Age Reid does a fantastic job setting up characters that you truly feel like you get to know (for better or worse). Come and Get It is definitely a thought-provoking read where you explore race, class, power dynamics, and more. It’s not very plot-driven, so keep that in mind, but it is a true study of people and what makes them tick. Overall, an interesting read and one I’m glad I read.

Was this review helpful?

Kiley Reid really knows how to hook you from beginning to end. I went into this book pretty blind, not knowing what I was getting myself into, my only prior knowledge was that I really liked her other book, Such a Fun Age. It was what most would call “no plot, just vibes” and I really enjoyed it. The way we follow so many characters that impact each others life in very small to very large ways. The character development and the way you learn more and more about each character’s past the farther you get was so interesting. I found myself thinking about this story whenever I had to put the book down. They only thing was, I felt the ending was very abrupt, I wanted a little bit more to wrap everyone’s story up.

Was this review helpful?

*Millie voice* So I actually kind of loved it?

Between this and Rebecca, Not Becky, I’m realizing that cheugy satire and Southern women caricatures really do it for me.

Come and Get It is the opposite of dark academia with a La Croix whisper of Yellowface. It’s not plot-driven, just vibes and character (un)development by absolute messes who would be right at home in the Peach Pit unsavory women universe.

I’m nosy and judgmental, so I had a great time. If you prefer minding your own business, plots, or characters you root for, this book will likely not spark joy.

Was this review helpful?

Just not as good as her first. It lost some clarity and big picture. I was really entranced and really liked a lot of the elements but the end just didn't feel so... Wrapped up in a satisfying way. I really liked the plot movement and the different POVs. It was so engaging and yet unfulfilling.

Was this review helpful?

Millie (24 years old) is a senior at the University of Arkansas. She is also an RA for the Student Residences and saving up to buy her own house. Agatha Paul, 38, is a writer and visiting professor at the University. She is purportedly interviewing students at the University to write a book about “Weddings” and Millie is assigned to help her coordinate with the students. Kennedy, Tyler and Peyton are all tween/20-year old students at the University and roommates assigned to Millie’s section of the residences. This leads to some not-so-pleasant, not-at-all-smart entanglements.
Kiley Reid has done a fantastic job of portraying how juvenile tweens and twenty-somethings behave in an university setting. In fact, some of the prankish shenanigans reminded me of the boarding school novels written by Enid Blyton with contemporary shades of race, class and gender thrown in. Millie and the other RAs, while trying to be adult and responsible at most times also have their moments of getting carried away. Agatha Paul, in the midst of an estrangement from her lesbian lover is most surprising and, in my opinion, ought to have shown more restraint and maturity. I don't want to describe her actions in greater details so as to avoid spoilers.
You have to read the book against the above-mentioned background and mindset for it to become likeable and readable. The novel is entirely character driven and the characters are neither wholly likeable nor unlikeable. If you are a fan of campus-based stories or dark academia narratives, this one is for you. Not my preferred genre. I’m already seeing a lot of polarizing views on this one.
Thank you Netgalley, Penguin Group Putnam and Kiley Reid for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher for an ARC of this novel.

I loved Reid’s first novel “Such a Fun Age” and I love a campus novel, so I would have thought this would be right up my alley. But unfortunately this just fell flat for me.

The premise is hard to explain because it very much seems that Reid is trying to go more character driven here instead of her previous novels very plot-forward tone. I definitely appreciate Reid’s desire to go more broad, to be more ambitious…but it felt like the number of characters and storylines she had going was just convoluted.

And the issue here really was that the story felt aimless for large parts - and not in a way that I didn’t know where it was going, but in ways that Reid didn’t seem sure herself where it was going.

Reid still has a lot of strength as a writer and I loved her first novel so much, and really did see enough strength in this, that I’ll definitely read what she comes out with next. But maybe with more measured expectations.

Was this review helpful?