Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I can't tell you what this book is even about. I wish there was more character development. Shame because I loved her other work!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately I stopped reading this book at 43%. I just couldn’t connect with any of the characters, and although I understand, the book is not intended to have a quick moving plot, they just wasn’t enough going on to keep my attention. I really enjoyed Reid’s previous novel, and I look forward to reading whatever she comes out with next, but this was just a bit too slow moving for me.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting…

I kept hearing about this author and was happy to give this a try. The plot caught my intention, with characters and their different motivations, slowly evolving into, seemingly, college hijinks. Quirky and intention-getting, the characters came to life, providing some interesting views into what makes people tick. Unfortunately, as I read further, it was hard to find one character or plot hook that made me care how it all played out. I didn’t click with any of the characters so it was hard to stay engaged.

So much feeds into the appreciation for a story and I’m hoping it was just a moment in time that didn’t allow me to appreciate this one more. The writing style, coupled with amazing things I’ve heard about other stories by this author, will have me checking out other titles. There’s definitely enough good to have me wanting a second chance…

Was this review helpful?

Early reviews claim "nothing happens in this book," but that's not the case. Kiley Reid's strength lies in depicting small slights and alliances that build to significant outcomes. If you can't see these subtle actions leading to chaos, Reid might not be for you.

The tension builds to intense levels of "Oh No," with characters making bad decisions that clearly won’t end well. The anticipation of the impending disaster and seeing how deeply intertwined the characters become is the true pleasure.

Reid's writing is confident and specific, capturing human behavior with ease. I found immense joy in this book's perceptiveness and accuracy. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the ARC.

College Senior Millie wants nothing more than to buy a house after graduating and the money she ears as an RA is put towards the down payment. When an opportunity to make a little extra money snooping on her residents presents itself, Millie gets caught up in a series of events that all unravel simultaneously.

Interesting read, not entirely sure how I feel about it yet! I read Reid's previous work, Such a Fun Age, and felt similarly. I was actually more intruiged by the collaborative memoirs Agatha, the visiting professor, wrote than finishing this book. Overall, it was a fresh and unpredictable story.

Was this review helpful?

Phenomenal. I’m not usually one for a character driven novel, but Reid is a notable exception for me. Her characters are so nuanced and well-developed that I could read hundreds of pages of their innermost thoughts without getting bored. She’s just that good. I absolutely loved this book.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this! Loved the setting - as someone from MO + having lots of friends that went to UofA. I just don't think this moved fast enough for me. I know that is part of the point, but the longer I read it, the less I wanted to pick it up. I have heard great things about this author's previous work though so I will be reading that!

Was this review helpful?

This is almost all character development with a little bit of plot. I enjoyed getting into the heads of these messy people. Uncomfortable at times and so much second hand embarrassment. I absolutely love the way Kiley Reid writes. It feels so unique.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this!! By the end of everything I wasn’t sure which (if any) of the characters I liked, but I wanted to know what happened to all of them. I loved.

Was this review helpful?

A character driven story about a residential assistant in her dorm, and her professor. There wasn’t much to the plot for me, making it a slow paced read overall.

*many thanks to Putnam, PRH audio and Netgalley for the gifted copy for review.

Was this review helpful?

"Come and Get It," set in 2017 at the University of Arkansas, centers on Millie, a senior resident assistant, who becomes embroiled in an inappropriate relationship with a visiting professor, Agatha Paul, while managing several students under her care.

I enjoyed Kiley Reid’s writing by the way she had her well-drawn characters express their thoughts and interactions from each of their povs throughout the novel. She also effectively used the various settings and incorporated themes of race, class, and morality in a way that provoked inward contemplation for me, the reader, as well. Despite this, the pacing is a bit uneven, with buildups leading to anti-climactic events.

The narrative seems designed to be a deep character study rather than a plot-driven tale. While I’m all for those types of stories, I never became positively invested in any of the characters. Agatha’s research exploring consumerism, money, and the complexities of human behavior among the students initially held my interest, but never really felt filled out. Her character gave me major ick btw.

Overall, it's a compelling read but not one that will likely stand out as a favorite for me this year.

Was this review helpful?

At times I wasn't really sure what was happening here, but that was okay because I loved getting to see these characters interact. I was, at times, frustrated with every single one of them, and I mean that as a complimentto Kiley Reid because it means she wrote them so well.

Was this review helpful?

COME AND GET IT
RATING: 2 ⭐️ - I Did Not Like This

Kiley’s follow up to SUCH A FUN AGE was high anticipated but in line with the mixed reviews, this one also missed the mark for me.

COME AND GET IT follows a residential assistant, her professor, and 3 new students under her purview.

❤️ for my LOVERS of CHARACTER DRIVEN novels, CAMPUS centered, stories about RACE, WEALTH, & STATUS

❤️ I’d highly recommend this on on AUDIO - it’s a long one, and moves slow, so getting through it on audio is the best way to go!

💔 the biggest critique I heard about this one was that it is CHARACTER DRIVEN and while that’s true, it also lacks any sort of plot - there were a TON of characters introduced at the beginning, some alternating timelines, but literally no idea what was happening

💭 What did you think about this one?

Was this review helpful?

Found the plot to be difficult to follow or discern. Did not feel like a cohesive story. Unfortunately was unable to finish it because of this.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to GP Putnams Sons, NetGalley, and the author for sharing this arc with me in exchange for my honest feedback!

I was so excited to get my hands on this one after absolutely devouring the writer’s debut novel, Such A Fun Age, a few years back. Unfortunately, this second novel just wasn’t it for me.

Where do I begin? Is the plot in the room with us? About halfway through this book I realized that the plot was going absolutely nowhere. It took me over three months to get through this short novel because I had zero interest in the characters or what was happening to them. The minimal action that did develop felt like the plot to a Riverdale episode. It was all just so slow paced and underdeveloped. And then the ending was just BLEH.

I had such high hopes for Come and Get It but this one missed the mark by a mile for me. 😩

Was this review helpful?

For anyone who is leaving a child at college with the RAs in the dorm, you might not want to read this. In some ways it seems there are a bunch of crazies working in residence life as well as some very different roommates. I think that there are a lot of characters with a lot of strange stories; sometimes it is hard to keep them all straight. Really, I don't know how I feel about this book...it kept me interested, but at the same time, I wanted to stop the story--some of the back stories are cringy--especially the one (spoiler alert) about the dog, I could see it coming, but couldn't stop it. I guess at the end the plot was all tied together, but it was sometimes painful getting there.

Was this review helpful?

Kiley Reid has a way of writing that makes people think. Come and Get it is no exception. It has been a week since I finished reading and I'm still thinking about it.

Was this review helpful?

The best dialogue writing you’ll ever read topped off with Kiley Reid’s now signature and extremely well-done social commentary on money and race.

The levity of a college dorm setting makes it so that you don’t even realize the tensions are rising until suddenly *you do*. Smart and funny with concise and perfect sentences-Reid’s sophomore novel has landed her as a favorite author.

Was this review helpful?

Description and dialogue were whip smart and fresh; characters popped. It has more of a non-plot, character study vibe than some more plot-driven stories, if you're into that sort of thing.

Was this review helpful?

This was an ok read about a residence assistance in a college dorm. Millie leaves midway to go home to care for her sick mother. She does online courses and works to save money. Her goal to graduate and buy a house. When she returns to school she has a new class of students residing in her dorm . When the chance to make extra money comes she jumps at it. Agatha Paul, a visiting professor and writer, offers Millie an easy yet unusual opportunity. But Millie's starry-eyed hustle becomes jeopardised by odd new friends, vengeful dorm pranks and illicit intrigue.

Was this review helpful?