I loved the concept and world building of this novel but I craved more character development and a deeper understanding of their desires. The plot seemed to stall a bit midway and I found myself wanting to give up on reading it.

I've tried multiple times to read this book and just have not been able to get into it. Sadly I'm guessing its because there's a male POV at all which I don't particularly care for anymore. I will likely keep trying though because it's Jewish, and I'm Jewish, and a friend of mine loved it - so keep eyes peeled on my socials!

If you're a fan of The Winternight Trilogy by Katherine Arden or S.A. Chakraborty's Daevabad trilogy, then I think you'll find a lot to love about The Pomegranate Gate.

I finished this one awhile ago, but it's stayed with me, which is to its immense credit. An impactful, engaging, richly portrayed tale that seamlessly combines history with Jewish folklore. (That a character can exist as an original and duplicate of themselves and evoke different yet equal investment in each version speaks particularly well of the characterization and storytelling.) The pacing was, perhaps, a bit inconsistent (my progress was somewhat slower about midway through, though it recovered), but not to the overall detriment of its efficacy. I received it as an ARC but intend to give it a place on my shelf.

DNF @ 11%

I just could not bring myself to care about these characters. I wanted to love this so much, but I think Kaplan tried to take on too much, making it hard to connect to the world.

WOW!! I didn't really know what to expect when I started reading this book. I don't I have ever read a YA novel about the Jewish community of Spain during the inquisition and edict of expulsion. Despite it being my heritage, I didn't know I was missing that representation until I read The Pomegranate Gate. Give me more please!!! And for it to be Sci-fi!!! Oh My GOD I didn't know I needed it but I did!! Kaplan weaves history and fantasy together in such a masterful way. I was gripped by every second, never really knowing what was going to happen. The world building is phenomenal. Every piece of the narrative puzzle fitting perfectly. I cannot wait to see what comes next!

It was objectively good, the writing and the characters and the premise, but this was a tough one for me. I would read it again just to try, but whew, this was hard to get through.

A complex but engaging portal fantasy world with a fresh narrative voice. Toby and Naftaly had my attention early on and they kept me going through significant world building; it was worth that commitment. Looking forward to book 2.

The Pomegranate Gate is a spellbinding mix of Jewish folklore and fantasy, set against the backdrop of the Spanish Inquisition. Toba and Naftaly’s journey through a realm filled with Maziks and danger is captivating. Kaplan’s world-building is rich, and while it takes time to unravel, it’s so worth it. A slow burn that hooks you for the next chapter in this magical saga!

I hate to say this, but after spending the past year and half trying over and over to pick this book back up, this is a DNF.

Honestly, I'm not entirely sure why. The premise is interesting, the writing is beautiful, and I'm enjoying the characters. I've just really struggled with immersing myself into this story.

I'm rating it 4 stars because I feel the DNF is just me. The author is a talented writer. I think I just keep repeatedly picking this book up at the wrong time.

When I started the first book, I did not get past the first chapter quickly. I felt it a little heavy and then it fell back in my reading queue. When I finally got around to it again, I had the next book in the series waiting as well so I was extra motivated.

It turned out that I needed no other motivation than the story itself. Once I understood the key players and the story itself, the fantasy and the real historical indications, I was hooked and I spent chunks of my reading time trying to get through it.

When this story begins we have two people living in the same town who are now going to be part of the exodus of others of their faith. Their lives and livelihoods are in danger whether they choose to stay or go.

Naftaly is an extremely average person, he feels like he’s disappointed his father by not being a good enough tailor and for having questions about the random dreams he has. Toba is a weak and strange girl whose grandparents do not even plan to get married. She has learning which girls her age do not usually undertake. As the two separately leave their town, they happen to have different interactions with Maziks and their world. For both people, older women come after them to keep them safe.

This is when the writing picks up and almost every description after this point is borderline hilarious ( on purpose) while still managing to be part of serious events. More characters join the plot and become more important to the bigger picture.

It’s a complex narrative, one that explains itself a little bit before wrapping up in this installment.

I immediately began the next.
I received an ARC thanks to NetGalley and the publishers but the review is entirely based on my own reading experience.

I keep hearing good things about this book but unfortunately I just didn’t like it.
Some might like but not me

Beautiful book that I just adored. A retelling that is a bit different. Thanks so much for the galley. I cannot wait to read book 2.

I forgot to leave a review for this when I first read it. give me all the jewish inspired fantasy please and thank you.

This book is an engaging and thought-provoking read that keeps you hooked from start to finish. The author’s writing style is both captivating and immersive, creating a world that feels rich and layered. With well-developed characters and a plot that unfolds in unexpected ways, it’s definitely a journey worth taking. Highly recommended for those looking for something that stays with you long after you've turned the last page.

I actually missed the date of this book but I had the chance to read it later in an app and I'm really sad that it took me so long, if you're looking for mythology this book is for you, both main characters are so good and the magical system is just amazing, it was one of those books that were really captivating and even if I missed the date limit I knew that I had to read it

Ariel Kaplan's "The Pomegranate Gate" is a masterful introduction to an immersive Sephardic Jewish fantasy trilogy, where the epic scope of "City of Brass" meets the enchanting atmosphere of Studio Ghibli. Set against the backdrop of a fantasy version of the Spanish Inquisition, Kaplan’s narrative weaves together history, myth, and magic into a rich tapestry that will undoubtedly captivate fans of high fantasy and Jewish folklore.

The story follows Toba Peres and Naftaly Cresques, two Jewish characters forced to flee their homes after the Queen of Sefarad decrees all Jews must convert or face exile. Toba, separated from her caravan, stumbles into a magical realm inhabited by the Maziks, mythical beings of immense power. Meanwhile, Naftaly, who dreams of an orange-eyed stranger and carries a book he can never read, embarks on a quest to rescue Toba, navigating both mortal and magical threats.

Kaplan’s narrative is meticulously paced, unfolding like an extended oral tale reminiscent of Shaharazad’s "One Thousand and One Nights." While some might find the pacing slow, it serves the story well, gradually revealing the complex political and magical landscape of this new world. The plot is dense and heavily political, requiring readers to pay close attention as various narrative threads are introduced and interwoven.

Toba and Naftaly are compelling protagonists, each with unique abilities and personal struggles. Toba’s journey is particularly poignant as it serves as an allegory for neurodivergence, specifically autism. Her discovery of latent powers in the Maziks' realm is both thrilling and deeply symbolic. Naftaly’s idealism and naivety provide a counterbalance to Toba’s more grounded perspective, and his romantic subplot adds a layer of emotional depth to the narrative.

The secondary characters, such as the enigmatic Courser and the flamboyant Barsilay, are equally well-developed, each bringing their own charm and complexity to the story. The interactions between these characters, especially Toba’s dynamic with Asmel, her reluctant mentor, are a highlight, offering moments of humor and pathos.

Kaplan’s world-building is exquisite, with every detail contributing to a fully realized setting that feels both fantastical and grounded in historical reality. The use of Jewish cultural elements, from language to religious practices, adds authenticity and depth to the story. The exploration of themes such as power, oppression, and identity is nuanced and thought-provoking, making "The Pomegranate Gate" a narrative rich in both plot and substance.

Kaplan’s writing is lyrical and evocative, drawing readers into the story with its poetic prose and vivid descriptions. The atmospheric charm of Studio Ghibli is evident in the whimsical libraries and courts, while the darker, more intense moments are reminiscent of epic fantasy traditions. The balance between these tones creates a unique narrative voice that is both enchanting and gripping.

"The Pomegranate Gate" is a remarkable debut that promises an epic journey through a world where history and magic collide. Its slow pacing and intricate plot might be challenging for some, but those who appreciate detailed world-building and richly developed characters will find much to love. This book is a testament to Kaplan’s storytelling prowess and leaves readers eagerly anticipating the next installment in the Mirror Realm Cycle.

The Pomegranate Gate by Ariel Kaplan is a captivating fantasy novel that weaves rich mythology, magic, and adventure. Set in a world inspired by Jewish folklore, the story follows two protagonists, Toba and Naftaly, as they are thrust into an alternate dimension filled with danger and intrigue. Kaplan's world-building is intricate, blending historical elements with mystical realms in a way that feels both fresh and immersive. The characters are compelling, each grappling with their own internal conflicts while facing external challenges. Fast-paced and full of twists, The Pomegranate Gate is a thrilling journey of courage, loyalty, and self-discovery.

I actually did not finish this book, for several reasons. 1 - life got hectic, so no fault of the book whatsoever. 2 - slow start + hectic life = me less likely to prioritize the book. I plan on attempting this book again and look forward to actually finishing it.

The Pomegranate Gate is Ariel Kaplan's epic Jewish fantasy that follows three main characters as they navigate their world of mysteries and the tension and high stakes of the Inquisition. Rich and luscious, set against a fantastical background, the book takes the reader on a journey through myths and lore as we follow our protagonist and the connections between them. I would recommend this book to fans of Naomi Novik as it has the same cadence-like story-telling.