Member Reviews
I appreciate so much the galleys offered by St. Martin’s Press through NetGalley. So many wonderful books have come to my attention that I otherwise might never have heard about.
This exceptional memoir is no exception. A rare firsthand account of life as a slave worker in Auschwitz, first published in 1950 but only recently translated. As the author was a poet and journalist, this has good bones and fabulous writing. It's hard to believe it's a translation -- just an effortless personal narrative of the every day occurrences.
The audiobook narrator Laurence Dobiesz makes this difficult-to-read account almost easy listening. I'll definitely look into what else he's narrated.
My heart kept breaking with this book.
Every time I read a WWll book I think this will be the hardest book but each one gets even harder.
somehow it seems like in the 40s nobody had a soul or a heart or I don't know if it was the level of ignorance in that era but I just can't understand the evilness of these people, over and over again
I read how inhumane they were but yet I haven't found any humanity at all.
This was a great book, it was hard to read but good. it was pretty informative as the book was written that way, not as a novel or a story more like you were an expectation of every cruelty of every face or torture that took place.
Thank you, Netgalley and St. Martin's Press, for the advanced audio copy of Cold Crematorium
Reporting from the Land of Auschwitz in exchange for my honest review
Thank you Netgalley for this ARC of Cold Crematorium by József Debreczeni. Debrecenzi is a Hungarian journalist who chronicled his stay at Auschwitz. This was first published in 1950, but not in English. While tragic, he is still able to convey such thought, irony, and sharp bits of humor. This isn’t the easiest book to read at times, but it’s an important one. I recommend this book.
Thank you Net Galley for the advanced copy of this book for the honest review. This was amazingly written, very haunting.
Jozsef Debreczeni gives us a raw and unvarnished look in to his experience of the Holocaust. Written with honesty and strength in to one of our world's greatest tragedies, Jozsef does not flinch from telling truth of his journey. Filled with details of the process, the feelings, the daily life in ways that others haven't fully expressed, helps deepen our understanding of the true horror of life in camps, the heirarchy of those struggling to survive, whatever the cost to themselves, and how bleak camp was, yet, yet how strong human hope truly was. One of the best (can one really value best/worst within this horror??) detailed accounts I have read. Thank you Jozsef, for sharing your truth. We will never forget.
*I received a copy of this audiobook from NetGalley. This review is my own opinion*
I got an ARC of this book.
I will read every Holocaust memoir, no matter its rating. No story should be forgotten. I have read a lot of memoirs. A lot.
This was the prettiest one I have read yet. It was beautifully written. Debreczeni was a reporter and clearly had years of practice writing. It was easy to get lost in the beauty of the words, but it did make some of the descriptions of brutality incredibly difficult to digest.
The book did not feel as intense as other memoirs, despite that fancy writing. I think part of that was there were so many detailed scenes that I felt like I got to know other people more than in other memoirs. I felt like I was really engaging with the people and they came alive. Their deaths hit harder. It is harder to not be impacted by the deaths when the people feel so real.
This was the first memoir I have read out of the “cold crematorium”. It was a part of camp life that I have never had to face before. It was chilling. There were so many details that I needed to know, but he focused so much on the other people that I don’t feel like I know about the location as much as other memoirs teach about the camp. Instead the focus came back to people again and again. So if you want to see humans and see how they survived, this is a great memoir. If you want something more traditional, this might be a pass for you.
I think every Holocaust memoir is worthy of reading and it is hard to review them. How do you judge a book about some of the most traumatic moments in history?
I think this book is sure to be entered into the genre of important Holocaust books. It was published in 1950 in Hungary, but is just now being published in English for the first time. Debreczeni's memoir follows his time in several different concentration camps during WWII. There were several elements that I hadn't heard about before (despite reading countless books centered around the Holocaust), such as hierarchies that existed within the camps and various illnesses that presented because of starvation and disease. This book read like a fictional story because of the writing style and the dialogue included, so there were many times when I had to remind myself that this was a true story. It was horrifying to read in many parts (and extremely disturbing obviously), but it was also moving and fascinating at the same time. It should be required reading for anyone who disputes the horrors that took place in these concentration camps.
I really enjoyed this book. It was different than anything else I've read recently. I couldn't put it down! I will keep an eye out for this author's future work!
This was one of the most stunning and haunting first-person narratives of the Holocaust that I have ever read. Debreczeni skillfully wove masterful prose into observant journalism and created a masterpiece out of the wreckage of all that was done to him and millions of others. There were several quotes that were so poignant that I had to put the book down and really absorb the words. I sometimes feel that a work loses something in the translation into other languages, but this translation couldn't be better. The gruesome descriptions of daily life are so detailed that they paint a vivid picture. While it can be incredibly difficult to bear witness to the suffering of others, it's imperative that we do so, especially when anti-antisemitism is still running rampant and frequently unchecked.
"Freedom stirs even in silence; freedom whispers amid all the noise..."
An incredibly detailed account of time in the Nazi death camps. Shockingly this hasn’t been translated into English until now. The author was a journalist, which can account for how straightforward his tone is in the book. Very matter of fact and the detail is incredible. This was not an easy read at all, which comes as no surprise. A very important book to add to the first hand accounts. Never forget.
It is so sad to read the words of a man tortured, along with millions of others . By other men! How can any human treat another so horribly is just beyond my capacity to understand. Hitler and his minions were not just at war. They were the bringers of evil.
This book is well written, describing the conditions, the emotions, the monstrous behavior that occurred while this man was forced to stay in multiple prisoner of war camps. I could literally see in my mind as he described the conditions.
I do recommend this book. I would hope everyone would read it. History can and dos repeat itself and people should learn from that.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for allowing me this ARC.
The author of this book lives in spite of the horrid conditions of the Holocaust camps of death. It is a memoir of his life living in the camps. He shows the brutality and cruelty of life yet the desire to live is very strong. It is a compelling book to read. He lives through the inprisionment and slave labour in a series of camps, ending in the 'Cold Crematorium' - the so-called hospital of the forced labour camp Dornhau, where prisoners too weak to work were left to die. He watches his neighbors in this “hospital” die. Whe he is finally freed from this horror, he writes this book giving us a shocking and his perception of life in the camps. It is not to be forgotten as you read this. Even though I have read several books about the Holocaust, this one was different. It is a memoir that will haunt the reader.
COLD CREMATORIUM: REPORTING FROM THE LAND OF AUSCHWITZ – BIOGRAPHY
Written by - József Debreczeni
Translated by - Paul Olchváry
‘József Debreczeni, a prolific Hungarian-language journalist and poet, arrived in Auschwitz in 1944; had he been selected to go “left,” his life expectancy would have been approximately forty-five minutes. One of the “lucky” ones, he was sent to the “right,” which led to twelve horrifying months of incarceration and slave labor in a series of camps, ending in the “Cold Crematorium” . . . .’
‘Come here, you visionaries who create with pen, chalk, stone, or paintbrush; all of you who’ve ever sought to conjure up the grimace of suffering and death; prophets of the danse macabre, engravers of terror, scribes of hells—come here!’
‘Night in Dörnhau.’
‘Six hundred men are pressed tightly up against each other. Every third person is dying.’
A Must Read—Highly Recommend!
Thank you, NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press, for providing me with an eBook of COLD CREMATORIUM at the request of an honest review.
I read Cold Crematorium the same time as I was reading Night by Elie Wiesel, in our tenth grade English class. It is interesting how many things were the same, yet the experiences were different based on where the Jews were encamped. The atrocities that Jozsef went through, as well as millions of Jews, were just unimaginable. Mr. Debreczeni does a great job of writing in such a way that you can feel what the Jews were going through. Incidents like the louse, the crawling, the itching, just made my skin crawl just thinking about it. We are lucky that Mr. Debreczeni was able to survive and give us such an account. Thank you for sharing your story! Thanks to Mr. Debreczeni, NetGalley, and St. Martin’s Press, for the opportunity to read and review this book. All opinions are my own.
My thanks to NetGalley as I was given a free copy for my honest opinion. This book was the first translated story as told by a German prisoner during World War II. The book is gripping and you find you can't stop turning the pages. We have all heard stories or read about the fate of the prisoners, but this book delves into more information about their everyday lives and what they did to maintain their courage, sanity and protect their lives. The book also describes the horrid living conditions.
Of all the non fiction, memoirs, biographies, and other survivor books I've read, I've never come across such detail add I did here. Jòzsef Debreczeni somehow managed to survive! He starts at Auschwitz, but gets moved from one camp to another, to another, months after months, after months only to find the next one worse than the last one! Each camp had longer work hours, less foods, less sleep, only making them weaker day after day.
When he arrives at Dörnhau, the "cold crematorium", he's discovered is just to suffer to death. Many are dying day after day. There's body waste everywhere, lice, tuberculosis, typhus, and with three bodies sharing a bed at a time, all it does is spread and get worse. The place is so horrific and gruesome, the Nazi's refuse to stay, especially when they learn their own men are picking up the lice and diseases.
Amazing to survive through this to give such a detailed story to remind us this should have happened. This needs to keep being brought up to make sure somebody as evil as Hitler can never create such a place again.
Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the arc.
You can read my review at Shelf Awareness here: https://www.shelf-awareness.com/sar-issue.html?issue=1216#m23220
“Above me, under me, all around me, this army of people ready to depart is crying out for God and water. Eyes turning glassy are soaking in the darkness of Hades or the foolish pinkness of heaven. Death is stepping between the bunks like a learned, confident young professor feeling quite at home.” -Cold Crematorium
"Cold Crematorium" by Jozsef Debreczeni is a truly heartbreaking account of survival amidst the darkest depths of human cruelty. Debreczeni's narrative not only unveils the horrors inflicted by the Nazis but also delves into the intricate dynamics of human behavior within the confines of the concentration camps.
One remarkable aspect of the book is its exploration of how prisoners navigated their relationships to survive. Unlike many other Holocaust narratives, Debreczeni's memoir delves into the complex interactions between inmates, revealing layers of resilience, strength, selflessness, and compassion amidst the direst circumstances.
Through Debreczeni's vivid prose, readers bear witness to the unfathomable diseases, the relentless torment of lice, and the lies that offered false hope to the prisoners, leaving an indelible mark on one's conscience.
Moreover, "Cold Crematorium" serves as a testament to the resilience of the human spirit, shedding light on the unwavering determination of individuals to endure and resist in the face of unimaginable adversity.
Debreczeni's unflinching portrayal of his experiences in three different camps underscores the necessity of confronting the brutal reality of the Holocaust. His account should indeed be required reading in schools, serving as a poignant reminder of the atrocities committed and the enduring strength of those who suffered through them. This masterpiece not only enriches Holocaust literature but also fosters a deeper understanding of the depths of human suffering and resilience.
My only question is… Why did it take so long for his account of these horrendous acts to be translated into other languages?
January 27 was Holocaust Remembrance Day . I didn’t read a Holocaust book near that date as I had planned , but it’s so important to remember it on any day. Gruesome, graphic, gut wrenching, this memoir written in 1950 was just recently translated from Hungarian.
Jozsef Debreczeni escaped the furnaces for the work camps, slave camps to be exact. For those who did, there was no escaping the horrors of daily life - no water to wash, the stench, lice, dysentery, typhus, whippings, almost no food with “daily rations: bread and a spoonful of sour jam” if that, soup with almost nothing in it . The hierarchy and cruelty of the kapo system pitting Jews against Jews , a tool of the Nazis is depicted in ways I had not read about previously. If the description of these horrific conditions don’t impact you, nothing will.
Translated works can sometimes lose something , but it feels as if the reality of this experience comes through vividly. The descriptions of the brutal reality of this all are difficult to read , but I couldn’t put this aside because I have to bear witness. It’s imperative to do so it doesn’t happen again . The only way I can do justice to this is to say, you must read it.
I received a copy of this book from St. Martin’s Press through NetGalley.
Gosh I am so glad that this memoir is available to the public. Cold Crematorium was so horrific and yet it's non-fiction. wonderfully written.