A novel about a culinary student and a musician has two of my favorite things: food and music.

Lexi wasn’t looking for love, she was only interested in staying on track and finishing culinary school with the dreams of becoming a chef. Well, when you’re not looking for something (or someone), that is when you are going to find it (them). Admittedly, Jake Taylor would have been pretty difficult to resist, so you can’t fault a girl for that.

An intimate weekend between Lexi and Jake was all that it was ever going to be, but they had a spark, a connection, they just seemed to fit together. Life and their ambitions had other ideas for them, and they were each on their own roads to success. It was never going to work out between an aspiring chef and a rock star, right? Well, that’s where it gets interesting.

Till There Was You was a good debut romance novel with characters that you couldn’t help but like. In fact, dare I say that Jake Taylor may have been one of the sweetest musician leads ever. With that being said, I like my love stories to have a bit more angst. Yes, of course their romance wasn’t easy or smooth, but I never really felt like their road was too rocky to overcome all of the obstacles. That may just be a me thing, though. I tend to gravitate to the stories that may or may not always work out. I want to feel the emotion in the pit of my stomach, feel the nervous tension.

All in all, Till There Was You was an entertaining novel. I did enjoy my time with the characters and their story. I appreciated that there was more to their story than their obvious attraction and romance, each of the main characters had their own issues that they had to deal with. It was a romance story that had layers. I would definitely read another book by Lindsay Hameroff in the future.

*4 Stars

Lexi and Jake meet a dive bar in NY one night; she is an aspiring chef out with friends and he is a musician. They have an instant connection that leads them to spending the weekend together. When Monday comes he is off to LA to record a demo and they plan to stay in touch. While he is out there, Jake gets discovered and becomes the next big thing with two of his hit songs are about Lexi. The instant fame leads to Lexi and him drifting apart. They reconnect in NY about a year later when Jake is back to record his second album and Leix is now working in a restaurant.

This was a fast and cute read. Once Jake and Lexi got back together, you could see that they loved each other but both have demanding careers that they are passionate about. As with all rom-coms, things always work out in the end and we have our HEA.

Read this if you enjoy:
🫐 Insta-love
🫐 Second chance romance
🫐 Closed door romance

While I enjoyed this book, there were parts of it that left me wanting more. I felt like the character development was there, I just unfortunately didn't love the characters that much. I found a lot of the same themes to be brought up repeatedly (restaurant work is difficult and it is hard to maintain relationships, is Jake going to leave again and never come back, etc.), and I felt like Lexi never really resolved a lot of the conflicts before the end of the book. I just left wishing that we had more of a wrap up at the end and less of the same repetitiveness in the middle of the book. Overall, I give this book a rating of 3.5 stars rounded down. I do think I will read more of this author in the future, especially because I enjoyed the beginning of the book so much!

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for an advanced copy of this book. All opinions within this review are my own.

Thank you to Netgalley for the opportunity to read this!

I really enjoyed this novel. It was a cute and fun rom com. I feel like Lexie and Jakes chemistry was well written. Though I do think his reasoning for ghosting her could have been better. It kind of just made want to kick him just a bit. But I still liked him.

I completely understand why Lexie didn’t want to talk to her dad. It’s always been a strong opinion of mine that if you’ve spent your life with someone you wouldn’t just replace them in five seconds. Of course they had to make up but I hated her dad. Months after her mom passed?? Yeah no I would haunt my husband lol.

But I still enjoyed Lexie and Jakes relationship and the side characters.

I do kinda want some blueberry pancakes now. Would have been amazing to add the recipe. Its 4am and I’m hungry 😂

Lexi Berman is a student hoping to eventually become an executive chef in a Michelin-star restaurant. Jake Taylor is the dive bar musician whom she meets and has a steamy weekend with. Jake leaves to record a demo in LA, and Lexi never expects to see him again. He's an overnight success, and she is doing well at her new job. When Jake turns up at her home, it derails her plans. The two can't seem to remain just friends, but a relationship with Jake means being in the tabloids as the subject of rumors and cruel comments that could potentially ruin her career. Is it worth keeping hold of?

This romcom stars a chef and a pop star, and both have incredibly busy careers. The two have chemistry and get along well. The demands of their jobs are hectic, as working in a restaurant requires many erratic hours just like recording an album and promoting it. While neither asked the other to drop their career, Jake asking Lexi to accompany him everywhere meant she was requesting time off a lot. She was also subject to paparazzi and staff that didn't want her involved with Jake. It preys on Lexi's self-doubts and fears of being abandoned again, leading to the low point in the relationship. We get our happily ever after on New Year's Eve, in the most dramatic fashion possible. It was such a fun finale, with real emotional stakes for both of them, but especially Lexi.

Thanks to netgalley or providing me with this ARC!

Did the author add in her own political commentary in a romance story? Yes. Was it unnecessary and did it take away from the story and make the author look childish? Yes.

I enjoyed the book more than I expected (I much prefer romances to be dual POV). The beginning felt somewhat slow and awkward, but the story hit its stride by the middle and was a low-angst, delightful read.

Alexa (Lexi) Berman has her goal set. Go to culinary school, work her way up to being a chef and getting a Michelin star. Then opening her own restaurant. There is no time for anything else. Her friends are trying to get her to loosen up but that's not working. Jake Taylor is a musician working in dive bars trying to get noticed. The chance meeting changes everything. The chemistry between them is off the charts. She gets her dream job and he heads to LA. Only it seems like he ghosted her. Can she get out of her head to let him back in? Not only are her fears giving her the blues, but his celebrity status is getting in the way. It takes advice from her dad to get her back on the right path. New Years Eve in NYC is the one time of the year for possibilities and HEA's.

Thank you to Netgalley and publisher for this cute and heart warming ARC! Loved Lexi and jakes story. While there were times the pacing towards the end felt rushed, I really enjoyed the development their relationship. I wish there was more development with Madison or Mia, but overall a cute read

Is being in the public eye is worth it?

Lexi Berman wanted to uphold her mother’s dream for her by finishing culinary school and becoming a professional chef. But Lexi never thought that the guy at the bar would write a bestselling viral song about her blueberry pancakes that she served him after their weekend together never expecting to see him again.

Musician Jake Taylor was getting ready to fly out to Los Angles to record his demo album when he met Lexi but after a whirlwind first album he tried to see Lexi as a friend after her returned to New York but there was something between them. But could Lexi deal with spotlights of his career and the hard work being on the lowest rung in a restaurant.

Till There Was You has a great romance about being in the public eye and the hard work in restaurants.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from the author and NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

This book is a realistic glimpse into the world of culinary arts students as well as a wanna-be pop star. The plot had some difficulty holding my attention since some of it was trite and other parts were predictable, but it was moderately paced, so I kept going. The characters are all flawed and realistic, but not terribly dynamic. There is not a lot of growth of character as the story moved along to the foregone conclusion. This book is more suited for younger readers, maybe 20-30 age graphic since the language and the steam/spice were both off-putting to me. The novel does include a lot of humor and some truth about staying focused on your goals in life, no matter how challenging they may be. Dealing with difficult topics like grief, self-discovery and self-image, the book was okay but not an attention grabber for me.
Disclaimer
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review and all opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16th CFR, Part 255, “Guidelines Concerning the Use of Testimonials and Endorsements in Advertising.”

Lexi wants to be a Michelin starred chef and has sworn off dating to stay focused on her career. When she meets handsome musician Jake just before he leaves for a tour, she decides to bend her own rule for a weekend romp. Jake’s tour takes off but he can’t get Lexi, or her blueberry pancakes, off his mind.

This one wasn’t my favorite, though you may enjoy it if you enjoy: 💨 insta love 🥞 blueberry pancakes 🎸 rockstar romance 👩🏼‍🍳 restaurant inner workings 🎧 he writes a song about her 🩷 new adult romantic comedy

3 stars.

"Till There Was You" by Lindsay Hameroff starts so strong! I loved the connection between the main characters, Lexi and Jake. I am not the biggest fan of insta-love as a trope, but Hameroff truly does it justice here. I really swooned hard for their romance in the beginning, and even rooted for them to get their second-chance romance. Unfortunately, the insta-love chemistry only lasts so long as the book's first half is better than the second half, where it all falls apart and becomes quite lackluster. Lexi devolves into a needy pick-me girl. She abandons her work, ethics, personality, friends, and wants for Jake. All of this happens... and for what? Jake doesn't speak up or advocate for Lexi or their relationship, he doesn't defend her/the two of them in any way, and I felt like he used Madison and the situation they were put in to garner more attention for himself (despite adamantly denying doing so). Let me be clear: Lexi is not innocent here. She abandons all of her principles while simultaneously sabotaging their courtship at every single turn. I feel like most authors have a hard time doing anything other than turning every single rock star romance with a "normal person" (aka non-famous person) into exactly the mess that happens here. It's quite cliched. Jake gets too big for his britches and puts his relationship on the back burner. Lexi questions everything they have ever had and needs constant reassurance that he's with her. Jake becomes more and more distracted by fame, performing, and living the high life that he loses himself entirely, and Lexi gives it all up for him, only to be ignored, so it ends in fiery chaos. While this was a fast read, I wish it had been more interesting. I didn't really believe that Lexi or Jake were happy at the end of the book, more that they tripped and fell into what happens to them in the end. Still, the chemistry between Jake and Lexi in the beginning might be enough to sustain most readers, it just wasn't enough for me. Also, the song "Blueberry"? It would never be a hit in real life and is cringe and not sweet. #sorrynotsorry

Thank you to NetGalley, Lindsay Hameroff, St. Martin's Press, and St. Martin's Griffin for the complimentary ARC of this book. All opinions are my own. I was not compensated for this review.

Thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin’s Griffin for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Till There Was You is the first book I’ve read by this author. I wanted to love it as the humor made me laugh out loud and I enjoyed the jokes. Unfortunately, the characters were one dimensional and the romance was pretty tame.

Since Lexi is a chef, allow me to compare this read to cotton candy. If you want a light, sugary, fluffy read with no real substance this may be the read for you.

Such a great rom com! Culinary student Lexi meets struggling singer Jake in a bar one night and that turns into the perfect weekend. Among other things, they fall in love over Lexi's blueberry pancakes. Jake heads to California for what should be a great opportunity and ends up being his big break. He is the next big thing and Lexi's friends have no idea his is the hook up that broke her heart. Imagine trying to get over someone with his voice literally everywhere singing about your pancakes. Fast forward to Lexi working her dream job and Jake reconnecting a few months later. Can she trust this is for good or is it just for his next inspiration. Even if it is for good, does she really fit in his crazy life? Warning, it will leave you searching for the perfect blueberry pancake recipe. I haven't found it yet, but if you know of one, send it my way!

This was such a fun book to read! I picked it for the @betweenthecoverspod and Between the Covers Book Club at @dogearedbooksAmes pick for April.

This was a pretty cute celeb romance!

I actually think this would have made a great novella.
The start and ending were super fun 🥰

I really enjoyed the story, probably since I’m a sucker for it - MCs getting together before fame, and navigating that afterwards.

📖 Till There Was You
📝 Lindsay Hameroff
🗓️ 02/20/2024
💜 Contemporary Romance

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️

This one had a really strong start for me - I loved the dynamic between Lexi & Jake, their instant connection and strong pull to one another.

Something in the middle was lacking for me - the conflict was a bit repetitive. I felt myself wanting to skip ahead and see how it worked out.

I also wanted MORE of the characters - I didn’t feel like I got to know them enough, especially Jake.

Tropes + topics:
😍 insta-love
⏳ second chance
👩‍🍳 chef fmc
🎶 musician mmc
🤩 famous person
🏠 temporary roommates
💖 single POV/first person

Thank you to NetGalley & St. Martin’s Press for an advanced copy. All opinions are my own.

TILL THERE WAS YOU – Lindsay Hameroff
Griffin
ISBN: 978-1250902917
February 20, 2024
Contemporary Romance

New York City – Present Day

One night, culinary student Lexi Berman meets aspiring musician Jake Taylor in a dive bar where he’s performing. They hit it off and end up spending a few days and nights together at her apartment. She even makes him her signature dish, Blueberry Pancakes. Fast forward several months later and Jake is a rising superstar with a hit single that he wrote called Blueberry. It’s clear to Lexi that he drew inspiration from her, but she can’t tell anyone. After all, Jake had told her when he left her apartment that morning, they would keep in touch, but he never contacted her. She has even deleted his phone number from her phone. In the meantime, Lexi has graduated from culinary school and has obtained a job in the kitchen of a top restaurant. Then Jake shows up one day at her apartment. It’s like there never was a chasm between them. While she insists that they only be friends, it’s soon clear that they care more about each other than only being friends. But can there be a future between a rock star and an aspiring chef?

TILL THERE WAS YOU takes place over several months and is told only from the viewpoint of Lexi. She is estranged from her father after he remarried shortly after her mother died and moved to Florida. She is living in the family apartment that is almost like a shrine to her mother. Meeting Jake in the bar that night led to an instantaneous attraction between them. Lexi went into the fling knowing that Jake was working on getting a recording contract and becoming a star. At the age of twenty-four, Lexi didn’t mind that because they were both young. However, after he left, she realized how much he meant to her. But it was radio silence from him. Now he’s back in her life and he is taking her on a whirlwind tour of what it’s like to live in the world of the rich and famous. However, Lexi begins to feel uncomfortable. Her job at the restaurant is important and she can’t give up her dreams to follow Jake around like a groupie. He wants to please her, but he has obligations to those around him. How will they resolve their conflicts? Is there a chance for a happily-ever-after for them?

Imagine yourself as an everyday person who suddenly finds yourself being the girlfriend of a famous person. While it might be fun, the stress eventually gets to you because there is always a competition going on from those who demand his attention, and you want to be alone with your guy. That is what Lexi is going through in the thought provoking TILL THERE WAS YOU. Jake is a good guy, but his career is as important to him as Lexi’s is to her. As they grow closer, once he returns, the more conflicted she becomes. Should she just break it off and forget about the one man she has fallen for? Their magical love may end up being cursed. Find out what happens by grabbing a copy of TILL THERE WAS YOU.

Patti Fischer
Romance Reviews Today

As a musical theater lover, I absolutely loved the Broadway thread that was woven into this story and the relationship between Jake and Lexi. It made me so happy that their shared appreciation of musicals was discussed the first time they met and that it influenced the very first song he chose to play for her. I can't think of a more immediate way to endear these characters to me, and the fact that it shows up throughout the book just brought me so much joy!

Also, I can honestly say that I never had the desire to be a famous musician or a chef --- and after reading this book I am grateful that I never found myself on either of those career paths. So often we are shown the glamourous side of celebrity --- whether as a singer or a chef --- but Lindsay Hameroff showed us the darker, less glitzy side of both jobs. It was useful insight in understanding both Lexi and Jake and their endeavor to chase their dreams but their realization that sometimes our dreams change when something or someone comes along that tips the balance of things. The description of what they both dealt with work-wise went a long way in making them sympathetic characters and helping the reader understand why they made some of the questionable choices they made.

I also have to mention how much I loved Lexi's 2 best friends and Jake's family!!
You may enjoy this book if you love:
- An inside look into the world of celebrity or restaurant kitchens
- Second chance romance
- Forced proximity
- Descriptions of delicious food
- Flawed characters that are not perfect but may be perfect for each other
- Broadway musicals
- HEA/love wins

Read with care and caution if you are triggered by loss of parent to cancer (prior to events of the story), strained relationship with parent, sexism, brief mention of workplace harassment, and manipulation.

Overall, I really enjoyed this story and spending time with Lexi and Jake. It was an engaging read and I am thankful to the publishers for the opportunity to read this advance review copy. I'm off to make some pancakes and listen to Les Mis ; )

I have chosen to withhold my review of Till There Was You by Lindsay Hameroff in accordance with the marketing boycott of reviewing and platforming titles published under St. Martin’s Press and associated imprints. As a company, St. Martin’s Press has yet to meaningfully acknowledge and address the harm caused by a marketing employee who perpetuated Islamophobic sentiments against those of Palestinian descent specifically, and has a documented history of discriminating against readers of Arab heritage in general. As a reader, I refuse to participate, even passively, in perpetuating harm against my fellow readers in an activity all should be able to enjoy.

Once action is taken by St. Martin’s Press as a company to address the harm caused and how they will be dedicated to a decisive plan of action to address needs for diversity, equity and inclusion, I will upload my review of Till There Was You by Lindsay Hameroff.

Lexi has wanted to be a Michelin starred chef ever since she was a teen, and once her mom died, she’s been determined to make her proud - and avoid any distractions. Jake Taylor is an aspiring singer, looking to make the big time, and Lexi simply can’t resist. The two spend one magical weekend together, but then Jake disappears… right as he becomes an overnight star. His hit single? A song obviously inspired by the blueberry pancakes Lexi made him during their brief time together. When Jake reappears in her life a year later, one of the most famous people in the world can she trust him enough not to abandon her again? And can she handle living in his spotlight?

Lindsay Hameroff takes two heavyweight tropes – the aspiring chef, the meteoric celebrity – and sets them on a collision course in her debut novel, Till There Was You. Mix in insta-love, a double whammy of daddy issues, and (dead) mommy issues, overnight success vs creeping failure, and you’ve got a recipe for a pair who really probably shouldn’t be together, but ends up there anyway. Jake screws up again and again – ghosting Lexi, allowing his very obviously doesn’t-have-his-client’s-best-interests-at-heart manager (his name is Vinny! Of course he turns out the villain!) to control his career in ways he hates and drives a wedge between him and Lexi, and showing up expecting Lexi to drop everything for him time and time again. Even more frustratingly, she basically does.

While Lexi and Jake are cute together, they felt really young to me. Both need to do a lot of work on themselves before they’re really ready to commit to each other (or anyone else). I wish Harmeroff had aged them down a few years (make them 21 or 22, rather than 25-26) – it would have better suited the story and the characters. Lexi’s friends were a hoot: I particularly enjoyed celebrity PR manager Chloe and her enfant terrible client, and sorta kitchen rival Mia. Plus, all the tasty sounding food inspired me to put down my book and make fresh pasta for dinner!

In sum: Fun, but slightly askew. Age down your characters or make them more mature – and market the book appropriately for a higher rating.

CW: Death of a parent (off page, in the past), sexual harassment in the workplace (described)

Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

4.5 ⭐️

After a random bar meet, sort of one night stand turned epic weekend, Jake and Lexi found more common ground than they thought they’d have. But when Jake pursues his music career in LA and skyrockets, Lexi finds herself trying to get over him. She’s been forgotten after all. Ready to move on after a year, she finds Jake at her front door. Between his busy celebrity engagements and her crazy chef hours at a restaurant, could their reunion spark a long lasting relationship or are they inevitably doomed?

This was the celebrity romance I was looking for! Plenty detail about Lexi’s chef life, Jake’s stardom, and the complexity of Lexi’s emotions around her father that left. All told in Lexi’s POV, I thought I got a lot of Jake’s thoughts because he was just the biggest cinnamon roll hero. Loved him! Even though I was anxiously waiting for the other show to drop practically the whole time after they reunited. Overall enjoyed this one and recommend to my lovely celebrity romance lovers!