The discrimination, the fight of magic against non-magic, and a hard nock protagonist who's fighting for the people she loves. This book has an excellent premise. But the characters and plot get a bit lost in the slow pacing, the clunky sentences, and over writing. The story is good but it drags on too long at the beginning before picking up and the whole thing would benefit with a little smoothing out.

Wow. This was a super unique story, I am having a hard time thinking of another book I've read to compare it to and coming up blank.
A Contemporary fantasy that deals with segregation, oppression, corrupt politicians, and people willing to fight for whats right. A very powerful read that should make you at least a little uncomfortable in the best way.
The representation in this of a non-binary character is done so well in how matter of factly its handled I love to see it.

The Poisons We Drink


This book was quite the ride. Twists and turns all throughout, and I never knew what was coming next. This story is a great mix of fantasy and political intrigue.

The main protagonist, Venus Stoneheart, is a potion maker; she makes her living mainly selling illegal love potions. In her world, witches and humans are divided and constantly at odds. When tragedy strikes her family, Venus is thrown into a political struggle for which she wasn’t unprepared.

The world-building is rich and incredible. The little blurbs at the beginning of each chapter help you to put the pieces of the world together. The characters’ harsh reality reflects many struggles in our current society. Venus is a unique protagonist; she is definitely not perfect and tries her best to protect and provide for the people around her. She is a young woman with the weight of the world on her shoulders, and I enjoyed following her story and seeing how she dealt with everything thrown at her. Overall, this was an intriguing read, with beautiful characters and a fascinating world.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this book.

The premise for The Poisons We Drink was interesting. I had been excited about this title for a while, even though it was ok, there was something off with the family relationship and I don't even want to get started on the mom. I felt myself wondering off and putting off reading, which is not something I typically do.

Don't let my review deter you from reading this book, I believe it was simply not for me.

Wow. Whew. This book was INCREDIBLE. I have chills and tears upon finishing. The underlying messages… I bow to the author. This book made me feel so many things. I am honored to have gotten to read it.

What a fun read! Bethany Baptiste creates a world of Witchers that parallels our own. Only a small part of the Witcher population, though, is skilled and dedicated enough to be brewer. While Venus originally brews to provide for her family, it soon takes on a life of its own as she decides if she will use it to ensure the safety of all Witchers.

The Poisons We Drink is a YA must-read. This urban fantasy hooked me from the moment I saw the cover's stunning art. It boasts a unique magic system, refreshing present-day setting, and fantastic LGBTQ+ representation.

But wait, there's more! The world-building is incredible. Bethany Baptiste crafts a detailed and immersive world that kept me enthralled throughout the entire story. Buckle up for an action-packed adventure – you won't be disappointed!

An entertaining YA urban fantasy about Venus, a Black "witcher," and her family in a war against humans and other witchers. I received a Netgalley eARC from the publisher but ended up listening to it on audiobook through my library's Libby. The audiobook narration was very well done and kept me on my toes throughout the novel. It was quite long and at times I was slightly confused and had to go back to re-listen, but it was very entertaining. I definitely didn't see some of the twists in the story. I struggle sometimes with understanding a fantasy world's rules but this one was written in a very understandable way. I thought the main character and side characters were very well written and generally complex, aside from the obvious villains. The complicated family relationships was very realistic and well done. Excited to read anything else Bethany Baptiste comes out with!

I really enjoyed this book! The Poisons We Drink is a Young Adult Urban Fantasy and I was immediately intrigued by the cover! This book has such a unique magic system, queer rep and it's set in present times which was really nice! Don't even get me started on the world building. I was enthralled the entire time and loved how in detail everything was. If you are looking for an action packed fantasy adventure then this is for you!

The Poisons We Drink is an incredibly rich debut by Bethany Baptiste. The world-building and magical systems here were beautifully and imaginatively constructed. This magical society and its politics are ruthless, and Venus (our MC), must navigate the world with care, without losing herself to the pull of dark magical power and corruption. It’s a cautionary tale in how easy it is to give in to our darkest urges, while also shining a light on some of society’s most neglected topics, such as racism, mental health, and political corruption. I love morally gray characters and their journeys, so Venus was a very compelling MC to me. She was complex and sometimes frustrating, but I needed to see her carry out her mission throughout the story. The writing vividly painted a magical society that made me want to immerse myself in its world to better understand the magic systems, to live with the characters, and to watch the political machinations of its leadership unfold. The story was action-packed, but also heartfelt and emotional. Highly recommended.

2.5/3 stars

I want to preface this by saying I DNF at 30%.
Let’s start with my likes. I like the characters, they felt like real people. I like the setting. I like how the themes were presented and how they flowed in the words. The magic system did truly seem interesting.

Despite this, I believe this is a book that didn’t like me far more than I didn’t like it.

The story was not engaging to me. The tone of the writing felt juvenile despite the book’s more mature themes. The characters felt real but i couldn’t relate to them which is a odd paradox.

I really wanted to love this but unfortunately it's just not working for me. While the premise sounded good and the beginning is intriguing, the narrative is dragging and isn't really keeping my interest.

holy shit holy. shit. i absolutely adore this. i love my morally grey witches so much.

thank you to netgalley and sourcebooks for the egalley!

This is my first book by this author and it was definitely a heavy one. This book touched on many different topics that I found very interesting to read. It was very well written but very strong content.

A queer witcher with her mother’s death to avenge, all in a political environment that pits humans against witchers. This is part fantasy, part thriller, and 100% badass.

THIS WAS MY FAV READ OF THE YEAR. Wow, so thrilling and yet, full of prose that I got lost in. The world building stood out in a great way and I am so glad I took a chance on it!

thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Fire for the arc

3.5 i loved the concept and the magic system was really cool, but there were SO many 'important' characters to keep track of their designation as "son of X character" made it really hard to figure out why any betrayal or gotcha moment had teeth. same with figuring out who had an alliance/oath/promise with whom. on the other hand i enjoyed reading it!

"Bethany Baptiste's 'The Poison We Drink' is a gripping and thought-provoking novel that delves into the complexities of human nature and society's darker undercurrents. Baptiste's writing is both elegant and evocative, drawing readers into a world filled with suspense and moral ambiguity. As the story unfolds, the characters grapple with their own demons while navigating a web of secrets and lies, ultimately leading to a stunning and satisfying conclusion. Through her skillful storytelling, Baptiste sheds light on pressing social issues, challenging readers to confront uncomfortable truths about power, privilege, and the consequences of our actions. 'The Poison We Drink' is a compelling read that will stay with you long after you turn the final page."

Baptiste crafted an alternate world that uses magic to explore themes of racism, classism, sexuality and generational trauma. Venus, still so young but straddled with such responsibility, literally puts her body and life in danger to support her family by brewing love potions. Her younger sister, Janus, wants to follow in her father’s footsteps and lead a revolution to guarantee the rights and freedom of witches, but her youthful overconfidence often puts both sisters in danger, adding to Venus’s stress and sense of responsibility. Adding to that tension is the fraught relationship both girls have with their mother. A mother who is more often terse, controlling, and detached when dealing with her two daughters. This complicated relationship drives much of the story and really packs an emotional punch.

The magical system is well developed and very interesting. I really enjoyed the lore of the brewers and their importance in history. There was just information given to keep the reader invested in the story without being too cumbersome with overly detailed rules. The magic was expertly woven into the story and always felt integral, not at all like it was used for convenience or to fill plot holes.

This is definitely a well paced, emotionally charged, and thought provoking book that will stay with you long after the last page. Thank you to Netgalley and the Publisher for the opportunity to read and review this title. All opinions and mistakes are my own.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. This is my honest review.

Even though this was a very heavy, at many times violent (Do read the trigger warnings!) book - very much outside of what I usually read - I still liked it. It is refreshing to read bipoc stories in fantasy. It was fast paced most of the time, but I do think it could have been trimmed down a little. It's fairly long for a YA story and in the middle it lulled for a bit.

That being said, I did feel like their was a lot of character development, which I personally prefer over a very deep plot. A number of characters, but I also liked that. It felt like each one really meant something and weren't just throw away.

It did feel more towards the New Adult end of the rating spectrum than Young Adult. (More towards the 15-20 age bracket because of the violence). I hope more books like this emerge and I will definitely read another from this author.