Member Reviews

Happy publication day to The Misfits #1: A Royal Conundrum by Lisa Yee! This was such a fun book. It's set on an island off the coast of San Fransisco that used to house a prison. Of course, Alcatraz and one of my favorite movies, The Rock, is what immediately came to my mind.

12-year-old Olive Cobin Zang often feels invisible. Even her parents don't seem to notice her most of the time. She doesn't have any friends and she doesn't seem to fit in anywhere. The one person who understood her was her grandmother, but she is gone and Olive misses her so much. Out of the blue, Olive's mother transfers her to a boarding school on an island. At her new school, Olive meets and becomes friends with a group of fellow "misfits" who have also been searching for friendship and a place to belong. It turns out that these misfits have been selected to become crime fighters! If the school can't raise some money fast, it is in danger of closing. Olive doesn't want to lose the one place that finally feels like home. Can she and her fellow misfits catch a thief and keep their school from closing? This book is sure to be a hit with middle-grade readers!

Thank you to Random House Children's and NetGalley for a review copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Such a fun middle grade read! Fast paced and intriguing from page 1. A must add to classroom shelves! I know my 4th and 5th graders will love this book when it is published!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun and super quick read! Olive and her band of misfits has found family, twists and turns and a school based on an old prison like Alcatraz Island, such a cool setting. Also, the cliffhanger at the end of the book definitely has me ready to jump right into RASCH when the second book comes out!

Was this review helpful?

This book is the first in a series and I requested it for my daughter (4th grade) because she is typically a fan of middle-grade adventure novels.

While she enjoyed some elements of the book, particularly the mystery of who stole the jewels and the action surrounding catching the thief, she said the characters fell a bit flat to her and there were times the plot was boring, as it seemed to have excessive dialogue.

Overall, while it was not a bad read, she said she would not be eager to pick up the next book in the series.

Was this review helpful?

The Misfits: A Royal Conundrum by Newbery Honoree Lisa Yee and Caldecott Medalist Dan Santat is about a team of crime-fighting underdogs who are out to catch a notorious thief!

I think a lot of children will easily relate to the main character, Olive. I think this book will be very popular with its intended audience.

Most of the artwork in the ebook ARC was noted as an initial sketch or not final. I can’t wait to see the final artwork!

I loved the way the ending brought everything together and left the reader wondering how the second book in the series will work out. The Misfits is a great addition to classrooms and libraries! I especially think fans of City Spies and the Spy School series will love this book!

Thank you to Random House Children’s Books and @NetGalley for the gifted ebook ARC in exchange for an honest review.

#TheMisfits1ARoyalConundrum #NetGalley #childrenslit #childrensfiction #middlegradereads #middlegradebooks

Was this review helpful?

The title and cover of this book caught my attention. I like how this book made someone with a low self esteem gain confidence. This book is a mood lifter. It does have some humor and problem solving, along with a mystery. I am a cat lover, so it was fun to have cats as part of this mystery. The way the book ended makes me think there will be a second book. I will definitely read the next…..

Was this review helpful?

A fun and adventurous romp, where the underdogs are the heroes! There's oodles of mystery, adventure, cool gadgets/tech and a whole lot of cavorting capers. Fast pace and plot driven. Plenty of diverse characters. And good overarching messages about not judging people based on their skin color, age, or gender.

Very upbeat, with antics perfect for middle grade readers.

Was this review helpful?

As a fan of illustrated chapter books, I give this a solid 3.5 stars. The story is there and will keep kids engaged, but the plot jumps around A LOT with a somewhat baffling timeline. The illustrations were only sketches in the ARC I reviewed, but looked very promising. The cast of characters are cute, each with their own believably goofy personality. It's a purposefully over the top tale, perfect for fans of Mac B. Kid Spy or The 13 Story Treehouse.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for an advance copy for review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun story filled with quirky kids who work as undercover spies to help stop a jewelry heist that threatens to destroy their beloved boarding school that is located in a former prison off the coast of San Francisco. I would recommend it to kids who like books like CITY SPIES or SPY SCHOOL that make heroes at kids who are a bit off-beat. This book is mostly text but benefits from illustrations from award-winning illustrator Dan Santat.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks so much to @netgalley and @randomhousekids for the early copy of The Misfits #1: A Royal Conundrum by Lisa Yee, Dan Santat (Illustrator). This was such a fun (and funny!) start to a new middle grade illustrated series, perfect for fans of Spy School.

Olive Cobin Zang’s always too busy parents drop her off at the strangest boarding school ever: a former castle turned prison that's now a “reforming arts school.” Or is it? The academy isn’t what it seems and Olive finds herself part of an elite group of misfit kids who fight crime.

This was a great read that I just flew through and highly recommend for middle grade readers. I love stories that feature “misfits” as the ones saving everyone and everything. Get your hands on this asap – it publishes January 2! A great start to a New Year!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the e-ARC. An engaging read that will be a hit for kids everywhere for it's message about fitting it and friendship. Looking forward to continuing the series.

Was this review helpful?

What a lovely book about finding a place where you fit in. I love this idea that every kiddo, no matter how unique their interests, can one day find a place where they fit in. More importantly, being able to find people who see what others might see as oddities as being a gift. Because finding the right people is truly the best way to go about life. While yes Olive finds these people because of a unique school, I love how her team is brought together. All their different skills make up the perfect team. Kids will love seeing unique skills being highlighted as positive instead of being an oddity. This is just such a fun book and because it is the first in a series kids will get to go on many adventures with these loveable characters. I do wish the ending had not been quite as rushed. But kids might not mind that as much as adults do.
Thank you to Random House Children and Netgalley for allowing me to read an advance copy of this title.

Was this review helpful?

My 10 y/o read this one in a few sittings, and really appreciated the diverse characters. Looking forward to future additions.

ARC from the publisher via NetGalley, but the opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the e-ARC of this book.

I liked this book a lot, but the best part is really that it's the first of a series. So many of our kids love diving into a series of this type, and this will be a perfect recommendation.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for the opportunity to read this in exchange for an honest review!

Olive feels invisible at school and at home. Her parents can’t even remember her age let alone her birthday.
But that all changes when she is enrolled in a school with secret spies!
I thought this was a fun and lovable read about a bunch of misfits. I definitely recommend this.
And the artwork is amazing I can’t wait to see what it looks like when it’s published.

Was this review helpful?

Like Harry, and other literary kids that get to go to special schools, Olive feels alone, lonely and left out. Her parents are always out of town for work, her beloved grandmother has "left us," and trouble seems to find her. However, that all changes when her mother drops her off at a special school, where she finds her tribe among a team of misfits and gets to help save her school. Experienced "special school" readers won't be as surprised as Olive is by the twist at the end, but most reader will enjoy following Olive on her first adventure with the misfits. The ending promises continuing adventures for this warm and fun pod of misfits.

Was this review helpful?

I adore this book. Very suitable for middle graders out there to find their places, bravery and acceptance.

This story follows Olive, who feel she didn't belong with everyone else in her school. Her super busy parents, then put her in RASCH. School for everyone where what matters is not your grade, but your creativity, attitude, teamwork. It's like no other school outside.
At RASCH, Olive gradually found her place and her people. And what's better? She was chosen as one of the elite groups to work undercover helping to solve the crime. When RASCH is on the brink of collapse and a notorious thief is out there, Olive and her team (Phil, Theo, James, Iggy,Modest, Monica) put into action and helped RASCH secure its place.

What I love:
- the school atmosphere, and their teachers!!!
- the characters were quite solid and well written.
- the plot was taking it easy to introduce everything. The pace was uite slow but not that bothering.

What I think could be written better:
- Phil and her unbelievable tools. It's way WAAAAYYY too convenient it's lessen the thrill😂
- the heist and how the dots were connected.
- the ending. I love it, but it just felt rushy the things with Olive parents turned out to be.

Overall, I enjoy the books a lot and children 9-14yo might feel the same way!!!

Was this review helpful?

A fun middle grade read! A group of uniquely talented students are trained to be secret agents. Together they work to solve a crime and save their beloved school. In the process, they learn to trust themselves and each other. Great for readers who loved City Spies!

Was this review helpful?

Action plus humor provided by a well-known author and a well-known illustrator.
Only child Olive Cobin Zang seems to be, or tries to be, invisible at school. She does so well that even her parents rarely notice her they are so busy traveling with their jobs. After her care giving grandmother dies, her mom takes her to a weird boarding school that was previously a castle and then a prison. There she finds her “people” i.e. other misfit kids like herself. But suddenly she finds this group being recruited to go undercover to track down a burglar who could, if they stole the jewels belonging to the school’s primary benefactor, shut down the school.

Was this review helpful?

This 288 page middle grade crime book follows Olive Cobin Zang as she finds her place in a unique school among a group of misfits tasked with using their age to go unnoticed and save the day. I sought out this book because of the undeniable hijabi on the cover. And while Philomena, Phil, is a very important side character, what is shared about her is very minimal. Twice it mentions the color of her headscarf, once a negative comment is aimed at her by delinquents on the street, and it mentions in passing that she speaks a little Farsi. Other than that and the critical part that she is a tech wiz, nothing further is shared. The text never mentions Islam, being Muslim or even uses the word hijab. Religion is not mentioned at all in the book, for any of the characters, and only Olive's background and family insights are shared. I appreciate that for the book at hand, a girl in hijab is a non issue, and will probably read future books in the story to see if her background is confined to stereotypes and tropes, or not. Based on the writing quality and story telling of this book, I'm hopeful that the series, like the first book, will be clean, exciting, and a fun recommendation for students to obsess over.

#islamicschoollibrarian #muslimbookreviewer #muslimcharacter #muslimintheillustration #2024

Was this review helpful?