Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thanks to Netgalley and Feiwel & Friends for the eARC!

I first read "Pride and Prejudice" when I was 12 and I hated it. I wanted nothing to do with it. As I got older I grew to appreciate the story and it's context. This is a long way of saying I actually enjoyed this more than I ever enjoyed P+P.

I feel I understand Olivers struggles to be seen for who he truly is than the period drama of it all.

This was such a fun, quick read. I really enjoyed myself!

Was this review helpful?

Imgur link goes to Instagram graphic scheduled for Jan 5th
Blog Post will go live January 5th
Will be cover on Youtube midmonth/month wrapup for December

Most Ardently is a remix of Pride in Prejudice in which Elizabeth is instead, Oliver a trans boy trapped, pretending to be Elizabeth. Naturally, do the time of P&P Oliver must hide who he is and though this is incredibly similar in the structure and some of the story beats to the original, it does take into consideration things from that period that would have been important/affected someone like Oliver.

The story is short, and truly sweet. We see Oliver struggle with when or how to tell his family who he truly is. The only people who know are Jane and Charlotte (though slowly more find out through the course of the book) and ultimately he does find that place and time. The writing in this was readable and pacy and the moments of Oliver changing into the clothes that truly fit him and presenting as he wanted to be seen made my heart happy.

I genuinely loved a lot about this, and in the end it was nothing but joy for Oliver and Darcy. I do wish we’d had a bit more, perhaps just more to the story? I feel it possibly was edited down to fit the series length requirements or something similar as the later half to this felt very rushed. If you’re interested, I really recommend this. The cover is stunning and the inside is just as rich and lovely.

4 out of 5 classic love letters

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this prepub in exchange for an honest review.

I love pride and prejudice. So when I saw a remix version where one of the main characters is trans, I got excited to read it. I love reimagined tales, but I feel they need to stay true to the times. I don’t see this type of ending as possible back then. I liked that the author made the story their own while staying as true to the original tale as they could, but when we got to the ending I became disappointed. Oliver probably wouldn’t have been as accepted, he would probably more likely have been sent to a sanatorium back then having revealed himself.

But even though it didn’t stick with historical accuracy I did enjoy the story.

Was this review helpful?

A fun retelling of Pride & Prejudice! I found myself quickly wrapped up and finished the story in one sitting which is very high praise these days! (It's been a chore to read some novels lately.) The characterizations felt authentic to the source material yet refreshed in the queer remixed style.

I feel that this book is great for young adults and older, especially those who wish to see some queer happiness in their stories.

Was this review helpful?

Full disclosure, I have not read Pride and Prejudice. So I won't be making a comparison in this review.

I was a little worried going into this book that I wouldn't like it, because I usually read historical fiction with a little more magic in them. However this book has no problem spinning its spell around you and keeping you hooked.

I found myself unable to put the book down, waiting for the next time Oliver and Darcy would interact with each other because their banter was so good. I really enjoyed Oliver's character and his sharp remarks against the society he lives in.

I also enjoyed seeing the bit of growth that Oliver goes through as he fights to build a life that he wants to see. I loved all of the side characters and some of the interactions with Oliver and his parents felt like a warm hug.

I think this was a wonderful retelling of a classic story that all readers can enjoy. I'm glad to see classic stories like this told from a queer lens.

Thank you to netgalley for giving me the chance to read and review this story!

Was this review helpful?

This was such an adorable and wholesome queer retelling of P&P. If you like the original story, you will love this. I thought it stayed quite true to the original Pride & Prejudice story, like a retelling should. I am obsessed with the Darcy we see when he spends time with Oliver, and was giggling everytime he was mean to “Elizabeth”
Mr. Bennet was the perfect father and I absolutely loved the author note at the end

Highly recommend!! Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an eARC in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

First of all, I love Pride and Prejudice. I have also enjoyed quite a few other books in this series, including my favorite at this point, Self-Made Boys. Secondly, this is a very short book, only 200 or so pages. With that being said, my major hang-up was with the pacing. This book needed to be an extra 50-100 pages longer. I felt like we were constantly flip-flopping between keeping to the original P&P storyline and the plotline where Darcy and Oliver meet when Oliver can go out as himself. I would rather have had more time to develop the relationship between Darcy and Oliver then rush those scenes to keep a storyline that follows the og P&P. But if the book was a bit longer, we could probably have had both (though I still say Darcy and Oliver scenes beat out any scene with Wickham or Collins). I would recommend this book if you want more trans rep in your historical fiction or if you want an easy-to-read queer story with a familiar plot because its short, sweet, and has a happy ending. But the main romance will end up feeling a bit underdeveloped.

Was this review helpful?

It's the early 1800's and Oliver Bennet feels trapped, by his mother's expectations, by societies standards, but mostly due to the fact that when everyone looks at him they see a girl. Oliver is trans and is only out to a few friends and family members, hiding his secret and sneaking out at night to try and find time to live the way he craves. I'm not familiar with the source material, i've never read the og Pride and Prejudice, so i'm not sure how faithful the plot is. Oliver does however, find hinself once he becomes friends with Darcy, a boy he met at Elizabeth and did not have a good impression of at first. As oliver realizes the depths of his feelings for Darcy, he'll have to decide what he wants his future to look like. This was a good adaption, the inclusion of trans and lgbtq characters felt natural and well done, they fit into society in a way that was realistic while still giving them plenty of room to be themselves. I particularly liked <spoiler> that it was Oliver's father who found out first of his parents, and kept the secret until Oliver told him, and stood by him to the point of changing his will to make him his heir. </spoiler> The character interactions were realistic and fun to read, with the characters all having unique identities that made them interesting to follow, even if some of them turn out to not be great people. The plot wrapped up a bit too quickly for me, but i'm not even mad because Oliver's character arc was done well.

Was this review helpful?

I am not a fan of Pride and Prejudice. I requested this because it was a queer take on the novel. But to be honest the only thing that i liked was the queer vibes. Other than that I really did not like this. If you are a fan of Pride and Prejudice I would suggest this.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Children's Publishing Group; all opinions expressed are exclusively my own.

Pride & Prejudice is one of my all time favorite stories, and so it was with anticipation and trepidation that I began reading Most Ardently. Some P&P retellings are great, and some leave me incredibly dissatisfied. In the case of Most Ardently, while I couldn't help the occasional internal squawks about the (really unimportant) original details ("Charlotte Lucas had siblings!" "The Bennets lived near Meryton, not London!"), I knew this book shone where it really mattered: as a queer coming-of-age romance set in the Regency era. The author took pains to introduce historical accuracy in terms of how trans and queer people existed in those times in England, and managed frequently to apply the original text when fitting into this remix. It doesn't hit the same notes as P&P with me, but that's not the point at all, and I think it's lovely that this book exists. Sensitive readers can take note of the warnings in the front of the book regarding misgendering, dysphoria, as well as historical transphobia, homophobia, and misogyny.

Was this review helpful?

This was absolutely adorable and such a delightful reimagining. Oliver and Darcy’s connection was silly, but intense and serious at the same time. I felt so deeply for Oliver as his mother and others called him by his deadname and constantly called him out for not being the “daughter” or “woman” that he was expected to be. It was rough but I appreciated the way that Novoa wrote Oliver’s journey overall. The author’s note at the very end on historical accuracy when it comes to queer and trans folks during that time period was chef’s kiss.

Was this review helpful?

Most Ardently is a beautiful queer retelling of Pride and Prejudice, in which Oliver, not Elizabeth, is the protagonist and Darcy's love interest. I love Pride and Prejudice, and cannot believe this is the second (very different) queer retelling I got to read this year!! The book overall sticks pretty close to the original, with the expected villainy of Collins and Wickham, but some extra space given for Oliver to grapple with his identity and with how he chooses to reveal it to his loved ones. It felt a little simple for my taste, but I think it would be perfect for a younger audience closer in age to Oliver.

Was this review helpful?

I am actually having so many emotions about this book. First of all, let me say that the Remixed Classics series is one of my all time favorite ideas. I love taking well known stories and asking: but what if it was queer? what if they weren’t white? what if they weren’t men? This is the third one I’ve read and it’s just as amazing as the others and makes me so excited to read every one in the series.

Admittedly, I am not a huge fan of Pride and Prejudice. The general idea of the story and the way I’ve seen people interact and react to it has always been interesting to me though and I loved another reimagining of the story, The Lizzie Bennet Diaries. I also love Gabe Cole Novoa’s writing in general, The Wicked Bargain is one of my top favorite reads so when I saw he was writing this and got approved for the ARC I was so pleased.

The thing that got to me the most, I think, was Oliver’s emotions and desires. The way he just wanted so badly to be himself and fought for it, even though it was so scary to do it. His relationship with Jane and his father got me a bit teary eyed more than once.

Each time Oliver came out, while not always intending to do so, I was braced for it to go horribly, but each time I was pleasantly surprised and reassured by the openness and pride that each character reacted with. I think between how society still reacts to trans people today and the way narratives for characters like Oliver usually go, I was expecting blatant and harsh transphobia. And while there was transphobia, for me the blows were softened by the acceptance of his sister, his father, and eventually Darcy and his mother. That being said, please still take care of yourself and know that there is still transphobia, homophobia, dysphoria, and misogyny that Oliver deals with throughout the book. Know what you can handle as a reader.

Thank you to NetGalley for making this available in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This was a delightful read! I'm a huge Jane Austen fan, so I was very excited about this and it didn't let me down! Gabe does a great job of staying true to Austen's iconic characters while making some important changes to the plot. At some points I did wonder if this would have been stronger as its own thing rather than as a remix, but it is wonderful to see a classic reimagined with queer characters.

Elizabeth Bennet isn't really Elizabeth Bennet. Oliver is a boy forced to be a girl because of society who nonetheless finds time to dress as his true self on occasion. While snubbed by Darcy as Elizabeth, Oliver and Darcy hit it off, creating complications that threaten to upend the delicate balance of Oliver's life. How can he resign himself to marrying and pretending to be a girl forever when he's had a taste of romance?

Was this review helpful?

<i>I received a copy of this story from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.</i>

Oh this book! What a beautiful celebration of queer joy! It makes my heart so happy.

I love Pride & Prejudice and so I was incredibly excited to read this queer remix. I liked how iconic moments or lines were used here. They were either used in the same manner but with a different impact or they were repurposed to suit this narrative. It was fun to guess how it would all come together.

I love Oliver. I cried with him, I danced for joy with him, I celebrated his small victories, and I felt his pain. It's so hard to move through a world that cannot or will not see you as you know yourself to be. I'm nonbinary (they/them pronouns) and I was frequently misgendered while I devoured this book. It's incredibly important to tell these stories from the trans person's point of view.

All the supporting characters were brilliant, too. Mr. Bennet in particular made me cry and yearn and feel hopeful. Charlotte and Lu helped bring the queer culture to life. Wickham was his distasteful self and it was perfect. Even Collins was the right level of odious.

The romance between Darcy and Oliver was charming. It felt historically accurate and appropriate for their ages (Oliver is 17 and Darcy a few years old). Knowing the original story, you know it's inevitable but the author still managed to make me feel like it might *not* work out here. It's a skillful balancing act and it made the ending all the more poignant.

Gabe, thank you for writing such a moving, delightful story. It brought such a smile to my face even as I cried. I'm honored to have had the opportunity to read an advance copy. And you're completely right: we deserve romances that will sweep us off our feet.

I've already started recommending this to absolutely everyone!

Was this review helpful?

A lovely twist on the story of pride and prejudice with refreshingly modern twist. Taking the original story and mixing in a trans storyline added a sense of urgency to this story that made it more enriching and engaging

Was this review helpful?

This was delightful. Sweet and funny, a really fun retelling of a favorite book. While I think this version lacks the wit and quickness of Austen's writing, I don't actually expect many to live up to her. It's a modernly-structured YA take - as it should be, it's written for that audience - on a classic story that I think accomplishes what it sets out to very well. I devoured this book cover to cover the day I started it when I had actually intended to spread it out over a week.

This book made me cry in a Barnes and Noble cafe. Fully in public.

Was this review helpful?

Well, I have a small confession to make. Pride & Prejudice isn't my favorite Jane Austen novel, however, I have read it 8-10 times, so I still felt a very strong urge to check this out when I saw it on Netgalley. Secondly, I absolutely adore the remixed classics from Feiwel and Friends. I think this is my fourth one that I have read and it is in contention to be my favorite.

In this remix LGBTQ+ remix of Pride & Prejudice we follow a transmasc Elizabeth who goes by Oliver. As he isn't out to his family yet, he is expected to wear dresses, dance with suitors and be an all-around perfect young lady. Also because he isn't out yet, he is deadnamed a lot. He meets Darcy at a dance and is immediately snubbed by the other man. The story generally follows the original until Oliver meets Darcy and the two strike up a friendship.
As they become closer, Oliver starts to realize that he has feelings for Darcy and... well you can imagine.

There were some really smart changes to the original plot and characters in this. I don't want to go into too much detail because I don't want to ruin the surprise for other readers, but if you have ever went, "I want Pride & Prejudice, but make it gay" this one is for you. It has some really beautiful and tender moments. Mr. Bennet is amazing in this. There are also some really hilarious moments in this too. If I hadn't been afraid of waking up my entire household I would have been cackling like a maniac at certain points.

Also, I can appreciate the research that the author did into the queer culture at the time. Yes, there was a queer culture. So these aspects come into play in this remix that obviously wouldn't have a place in the original. Some characters and plot lines were cut, but honestly, I'm not mad about it. I think Novoa was really smart with the changes and the edits made to make this so compulsively readable and charming.

Overall, I would recommend this for fans of Pride & Prejudice, historical queer romances, stories of manner, and of course people being true to themselves. It's a really quick read and is actually shorter than the original. Like I said, some things were cut, some things were added, but everything came together to create a story that is engaging and adorable. I have another novel by Novoa on my shelf, I just haven't gotten around to it, but this makes me feel like I should push it up the waitlist. Also, I hope that Feiwel and Friends continue the remix series for a long time. These remixes are always so much fun and generally enjoyable. Oh yeah, and Marlowe Lune's cover? *chef's kiss*

Was this review helpful?

"In the Remixed Classics series, authors from marginalized backgrounds reinterpret classic works through their own cultural lens to subvert the overwhelming cishet, white, and male canon. This bittersweet Pride and Prejudice remix follows a trans boy yearning for the freedom to live openly, centering queerness in a well-known story of longing and subverting society's patriarchal and cisheteronormative expectations.

London, 1812. Oliver Bennet feels trapped. Not just by the endless corsets, petticoats and skirts he's forced to wear on a daily basis, but also by society's expectations. The world - and the vast majority of his family and friends - think Oliver is a girl named Elizabeth. He is therefore expected to mingle at balls wearing a pretty dress, entertain suitors regardless of his interest in them, and ultimately become someone's wife.

But Oliver can't bear the thought of such a fate. He finds solace in the few times he can sneak out of his family's home and explore the city rightfully dressed as a young gentleman. It's during one such excursion when Oliver becomes acquainted with Darcy, a sulky young man who had been rude to "Elizabeth" at a recent social function. But in the comfort of being out of the public eye, Oliver comes to find that Darcy is actually a sweet, intelligent boy with a warm heart. And not to mention incredibly attractive.

As Oliver is able to spend more time as his true self, often with Darcy, part of him dares begin to hope that his dream of love and life as a man could be possible. But suitors are growing bolder - and even threatening - and his mother is growing more desperate to see him settled into an engagement. Oliver will have to choose: Settle for safety, security, and a life of pretending to be something he's not, or risk it all for a slim chance at freedom, love, and a life that can be truly, honestly his own."

I love this remix series but I adore Marlowe Lune's artwork even more. Every book that they have done the cover art for has a precious place on my bookshelves.

Was this review helpful?

Obviously I love Jane Austen, so this was a no-brainer for me to read. And I'm so glad I did!
This was incredibly sweet, moving, and fresh. Retellings are such a delicate business, and can be so hit or miss, but this is a hit! And I'm not honestly sure I'd call it a "retelling", more of a reimagining. Some significant changes were made with regards to characters ages and the locations/geography. It's also much shorter than the original, so big edits to side stories and characters were made.
All that being said, the heart of the story is Oliver and his character development and his journey of coming out and being accepted. We are in his head for the whole book, and it really just shines a light on how incredibly important it is to be recognized for who you are and to be able to live your life as you see yourself. The way Oliver feels about his clothes, his name, and how he is perceived are so so so important. You feel his joy when he can dress as a man and his despair at ever being called a lady or "Elizabeth." I loved the way his relationship with Darcy developed, and it was just an interesting contrast with "Elizabeth" and Darcy.
Mr Collins and Wickham managed to be even worse in this version. But Mr Bennett was the real MVP. I absolutely loved how he embraced Oliver and supported him. Mrs Bennett at the very end had me both cackling and emotional.
I definitely would recommend this book, even if you're not a huge fan of classics.

4.5 stars

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advanced look at the book to review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?